Question News & Politics

Was Lou Dobbs forced off CNN due to political intolerance?

Art November 12, 2009 01:39:30

Read more: http://newsbusters.org/blogs/jeff-poor/2009/11/11/...

Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN
No, CNN is fair and balanced
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Comment
  • +23 Art November 12, 2009 01:40:11
    Art

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Remember the left-wing tactic: accuse others of what they are doing.
    View thread
Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Comments
  • +2
    mr jiggs Lavende... November 12, 2009 14:55:22
    mr jiggs
    When Kline told Dobbs to keep his opinions to the radio it ruined his show. You cannot stifle the truth and that's what Lou did .told the truth. The only one on that station who did.
  • +2
    Lavende... mr jiggs November 12, 2009 15:06:48
    Lavendergrl
    I liked Dobbs and I'm sad to see him leave CNN, but opinion and fact aren't always synonymous.
  • +1
    USER DE... Lavende... November 13, 2009 20:52:15
    USER DEACTIVATED
    Especially on CNN, eh? /sarc
  • +1
    Lavende... USER DE... November 13, 2009 22:13:45
    Lavendergrl
    I would leave it at a generalization.
  • +1
    USER DE... Lavende... November 14, 2009 08:45:08
    USER DEACTIVATED
    There is NOTHING 'general' about Kline telling Dobbs to keep his opinions to himself.

    CNN has become the joke of the cable news networks.
  • +1
    Lavende... USER DE... November 14, 2009 08:58:00
    Lavendergrl
    The generalization I made, that opinion and fact aren't always synonymous, was not in reference to Kline's ultimatum.

    But it does lend itself to my opinion, and also to yours.
  • +5
    Terry ~Stop Communist Obama~ November 12, 2009 04:14:34
    Terry ~Stop Communist Obama~

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Goes to show how intolerant the left wing nutbags are, to whoever oppose their massiah's polilicies. To liberals, conservitives and free thinkers are the enemy more than muslim terrorists. Just look how they are reporting about Hasan.
  • +3
    Pegasis November 12, 2009 04:06:52
    Pegasis

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Does any one doubt it? Ted Turner? Puh-leeze!
  • +4
    texasred Pegasis November 12, 2009 05:12:31
    texasred
    Yep, he WAS married to Hanoi Jane.
  • +8
    AV November 12, 2009 04:03:29
    AV

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Is CNN still on the air?
  • +4
    jackolantyrn356 November 12, 2009 04:01:57
    jackolantyrn356

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Well, duh!
  • +4
    leahcim368 November 12, 2009 03:56:45
    leahcim368

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    I was thinking that as I watched him tonight!
  • +4
    Kane Fernau November 12, 2009 03:43:42
    Kane Fernau

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Liberal diversity!!
  • +12
    PeterB November 12, 2009 03:43:20
    PeterB

    No, CNN is fair and balanced

    Lou Dobbs was the only show I ever watched on CNN. Always thought he was fair and balanced. Look forward to seeing him over at the only real news network, the one who stands alone against the great Liberal steamrolling media wannabees, Fox News!
  • +8
    Terry ~... PeterB November 12, 2009 04:20:21
    Terry ~Stop Communist Obama~
    So tell me, if Fox news is a wannabe news network, why are their ratings higher than any other cable news channel combined?

    Why does Fox News have more viewers than CNN and pMSNBC put together?

    I bet now that Lou Dobbs is gone from CNN, their ratings will fall even more.
  • +3
    Jada Terry ~... November 12, 2009 05:08:03
    Jada
    I have to agree. Watch them fall. Bah ha ha.
  • +1
    marty PeterB November 14, 2009 00:15:06
    marty
    DID NOT MEAN TO RAVE YOU!
  • +9
    The Frog Prince November 12, 2009 03:42:50
    The Frog Prince

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    I had heard through various sources that Dobbs was moving to Fox News. There were contractual issues that he has addressed here. Evidently, those have been resolved. I think he explained it well.
  • +11
    Alleyoop "American" November 12, 2009 03:39:21
    Alleyoop "American"

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Communist Network News.
  • +7
    JT November 12, 2009 03:14:37
    JT

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    In my area, he is the only thing on that makes any sense whatsoever at 7 PM, now he will be gone and he is one of the few that stayed true to an independent form of thinking. He caught hell by groups like LaRaza even though he was not anti immigrant, he was for legal immigration and for protecting our borders and basically for the American people. This man in my eyes, is a true patriot. My wife and I will miss him.
  • +4
    Marlow ~ Let There Be Light November 12, 2009 03:09:54
    Marlow ~ Let There Be Light

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    I really don't know actually, but it does sound like it was. Actually Dobbs sounds rather pompous here.
  • +1
    AL Marlow ... November 12, 2009 09:18:54 (edited)
    AL
    And thats a good reason why there shouldn't be any free speech on the right wing side on CNN any more?
  • +2
    Marlow ... AL November 12, 2009 12:46:28
    Marlow ~ Let There Be Light
    No I didn't say he was pompous all the time. Just in that video clip.
  • +1
    AL Marlow ... November 12, 2009 20:29:01
    AL
    Oh really! Now that sounds just like a real cop out to me! I guess the next thing you'll say is I just love him other wise right?
  • +2
    Marlow ... AL November 13, 2009 02:02:48
    Marlow ~ Let There Be Light
    he's only so-so to me. He's not a real conservative.
  • +1
    AL Marlow ... November 13, 2009 04:51:50 (edited)
    AL
    He has said in the past that he's a real independent the last I heard!
  • +6
    BenIII November 12, 2009 03:08:02
    BenIII

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Unfortunately, I didn't begin listening to Lou until earlier this year. I was shocked to see how much I agreed with him, and even MORE shocked that he has been a staple there for 30 years. Was hoping he'd say he was going to Fox. Maybe he yet will. I got the impression he might enter politics.
  • +3
    no1badboy56 November 12, 2009 03:04:49
    no1badboy56

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Hmmmmm wonder if Fox is getting his desk all set up as we speak?
  • +5
    Informed Voter November 12, 2009 03:02:27
    Informed Voter

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    That's it now... CNN belongs wholly and solely to the lemmings.
  • +3
    brandi_wine112 November 12, 2009 03:01:32
    brandi_wine112

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    LOU DOBBS WELL RESPECTED - YOU HAVENT HEARD THE LAST FROM DOBBS!

    1980 - Dobbs joined CNN
    ---> A. CHEIF ECONOMICS CORRESPONDENT
    ---> B.HOSTED MONEYLINE ON CNN.
    ---> C. CORPORATE EXECUTIVE for CNN, as its EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT and as a MEMBER OF CNN's EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE.
    ---> D FOUNDED CNN FINANCIAL NEWS serving as its PRESIDENT
    ---> E.ACHORING the program BUSINESS UNUSUAL which EXAMINED BUSINESS & CREATIVE LEADERSHIP.

    1997 -RICK KAPLAN, who became PRESIDENT OF of CNN.
    --->Dobbs said KAPLAN ,Friend of President Bill Clinton, was "CLEARLY PARTISAN" and "was PUSHING CLINTON STORIES" while Kaplan said Dobbs was "a very difficult person to work with.

    April 20, 1999 - CNN was covering Clinton's speech in Littleton, Colorado,
    ---> A. Dobbs ordered the producer to cut away from the speech and return to broadcast Moneyline.
    ---> B. Dobbs was countermanded by Kaplan, who ordered CNN to return to the speech.
    ---> C. Kaplan said, "Tell me what journalistic reason there was not to cover the president at Columbine soon after the shootings? Everyone else was doing it."
    ---> D Dobbs announced on the air that "CNN President Rick Kaplan wants us to return to Littleton."
    --->E A few days later, DOBBS ANNOUNCED -HE WAS LEAVING THE NETWORK to start Space.com, a website devoted to astronautic...>>>>>>>>
    LOU DOBBS WELL RESPECTED - YOU HAVENT HEARD THE LAST FROM DOBBS!

    1980 - Dobbs joined CNN
    ---> A. CHEIF ECONOMICS CORRESPONDENT
    ---> B.HOSTED MONEYLINE ON CNN.
    ---> C. CORPORATE EXECUTIVE for CNN, as its EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT and as a MEMBER OF CNN's EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE.
    ---> D FOUNDED CNN FINANCIAL NEWS serving as its PRESIDENT
    ---> E.ACHORING the program BUSINESS UNUSUAL which EXAMINED BUSINESS & CREATIVE LEADERSHIP.

    1997 -RICK KAPLAN, who became PRESIDENT OF of CNN.
    --->Dobbs said KAPLAN ,Friend of President Bill Clinton, was "CLEARLY PARTISAN" and "was PUSHING CLINTON STORIES" while Kaplan said Dobbs was "a very difficult person to work with.

    April 20, 1999 - CNN was covering Clinton's speech in Littleton, Colorado,
    ---> A. Dobbs ordered the producer to cut away from the speech and return to broadcast Moneyline.
    ---> B. Dobbs was countermanded by Kaplan, who ordered CNN to return to the speech.
    ---> C. Kaplan said, "Tell me what journalistic reason there was not to cover the president at Columbine soon after the shootings? Everyone else was doing it."
    ---> D Dobbs announced on the air that "CNN President Rick Kaplan wants us to return to Littleton."
    --->E A few days later, DOBBS ANNOUNCED -HE WAS LEAVING THE NETWORK to start Space.com, a website devoted to astronautical news.
    --->F Dobbs replaced as host of Moneyline by Willow Bay and Stuart Varney

    August 2000 - KAPLAN LEFT CNN in August 2000, and DOBBS RETURNS the following year, at the behest of his friend and CNN FOUNDER TED TURNER,
    --->A. HOST & MANAGING EDITOR - general news program Lou Dobbs Reporting, which later became CNN News Sunday Morning.

    June 2003 - Lou Dobbs Moneyline (which became Lou Dobbs Tonight)
    --->A.HOST -The Lou Dobbs Financial Report
    --->B.COLUMIST IN MONEY- MAGAZINE, U.S. NEWS & WORLD REPORT,& NEW YORK TIMES DAILY NEWS.

    On November 11, 2009, Lou announced, on the air, that HE WOULD BE LEAVING the NETWORK HE HELPED CREATE, , CNN.
    --->A LEAVING CNN -EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY.
    --->B Dobbs leaves the network to PURSUE OTHER OPTIONS, saying that he is considering "a NUMBER OF OPPORTUNITIES AND DIRECTIONS"
    --->C.DOBBS LEAVES CNN with about 30 YEARS OF SERVICE to the network
    --->D MANY SPECULATE DOBBS MAY PURSUE A POLITICAL CAREER
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...
    (more)
  • +1
    brandi_... brandi_... November 12, 2009 04:09:53
    brandi_wine112
    POLITICAL VIEWS - LOU DOBBS ( PERHAPS 2012 PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE?)
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

    EARLY CAREER - known as a FISCAL CONSERVATIVE as time passed he became increasingly SOCIALLY CONSERVATIVE.

    CRITICAL of "EXCESSIVES OF CAPITALISM defines as "GLOBALIZAION, OFFSHORE
    OUTSOURCING, RUNAWAY FILM PRODUCTION (the outsourcing of Hollywood jobs), ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION, FREE TRADE DEALS, CORPORATE/BIG BUSINESS INFLUENCED IN GOV'T and the Bush administration's TAX CUTS..

    DOBBS describes himself as an ADVOCATE OF ECONOMIC POPULISM, , warning that OUTSOURCING & US TRADE & BUDGET DEFICIT THREATENS the AMERICAN MIDDLE CLASS. Dobbs tends to OPPOSE LONG-RUN TRADE DEFICITS & OUTSOURCING for the sake of LABOR ARBITRAGE to obtain CHEAP LABOR.

    NOTED -for two positions: AMERICAN IMMIGRATION POLICY and and EXPANDED INTERNATIONAL TRADE.

    ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION AND BORDER SECURITY
    STRONGLY OPPOSES - ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION as well as VARIOUS LABOR OUTSOURCING PROGRAMS (Such as the H-1B visa program and guest worker programs)

    LOU DOBBS TONIGHT - "Exporting America," "Broken Borders," and "War on the Middle Class". The newscast often describes ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION as "INVASION"

    2007 - Dobbs - CRITICIZED LOCAL OFFICIALS for their approach to BORDER SECURITY. DOBBS LABELED-New York Go...>>>>>>>>>>
    POLITICAL VIEWS - LOU DOBBS ( PERHAPS 2012 PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE?)
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

    EARLY CAREER - known as a FISCAL CONSERVATIVE as time passed he became increasingly SOCIALLY CONSERVATIVE.

    CRITICAL of "EXCESSIVES OF CAPITALISM defines as "GLOBALIZAION, OFFSHORE
    OUTSOURCING, RUNAWAY FILM PRODUCTION (the outsourcing of Hollywood jobs), ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION, FREE TRADE DEALS, CORPORATE/BIG BUSINESS INFLUENCED IN GOV'T and the Bush administration's TAX CUTS..

    DOBBS describes himself as an ADVOCATE OF ECONOMIC POPULISM, , warning that OUTSOURCING & US TRADE & BUDGET DEFICIT THREATENS the AMERICAN MIDDLE CLASS. Dobbs tends to OPPOSE LONG-RUN TRADE DEFICITS & OUTSOURCING for the sake of LABOR ARBITRAGE to obtain CHEAP LABOR.

    NOTED -for two positions: AMERICAN IMMIGRATION POLICY and and EXPANDED INTERNATIONAL TRADE.

    ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION AND BORDER SECURITY
    STRONGLY OPPOSES - ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION as well as VARIOUS LABOR OUTSOURCING PROGRAMS (Such as the H-1B visa program and guest worker programs)

    LOU DOBBS TONIGHT - "Exporting America," "Broken Borders," and "War on the Middle Class". The newscast often describes ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION as "INVASION"

    2007 - Dobbs - CRITICIZED LOCAL OFFICIALS for their approach to BORDER SECURITY. DOBBS LABELED-New York Governor Eliot Spitzer an "IDIOT" for ADVOCATING the issuance of DRIVERS LICENSE to ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS. HILARY CLINTON - labeled Dobbs' illegal immigration segments as having "ALL THAT HOT AIR"

    OCT 5,2009 - a gunshot was fired in the vicinity of Dobbs and his wife as they stood outside their home.
    OCT 26, 2009 - Dobbs on his radio program, told his listeners that the INCIDENT was attributed to his STANCE AGAINST AMNESTY for ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS.

    Dobbs - NO LONGER openly SUPPORTS ANY PARTY
    January 2001 he often has described the Bush administration and the then Republican-controlled Congress as "DISGRACEFUL." He has also argued that BOTH PARTIES CONTROLLED by CORPORATE INTEREST.

    Dobbs- PRO CHOICE, OPPOSES GUN CONTROL and, though he is a fiscal conservative, SUPPORTS SOME GOV'T REGULATIONS

    Dobbs' STANCE ON TRADE has earned plaudits from some trade union activists on the traditional political left, while his STANCE ON IMMIGRATION tends to appeal to the right Dobbs revealed that he is now "an UNAFFILIATED INDEPENDENT" owing to dissatisfaction with both the Republican and Democratic parties.

    Dobbs has been generally SUPPORTIVE OF GAY ISSUES In June 2006, as the U.S. Senate debated the Federal Marriage Amendment, Dobbs was critical of the action. He asserted that traditional marriage was threatened more by financial crises perpetuated by Bush administration economic policy than by gay marriage

    In July 2006, Dobbs CRITISIZED U.S. FOREIGN POLICY as being DISPROPORTIONATELY SUPPORTIVE OF ISRAEL , pointing out the U.S.' rapid recognition of Israel in 1948, foreign aid to Israel, and other policy choices in the past and present

    Dobbs - (BOOK) WAR ON THE MIDDLE CLASS - claims that both DEMOCRATS and REPUBLICANS are HARMING THE MIDDLE CLASS.

    Dobbs has been CRITICAL of the RESCUE PACKAGE - Bush Administration and supported by the Democratic-controlled Congress, which he and others call as a "WALL STREET BAILOUT." Dobbs describes this package as a way for U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson to help corporate interests rather than average Americans.

    In mid-2009, DOBBS CRITICIZED for giving air time to BARACK OBAMA CITIZENSHIP CONSPIRACY THEORIES - claim Barack OBAMA WAS NOT BORN in the UNITED STATES.
    --->His willingness to repeatedly raise the "birther" issue- even though CNN itself considered it a "discredited rumor", led the Washington Post's TV critic to remark that this "explains their upcoming documentary: 'The World: Flat. We Report -- You Decide.'"[

    2008 - issue had come up in 2008 during the Presidential campaign
    --> LARGELY DISAPPEARED FROM THE MEDIA SPOTLIGHT until Dobbs picked up the issue again
    ---> DOBBS statements in SUPPORT OF THESE INVESTIGATIONS -dubbed "RACIST" and "DEFLAMATORY" by the Southern Poverty Law Center
    ---> CONTROVERSY led to MEDIA MATTERS airing ADS CRITICAL OF DOBBS and of CNN,
    --->JON STEWART MOCKING DOBBS - The Daily Show.
    --->THE NEW YORK TIMES - DOBBS "BECOME A PUBLICITY NIGHTMARE FOR CNN, CNN,
    --->EMBARRASSED- his boss and hosted a show that seemed to contradict the network's 'no bias' brand.
    ---> Dobbs announced that he would broadcast two episodes of Lou Dobbs Tonight from the "Hold Their Feet to the Fire" conference in Washington, D.C., organized by the Federation for AMERICAN IMMIGRATION REFORM (FAIR), an anti-immigration advocacy group
    --->Media Matters - CRITICIZED this move, citing FAIR founder John Tanton's history of making RACIALLY DEROGATORY REMARKS and SUPPORTING WHITE SUPREMACIST ORGANIZATIONS.
    --> Media Matters president Eric Burns- OPEN LETTER TO CNN vice president Jonathan Klein, asking that the network TAKE ACTION AGAINST DOBBS.

    "Mr. Dobbs represents an ONGOING THREAT TO to CNN's CREDIBILITY as a serious news organization, in no small part BECAUSE OF HIS - POLEMICAL COVERAGE OF IMMIGRATION ISSUES and his continued use of his CNN show to lend prominence to groups such as FAIR", wrote Burns. "The attention and legitimacy he gave to the 'birther' movement -- and CNN's condoning of his actions -- did real damage to that credibility. His participation in the upcoming FAIR rally would do further, serious damage. We urge you to finally acknowledge that Mr. Dobbs' actions in this and other contexts are inconsistent with the reputation that CNN strives to maintain."


    DOBBS AWARDS
    LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT EMMY AWARD
    CABLE ACE AWARD.
    GEORGE FOSER PEABODY AWARD -1987 stock market crash
    LUMINARY AWARD - Business Journalism Review in 1990
    HORATIO ALGER ASSSOCIATION AWARD - Distinguished Americans in 1999
    NATIONAL SPACE CLUB MEDIA AWARD - in 2000.
    THE WALL STREET JOURNAL - named Dobbs "TV's Premier Business News Anchorman".
    In 2004- EUGENE KATZ AWARD - Excellence in the Coverage of Immigration by the Center for Immigration Studies
    2005 - ALEXIS DE TOCQUEVILLE INSTITUTION'S STATESMANSHIP AWARD
    1993 - FATHER OF THE YEAR AWARD by the National Father's Day Committee

    DOBBS BOOKS
    1. 2004- EXPORTING AMERICA - Why Corporate Greed Is Shipping American Jobs Overseas
    2. 2005 - SPACE - The Next Business Frontier with HP Newquist
    3. MAY 2005- RON HIRA AND ANIL HIRA - with foreword by Lou Dobbs, OUTSOURCING AMERICA - What's behind Our National Crisis and how we can reclaim American Jobs. (AMACOM), American Management Association
    4. 2006- WAR ON THE MIDDLE CLASS - How the Government, Big Business, and Special Interest Groups Are Waging War on the American Dream and How to Fight Back
    2007- INDPENDENTS DAY :AWAKENING -The American Spirit
    5. 2007 - INDEPENDENTS DAY - Awakening The American Spirit
    (more)
  • +1
    brandi_... brandi_... November 12, 2009 04:12:36
    brandi_wine112
    Soda heads changed the format....argh ill remember this in the future...go smaller ! sorry :)
  • +6
    marty November 12, 2009 02:55:55
    marty

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    He was tired of all the ass kissing they do to Obama and his group of idiots. He will be on FOX NEWS soon!
  • +3
    Terry ~... marty November 12, 2009 04:28:25
    Terry ~Stop Communist Obama~
    I bet now that Dobbs is gone from CNN, their ratings are gonna get worse than what they are now. And if it's true about him going to Fox News, well, that's just gonna bring their ratings up more... So I hope he does go to Fox. Just like when Glenn Beck moved from HLN to Fox News, his ratings went higher than before.
  • +6
    debadow November 12, 2009 02:55:02
    debadow

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    It will be great to see Him on Fox.
  • +2
    Dan-Proud American November 12, 2009 02:53:09
    Dan-Proud American

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    I never really liked his show very much, but at least he seemed to be pretty fair-minded.
  • +1
    hisomouth November 12, 2009 02:50:59
    hisomouth

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Everyone knows that if you all sing the same note over and over and over it gets boring.
    It also happens to the brain when only one view is given it get boring and in the case of the brain it goes stale.
  • +3
    1oct1 "Marko" November 12, 2009 02:47:48
    1oct1 "Marko"

    Yes, anyone outside the left-wing political orthodoxy is not welcomed at CNN

    Maybe MSNBC will pick him up. LOL, had to.
  • +2
    PeterB 1oct1 "... November 12, 2009 03:47:48
    PeterB
    Best laugh of the night! Thanks for the chuckle...
  • +2
    Terry ~... 1oct1 "... November 12, 2009 04:29:29
    Terry ~Stop Communist Obama~
    LOL!!! Good joke.
or
Cancel