Quantcast

Why Obama's Decision To Stop Deporting DREAM-Eligible Youth Is Good For The Economy

ProudProgressive 2012/06/15 15:52:08
Why Obama's Decision To Stop Deporting DREAM-Eligible Youth Is Good For The Economy
By Travis Waldron
Jun 15, 2012

President Obama will announce a new immigration policy today that will allow some undocumented youths to avoid deportation and receive work permits to remain in the United States. Students in the U.S. who are in deportation proceedings or those who would have qualified for the DREAM Act and have yet to come forward to Department of Homeland Security officials will not be deported and will be allowed to work in the United States.

Though exact details of the plan are still unclear, it could benefit as many as one million undocumented students living in the country, and it will almost certainly have tangible benefits for the long-term health of the American economy.

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated that the DREAM Act — which Republicans blocked in 2010 — would increase federal revenues by $1.7 billion over the next 10 years, reducing federal deficits by $2.2 billion over that time. DREAM-eligible students would generate between $1.4 and $3.6 trillion in taxable income over the course of their working lives, according to a study by UCLA's North American Integration and Development Center.

DREAM-eligible youth could also help fill the 16 million shortfall of college-educated workers that is expected to hit the U.S. by 2025, and with 31.5 percent of science and engineering graduates coming from Latino backgrounds, Obama's decision could add 252,000 new scientists, engineers, and technical workers to the nation's dwindling supply in those fields.

The decision will help raise wages for American workers too. "As long as a cheap, compliant pool of undocumented labor is available, employers have every reason to take advantage of the situation, keeping wages as low as possible," Cristina Jimenez wrote in the American Prospect in 2010. "Only when undocumented immigrants have the ability to exercise complete workplace rights will they help exert upward pressure on wages and labor standards that will benefit other workers."

These benefits are obvious even to leading Republicans. "The economy will be better when that [undocumented] kid is able to fully realize his potential and break the pattern of his parent's illegal activity," former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee (R) said in 2010. Obama's decision isn't just good because it protects young adults who have spent most of their lives establishing homes in the United States, it's good because it will help our struggling economy too.

Read More: http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2012/06/15/500354...

You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • jubil8 BN-0 PON 2012/06/16 18:56:09
    jubil8 BN-0 PON
    +1
    This article is so one-sided it should fall over and be stomped into the ground.

    How about all the LEGAL citizens of LEGAL parents who WON'T go to college and have jobs because of these "DREAM-eligible students?" The DREAM Act was defeated, stop giving it CPR.

    A study says these "eligible" people will generate $1.4-$3.6 Trillion in taxable income. Wouldn't the same LEGAL people generate the same income?

    A procedure exists for illegals to become legal: Leave, pay a fee, and reenter legally. Sayonara, see you in 6 months, don't let the border hit you in the ass on the way out.

    Alternatively, enlist for 2 years and pay back some of the money you've enjoyed at legal citizens' expense FIRST.

    And what about the teeny fact that the President of the U.S. is ignoring and side-stepping the law he has sworn to uphold? Doesn't matter? YES, IT DOES!!!
  • Flowers 2012/06/15 19:23:28
    Flowers
    +1
    Wouldn't it be easier to have all the people who are illegal go back to their own countries, make them apply and pay the fees like everyone else does, and explain to the the citizens that if they want the country to continue they will have to accept that some jobs aren't CEO's and have wages that are fair for the job they are doing. Why should we reward the people who continue to break the law by being here illegally? there are so many other more important things that this country should be working on. Like figuring out a way to educate the children of our country more efficiently without throwing more money at the states. Citizens, not illegals, first. Why is it that only the USA is worried more about illegals then it's own citizens?
  • darcie lamar 2012/06/15 18:02:05
  • ProudPr... darcie ... 2012/06/16 01:15:51
    ProudProgressive
    That's right. Illegal immigrants cost us a fortune. So by taking a few hundred thousand people off the rolls of illegals, we save money.

    Did you not bother to read your own article? I can't believe you'd agree with the President on anything.
  • Evil 1 2012/06/15 17:23:11
    Evil 1
    +2
    All that can be said in response to that heap of steaming BS is.................


    response heap steaming bs
  • Sport_Geoff 2012/06/15 17:11:58
    Sport_Geoff
    +1
    The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated that the DREAM Act — which Republicans blocked in 2010 — would increase federal revenues by $1.7 billion over the next 10 years, reducing federal deficits by $2.2 billion over that time. DREAM-eligible students would generate between $1.4 and $3.6 trillion in taxable income over the course of their working lives, according to a study by UCLA's North American Integration and Development Center.

    Only an ignorant liberal or progressive can make 1.7 billion in revenues equal 2.2 billion in deficit reduction. It's smoke and mirrors math that ASSUMES the 1.7 billion would actually be applied to debt in which case if it was there would be a 2.2 billion savings because of interest payments.

    The problem with this is that democrats have never applied any increase in tax revenue to the debt they strictly use it to fund and run up more debt with ignorant ass projects that benefit no one but themselves, family members, and donors. The other lie that isnt being told is that most likely every freaking dime of the 1.7 billion and then some more is refunded to these illegals because they are poor and suck up millions more in welfare and illegal child credits taken for their kids living in Mexico.

    The B.S. is getting deep and Obama and the libtards are in panic mode as evidenced by Obama illegal ass kissing just announced.
  • ProudPr... Sport_G... 2012/06/16 01:18:22
    ProudProgressive
    God, can't you understand the simplest things? the 2.2 billion in deficit reduction doesn't all come from increased revenues. It also figures in the fact that with less illegals to track and try to capture we won't be spending as much. But you tell me which costs more - keeping an illegal alien in a jail cell for months or years while our wonderfully efficient legal system works through the case or letting him work, support himself, pay taxes, and contribute to society?
  • Kanaka Rican - Now's the ti... 2012/06/15 16:09:52
    Kanaka Rican - Now's the time for ACTION
    +7
    So, let’s eliminate the process….eliminate Congress….
    WE LIVE IN A REPUBLIC! THIS IS NOT A DICTATORSHIP!

    OMG......Obama MUST GO!

    obama must go
  • lm1b2 2012/06/15 16:07:43
    lm1b2
    +3
    How about the Dream of US citizens that ALL illegal aliens be deported,and all of our immigration laws be enforced,and all illegal Drugs,and Guns, be stopped,along with people by securing our Border with Mexico by using US troops if need be!
  • ProudPr... lm1b2 2012/06/15 16:52:59
    ProudProgressive
    +2
    The majority of Americans support the DREAM Act. It's true that some, like you, do have dreams of an ethnic cleansing of America so that only rich white male "Christians" are left (with women kept as slaves, of course), but most Americans respect and support the principles this nation was founded on.
  • tommyg ... ProudPr... 2012/06/15 17:10:55
    tommyg - POTL- PWCM-JLA
    +1
    Show me the data point where the majority of Americans support the DREAM Act.
  • ProudPr... tommyg ... 2012/06/16 01:13:28 (edited)
    ProudProgressive
    +1
    http://www.jsonline.com/blogs...


    "The poll showed that 66% of all registered voters support giving undocumented immigrants the latitude to remain in the country and eventually qualify for citizenship on the condition that they meet requirements including learning English, paying back taxes, and pass background checks. Even more surprising, 57% of Republicans surveyed in the December poll supported a path to citizenship under the same requirements."
  • tommyg ... ProudPr... 2012/06/16 02:04:56
    tommyg - POTL- PWCM-JLA
    +1
    Thanks for the link. You know Proud, until the border is secure, all this is moot.
  • lm1b2 ProudPr... 2012/06/16 00:32:01
    lm1b2
    BS,We just want our borders secured,and our immigration laws enforced just like every Nation on Earth does! You are a Ass H_ _ _ Amigo!
  • The Lib... ProudPr... 2012/06/16 01:16:03 (edited)
    The Lib Hater.
    +2
    Get off that crap, you know dam well what's going on here, and the idea is to give energy to the Hispanic voters. See lib, the move comes in an election year in which the Hispanic vote could be critical in swing states like Colorado, Nevada and Florida.
    This is why the Muslim,along with the Socialist Party is deliberately re-engineering the country’s demographics. Caucasian Americans are being ethnically cleansed through displacement. Treason is too mild a word for it. Would you agree Comrade?
    Time Cover Promotes the Illegal Alien Invasion.
    cleansed displacement treason mild comrade cover promotes illegal alien invasion
  • ProudPr... lm1b2 2012/06/15 16:53:42
    ProudProgressive
    +1
    The majority of Americans support the DREAM Act. It's true that some, like you, do have dreams of an ethnic cleansing of America so that only rich white male "Christians" are left (with women kept as slaves, of course), but most Americans respect and support the principles this nation was founded on.
  • tommyg ... ProudPr... 2012/06/15 17:13:18
    tommyg - POTL- PWCM-JLA
    +1
    You hit all the "hot points" with that comment. You earned your name with this one.

    rich - class warfare
    white - racial warfare
    male - gender warfare
    Christians - religious warfare
  • ProudPr... tommyg ... 2012/06/16 01:22:15
    ProudProgressive
    +2
    I forgot to include heterosexual.

    And you're right. it is a war. A war launched on January 20, 1981 by Ronald Reagan that's been raging for the last 30 years. A war to deprive women of their right to control their own bodies and to have access to the medical care they need. A war to roll back the Civil Rights Act and every other antidiscrimination law we've passed in the last century because "we have a right to discriminate if we want to". A war to destroy the American middle class by breaking the unions that built the most prosperous nation in the history of the world, diverting more and more of the nation's wealth into fewer and fewer hands, forcing people to work for pennies in factories that we can't have any safety regulations for because that's "big government taking over", and even a war to get into your bedroom to make sure that the person you're sleeping with has the "right" anatomy.
  • Sport_G... ProudPr... 2012/06/15 17:13:29
    Sport_Geoff
    +3
    Post a valid poll proving this lie....don't put anything from Stinkprogress up because everyone knows that next to you they are the biggest liars on the internet.
  • ProudPr... Sport_G... 2012/06/16 01:22:59
    ProudProgressive
    http://www.jsonline.com/blogs...
    http://peoplesworld.org/dream...

    "The poll showed that 66% of all registered voters support giving undocumented immigrants the latitude to remain in the country and eventually qualify for citizenship on the condition that they meet requirements including learning English, paying back taxes, and pass background checks. Even more surprising, 57% of Republicans surveyed in the December poll supported a path to citizenship under the same requirements."
  • The Lib... ProudPr... 2012/06/16 01:06:44
  • ProudPr... The Lib... 2012/06/16 01:23:41 (edited)
    ProudProgressive
    I always back up what I say. What do you think I am, a conservative?

    http://www.jsonline.com/blogs...

    "The poll showed that 66% of all registered voters support giving undocumented immigrants the latitude to remain in the country and eventually qualify for citizenship on the condition that they meet requirements including learning English, paying back taxes, and pass background checks. Even more surprising, 57% of Republicans surveyed in the December poll supported a path to citizenship under the same requirements."
  • Todd~AFCL ProudPr... 2012/06/16 02:25:14
    Todd~AFCL
    +1
    It is very rare that you back up anything you say, PP! In fact, when you do provide links, they are usually from a far left source that is trying to shape public opinion instead of reporting on it. These Gallup polls are no different. http://spectator.org/blog/201...
  • The Lib... ProudPr... 2012/06/16 02:36:47 (edited)
    The Lib Hater.
    +3
    Look here that 0bama is in full panic mode. Why? Because people are paying attention, and we don't like what we are seeing or what we are getting from 0bama.
    First the churches, then women, then Bain Capital, then gays, and now this. Not going to work P.P. that Muslim is throwing everything up against the wall, hoping something's gonna stick. He's getting slammed hard in the media over this speech yesterday. And now, don't deport the young illegals; give 'em work permits. Wonder what that will do to the unemployment number? LOL...Voters ARE Paying Attention.
    OBAMA
  • Todd~AFCL ProudPr... 2012/06/16 01:26:30
    Todd~AFCL
    +1
    You're right on one point; most Americans do respect and support the principles this nation was founded on. However, that number excludes people like you who are celebrating the fact that 0bama is rewarding criminal actions and undermining the rights of citizens.
    By the way, do you know the difference between Communists and Modern American Liberals?
    The Communists support their military and protect their borders. Other than that, there is NO difference.
    http://www.illegalimmigration...
    http://www.fairus.org/facts/p...
  • ProudPr... Todd~AFCL 2012/06/16 01:27:43
    ProudProgressive
    How is it a criminal action for an infant to be carried across a border? And no one's rights are being undermined by this action.
  • tommyg ... ProudPr... 2012/06/16 02:09:15
    tommyg - POTL- PWCM-JLA
    +2
    I didn't think you guys gave babies any rights. (small snicker)
  • Todd~AFCL ProudPr... 2012/06/16 02:14:54
    Todd~AFCL
    +1
    This is NOT about infants! Do you even read your own posts to see how ignorant they appear?
    So tell me, how does allowing illegal immigrants take jobs from citizens NOT undermine the rights of citizens?
    How does 0bama breaking the laws not do this as well?
    http://www.americanthinker.co...
  • The Lib... ProudPr... 2012/06/18 13:31:31 (edited)
  • Rebel Yell 2012/06/15 16:06:15
    Rebel Yell
    +3
    The " Send them all over the border" and " Shoot on sight" crowds will be along shortly with "Obama the Dictator " and " Amnesty" talk. Consider the source.

    Most people have no idea whatsoever how wildly expensive deportation is. Let's start with the cost. According to the Department of Homeland Security, in 2010 alone it spent roughly $9.2 billion to deport 392,000 individuals. That comes out to about $23,500 per person. Why so expensive? Over half came here by plane and must be returned the same way.
    Assuming that the cost of rounding up 11-20 million is scalable (which is almost certainly not the case), it would cost about $263 billion to deport all illegal immigrants. That is about twice what we are currently spending annually in Afghanistan. In actuality, the cost would be much higher, because trying to ramp up to arrest and deport 11 million in a short time would be enormously difficult.

    So, what to do with them? They can continue to hide out and work minimum jobs, or we can put them on a path to citizenship where they get to pay into Social Security and Medicare just like everyone else.

    But that old cry about just rounding them all up smacks of sheer ignorance.
  • Dana Rebel Yell 2012/06/15 23:16:18
    Dana
    Damn. All the logic is probably way too hard for these nim wits on here. Great job though, you educated me at least!!
  • tommyg - POTL- PWCM-JLA 2012/06/15 16:03:21
    tommyg - POTL- PWCM-JLA
    +5
    Nothing this President has done has helped the economy. Why should I think this would be any different?
  • ProudPr... tommyg ... 2012/06/15 16:57:06
    ProudProgressive
    +3
    Excuse me? Four and a half million private sector jobs created? More manufacturing jobs created in 2011 alone than in all eight years of the Bush Administration? Turning 750,000 jobs a month lost into 27 consecutive months of private sector growth? Dropping the unemployment rate two full points from the Bush highs? Doubling the stock market indexes? The lowest rate of government spending in 30 years? Cutting YOUR taxes? Cutting taxes for small businesses EIGHTEEN times?
  • Todd~AFCL ProudPr... 2012/06/16 06:16:44
    Todd~AFCL
    +1
    I guess you don't want to talk about the 5 million jobs lost during his first 14 months, or the fact that even at the end of Bush's administration there were more jobs than at the beginning. http://www.freerepublic.com/f... And I know you don't want to talk about the true unemployment numbers or even how the White House manipulates the numbers to make O-Blame-O look good! http://larrymwalkerjr.blogspo...
    Could you at least tell us how devaluing our money is NOT a defacto tax increase? http://www.forbes.com/sites/c... Who cares if the stock market indexes are going when the value of the dollar is going down?
    Claiming that the rate of government spending is at its lowest in 30 years is just a lie!
    http://hotair.com/archives/20...
  • zbacku 2012/06/15 15:57:01
    zbacku
    +4
    I anyone thinks that a President that over rides Congress in everything he does they are only blinding themselves to the fact that this president is just one step away from declaring himself a Dictator. That my friend is not good for the economy or anything else.
  • Sparky zbacku 2012/06/15 15:59:44 (edited)
  • Mr. T Sparky 2012/06/15 16:21:47
    Mr. T
    +3
    And look at who bought into it....hehehe (poster)
  • ProudPr... zbacku 2012/06/15 16:58:45
    ProudProgressive
    +2
    When Congress refuses to act it is the President's responsibility to do everything within his Constitutional powers to "establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity." The majority of the American people support the DREAM Act, and only the most hardline conservatives consider a baby who was carried across a border to be a criminal.
  • Dana zbacku 2012/06/15 23:17:55
    Dana
    +1
    Overrides congress? How? If he could do that, we would not be in the F'ing mess we are in!!!!!!!!!!!! Congress IS the reason why so much is so screwed up! Only they can write and pass the bills. All the POTUS can do is sign or veto, he does not even get a vote.

News & Politics

2013/05/20 05:47:41

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals