Quantcast

Zimmerman charges should be reduced NOW.

Apocalypse Island 2012/05/21 16:17:18
You!
Add Photos & Videos
By reducing the charge from second degree murder to manslaughter or negligent manslaughter now, the prosecutor can avoid the embarrassment of having to admit an unjustified charge at the trial.
By reducing the charge now she can help prepare those who still want to lynch Zimmerman even though he has been shown to be innocent for his eventual release as "not guilty" and thereby help to prevent riots.
See these previous questions:
http://www.sodahead.com/united-states/alan-dershowitz-zimmerm...
http://www.sodahead.com/united-states/do-you-believe-that-geo...
http://www.sodahead.com/united-states/zimmermans-medical-reco...
http://www.sodahead.com/united-states/in-your-opinion-was-geo...
http://www.sodahead.com/united-states/the-voice-of-reason-on-...

Read More: http://abcnews.go.com/US/george-zimmerman-case-cha...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Deputy Chief 2012/05/24 07:09:58
    The charges against Zimmerman should be reduced or dropped now.
    Deputy Chief
    +33
    The prosecution will NEVER sustain a 2nd Degree Murder Conviction, based on the fact that Zimmerman sustained visible, documented injuries inflicted by the deceased.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Apocalypse Island 2012/05/29 16:09:13
    The charges against Zimmerman should be reduced or dropped now.
    Apocalypse Island
    +26
    When I asked this question, I never intended to start a debate on whether Zimmerman is guilty or of what. Absolutes are unknowable, but probabilities can be estimated. In terms of what will happen in the court and the money spent trying this case, it does not much matter whether he is guilty or what the correct charge should be. What matters is what can be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. An awful lot of money is being wasted bringing a case to court if there is no possibility of getting a conviction. I believe that when the medical report came in there was no longer a glimmer of hope of getting a conviction. Therefore the prosecutor is wasting an awful lot of time and money trying a case she knows she is going to lose just to make a political point. It is extremely unfair to the jury to make them sit through a trial where everyone knows what the outcome will be.
  • Siddiqi 2012/05/28 17:55:27
    The charges against Zimmerman should be reduced or dropped now.
    Siddiqi
    +11
    I am a member of the Nation of Islam, a "Black Muslim". I have a gun to protect my family, my home and myself. I had not thought about it much before this case became big news, but I have realized that I did not get that gun to repel Klansmen coming to lynch me. If I had to use it, it would probably be on a burglar robbing my home, which in my neighborhood probably means a black man. So be it. I really think it is time we took race out of this case. Zimmerman was injured and frightened at the time he shot Martin. That makes the shooting self defense. Now, I think Zimmerman is guilty of something in the events leading up to the shooting, even if the shooting itself is innocent. Something like stalking or harassment. But that is a far cry from murder.
  • RushSchlafly 2012/05/28 16:31:21
    The charges against Zimmerman should be reduced or dropped now.
    RushSchlafly
    +13
    When the medical report was released showing Zimmerman was attacked and his head beaten against the sidewalk, all charges should have been dropped. What happened before that point is totally irrelevant. A person has a right to defend himself from having brain damage from beating, Simple self defense. Color or race does not matter, who started the confrontation does not matter, even who assaulted who first does not matter. All that the defense has to prove is that Zimmerman could reasonably believe he was in danger of being killed or maimed at the moment he fired. His wounds plus the fact he only fired once proves that. Most people would empty the clip to make sure their attacker was dead.
  • Joey RushSch... 2012/06/02 22:27:19
    Joey
    I love the double standard here .. Zimmerman can kill someone .. even if he starts a fight and lose. I guess stand your ground does not apply to some people. Also the medical report did not prove that attack happen like Zimmerman said it does.
  • C-ZAR™, Emperor of the PHÆT 2012/05/27 11:05:59
    Prosecutor should proceed with second degree murder charge.
    C-ZAR™, Emperor of the PHÆT
    [...]
  • jujunme 2012/05/24 20:21:36
    Prosecutor should proceed with second degree murder charge.
    jujunme
    +1
    Without a doubt, now i see on the news that good old Zim was walking along freely in the Sanford Police station 3 days after shooting Martin..interesting! to say the least.Also, for someone who reportedly had their head smashed in 3 days prior and despite the small bandage on the back of his head , he didn't look or act very injured at all.
  • Deputy Chief 2012/05/24 07:09:58
    The charges against Zimmerman should be reduced or dropped now.
    Deputy Chief
    +33
    The prosecution will NEVER sustain a 2nd Degree Murder Conviction, based on the fact that Zimmerman sustained visible, documented injuries inflicted by the deceased.
  • Joey Deputy ... 2012/05/24 11:27:45
    Joey
    +1
    Time out .. So anyone who starts a fight will always win it?
  • Deputy ... Joey 2012/05/24 17:41:53
    Deputy Chief
    +5
    The "Stand your Ground Law" in Florida allows one to defend himself if he/she feels his/her life is threatened. Obviously Zimmerman sustained injuries that indicate he was being beaten. If the beating continued (such as head being continually pounded against the cement) this could have resulted in loss of life.
  • Joey Deputy ... 2012/05/24 18:29:25
    Joey
    +1
    Since as he did not have a concussion, and Martins phone and other effects were found on the grass it does not seem likely that his had was being beat in to the ground.

    Also are you telling me that you can start a fight and if you lose you can shot someone . Since the only witness that heard what happen say that Martin Scream get off of me before the fight ..

    Lastly wouldn't Stand your ground work for Martin since he had a man with a gun following him in the dead of the night ?
  • Deputy ... Joey 2012/05/24 20:52:58 (edited)
    Deputy Chief
    +4
    A person does not have to be beat til almost DEAD before we are allowed to defend our selves.

    Witnesses saw Martin on top of Zimmerman beating him. Cooberating evidence were injuries that included Zimmerman bleeding from the back of the head, broken nose and grass stains on the back of his shirt. The ONLY injury on Martin other than the gunshot wound, were scrapes on his knuckles that resulted from him beating Zimmerman.

    Also Zimmerman called 911 to report Martins' suspicious conduct in a neighborhood where mulitple breakins had occurred.

    Carrying a concealed weapon with a permit is LEGAL. Zimmerman had a permit.

    I am retired Law Enforcement and can legally carry a firearm. If I see a suspicious unknown person in my neighborhood I have the legal right to watch him. If that person attacks me. I will defend myself and if that means using a gun to stop him from pounding my head against the cement, I will.

    This incident is a tragedy and my sympathies go out to the Martin family. There are a lot of what if's that shouldn't have happened for this to occur. Both Zimmerman and Martin could have avoided this confrontation.
  • Joey Deputy ... 2012/05/24 21:23:01
    Joey
    +2
    First you still have not shown that Martin started the fight you just highlighted that in the fight he was getting the best of Zimmerman. Also Martin did not have scrapes .. he had ONE mark on his knuckles. Also there are 3 witnesses that say Zimmerman was on top. And the person who said Martin was on top have since changed their story.

    And this suspicious conduct was walking...

    See what you said .. you said that you have the legal right to WATCH him. Zimmerman went after Martin with a loaded weapon on his person .

    Every step of the way it was Zimmerman who was showing signs of aggression ..
    He was the one who was so bad he called Martin names.
    He showed that he was upset that people like Martin always get away.
    HE was the one who was went after him while carrying .
    He was the one how started the whole incident.
    Martin was just walking ...
    The girl that was on the phone with Martin heard him say GET OFF ME .
    And why would Martin start a fight while he was on the Phone?

    Lastly would you say that skater was in the wrong here for beating up that other guy .



  • Deputy ... Joey 2012/05/25 01:29:02
    Deputy Chief
    +4
    I suggest you listen to all the 911 calls. Your comments about witnesses and comments that Zimmerman made are totally incorrect.

    You are correct that Martin had was a scrape on a knuckle. Obviously Zimmerman did not harm him. Zimmerman sustained the injuries I mentioned which is consistant with one who had been beaten.

    Next you will say that it is okay to knock someone on the ground and beat them because they are watching you (a stranger) in their own neighborhood and that you do not have the right to defend yourself.
  • Joey Deputy ... 2012/05/25 08:50:32
    Joey
    +1
    I will refer you back to the video I showed ... the person who had the most injuries did not start the fight . So can you prove that Martin started the fight? I mean this should be something simple .. since you claim that he did. Winning a fight and starting it are to different things. I will give you another example .



    Since the person who had the most injuries was the little kid would you assume that he started it ?

    And nothing I said about Zimmerman was incorrect .

    For your statement it seems like you support the murder of Latasha Harlins.
  • Deputy ... Joey 2012/05/25 16:48:18 (edited)
    Deputy Chief
    +2
    Let us assume you are correct about Zimmerman starting the fight (which I do not believe, and you cannot prove). Martin who obviously had the upper hand in the beating, could have stopped his hitting Zimmerman (which was witnessed) and ran, but instead he continued beating Zimmerman until he was shot and killed.

    It is unfortunate that Martin was suspended from school for possession of MJ therefore putting him in the area of the assault. His father since the young man obviously had issues should NOT have allowed him to be unsupervised at night. Martin was a troubled young man and the results are tragic for everyone involved

    If Martin would have been on top of me slamming my head on the cement, I would scream for help and do whatever it took to STOP the beating. Self defense is a right. Martin was 6'3" 160lb an obviously tough young man.
  • Joey Deputy ... 2012/05/25 21:14:46
    Joey
    +1
    Wow I love the double standards that you show . You think that Zimmerman could kill Martin for a fight ...yet Martin was suppose to hit him once and ran. If that happen you would be supporting him getting shot in the back. I forgot Martin could not stand his ground but Zimmerman could .You state that I can not prove that Zimmerman started the fight .. yet the only witness before the fight say she heard Martin saying get off me . And you still have not told me why someone would start a fight while being on the phone.

    Zimmerman had a criminal record NOT Martin. Our last 3 presidents have smoked MJ. Yet since Martin did it he should have been shot . Zimmerman attacked a cop . Yet you think Martin is the Bad one .

    First that is not how tall Martin was, and if it was why would it matter. HE did not go after Zimmerman .. Zimmerman went after him.also about walking away Latasha Harlins. walked away and was shot in the back . And YOUR system let her murderer walk away with no jail time.Did you support that ?
  • Deputy ... Joey 2012/05/25 23:12:13
    Deputy Chief
    +2
    WRONG
    The witness said that it was Martin on top of Zimmerman who was screaming for help. He screamed because he needed to be rescued from the beating.

    Obviously you are ignorant to the juvenile justice system as Martin was known to them for possession of burglary tools and violence against a bus driver. No convictions, because in the juvenile system convictions do NOT exist only adjudications. Martin was far from being a model juvenile with his gold teeth, possession of drugs and flashing gang signs in pictures. These are documented facts.
    Trayvon martin gang signs and gold teeth Trayvon martin gang signs and gold teeth Trayvon martin gang signs and gold teeth
  • strawberry Deputy ... 2012/05/26 04:40:06
    strawberry
    +3
    First Martin's father lied to police then later admitted it was not his son's voice screaming for help on 911 tapes.
  • Deb strawberry 2012/05/27 14:16:57
    Deb
    How could his parents NOT recognize his voice? Bizarre
  • Joey Deputy ... 2012/05/26 15:27:33
    Joey
    +1
    I love how you say Wrong when you are full of Wrongness. The Picture of the person in the blue room is not Martin . But I guess all black people look alike . I mean I love it .. it you call something something a fact that is wrong.

    First about the Jewelry: Police found that they were not stolen.

    http://www.theblaze.com/stori...

    Fake Picture:

    http://host-53.242.54.159.gan...

    And there is not proof that he did anything to a bus driver . Also the witness that claims that your hero Zimmerman was on top has changed his story.

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com...

    Hope Many innocent black people did you harass think you think we all look a like .
  • Deputy ... Joey 2012/05/26 18:38:48
    Deputy Chief
    +1
    You sound very racist. I guess OJ was innocent too. I will terminate my discussion with someone who engages in unsubstantiated personal attacks because they cannot legitimately refute facts. I guess my children who are NOT white all look alike too.
  • Joey Deputy ... 2012/05/26 22:49:59
    Joey
    +1
    How can not refute facts !!?!?!

    You are posting a picture of a someone who is not the young man who was killed. Now that is a Fact. And then you call me racist that is funny .
  • Ike Deputy ... 2012/06/18 17:17:50
    Ike
    So exactly what does Martins suspension from school or these photos have to do with Zimmerman killing him. None of this mess has anything to do with the incidents that happen on that night. So let me guess Rodney King deserved to be beaten on the side of the road that night in L.A. or perhaps Emmett Teal should have been beaten and hang to death because he looked upon a white woman.
  • strawberry Joey 2012/05/26 04:36:41
    strawberry
    +4
    Both my son and brother are attorneys. FACT: Zimmerman legally had every right to be on neighborhood watch. FACT: Zimmerman had every legal right to carry a gun. FACT: While on watch Zimmerman had a right to question Trayvon Martin. All Martin had to do was say where he was going. FACT: There were at least 18 robberies by black males in that community in less than a year. FACT: Martin's father first lied then admitted it was not his son's voice yelling for help on 911 tapes. FACT: Zimmerman did not just fire his gun at the Martin boy. FACT: Martin had one gun shot in him. FACT: Zimmerman had face and head injuries, already proven by paramedics. FACT: Martin assaulted Zimmerman. If Zimmerman just shot Martin, Martin would have been dead. Zimmerman would have no injuries on him. FACT: Police did take Zimmerman to station that night, questioned him for hours, found no cause to arrest Zimmerman. They would have that night. FACT: Al Sharpton deliberately turned this into a racial matter. FACT: Black Panthers threatened Zimmerman with murderous threats. FACT: There was no factual information when Sharpton and Panthers among other African Americans yelled racist remarks.
    Fact: Zimmerman shot Martin once in self defense. He had no idea how much injury Martin could have caused him. Martin could have also had any weapon on him.
    FACT: Zimmerman should not have been arrested later on.
  • Joey strawberry 2012/05/26 15:30:33
    Joey
    I love how you say things are fact with out anything to back it up in many cases . Yet you can not prove that Martin attack him first . Also tell your grand kids to tell odd many following them where they live ?
  • Deputy ... Joey 2012/05/26 23:52:04
    Deputy Chief
    +2
    I see your having difficulty refuting Strawberry's facts as well. Your racist comments (about caucasions) cloud your judgement.
  • Joey Deputy ... 2012/05/27 03:14:48
    Joey
    So you are not going to comment on you posting a picture of someone who was not the person killed. Also I could address more of what your buddy posted . If she or he can answer what I did address. Also I love how you claim said something racist about white people when I have not .

    Last note .. you being in law enforcement would you advance women who are being chased to tell the person who is chasing them were they live ?
  • Deputy ... Joey 2012/05/27 06:18:49
    Deputy Chief
    +2
    You ignore ALL the facts about the physical evidence in this case, I am glad YOU are NOT on the jury.

    By the way I am a FEMALE who promoted within a male dominated field. I treat men and women equally, by assessing the nature of your question, you obviously do not.
  • Joey Joey 2012/05/27 10:37:26
    Joey
    Since you Blocked me Deputy .. I take it that you will not address the fact that you posted a picture that was not of the young man that was killed .. nor would you address that just because you start a fight does not mean you will in it. As seen in the two fights that I have shown before.
  • strawberry Joey 2012/05/27 23:14:37
    strawberry
    +1
    http://www.topix.com/forum/st...
    Aug. 21, 2007 "Posted in the West Virginia Forum"
    "High Number of Black on White Crimes"
    "Here are some shocking statistics: More than 1,600 Whites are murdered by Blacks each year. Blacks murder Whites at 18 times the rate Whites murder Blacks.
    About 1 million Whites were murdered, robbed, assaulted or raped by Blacks in 1992. In the last 30 years, 170 million violent and nonviolent crimes were committed by Blacks against Whites in the U.S. Blacks under 18 are more than 12 times more likely to be arrested for murder than whites the same age.
  • strawberry Joey 2012/05/27 23:22:40
    strawberry
    +1
    cont. http://www.topix.com/forum/st...
    "On a per-capita basis, Blacks commit 50 times more violent crimes than Whites. Some 27 million non violent crimes were committed in the U.S. In 1992 alone, 31% of the robberies involved Black offenders and White victims; only 2% involved White offenders and Black victims.

    1.3 million of the 6.6 million violent crimes committed in the U.S. each year are interracial. Between 1964 and 1994, more than 45,000 people were killed in interracial murders in the U.S., compared to 58,000 killed in Vietnam, and 38,000 killed in Korea,"
  • strawberry Joey 2012/05/27 23:31:27
    strawberry
    +1
    http://www.topix.com/forum/st...

    "In 1989 the FBI reports the following"
    A) Blacks commit 8 times more assaults than Whites.
    B) Blacks commit 9 times more rapes than Whites.
    C) Blacks commit 14 times more murders than Whites.
    D) Blacks commit 19 times more armed robberies.
    E) Black neighborhoods are 35 times more violent than White neighborhoods.
    F) There were 629,000 interracial attacks committed in 1985 (the last year the FBI "chose" to report the information). Some nine out of every ten were committed by Blacks against Whites.
    G) Black males (6% of the population) make up 46% of the national prison population
  • strawberry Joey 2012/05/27 23:03:32
    strawberry
    +1
    Before you speak go study law.
  • Joey strawberry 2012/05/27 23:57:04
    Joey
    Time you you study nothing you said you asked your family member. Also Iove all the stats but that does that have to do with Martin on that night .Unless people should be held accountable for the factions of others.
  • strawberry Joey 2012/05/28 02:57:59
    strawberry
    +1
    You don't want facts about Martin.
  • strawberry Deputy ... 2012/05/27 23:02:23
    strawberry
    +2
    He does not want facts. He is race defensive right or wrong.
  • strawberry Joey 2012/05/27 22:57:26
    strawberry
    +1
    Take your own time and look them up if you dare to. I'm have no interest in you.
  • strawberry Joey 2012/05/27 22:59:58
    strawberry
    +1
    Look them up yourself. I have no interest in you. You are too defensive to your African American Race. You are not looking for facts.
  • Deputy ... strawberry 2012/05/28 04:23:52
    Deputy Chief
    +2
    He probably was one of the ones who cheered when OJ was aquitted.
  • Deputy ... strawberry 2012/05/26 23:49:28
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 30 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/24 05:29:59

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals