Quantcast

Why are Mitt Romney's tax returns so important to the Obama Campaign?

sarah.j.frohberg2010 2012/08/18 14:30:35
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Zuggi 2012/08/18 15:32:34
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    Zuggi
    +9
    Because Romney and Ryan want to cut the tax rate on the richest; if Obama can show that the richest already pay a lower rate than the vast majority of Americans that shows that the real class warfare is being waged by the rich against the middle class.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • carl.noon.3 2012/08/21 23:32:23
  • sjalan 2012/08/20 05:35:58
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    sjalan
    Whis is most certainly buried in Mitt Romney Tax Returns. Which we still don't know if they were even FILED IN THE US!!! They could easily have been filed in one of the countries where Bain Capital deposits his checks each month! We KNOW he still gets an income from them we just don't know how much and what kind.
  • nothingbutthetruth 2012/08/20 01:41:24
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    nothingbutthetruth
  • melly~thwarting Satan since... 2012/08/19 23:58:30
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    melly~thwarting Satan since 1971
    +5
    They're important to voters, not the Obama campaign. It's disturbing, and grossly unfair, that he pays a lower percentage than hardworking poor and middle class families. That his horse gets a 77k deduction each year and your kid gets a 1k.
  • luvguins 2012/08/19 23:43:52
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    luvguins
    +7
    Must be dirt to dig up like tax evasion if he won't show his income tax returns. Tax evasion is a felony and would disqualify him for president. Mitts tax returns
  • **Starz... luvguins 2012/08/19 23:56:13
    **StarzAbove**
    +4
    I think you're absolutey right. Unless he shows them soon, it's gonna be his Waterloo!
  • luvguins **Starz... 2012/08/20 00:32:12
    luvguins
    +4
    It is not going away as 63% of voters polled are asking for them.
  • **Starz... luvguins 2012/08/20 00:34:12
    **StarzAbove**
    +4
    I know, I heard tonight that he was going to release a couple more years but only when he feels like it. When do you think that will be? Never, I'm thinking.
  • luvguins **Starz... 2012/08/20 00:51:41
    luvguins
    +4
    The staff must be busy forging them for Mitt to hide his ooffshore dough.
  • **Starz... luvguins 2012/08/20 00:53:20
    **StarzAbove**
    +4
    I think you're right. What a crook he's turned out to be. People better wake up to this guy before it's too late.
  • Dweezle 2012/08/19 06:15:23
    Because the President has no record to run on.
    Dweezle
    +3
    Typical one sided Right wing slanted question with only LIES as answers. The American PEOPLE want to see the Tax returns. all recent Presidential candidates have produced them. It is Rmoney that is intent on hiding the truth from the nation. His Swiss, Caribbean, and other offshore accounts. He is a typical Banker Thief!
  • Idiot repubs 2012/08/18 22:52:06
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    Idiot repubs
    +7
    tax evading draft dodging corporate raider - ROMNEY!!
  • **StarzAbove** 2012/08/18 16:49:29
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    **StarzAbove**
    +7
    Poor choices as usual.

    If Romney can't trust the American people enough to show us his records, why should we trust him. Obama The Right Man For The Job
  • Wilde~MoonChild ™ 2012/08/18 16:34:14
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    Wilde~MoonChild ™
    +8
    And I'm sure there is dirt to dig up, and Ann Romney pretty much said so when she said they just want ammunition. If there isn't anything wrong, there's no ammunition. Romney's father set the example by showing his records, and Mittens can't even come through.. what a disappointment.
  • Zuggi 2012/08/18 15:32:34
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    Zuggi
    +9
    Because Romney and Ryan want to cut the tax rate on the richest; if Obama can show that the richest already pay a lower rate than the vast majority of Americans that shows that the real class warfare is being waged by the rich against the middle class.
  • FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX 2012/08/18 15:24:30 (edited)
    Because they want to dig up dirt.
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +8
    There is no doubt that he has filed. That is not in question. I also have no doubt he paid some amount of tax - most likely very low but again that is not the main concern.

    The most likely reason Mitt is hiding his returns is that they contain evidence of at least 2 felonies. 1) If he filed his primary residence was Utah when he was running for governor of Massachusetts (a felony) and 2) Tax Amnesty for his admitted previously held Swiss Bank Accounts. If the Romneys had filed under the Tax Amnesty program they would have had to first admit they committed a felony by sheltering income in Switzerland.

    Statements made by the Romneys indicate an extremely high possibility that either if not both of the above are true. That is not just "dirt" ... That is grounds for disqualification.
  • sarah.j... FAWKES'... 2012/08/18 15:28:06
    sarah.j.frohberg2010
    If that is the case then Obama should be forced out of office now because his birthplace is in question.
  • sarah.j... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 15:31:12
    sarah.j.frohberg2010
    +1
    Another disqualification which was ignored in 2008. I guess the old saying if you live in a glass home you should not cast stones does not apply here. Even though it will never be revealed Obama is not qualified Constitutionally to be president. When your own Grandmother said that you were born in Kenya and no one picked up on it there is something wrong
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 15:37:54
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +6
    It is impossible for President Obama to have been born in Kenya. The passport records of Stanley Ann Dunham show that the earliest she could have held a Passport to leave the country was 1965.

    Existing Passport Records of Stanley Ann Dunham:

    http://www.scribd.com/puzo1/d...

    The earliest record is for a 1968 renewal of her passport dated July 19, 1965 which extended her passport a further 2 years to July 18, 1970. Pub. L. 86-267 in 1959 stated the initial term of a passport to be 3 years and renewal to 5 years, therefore the July 1965 passport can only be her first passport since it had to be renewed 3 years later, which she did on August 13, 1968 through the US Embassy in Indonesia. If it was a second renewal, she wouldn't have had to file until 1970.

    On July 26, 1968, Pub. L. 90-428 provided provisions that "a passport or passport visa be limited to a period of three years, that a passport be renewed pursuant to regulations of the Secretary for a period not to exceed two years, provided that the final date of expiration not be more than five years from the original date of issue, that the Secretary be authorized to limit the validity of a passport, passport visa, or period of renewal of a passport to less than two years." - Therefore her 1968 renewal application was renewed unti...





    It is impossible for President Obama to have been born in Kenya. The passport records of Stanley Ann Dunham show that the earliest she could have held a Passport to leave the country was 1965.

    Existing Passport Records of Stanley Ann Dunham:

    http://www.scribd.com/puzo1/d...

    The earliest record is for a 1968 renewal of her passport dated July 19, 1965 which extended her passport a further 2 years to July 18, 1970. Pub. L. 86-267 in 1959 stated the initial term of a passport to be 3 years and renewal to 5 years, therefore the July 1965 passport can only be her first passport since it had to be renewed 3 years later, which she did on August 13, 1968 through the US Embassy in Indonesia. If it was a second renewal, she wouldn't have had to file until 1970.

    On July 26, 1968, Pub. L. 90-428 provided provisions that "a passport or passport visa be limited to a period of three years, that a passport be renewed pursuant to regulations of the Secretary for a period not to exceed two years, provided that the final date of expiration not be more than five years from the original date of issue, that the Secretary be authorized to limit the validity of a passport, passport visa, or period of renewal of a passport to less than two years." - Therefore her 1968 renewal application was renewed until July 18, 1970 (less than 2 years). http://codes.lp.findlaw.com/u...

    Also, there are no records of Barack Obama Sr. leaving the country until 1965, which matters unless you are implying she went to Kenya to have a baby by herself.

    This proves the President was born IN THE UNITED STATES without even needing to look at a birth certificate as his mother could not have held a valid passport to travel anywhere else in 1961. If you still don't believe it was Hawaii.. fine. Call it Cleveland then. It doesn't matter.

    Birther logic: "I'm a US citizen and about to have a baby so I think I'll fly halfway around the world to have it in a 3rd World country - without a passport."
    (more)
  • Wilde~M... FAWKES'... 2012/08/18 16:27:16
    Wilde~MoonChild ™
    +5
    Are we doing this again??
  • FAWKES'... Wilde~M... 2012/08/18 16:43:01
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +6
    LOL!! Yuuuuuuup!

    dead horse gif
  • Wilde~M... FAWKES'... 2012/08/18 20:20:01
    Wilde~MoonChild ™
    +8
    Just stupid! They really should be embarrassed but they aren't bright enough to know it!
  • **Starz... Wilde~M... 2012/08/20 00:32:49
  • **Starz... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 16:52:20
    **StarzAbove**
    +6
    It if was ignored then it was ignored by your Republican Party as well. Even the top republicans have agreed he was born in Hawaii. Only the birthers who have nothing better to argue about would believe that nonsense.
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 15:36:32
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +6
    No. Its not. The President's place of birth has been duly Certified by the State of Hawaii. If you have a problem with that you'll have to take it up with Governor Abercrombie.

    But now that you mention it, Mitt Romney has also failed to provide his Certified Long Form Birth Certificate. He has only presented an abstract of birth from a State where his father formerly held the Governor's seat. The document Mitt provided contains no original information - only a computer record of data "on file." When President Obama presented his abstract, Cons said that was unacceptable and demanded a Long Form Birth Certificate.

    Its only OK for the White Guy, right?
  • sarah.j... FAWKES'... 2012/08/18 15:40:19
    sarah.j.frohberg2010
    +1
    Please do not play the race card, Obama is half WHITE too! and I am by far not racist
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 15:42:49
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +5
    Then explain another reason why Obama must provide a Certified Long Form Birth Certificate but Mitt Romney does not.

    There is a much greater chance Mitt was born outside the United States than Obama. The President's mother was on an island with no passport. Mitt's family has had ties to Mexico for generations and travel between the US and Mexico was virtually unrestricted in 1947.
  • sarah.j... FAWKES'... 2012/08/18 15:52:02
    sarah.j.frohberg2010
    My cousin was born in the UK when my Uncle and Aunt were stationed in England she had duel citizenship for a while, under your research would that disqualify her for a run for President? Mitt Romney's FATHER was born in Mexico
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com...
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 16:01:35 (edited)
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +5
    If your cousin was born on the US Military Base where your Aunt and Uncle were stationed than he/she was born on US Soil and therefore automatically a US Citizen under Jus Soli and eligible for the Presidency. John McCain's birth was under similar circumstance.

    Now explain why the President must provide a Certified Long Form Birth Certificate but Mitt Romney does not.
  • sarah.j... FAWKES'... 2012/08/18 16:08:14
    sarah.j.frohberg2010
    I will explain when you provide the proof that the Romney's were Mexican nationals
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 16:14:39 (edited)
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +5
    That information is academic. You can look it up anywhere. Simply the fact that George Romney was born in Mexico automatically makes him a Mexican National. Some brief info in Gaskell Romney for you also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

    QUID PRO QUO. Answer my question first. You claim your demand for the President's Birth Certificate is not motivated by race. Explain why the President must provide a Certified Long Form Birth Certificate but Mitt Romney does not.
  • sarah.j... FAWKES'... 2012/08/18 16:16:44
    sarah.j.frohberg2010
    That does not disqualify Mitt to run as president though, his parents were citizens, His grandparents had dual citizenship. Just because they were doing mission work in Mexico does not make their children Mexican nationals. Find the proof
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 16:45:31
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +6
    I didn't say it did. My question was "Why do you demand the President must provide a Certified Long Form Birth Certificate but Mitt Romney does not have to." I say that demand is race-based. You insist it is not. So tell us the reason. Aren't you going to defend yourself?

    The felonies in Mitt's tax returns will disqualify him for the Presidency, not where he was born.
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 17:36:54
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 20:15:08
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +7
    I thought so.

    "ITS ONLY OK FOR THE WHITE GUY"
  • Wilde~M... FAWKES'... 2012/08/20 04:05:24
    Wilde~MoonChild ™
    +1
    I'm not sure she realizes her inability to answer your simple question solidifies your assertion! You might want to let her know, because this is starting to get painful it's so obvious!!
  • sarah.j... FAWKES'... 2012/08/18 15:55:46
    sarah.j.frohberg2010
    +1
    His GRANDPARENTS were MORMAN MISSIONARIES! US CITIZENS doing work through their church in Mexico
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 15:59:08 (edited)
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +5
    That is half correct. Romney's recent ancestors were run out of the United States to avoid prosecution for polygamy. They took up residence in Mexico, became Mexican Nationals and established a branch of the LDS Church there. There were not merely "doing missionary work."
  • sarah.j... FAWKES'... 2012/08/18 16:10:45
    sarah.j.frohberg2010
    +1
    Show me where you are finding this information, because what I am finding is that they were doing missionary work. If that is the case, then all children of missionaries would be disqualified.
  • FAWKES'... sarah.j... 2012/08/18 16:50:36 (edited)
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +4
    I already gave you a link. Feel free to look up other sources on your own though.

    "Miles Park Romney and his three wives and various children were then sent to settle St. Johns, Ariz., as part of the church leadership’s plan to settle across the entire American West. St. Johns was not particularly welcoming to the Mormon newcomers, and after various threats to hang the lot of them, the polygamous Romney family was told to try Mexico instead."

    "Gaskell Romney moved to Mexico when his father helped to found the Mormon colony in Colonia Dublán, Galeana, Chihuahua, Mexico, in 1885. The Romney families lost their holdings in Chihuahua during the Mexican Revolution and in 1912 Romney moved back to the United States. Eventually he was reimbursed by the Mexican government for some of his losses. He married in 1895 to Anna Amelia Pratt. Romney was the father of five sons: Maurice, Douglas, Miles Pratt Romney, George W. Romney, Lawrence and Charles. Gaskell himself was a candidate for County Commissioner 1931 as a Republican. He died in Salt Lake City, Utah, on March 7, 1955 and is buried in Wasatch Lawn Memorial Park in the city"

    Incidentally, note that: "Eventually he was reimbursed by the Mexican government for some of his losses." The Mexican Government would not have done this unless ...
    I already gave you a link. Feel free to look up other sources on your own though.

    "Miles Park Romney and his three wives and various children were then sent to settle St. Johns, Ariz., as part of the church leadership’s plan to settle across the entire American West. St. Johns was not particularly welcoming to the Mormon newcomers, and after various threats to hang the lot of them, the polygamous Romney family was told to try Mexico instead."

    "Gaskell Romney moved to Mexico when his father helped to found the Mormon colony in Colonia Dublán, Galeana, Chihuahua, Mexico, in 1885. The Romney families lost their holdings in Chihuahua during the Mexican Revolution and in 1912 Romney moved back to the United States. Eventually he was reimbursed by the Mexican government for some of his losses. He married in 1895 to Anna Amelia Pratt. Romney was the father of five sons: Maurice, Douglas, Miles Pratt Romney, George W. Romney, Lawrence and Charles. Gaskell himself was a candidate for County Commissioner 1931 as a Republican. He died in Salt Lake City, Utah, on March 7, 1955 and is buried in Wasatch Lawn Memorial Park in the city"

    Incidentally, note that: "Eventually he was reimbursed by the Mexican government for some of his losses." The Mexican Government would not have done this unless they were Mexican Citizens. Additionally, you are actually attempting to imply that the Romneys established a Mormon Colony in Mexico as illegal aliens. That in itself is absurd. They were Mexican Citizens. How hard do you think it was to become a Mexican Citizen in 1885? $2 and sign your name or make your mark.
    (more)

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/24 21:43:00

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals