Quantcast

Will Evidence Make Obama 'Birthers' Finally Give Up?

SodaHead News 2010/12/31 12:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
You’d think that after two years in office and a slew of historic legislation aimed at getting the country back in the black that the Obama birthers would give up their pursuit of proof that the president was not born in the United States.

And while solid evidence to the contrary hasn’t swayed them yet, Democratic Hawaiian governor Neil Abercrombie is determined to shut down the movement once and for all. ABC News reported that just three weeks into his first term, Abercrombie said that ending the conspiracy theories about Obama’s birthplace is one of his priorities.

A friend of Obama’s late parents, Abercrombie has said in a number of interviews that he has a personal interest in closing the debate, which is why he’s instructed the state attorney general and health department director to look for ways to let the facts about Obama's birth prove his origin once and for all.

"It's an emotional insult. It is disrespectful to the president; it is disrespectful to the office," Abercrombie told The New York Times. "There's no reason on earth to have the memory of his parents insulted by people whose motivation is solely political. ... Let's put this particular canard to rest."

One reason the so-called birther debate has had such long legs is that long-form birth certificate for Obama with the name of the hospital and the doctor, his or her signature, the baby's birth weight, and the national origin of the parents has never been made public. During the 2008 campaign, the Obama camp released a short-term copy of a "certification of live birth,” which has the same legal weight as the longer one.

Birthers weren’t swayed by that, though, complaining that the document – which has the embossed seal of authenticity from the Department of Health -- only listed the date, hour and location of Obama's birth and the names and race of his parents. They are convinced that the withholding of the original birth certificate is part of a conspiracy to cover up the president’s ineligibility to hold the nation’s highest office.

Whether you’re the president or a sun-kissed surfer nobody, Hawaiian state law prohibits the release of original birth records to persons without a "direct and tangible interest” and only the president, his wife, children, relatives, parents or lawyers have such an interest, according to the text of the law. And so far, none of them have given their consent for the document to be made public. Regardless, the Health Department reports getting dozens of requests in November for the document and up to 50 in one month earlier this year, many apparently from the same person using different aliases.

Like the lingering false information about Obama’s religion, the birther debate has been sticky, with a recent ABC News-Washington Post poll finding that 14 percent of Americans saying they think Obama was born in another country.

Do you think Abercrombie’s actions will end birther debate?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Patrick Jones 2011/01/02 06:31:41
    No
    Patrick Jones
    +97
    I checked "no" becuase there should have been a "maybe".... Obama and his supporters have spent at least million dollars fighting bringing out the long form birth certificate. It would have cost a plane ticket and $24 to end it once and for all. And he has already visited Hawaii on OUR DIME! So he would not have even had to but the plane ticket.... $24.... Thats IT! That is ALL he would have to pay to END the entire debate!

    Honestly, If you don't see something fishy about someone spending $1,000,000 to avoid spending $24.... You are blinded by your love for Obama.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Kay Albert ... 2011/01/04 08:28:34
    Kay
    Having had a son born oversees living on a foreign country's economy gave him a choice of citizenship but naturally he chose the U.S. He paid for his own College degrees also. He's an honest man.
  • Albert ... Kay 2011/01/05 23:14:43
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    Suggest you read what I send before responding with gibberish. Barry wasn't born overseas (if DNA analysis shows he was the child named in the original birth certificate).

    On the basis of publicly available information, his adoptive mother Stanley Ann Dunham (probably his paternal half-sister) expatriated Barry from the U.S. He almost certainly acquired Indonesian citizenship. There is no public evidence that he renewed U.S. citizenship. Even if he did, he would be a naturalized citizen, not natural born.

    Barry is the polar opposite of honest. He pretends to be African-American, but is neither. If he were honest, he would have no objection to exhaustive official investigation of his past, and in fact would cooperate by consenting to the disclosure of records pertaining to his birth and life history.
  • urdumbas 2011/01/04 08:01:26
    No
    urdumbas
    +2
    They will forever think he was not born here even if you showed them the home video, a picture of the daily newspaper and 100 people who all single-handedly watched him crown out of his mother's you know what.
  • Albert ... urdumbas 2011/01/05 23:17:25 (edited)
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    Evidence will show he was born here, a natural born U.S. citizen, who became and remains Indonesian, an illegal alien, and a mole.

    See "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II", at http://forums.about.com/n/pfx...
    Search for eingriff. Click on the first entry in the list, "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II". Read the first entry by eingriff. Go to the last entry, number 7 by eingriff. It's long. It will be easier to read and print out by clicking "View Full Message" at the end.

    See also Philip J. Berg, Esq., http://obamacrimes.com/?p=423.

    Exhaustive official investigations, which can be expected to result, if diligently conducted, in impeachment and prosecution, are essential. The Honorable Darrell Issa, by failing to do so much as subpoena Barry's vital records for fear of being viewed as "overreaching", is guilty of grave dereliction of duty.
  • jabo 2011/01/04 07:41:58
    No
    jabo
    If this is real evidence and not manufactured evidence, I think most would accept it. But why has it taken so long. Obama could have put this to rest long ago if he had wanted to.
  • urdumbas jabo 2011/01/04 08:02:22
    urdumbas
    In the same vane, he could have manufactured it years ago too! It doesn't take this long to produce a fake.
  • bem179 urdumbas 2011/01/04 18:58:16
    bem179
    ...see, this is what some the more intelligent folks are talking about, there's no end to how far these birthers will go to propogate this MORONIC lie.
  • Albert ... bem179 2011/01/05 23:30:59
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    Dispel the lies, if you can, by official investigations to elicit all of the evidence bearing upon Barry's citizenship.
  • bem179 jabo 2011/01/04 18:56:51
    bem179
    He's an intelligent man; and he's the President of the U.S., why do you think he would feel he has to prove his birth-hood to every insignificant "doubting Thomas" that comes along???? Silliness never stops!
  • Albert ... bem179 2011/01/05 23:32:12
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    He's a sly and clever mole, masquerading as an African-American when he is neither.
  • Albert ... jabo 2011/01/05 23:28:23
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    He didn't disclose his original birth certificate because it would show that neither of his actual birth parents was black.
  • Opinion8ed 2011/01/04 07:37:41
    No
    Opinion8ed
    A qualified "NO". If the proof was legit, then I hope they'd drop it. But just having one of his flunkies say "trust me, he's okay." isn't proof at all. In fact, it screams "cover up!"

    What a nut that governor is. "it's an emotional insult, disrespectful to the office, etc."? WTF? What's an insult is that there is even an issue. If there are basically only two qualifications to being president: born in the US and being 35, then he should have had to show proof! I get asked for my "papers" every time I get stopped by a cop. I have to send in original docs (college transcripts, birth certificates, etc) for "regular" jobs. When I joined the military, they did everything but take a DNA test. They took blood, fingerprints, birth certificate, dental xrays, swimming test, etc. just to get into a military academy. You'd think the CINC (commander in chief) would have to at least produce one lousy document...the same one every member of the armed forces had to produce...to be the leader of the armed forces!

    I don't get why it had to be such a secret. It obviously begs the question, "what's he hiding?". There isn't anything embarrassing about it like we'll find out his middle name is Hussein, or that he's AB- blood type, or that he's got one testicle or whatever. It's ju...



    A qualified "NO". If the proof was legit, then I hope they'd drop it. But just having one of his flunkies say "trust me, he's okay." isn't proof at all. In fact, it screams "cover up!"

    What a nut that governor is. "it's an emotional insult, disrespectful to the office, etc."? WTF? What's an insult is that there is even an issue. If there are basically only two qualifications to being president: born in the US and being 35, then he should have had to show proof! I get asked for my "papers" every time I get stopped by a cop. I have to send in original docs (college transcripts, birth certificates, etc) for "regular" jobs. When I joined the military, they did everything but take a DNA test. They took blood, fingerprints, birth certificate, dental xrays, swimming test, etc. just to get into a military academy. You'd think the CINC (commander in chief) would have to at least produce one lousy document...the same one every member of the armed forces had to produce...to be the leader of the armed forces!

    I don't get why it had to be such a secret. It obviously begs the question, "what's he hiding?". There isn't anything embarrassing about it like we'll find out his middle name is Hussein, or that he's AB- blood type, or that he's got one testicle or whatever. It's just proof that he was born in the US! What could possibly keep him from whipping it out on request?? His refusal is VERY suspect. Imagine a plain clothes cop arresting you and REFUSING to show you his badge. Imagine the FBI kicking in your door and refusing to show you credentials. You get pulled over without proof of insurance...ticket. Hell, you have to have proof of identity to pick your kids up at school, get something notarized, two forms of ID to open a bank account, ID to buy beer or cigarettes, etc. But when someone asks for your proof to be elected the MOST POWERFUL PERSON IN THE WORLD, you can say "F-U. I ain't showin'!" And 300 million Americans are okay with that???

    The problem is that if he wasn't born in the US, I think he'd have to be impeached and ousted. I think the SC would have to rule the election invalid. And not as a Republican ploy but rather a CLEAR constitutional issue. Clearer than any free speech or gun rights issue is the requirement for being president. And that's what he's hiding. Actually, he might not even know if he was really born in the US. I only say I was born in Florida because I was always told that. I obviously don't remember being born in FL. Maybe he always thought he was and then after the election, his moms told him a little family secret. I can't imagine the DNC ran him thinking "we'll just keep this under the rug".

    After all, if he's eligible to remain president if the "truth" comes out against him, then I guess all bets are off. Any African Muslim can be the US president. I personally always wanted Arnold to run but thought he couldn't since he was born in Romania or Austria or wherever. Maybe he'll run after all!
    (more)
  • Albert ... Opinion8ed 2011/01/05 23:33:20
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    He's hiding the fact that he's not the son of a black Luo tribesman.
  • ChrisAH 2011/01/04 07:26:49
    No
    ChrisAH
    +1
    Its the same yappy idiots who keep yammering about him being a muslim - they will never STFU about these "issues" no matter what evidence is produced.
  • ucntbsrius 2011/01/04 07:15:12 (edited)
    No
    ucntbsrius
    They could have a video of President Obama's birth with backdrop of Hawaii out the window and the birthers wouldn't believe it. Rush and Beck would have a hard time convincing those wacko's
  • Kathy O... ucntbsrius 2011/01/04 14:21:14
    Kathy Overhauser
    Just the long form birth certificate would be nice for a start. Rush could not convice me of anything he is by his own admission an "entertainer". His rantings have nothing to do with news.
  • ucntbsrius Kathy O... 2011/01/04 21:56:31
    ucntbsrius
    Hawaii does not issue those. The hospital has cconfirmed he was born there. The state has confirmed he was born there. What else do you need?
  • Tim St. John 2011/01/04 06:42:17
    No
    Tim St. John
    At this point, I couldn't care less if he were born on the moon, he needs to get his ass in gear, and try to do something about this country and this economy !
  • Kathy O... Tim St.... 2011/01/04 14:22:29
    Kathy Overhauser
    Well he made a good start letting the bail out money for the banks go to foreign countries. Good way to get us "in the black."
  • bem179 Kathy O... 2011/01/04 19:02:02
    bem179
    Now I'll resort to your type of communication... 'WTF?????" are you talking about - you have no clue and the fact that some people will even believe these damaging lies your type like to spread, is apalling! Get a brain, even half a brain would help! Thank God there's not that many of you mal-functioning excuses for human beings around! God help us!
  • Albert ... Tim St.... 2011/01/05 23:35:52 (edited)
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    If he's ineligible, his feckless and harmful acts are null and void.

    Any necessary and proper acts that he has accidentally performed can be re-enacted.
  • nancy 2011/01/04 06:38:08
    No
    nancy
    It hasn't so far. Some people choose to be uninformed and instead, to get all their news from hate talk media commentators.
  • Albert ... nancy 2011/01/05 23:45:05
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    If you wish to be informed, check out the following:

    On Barry's status at birth, See "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II", at http://forums.about.com/n/pfx...
    Search for eingriff. Click on the first entry in the list, "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II". Read the first entry by eingriff. Go to the last entry, number 7 by eingriff. It's long. It will be easier to read and print out by clicking "View Full Message" at the end.

    See also Philip J. Berg, Esq., http://obamacrimes.com/?p=423.

    Exhaustive official investigations, which can be expected to result, if diligently conducted, in impeachment and prosecution, are essential. The Honorable Darrell Issa, by failing to do so much as subpoena Barry's vital records for fear of being viewed as "overreaching", is guilty of grave dereliction of duty. Both Congress and the public need to know the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, instead of disinformation.
  • shermanmeister 2011/01/04 06:28:43
    No
    shermanmeister
    +2
    there are just too many people who want to see Obama fail - their response will be that the evidence is "made up" ... it really is sad what we have become
  • Greywolf~In God We Trust~ 2011/01/04 06:26:47
  • frank 2011/01/04 06:23:03 (edited)
    Yes
    frank
    +1
    It would be neat to finally see the long form. Regular folks repeatedly have to produce documents for various events in their lives. I am sure I had to produce mine for passport and military service. I had it to produce. Apparently Obama does not have the document handy or he would have produced it. It is about right and wrong. Follow the rules. A respectable way to live a life.
  • RobertC... frank 2011/01/04 10:25:31
    RobertChristopherLaity
    If Obama was born in the Oval Office he would still be disqualified. His father was a Brit.Obama was born a Brit:
    http://www.thepostemail.com/2...
  • Albert ... RobertC... 2011/01/05 23:53:40
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    The alien named as his father in the COLB was an adoptive father. His birth parents were probably father: Caucasian; mother: predominantly Polynesian. Both U.S. citizens. As to his status at birth, the original birth certificate is Barry's ace in the hole. He doesn't want it disclosed because it would show he's not black, and it distracts the public from the real issue, that he was expatriated from the U.S. and became Indonesian as a lad and confirmed his Indonesian allegiance as an adult.

    On Barry's status at birth, See "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II", at http://forums.about.com/n/pfx...
    Search for eingriff. Click on the first entry in the list, "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II". Read the first entry by eingriff. Go to the last entry, number 7 by eingriff. It's long. It will be easier to read and print out by clicking "View Full Message" at the end.

    See also Philip J. Berg, Esq., http://obamacrimes.com/?p=423.

    Exhaustive official investigations, which can be expected to result, if diligently conducted, in impeachment and prosecution, are essential. The Honorable Darrell Issa, by failing to do so much as subpoena Barry's vital records for fear of being viewed as "overreaching", is guilty of grave dereliction of duty. Both Congress and the public need to know the truth, t...
    The alien named as his father in the COLB was an adoptive father. His birth parents were probably father: Caucasian; mother: predominantly Polynesian. Both U.S. citizens. As to his status at birth, the original birth certificate is Barry's ace in the hole. He doesn't want it disclosed because it would show he's not black, and it distracts the public from the real issue, that he was expatriated from the U.S. and became Indonesian as a lad and confirmed his Indonesian allegiance as an adult.

    On Barry's status at birth, See "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II", at http://forums.about.com/n/pfx...
    Search for eingriff. Click on the first entry in the list, "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II". Read the first entry by eingriff. Go to the last entry, number 7 by eingriff. It's long. It will be easier to read and print out by clicking "View Full Message" at the end.

    See also Philip J. Berg, Esq., http://obamacrimes.com/?p=423.

    Exhaustive official investigations, which can be expected to result, if diligently conducted, in impeachment and prosecution, are essential. The Honorable Darrell Issa, by failing to do so much as subpoena Barry's vital records for fear of being viewed as "overreaching", is guilty of grave dereliction of duty. Both Congress and the public need to know the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, instead of disinformation.
    (more)
  • bem179 frank 2011/01/04 19:05:39
    bem179
    ...yes, REALLY? ...and just why would that be "neat", as you put it? You say people like you " have to produce documents for various events in their lives"....and what do you think people have to produce to get into Harvard, and to get into the Presidency...????? Could you get any dumber???
  • Albert ... bem179 2011/01/06 00:02:08 (edited)
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    Yes, one could get dumber by forging ahead with an illegal alien as a usurper, regardless of ignorance of the essential facts to determine eligibility.

    One who wants to learn, instead of reveling in invincible ignorance, can start with analyses based on publicly available information.

    On Barry's status at birth, See "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II", at http://forums.about.com/n/pfx...
    Search for eingriff. Click on the first entry in the list, "Ancestry of Barack Hussein Obama II". Read the first entry by eingriff. Go to the last entry, number 7 by eingriff. It's long. It will be easier to read and print out by clicking "View Full Message" at the end.

    See also Philip J. Berg, Esq., http://obamacrimes.com/?p=423.

    Exhaustive official investigations, which can be expected to result, if diligently conducted, in impeachment and prosecution, are essential. The Honorable Darrell Issa, by failing to do so much as subpoena Barry's vital records for fear of being viewed as "overreaching", is guilty of grave dereliction of duty. Both Congress and the public need to know the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, instead of disinformation.
  • frank bem179 2011/01/06 10:06:21
    frank
    So then why was Obama allowed to run without producing a long form birth certificate? It would seem to be a simple thing for him to do if he had one. We have to submit to gropings if we fly and nude scatter scanner under the scrutiny of the TSA. To qualify for activities we sometimes have to submit to scrutiny. Not so our eminent leader.
  • Albert ... frank 2011/01/11 09:12:56
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    +1
    People didn't do their duty. Election officials of 49 states accepted certificates of nomination by the Democrats without the traditional certification of eligibility.

    Legislative and law enforcement officials did not investigate Barry's citizenship status.They must now play catch-up, but seem strung out and apathetic. Most officials are shirking their constitutional duty, putting the subject off with idiotic sound bites.
  • carol frank 2011/01/13 00:17:07
    carol
    Do you read? Hawaii did not have long form birth certificates at that time and may not still. Now I don't know but it was reported by Hawaiin officials that the birth certificate we have seen is what they had.
  • frank carol 2011/01/13 09:05:11
    frank
    I wonder how something like that could have happened. I was born way back in 1950 and my parents were born in the thirties. We all have birth certificates and have had to use them at various times in our lives. Many have been asleep at the switch.
  • carol frank 2011/01/18 14:28:20
    carol
    I was born in the 40's. My kids in the 60's and 70's. And the BC are all different from each others. Athough different in appearance, all short forms mailed by the State with the embossed seal on them. No doctors signature on them and no footprints. But some of these people seem to think because their birth certificate appears different from Obama's, that HIS must be a fake because it is different from THEIRS.

    I'm sure Obama has his birth certificate. I would think since it has been verified by a dozen sources by now it should be enough. Should 3000 people line up so he can show it to them individually when it's already been vertified by higher sources than themselves? They wouldn't believe it if they saw it because they simply don't want to because to get others to follow their conspiracy they have hatched up would have no more meaning.
  • frank carol 2011/01/28 04:47:22
    frank
    No one has reported seeing verification of his authenticity. I am not crazy just curious and I have read the US Constitution. He at this time does not act like a natural born US citizen.
  • Roblem BN-0 2011/01/04 06:08:23
    No
    Roblem BN-0
    +1
    http://www.factcheck.org/elec...

    But then I suppose one could argue that factcheck is just a liberal/democratic run scam. People believe what they WANT to believe and sadly many gobble up the misinformation especially when it fits in with their own view point.
  • Konraden Roblem ... 2011/01/04 06:16:11
    Konraden
    Reality has a liberal bias.
  • bem179 Konraden 2011/01/04 19:07:51
    bem179
    It's because only the Liberals seem to live in a "REAL" world!
  • Albert ... Roblem ... 2011/01/06 00:15:58
    Albert W. L. Moore, Jr.
    I'm assuming the COLB is true as far as it goes.

    But it is inherently ambiguous. The parents named could be adoptive parents from the amended birth certificate or birth parents.from the original birth certificate, the contemporaneous record of birth.

    Whatever one wants to believe, the original birth certificate is necessary to confirm the true birth parents; to exclude a possible (albeit not probable) ringer, DNA analysis is called for, also.

    See the reply to bem179.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/25 17:54:26

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals