Who's hotter? Alyson Hannigan or Amber Benson?

by Jane Posted 2009/11/04 04:46:56

Read More

114 votes
Read all 71 opinions
View Results and Demographics + View Demographics

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	Alyson Hannigan.	44 votes	39%
	Amber Benson.	30 votes	26%
	Can't choose.	40 votes	35%

Add a comment above

kkhurshi 2009/11/04 13:00:21

Can't choose.

+6
both are pretty....
>> See Replies

More polls by Jane

acb3w 2013/03/28 07:03:37

Amber Benson.

AMBER BENSON!! I've had the hugest crush on her since watching "The Crush" when I was 10 LOL. Those eyes and those cheekbones...YUUUMMM. (Those EYES...)

I think Alyson is adorable, and I'd even say that she is definitely HOT now that she's in her late 30's. But Amber has had my heart for almost 17 years now. I love that woman!

reply
steven.luther1 2013/03/07 00:57:15

Alyson Hannigan.

reply
wallygator64 2012/07/11 23:37:42

Alyson Hannigan.

I liked her in the American Pie movies,as well as Buffy and How I met your mother.

reply
Brosia 2012/07/04 16:16:12

Alyson Hannigan.

I have always loved her.

reply
dahvievanity<3er 2012/06/15 00:40:27

Can't choose.

i dont know who one is so its not fair

reply
waternymphxD 2012/06/13 20:39:36

Can't choose.

As iv said before neither are HOT they are PRETTY:) hot is Scarlett johannsen and J. Lo!

reply
BBCoach 2012/06/13 20:21:53

Alyson Hannigan.

Alyson Hannigan is HOT

reply
Wayne TH G 333 2012/06/13 14:09:57

Alyson Hannigan.

reply
Sister Jean 2012/06/13 14:02:53

Can't choose.

both

reply
Laura Lovegood 2012/06/13 13:59:08
Jack's Pearl 2012/06/13 13:56:07

Alyson Hannigan.

+1
By far to me.

reply
GinnyWeasley_13 2012/06/13 12:32:20

Can't choose.

+1

reply
tWiLiGhT 2009/12/11 02:15:02

Can't choose.

+2
There Both Hott its IMPOSSOBLE to choose!!!

reply
Jane to tWiLiGhT 2009/12/14 01:48:38

+1
I know!! Haha!!

reply
rlbdo 2009/11/30 07:13:00

Amber Benson.

+2
I used to be a big Alyson fan but as of recently switched to Amber. I don't know why! Both are so very sweet and gorgeous, though :)

reply
Jane to rlbdo 2009/11/30 23:22:08

+1
They are!! Did you watch buffy??

reply
gingertwin2 2009/11/11 18:04:41

Can't choose.

+2
. . . They are both beautiful women.

reply
Jane to gingert... 2009/11/11 18:11:51

+2
True that.

reply
whitneyyy 2009/11/10 08:55:09

Amber Benson.

+2
I think If I liked girls I would go for amber..she has the hips butt and boobs (:

and she is extremely gorgous in a goofy way, she has charisma (:

reply
Jane to whitneyyy 2009/11/11 04:43:50

+2
Lol. Yeah she does and she is. Hehe.

reply
les mots sont je t'aime et ... 2009/11/07 00:32:26

Can't choose.

+2
Impossible
i love them both!!
but i like amber a lil bit more

reply
Jane to les mot... 2009/11/07 01:22:11

+2
I know what you mean, but the opposite. I like Alyson just alittle more. Lol!

reply
les mot... to Jane 2009/11/07 01:36:03

+2
haha nice

reply
Jane to les mot... 2009/11/07 01:49:33

+2
I know right!!

reply
Vampgrrl108 2009/11/04 19:26:51

Can't choose.

+2
Honestly I love Alyson but Amber is pretty hott too!

I like drool over this one pic of Alyson

I also love her with black hair!

reply
Jane to Vampgrr... 2009/11/04 19:54:58

+1
I know what you mean. They're both hott, but those pics of Alyson...mmhm... Lol!! Plus Alysons personality is just much sexier. You know? Like in american pie. Lol! :)

reply
Vampgrr... to Jane 2009/11/06 22:03:36

+2
TELL ME ABOUT IT!!!! lol

reply
Jane to Vampgrr... 2009/11/07 01:23:50 (edited)

+1
Lol. I could too.(tell you about it)
Lol!! Hehe.
She's just so hot.
I could keep saying that over and over again. Lol!

reply
Vampgrr... to Jane 2009/11/08 18:18:15

+2
ME TOO!!! seriiously though...she's WAY hott!!!!

reply
Jane to Vampgrr... 2009/11/08 20:28:16

+1
Hell yeah!! She's one sexy human! Lol!!

I was just thinking, (don't be afraid, I did it carefully lol) that what if Alyson had a sodahead, but wasn't being herself on it, you know and then she saw us talking about her. Lol. That'd be funny.

reply
Vampgrr... to Jane 2009/11/08 21:10:42

+2
That would lol!!!! just imagine! she'd be like oh, wow!

reply
Jane to Vampgrr... 2009/11/09 02:07:30

+1
Hehe. I know, I'm imagining. . . *dazes off, smiles, then snaps out of it shaking head* Wait! What am I 'suppose' to be imagining? I know what I'm imagining, but it's probably not what I'm suposse to be think of a this moment. . . Lol!!

reply
Vampgrr... to Jane 2009/11/09 03:08:44

+2
hahaha lol I know right!!!! Do you watch how I met your mother?

reply
Jane to Vampgrr... 2009/11/09 03:42:17

+1
Sometimes. Why?

reply
Jane to Vampgrr... 2009/11/09 03:44:55

+1
I mostly forget it's monday when it's monday. I like her character, though. It's funny, Lily is so ditzy. It knind makes her seem hotter like that, kinda innocent, but not. Lol. I always think like that. (about her at least) Lol!

reply
Vampgrr... to Jane 2009/11/09 19:37:37

+2
yea I know!!!! I like her in the episode where they find a stripper that looks just like her lol. she's all "Crawl for that money stripper-me! whoa...she crawls fast!" LMAO

reply
Jane to Vampgrr... 2009/11/10 00:53:17

+1
I know that was the first one I saw and my fave!!!! lmfbo!!
Hey!! Today is monday!!!

reply
Vampgrr... to Jane 2009/11/13 16:15:38

+2
oh sorry I haven't been on in a while! Its friday!

reply
Jane to Vampgrr... 2009/11/13 23:37:03

+1
Yeah, now it's Friday. Hehe.

reply
Nick~believe ^MOTOOP^ 2009/11/04 18:17:33

Alyson Hannigan.

+2
I must say I really don't know who Amber Benson is, but from the pic, I'd say I prefer Alyson Hannigan.

reply