Quantcast

CAN MUSLIMS BE GOOD AMERICANS?

Soup Man 2012/07/09 02:52:13
You!
Add Photos & Videos
his is certainly
'food-for-thought'.
This is very interesting and we all need to
read it from start to finish. And send it on to
everyone. Maybe this is why our American Muslims are so
quiet and not speaking out about any atrocities.


Can a
good Muslim be a good American?


This
question was forwarded to a friend who worked in Saudi Arabia for
20 years.
The following is his
reply:


Theologically - no. . . .
Because his allegiance is to Allah, The moon god of Arabia.


Religiously
- no.. . . Because
no other religion is accepted by His Allah except Islam. (Quran,
2:256)(Koran)


Scripturally - no. . .. Because
his allegiance is to the five Pillars of Islam and the
Quran.


Geographically - no . Because
his allegiance is to Mecca, to which
he turns in prayer five times a
day.


Socially - no. . ..
Because his allegiance to Islam forbids him to make friends with
Christians or Jews
.


Politically - no.. . . Because
he must submit to the mullahs (spiritual leaders), who teach
annihilation of Israel and destruction of America, the great
Satan.


Domestically - no. ... .
Because he is instructed to marry four Women and beat and scourge
his wife when she disobeys him (Quran4:34
)


Intellectually - no. . Because
he cannot accept the American Constitution since it is based on
Biblical principles and he believes the Bible to be
corrupt.


Philosophically - no. . .
. Because
Islam, Muhammad, and the Quran does not allow freedom of religion
and expression. Democracy
and Islam cannot co-exist. Every Muslim government is either
dictatorial or autocratic.


Spiritually -
no.. . . Because
when we declare 'one nation under God,' The Christian's God is
loving and kind, while Allah is N0T EVER referred to as Heavenly
father, nor is he ever called love in the Quran's 99 excellent
names.


Therefore, after much study and
deliberation.... Perhaps we should be very suspicious of ALL
MUSLIMS in this country. - - - They obviously cannot be both
'good' Muslims and good Americans. Call it what you wish,
it's still the truth. You had better believe it. The more who
understand this, the better it will be for our country and our
future.


The religious war is bigger than
we know or understand. ....


Footnote: The
Muslims have said they will destroy us from within. SO
FREEDOM IS NOT FREE.

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • LindaM 2012/07/11 12:49:50
    None of the above
    LindaM
    +6
    This poster is generalizing because there is good and bad in every religion. Take the Mormon religion, it's mostly secretive and you are not allowed in the Temple unless you are mormon. I think most people in all religions are peaceful. You do have the radical in everyone of them, though. Celebrities that are muslims Celebrities that are muslims Celebrities that are muslims Celebrities that are muslims Celebrities that are muslims

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • None of the above
    ♥☆ ـــاطمةfēmàłėفـــــ☆♥
    +1
    Being a clueless person is what considering a BAD american ,,,,just like this sick beliefs that provides that kind of posts .
  • irish 2013/01/06 17:42:09
    None of the above
    irish
    +2
    no? no? are your choices?
    lets ask who can be good americans! anyone who is born in america is the answer. anyone who becomes a citizen is the answer.
    can jews be good americans?? not when they embrace zionism. their 1st an only allegiance is to israel.
    how about catholics or christians? especially the fundamentalist ones who are slavish to israel too?? nope.

    this islamaphobia is stupid and ridiculous.
  • Soup Man irish 2013/01/06 19:40:50
    Soup Man
    let's look at the current time line and try living into day
  • irish Soup Man 2013/01/07 00:14:17
    irish
    +1
    yes do that. your absurd fear of people is disturbing.
  • Soup Man irish 2013/01/07 00:33:16
    Soup Man
    no your absurd not seeing facts fact
  • irish Soup Man 2013/01/07 13:39:15
    irish
    +1
    LOL LOL i see you believe in myths. that islam is not taking over the world. and this jihad , which means inner struggle,is a bunch of hooey. after all,if that was their intent,where have they been all these 1000's of yrs???LOL
  • Soup Man irish 2013/01/07 17:31:18
    Soup Man
    1000's how about 1400 yrs or so
  • Kelsey Soup Man 2013/01/07 22:33:22
    Kelsey
    +2
    Dude screw off ur obviously one to complain. If u think Muslims can't be good Americans. Christians can't be good americans a girl shoved a Hindu infront of a train thinking he was Muslim. Some random joker started shooting ppl in a mosque but later found out it wasn't it was so other religion. A guy started shooting kids in elementary school.This is how ppl like u r. U r the one that can't be an American.
  • Soup Man Kelsey 2013/01/08 17:16:08
    Soup Man
    Why are you here? Are you not a female? In the Muslim world your father would beat you for disrespecting an elder male
  • irish Soup Man 2013/01/08 12:00:26
    irish
    +1
    arabs have been around a long time.
  • Soup Man irish 2013/01/08 17:18:11
    Soup Man
    It’s not of people it's of an ideology
  • irish Soup Man 2013/01/08 18:13:38
    irish
    you are still wrong. islam is a step child of judaism and christianity. you all believe in the same god ,prophets etc etc . i guess all of you are threats then.
  • Soup Man irish 2013/01/09 01:15:50
    Soup Man
    Oh really! You may find it hard for a muslim to collaborate that point of view
  • irish Soup Man 2013/01/09 11:42:49
    irish
    nope. you don't like facts i see. 3  abrahamic    religions
  • Kelsey irish 2013/01/07 22:29:31
    Kelsey
    +2
    YEA MAN SHOW EM WHO'S BOSS
  • irish Kelsey 2013/01/08 12:01:06
    irish
    +1
    thanks.
  • ♥☆ ـــا... irish 2013/01/08 19:52:36
  • irish ♥☆ ـــا... 2013/01/09 11:43:13
    irish
    +1
    thank you!
  • LibertyCaroline 2013/01/06 17:30:06
    None of the above
    LibertyCaroline
    +2
    Really??? Can "Christians" be good Americans?
  • Soup Man Liberty... 2013/01/06 19:41:18
    Soup Man
    In god we trust
  • irish Soup Man 2013/01/07 00:16:57
    irish
    +1
    what do you think islam trusts if not the same god? 3  abrahamic  religions
  • Kelsey 2013/01/05 07:34:43
    None of the above
    Kelsey
    What have Muslims done? I'm white my background is Irish but my closest friend at school is muslim. She's so sweet and won't even harm a butterfly. Of course they can be good citizens! There are SOME terrorist Muslims but not in America. Blacks (not to be racsist) and Mexicans are MORE likely to kill. There r sooooo many of them selling drugs n in my school I know many illegal immigrants from Mexico fighting in classes. Blacks sell drugs at school
  • Sumātogai 2012/09/02 09:42:54
    None of the above
    Sumātogai
    +1
    Yes,they can,if people would learn to give them a chance.
  • Enn 2012/08/04 01:27:31
    None of the above
    Enn
    +1
    Why do you generalise all Muslims based on a few. And also those "quotes/evidence" can easily be misinterpreted cause its been taken out of context.

    Yes... Muslims CAN be good Americans.

    What's your definition of a "Good american" anyway?
  • Soup Man Enn 2012/09/09 23:32:59
    Soup Man
    The silence is deafening
  • Corky 2012/07/25 16:24:31
    no
    Corky
    +1
    Muslims and islam are the new Nazis and Nazi party. I thin the entire civilized world is aware of this now.
  • Kelsey Corky 2013/01/05 07:42:15
    Kelsey
    +6
    Ummm sweetie? Have u not noticed American are the main terrorists we have created the nuclear weapon and killed MANY much much much more than 9/11 and we r blaming them as terrorists. We Americans sound pathetic! We r the killers. And have u also noticed that in every world war they join last and join the winning team. Also HITLER WAS A WHITE CHRISTIAN AND UR CALLING THEM THE NEW NAZIS? Wow just wow....
  • irish Kelsey 2013/01/06 17:43:59
    irish
    well said.
  • irish Corky 2013/01/06 17:43:40
    irish
    LOL LOL hardly!
  • kiwimac 2012/07/23 09:59:49
    no
    kiwimac
    +1
    This rant of yours has long been debunked. Try some original thinking rather than spewing out old, rancid stuff.
  • smileysouma 2012/07/21 18:49:56
    None of the above
    smileysouma
    +2
    Yes of course they can be good Americans!!.Aren't they human beings in the first place!. Before they r muslims, they r human beings and they do have the good ethics as everyone else around!. Good muslims shud be good citizens!.
  • Red 2012/07/14 07:38:23
  • Anna 2012/07/13 22:32:31
    None of the above
    Anna
    +2
    All I consider necessary to be a good American is to be a good person, and I've met many Muslims who are good people.
  • Marie-Jacqueline 2012/07/13 21:28:44 (edited)
    None of the above
    Marie-Jacqueline
    +4
    Yes, they can!

    What a bunch of stupidity this article is.
    It is bias, it discriminating, it deny an American who's religion is Islam the freedom of religion!

    To comment on the points in this article:
    Theologically:
    A lot of Americans put God before country!
    The even enforce their children in school to say the Pledge of Allegiance.
    That is not the problem but they add "under God " to it.

    Religiously:
    A lot of religious conservative Christians in the US don't accept any other religion that Christianity and than often only a certain denomenation!.

    Scripturally:
    Many Americans put their allegiance in the Bible.

    Geographically:
    Many Americans are Jewish, Jerusalem is important to them;
    many Americans are Catholic, The Pope and Rome is important to them.

    Socially:
    In the past you had to be white, Protestant, English speaking to be accepted in American society. In some places, with some, often right wing groups in the US, it still hasn't changed much.

    Domestically:
    The Bible, certainly the Old Testament, but also the New Testament mentions some horrific ways to treat a woman.

    Intellectually:
    The United States Constitution is based amongs other things in the separation of church and state.
    The Constitution doesn't state nowhere that you have to be of a certain rel...









    Yes, they can!

    What a bunch of stupidity this article is.
    It is bias, it discriminating, it deny an American who's religion is Islam the freedom of religion!

    To comment on the points in this article:
    Theologically:
    A lot of Americans put God before country!
    The even enforce their children in school to say the Pledge of Allegiance.
    That is not the problem but they add "under God " to it.

    Religiously:
    A lot of religious conservative Christians in the US don't accept any other religion that Christianity and than often only a certain denomenation!.

    Scripturally:
    Many Americans put their allegiance in the Bible.

    Geographically:
    Many Americans are Jewish, Jerusalem is important to them;
    many Americans are Catholic, The Pope and Rome is important to them.

    Socially:
    In the past you had to be white, Protestant, English speaking to be accepted in American society. In some places, with some, often right wing groups in the US, it still hasn't changed much.

    Domestically:
    The Bible, certainly the Old Testament, but also the New Testament mentions some horrific ways to treat a woman.

    Intellectually:
    The United States Constitution is based amongs other things in the separation of church and state.
    The Constitution doesn't state nowhere that you have to be of a certain religion to be considere a "true" American.

    Philosophically:
    The US is based on the principle of freedom of Religion!
    You limit yourself to the Middle -East. Millions of Muslims live in many countries you hardly can call un-democratic.

    Spiritually:
    Nahum 1:2-9 2 The LORD is a jealous and avenging God; the LORD is avenging and wrathful; the LORD takes vengeance on his adversaries and keeps wrath for his enemies.

    So what is left of this anti-Islam rant you placed here?
    Nothing!
    (more)
  • SilveryRow 2012/07/13 20:25:00
    None of the above
    SilveryRow
    +3
    What a hate-encouraging article *shudder*
  • flyingseaturtle BN 2012/07/13 16:36:47
    None of the above
    flyingseaturtle BN
    +3
    Most muslims can. There are some people that can't and it doesn't matter what religion.
  • bags the Indigenous Guru 2012/07/13 14:54:12
    None of the above
    bags the Indigenous Guru
    +5
    Of course they can be. Just ask Congress man Keith Ellison of Minnesota of Congressman Andre Carson of Indiana..

    By your logic, neither Christians of Jews would be good Americans because their first allegiance goes to God/Jesus.
  • Ronzo bags th... 2012/07/14 13:01:35 (edited)
    Ronzo
    The muslim's believe all are infidels if they do not serve Islam which came about 600 years after the Birth of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. The Muslim hates the Christian and they are trying to destroy America from within. I remember when the world would not believe Adolf Hitler was murdering the Jews, people who believed it to be true were mocked and called crazy and paranoid. Hitler was as other political leaders of that day Calling for Change sound familiar, well Hitler led Germany down the road to hell, so I don't worship people I demand them to be loyal and abide by constitutional laws and that is a sign your a true American/Patriot. This country has always showed allegiance and honor to God, look at your money, in God We Trust. You maybe an atheist or muslim I'm not sure, I do believe your nut is loose. We the People want to maintain our Christian Heritage just as the Arab Country's what to maintain Islam. Wake up DA.
  • bags th... Ronzo 2012/07/14 13:57:53
    bags the Indigenous Guru
    +1
    The term Islam means peace and encompasses all the religions who worship the God of Abraham. I am not a Muslim, nor am I a Christian. I have had the experience of being able to study both religions. Nor am I an atheist. I haven't insulted you or anyone else and i don;t discuss with those who do. Have a good day....we must agree to disagree.
  • irish Ronzo 2013/01/06 17:48:45
    irish
    +1
    LOL LOL stop reading and or listening to propaganda. muslims abide by their holy book much better than so called christians and jews. they are taught to be tolerant of others.
    hitler was NOT murdering jews,it was a war. actually if you actually knew any real history hitler was leading germany to prosperity with out the bankers. the bankers started ww2 to destroy german.
    i note you ignore al;l the traitors in d.c. who regularly violate the laws of this country without and problems from you.
    america was NEVER a christian country.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2014/04/19 09:30:49

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals