Quantcast

Was James Buchanan our first gay President?

Gramma Lil 2008/02/19 00:32:41
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Particularly when homosexuality is as American as apple pie. The 15th president of the United States, James Buchanan, almost certainly was gay. Finally, prize-winning historian James W. Loewen, author of "Lies My Teacher Told Me," has outed President James Buchanan, who served as chief executive during tumultuous events on the eve of the Civil War, and had more pre-White House domestic and international expertise than all of the current crop of presidential wannabes put together. In Prof. Loewen's newest book, "Lies Across America: What Our Historic Sites Get Wrong," the scholar asserts that Buchanan's long-time living companion, William Rufus King, was referred to as "Aunt Fancy" by that era's Beltway crowd. Apparently, Buchanan's sexual orientation was widely rumored around Washington, to the point that King was called "Mrs. Buchanan."

President James Buchanan was, as they say, a life-long bachelor. That, of course, is code. As usual, the truth is cloaked in historical distortion. You must read between the lines, and connect the dots. "As a young man," writes "Historic Traveler's" Lisa Manhart, Buchanan "committed an unspecified indiscretion that angered his intended bride, and she broke off their engagement. When she died of an illness a few months later, her family forbade him to attend her funeral. Buchanan was devastated, and he disappeared for a time. In the absence of a Mrs. Buchanan, his niece Harriet Lane served as his hostess ... often entertaining guests by playing the piano. When Buchanan moved into the White House as president in 1857, she assumed the social duties of first lady."

While Secretary of State in 1848, James Buchanan had purchased Wheatland, his 22-acre country estate in Lancaster, Penn., attracted to the "privacy, quiet, and beauty of its rural beauty," Manhart notes, and there, he would eventually lead "the life of a country gentleman." The Pennsylvania native was born April 23, 1791, second of 11 children. After graduating from Dickinson College in Carlisle at age 18, Buchanan studied law in Lancaster, and plunged into local politics. Voters elected him state representative in 1814, and he served two terms in the new capital of Harrisburg. Buchanan took his next step up the political ladder in 1820 when he was elected to the first of four terms in the House of Representatives as a Federalist and then, as the Federalist party disintegrated, a fifth term as a Democrat in 1828. President Andrew Jackson appointed him as minister to Russia, where he served in 1832 and 1833. In December of 1833 he was elected to the Senate, where he served until he was appointed Secretary of State under President James K. Polk in 1845.
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Gramma Lil 2008/02/19 00:34:52
    Yes
    Gramma Lil
    +14
    I think that is awesome that we had our first gay president before we had a black or a women in the White House. I just saw this subject while I was watching the Presidents on the History Channel!

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • IrishPo... Jaigo 2011/10/04 22:16:11
    IrishPolishLass
    +1
    They're the largest portion most likely becasue they make up a large if not the largest portion of the human population. It's basic stats that even an idiot can comprehend.
  • scott_t Jaigo 2011/07/17 04:17:55
    scott_t
    +1
    " ... what you do in the bedroom is not who you are ..." It's part of who you are, but I agree it's not the entirety. However, do straight people keep pictures of their wives/girlfriends (or husbands/boyfriends) on their desk at work to force their heterosexuality on others or to proclaim their heterosexuality. Of course not. They do it because seeing the person they love makes them happy. Well, it's the same for gay people.

    As for the sex part, knowing someone is "straight" or "gay" tells me NOTHING about what they like to do in bed, only whether they like doing it with someone of the same or different gender. You could have a straight person who is fun and wild in bed, and one who is boring and uptight. Same is true of gay people.
  • ArtGuyNYC Jaigo 2011/08/10 03:37:37
    ArtGuyNYC
    +1
    I think you have it wrong. It's usually straight 'Christians' who can't comprehend that what you do in the bedroom if you are homosexual doesn't define you. Otherwise we would all be equal citizens.
  • kevin 2010/12/18 23:02:54
    No
    kevin
    I don't know where O'Reilly gets his info. I read that Buchanan was engaged to a female until he had an indescretion with the wife of a friend. His fiance broke the engagement and died shortly there after from an overdose of laudanum. In his grief for her loss, he swore he could never marry another. Is there any solid evidence other than circumstantial that Buchanan had a homosexual relationship?
  • ginger315 2010/12/17 23:19:32
    No
    ginger315
    Neighter the writing here nor nothing offered has a bit of proof of Buchanan's sexuality. Where did Bill O'Reilly get his information?
  • Montana1 2010/12/17 16:02:35
    Yes
    Montana1
    Buchanan blew King's horn.
  • Bonnie B. 2010/12/17 15:52:55
    Yes
    Bonnie B.
    Heard it on Bill O'Reilly on 12/16/10.
  • sketchbone 2010/12/17 04:54:20
    Yes
    sketchbone
    Not that there's anything wrong with that........
  • JimboNaught 2010/12/17 04:49:21
    Undecided
    JimboNaught
    You know....that might just explain why he "sucked" as President......
  • Dale 2010/12/17 04:39:32
    Undecided
    Dale
    He was also a Martian! We have proof he never claimed to be an earthling. And if you don't believe it, ask him...he is still living as an old Amish man in Lancaster PA. Martian life span is nearly 400 earth years.
  • Bonnie Shubiak 2010/12/17 04:31:41
    Yes
    Bonnie Shubiak
    Heard this on O'Reilly 12/16/10
  • danny 2010/12/17 01:45:29
    No
    danny
    +1
    But since we're re-writing all of our history....make him black, too.
  • jane Lu... danny 2010/12/17 01:56:47
    jane Luellen
    +2
    . . . love danny's comment - it's all a bunch of bunk - we are just simply re-writing history. why is there such a need for a gay person in every aspect of our lives, past and present?
  • Gary S 2010/12/01 08:06:40
    Yes
    Gary S
    +1
    Buchanan wrote to a Mrs. Roosevelt, "I am now 'solitary and alone', having no companion in the house with me. I have gone a wooing to several gentlemen, but have not succeeded with any one of them. I feel that it is not good for man to be alone, and [I] should not be astonished to find myself married to some old maid who can nurse me when I am sick, provide good dinners for me when I am well, and not expect from me any very ardent or romantic affection."
  • bob 2010/10/29 03:47:27
    No
    bob
    Many, not all, but many of you are clearly NOT SMART ! Buchanan was not gay! He also wasnt racist! The sad thing is most of you believe all the bad things you hear about him that are not true. I would have to say show me the evidance, and clearly there is none! You all malign an honorable man. Actually after doing great research I have found that Buchanan was clearly not racist, and he had no slaves. Actually he went to the south and bought slaves from slaveowners and let the free in Penn. He also wasnt gay, with the loss of his soon to be wife, Buchanan was lonely and had no one else. When you go through a hard time in your life you hold onto the person that can get you out of that sad state of being you are in, and that was King for Buchanan. They were very good friend, and actually at the time Buchanan was still a ladies man he was in his late 30's and was still chasing the ladies around! So in the end I hope I have opened your eyes to all the lies about a president that did the very best he could in the circumstances of his presidency.

    P.S. Dont believe every stupid lie you hear. Do good reseach and find the truth!
    P.P.S Only SC had seceded during Buchanan's Presidency. After the southern states found out in November of 1860 that Lincoln was becoming president 7 more states had seceded, I will say they did secede while Buchanan was still President but it was because of Lincoln that they had seceded!
  • HByerley bob 2010/12/23 07:54:34
    HByerley
    +2
    Great points.

    I’ve never understood why some folks gossip about others, and why they are so eager to assume things about people with no hard evidence to back their assumptions.

    Most of us have gay friends, yet their association with those who are straight is never cause for gossip, and no one would ever accuse a homosexual of being straight merely because they befriend or socialize with heterosexuals. Go figure.
  • Bill 2010/08/23 23:26:21
    Yes
    Bill
    +5
    I am a 68 yr old male and have always said there are "gays" in all walks of life and have always been. They have fought and died for this country as well as others. I have heard said that the world would be better off without gays. There have been great composers,statesmen,doctors,l... etc. who were gay. My minister,who did not like gays, quoted an author to support his sermon. I guess he didn't realize this author was gay.
    I am not gay but believe that ALL people have worth in God's eyes.
  • Bonnie B. Bill 2010/12/17 15:54:41
    Bonnie B.
    +3
    Totally agree with you.
  • Danzamagu Bill 2011/04/19 17:34:48
    Danzamagu
    Well said.
  • glen 2010/07/24 12:15:19
    No
    glen
    +2
    He had to be gay. Its quite obvious that God punished this nation with the civil war shortly after he took office. How ironic, a same nation war, to go with a same sex loving president.
  • william glen 2010/08/11 21:27:56
    william
    +2
    a little superstitious are we?
  • jc glen 2010/12/17 04:35:43
    jc
    +1
    My God of Love wouldn't let thousands die because one president was gay. That is nonsense.
  • Christopher 2010/04/19 07:18:22
    Yes
    Christopher
    I 1st read that a few years back, and I'm convinced he was gay. Too bad he was also a racist bigot, and so ashamed of his own sexuality to come out & admit it. Being gay, of color, of a different religion, whatev... your character comes from being yourself regardless of what others might have to say. Pax!
  • JamesPa... Christo... 2010/09/01 02:46:41
    JamesPadilioniJr
    +3
    You seriously aren't faulting him for staying in the closet in the 19th century are you? Like get real. Nobody "came out" back then. Sodomy was illegal in many states and enforced.
  • Ashley ... JamesPa... 2011/06/26 20:24:51
    Ashley Vogt
    +3
    lol I just had to add Sodomy is STILL very illegal in a lot of states but then again so is not giving horse drawn carriages the right of way
  • hitchike 2010/04/13 11:32:27
    Yes
    hitchike
    +3
    yes he was gay ,but being a top mason its covered up by the masons same as E. Hoover,all the masons r good at hiding the truth...
  • Neiko70 2009/07/10 18:25:32
    Yes
    Neiko70
    +1
    Thanks for the poll, Gramma Lil!! Sorry I stumbled upon it a year later...

    Oh, and as far as other presidents go...what about FDR and Eleanor? If that wasn't a marriage of convenience, I don't know what was! ;)
  • Miky Neiko70 2010/03/05 17:14:03
    Miky
    +3
    ok so he was the first and only [...] President,,,,did he get his Lowenskys?
  • william Neiko70 2010/08/11 21:28:43
    william
    +2
    he was crippled, she was a sapphist for sure!
  • Brian S. william 2010/10/12 02:32:23
    Brian S.
    +3
    Um, based on what I've read, Eleanor Roosevelt was probably bi, and ceased being physical with Franklin a few years BEFORE he got polio, after they had been married for about a decade. They chose to not get divorced, as they both knew that this would negatively impact BOTH their political careers; that's where the "marriage of convenience" came in, it had nothing to do with his impairment.

    Also, I myself have a physical impairment that means that I have to use a wheelchair to get around, just like FDR. I see my use of a wheelchair, which vastly improves my physical mobility, to be little different from people who use contacts or glasses to improve their vision. A good wheelchair takes away from most of the physical inconveniences that come with having paralyzed legs, just like a good set of glasses or contacts take away most of the inconveniences of bad vision.

    I am physically active, have an upper body that makes most guys jealous, and while my most prominent two legs don't work, my third leg works just fine (no Viagra or Cialis necessary) Just ask all of the girls I've ever been inside ;)

    P.S. Please don't use "crippled," or "incapacitated;" it's no better than calling a black guy a "nigger", or some Hispanic a "spic." The only thing I can think of that's truly crippled is a city temporarily covered in 6 feet of snow, where absolutely NO ONE can get around. Now that's a city I would definitely call crippled. :)
  • Lani Todd Brian S. 2010/12/17 01:41:29
    Lani Todd
    +4
    wow...i was slightly turned on!! lol so um um...how you doin?
  • Ashley ... william 2011/06/26 20:45:07
    Ashley Vogt
    +3
    although there are plenty of evidences to speculate she may have been it is a fact that FDR cheated on Eleanor before she moved out of the bedroom and it is well known that they stayed together for their careers
  • ♡Short Sparkley Ginger♡ 2009/07/05 23:48:39
    Yes
    ♡Short Sparkley Ginger♡
  • Dizzi 2009/07/05 23:34:56
    Yes
    Dizzi
    +5
    HaHa i saw it on the history channel as well. The truth is what it is and History has already happened.
  • Byzantine_Catholic 2009/05/26 16:51:40
    Yes
    Byzantine_Catholic
    +1
    William Rufus King, buchanan’s long-time living companion, was referred to by critics as “Aunt Fancy".

    But He as NOT elected as a openly Gay candidate
  • TJR 2008/07/23 02:23:51
    Undecided
    TJR
    +1
    So every guy out there that does not marry is Gay? HMMMM
  • Gramma Lil TJR 2008/07/23 03:06:51
    Gramma Lil
    +1
    Of course not! But I think any man back in those times would have never come out of the closet and that is so sad to me. I think he should have been able to love whom ever he chose and still been free to become a President.
  • Amanda TJR 2009/04/23 06:55:41
    Amanda
    no
  • True~Male 2008/05/22 05:12:37
    Yes
    True~Male
    +1
    Yes , that is what I have heard from the History Channel , It's too bad that back in those days he couldn't Come Out of the closet. I hope he had a good sex life even tho he probably had to keep it quiet.
  • Gramma Lil True~Male 2008/05/22 17:01:44
    Gramma Lil
    +1
    I hope he did too!!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/06/18 05:06:26

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals