Quantcast

Was James Buchanan our first gay President?

Gramma Lil 2008/02/19 00:32:41
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Particularly when homosexuality is as American as apple pie. The 15th president of the United States, James Buchanan, almost certainly was gay. Finally, prize-winning historian James W. Loewen, author of "Lies My Teacher Told Me," has outed President James Buchanan, who served as chief executive during tumultuous events on the eve of the Civil War, and had more pre-White House domestic and international expertise than all of the current crop of presidential wannabes put together. In Prof. Loewen's newest book, "Lies Across America: What Our Historic Sites Get Wrong," the scholar asserts that Buchanan's long-time living companion, William Rufus King, was referred to as "Aunt Fancy" by that era's Beltway crowd. Apparently, Buchanan's sexual orientation was widely rumored around Washington, to the point that King was called "Mrs. Buchanan."

President James Buchanan was, as they say, a life-long bachelor. That, of course, is code. As usual, the truth is cloaked in historical distortion. You must read between the lines, and connect the dots. "As a young man," writes "Historic Traveler's" Lisa Manhart, Buchanan "committed an unspecified indiscretion that angered his intended bride, and she broke off their engagement. When she died of an illness a few months later, her family forbade him to attend her funeral. Buchanan was devastated, and he disappeared for a time. In the absence of a Mrs. Buchanan, his niece Harriet Lane served as his hostess ... often entertaining guests by playing the piano. When Buchanan moved into the White House as president in 1857, she assumed the social duties of first lady."

While Secretary of State in 1848, James Buchanan had purchased Wheatland, his 22-acre country estate in Lancaster, Penn., attracted to the "privacy, quiet, and beauty of its rural beauty," Manhart notes, and there, he would eventually lead "the life of a country gentleman." The Pennsylvania native was born April 23, 1791, second of 11 children. After graduating from Dickinson College in Carlisle at age 18, Buchanan studied law in Lancaster, and plunged into local politics. Voters elected him state representative in 1814, and he served two terms in the new capital of Harrisburg. Buchanan took his next step up the political ladder in 1820 when he was elected to the first of four terms in the House of Representatives as a Federalist and then, as the Federalist party disintegrated, a fifth term as a Democrat in 1828. President Andrew Jackson appointed him as minister to Russia, where he served in 1832 and 1833. In December of 1833 he was elected to the Senate, where he served until he was appointed Secretary of State under President James K. Polk in 1845.
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Gramma Lil 2008/02/19 00:34:52
    Yes
    Gramma Lil
    +14
    I think that is awesome that we had our first gay president before we had a black or a women in the White House. I just saw this subject while I was watching the Presidents on the History Channel!

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • EddieTh... Pat 2012/11/06 16:36:37
    EddieTheSnitch
    +1
    I'd argue the worst was Carter.
    Buchanan, although mostly in favor of slavery, intentionally appointed moderates to dilute his inflammatory position. He at least was astute enough to know how to favorably work the political area in such a volatile time -- immediately before Lincoln.
  • Ashley ... footwork61 2011/06/26 20:07:34
    Ashley Vogt
    +2
    he also supposedly "TRIPPED" and kissed John Adams too
  • Logger1 2011/01/25 15:45:54
    Yes
    Logger1
    +3
    So what if he was gay?? Who cares! It was in the 19th century! Really...I don't believe there were too many pride parades back then. As far as him being a Christian; I believe he was. Whether it is right or wrong (according to some opinions) it is not our place to judge. If you believe the Bible says it's wrong; then keep believing that. If you believe that the Bible isn't to be taken so literal, then do that too. Point is, NOT ONE OF US can judge another for his/her actions. I believe in the Bible, and I believe in what the Bible stands for. But in the Bible I believe it tells us of a loving God. And when judgement comes, it is He who will decide who is rightous and worthy. Those who sit in judgement of others aren't very Christian. Who are you (we) to decide? And for those "Christians" that say they don't sin or haven't sinned, well read your Bible... I John 1:5-11.
  • Sofa King Deep 2011/01/20 07:21:47
    Yes
    Sofa King Deep
    +1
    Was he gay? Probably. If he was does that mean he didn’t do his job making this country his priority? And when did the topic change from gay to race? Or even religion for that matter. We are not living in the time of this honored man yet we still have people spewing hate as if it really mattered if he was gay or not. That’s like saying that our president is incompetent or against God by being black or having beliefs in Greek mythology. Please. I don’t care who is reading that prepared television statement as long as they have American interests in mind. Yes, I am gay and I consider myself a Christian. My employees don’t care if I am gay or not as long as I do my job ensuring they get a paycheck. As far as those who think that I am less of a person for being gay? I do not require your approval. God bless us all and God bless America.
  • Ashley ... Sofa Ki... 2011/06/26 20:09:53
  • AmidAmidi 2011/01/06 00:32:38
    Yes
    AmidAmidi
    I would have blown him
  • morgan 2011/01/05 16:13:58
    Yes
    morgan
    I never heard this rumor and never questioned, "Gee, could one of our Presidents be gay?". Until, the other day while I was going over President flashcards with my kid, I came to this guy. Judging only by his picture at first, I thought, "Wow, he looks like a flamer!" Then I flipped over the card and it said he was the only President never to be married. So, I just put 2 and 2 together.
  • bob1 2010/12/28 07:45:37
    No
    bob1
    +1
    Like I said below many of you can jump on the banwagon and allow the lies to flow into your mind that we had a guy president but clearly many of you dont understand. Ask your self this, Was Buchanan religious? The answer with research is yes, he was a very strong Christian. Now ask your self this, Are gay people Christian? No they are not because one can not be gay and be Christian because they are going against a basic principle of the bible. Buchanan had a fiancee and he truly loved her. With his lose he stuck to the only friend he had and that was King. Now if you take the quote about his "wooing to gentlemen" out of context then it clearly sounds like he is gay but if you look into it more clearly you will see that, that was after King had left and he had no friends to be around. There for in the whole quote he is saying it's not good that he is lonely and he needs a friend, he is looking for compantionship in other gentlemen, as in friendship, not in a relationship! Like I said Buchanan truely loved is fiance and was very hurt with her death. Below is a letter he wrote to his fiance's father after her death.

    My dear Sir:
    You have lost a child, a dear, dear child. I have lost the only earthly object of my affections, without whom life now presents to me a dreary blank. M...






    Like I said below many of you can jump on the banwagon and allow the lies to flow into your mind that we had a guy president but clearly many of you dont understand. Ask your self this, Was Buchanan religious? The answer with research is yes, he was a very strong Christian. Now ask your self this, Are gay people Christian? No they are not because one can not be gay and be Christian because they are going against a basic principle of the bible. Buchanan had a fiancee and he truly loved her. With his lose he stuck to the only friend he had and that was King. Now if you take the quote about his "wooing to gentlemen" out of context then it clearly sounds like he is gay but if you look into it more clearly you will see that, that was after King had left and he had no friends to be around. There for in the whole quote he is saying it's not good that he is lonely and he needs a friend, he is looking for compantionship in other gentlemen, as in friendship, not in a relationship! Like I said Buchanan truely loved is fiance and was very hurt with her death. Below is a letter he wrote to his fiance's father after her death.

    My dear Sir:
    You have lost a child, a dear, dear child. I have lost the only earthly object of my affections, without whom life now presents to me a dreary blank. My prospects are all cut off, and I feel that my happiness will be buried with her in the grave. It is now no time for explanation, but the time will come when you discover that she, as well as I, have been much abused. God forgive the authors of it. My feelings of resentment towards them, whoever they may be, are buried in the dust. I have now one request to make, and, for love of God and of your dear, departed daughter whom I loved infinitely more than any other human being could love, deny my not. Afford me the melancholy pleasure of seeing her body before its interment. I would not for the world be denied this request.
    I might make another, but, from the misrepresentations which must have been made to you, I am almost afraid. I would like to follow her remains to the grave as a mourner. I would like to convince the world, and I hope to convince you, that she was infinitely dearer to me than life. I may sustain the shock of her death, but I feel that happiness has fled from me forever. The prayer which I make to God without ceasing is, that I yet may be able to show my veneration for the memory of my dear departed saint, by my respect and attachment for her surviving friends.
    May Heaven bless you, and enable you to bear the shock with the fortitude of a Christian.
    I am, forever, your sincere and grateful friend,
    James Buchanan

    So If you have read this maybe it has opened your eyes that he was a strong Christain and that he truely lost the love of his life, causing him to never find love again. But the only person that he could consult was his dear friend King. So hopefully you can see now the difference between a true friendship Buchanan and King and see that it is far from a relationship,
    and once again I will close by saying he was one of our greatest presidents and " History will vindicate me memory" -JB
    (more)
  • morgan bob1 2011/01/05 16:24:17
    morgan
    +6
    I'm not sure how you come up with "Gays can't be Christian". Following through with gay sex is a sin, but do you know any Christians that don't sin? I can't think of one. If you'd read your Bible, you'd know that God says no sin is worse than another. Most prisoners are Christian! Do you really think a murderer can be a Christian but not a homo?! So following your reasoning, nobody can be a Christian because we all sin.
    Also, just because someone claims to be a Christian doesn't mean it's so. Priests that screw little boys claim they're Christians.
  • bob1 morgan 2011/01/18 06:15:30 (edited)
    bob1
    +3
    Well "if you read your bible" you will find that God created man and woman, together they make one flesh and they will be one with each other. I will agree God says no sin is greater than another. One can claim to be Christian but that still doesnt make one Christian. I dout there are any prisoners that are Christians, and if so its because they see from being in jail they did wrong and are reaching out to God at that point but durring the time they committed the wrong full act they did not have God on their mind. Everyone sins but the people that live lives trying not to and when they do sin confess to God are the ones God forgives but you truly must be sorry, not just saying sorry will cut it you must be sorry from your heart and you mustnt fall in the same sinfull path as before. God wants male and female together thats why he made Adam and Eve not Adam and Jack or something so truly God made man and woman and wants them to be together. So I am sorry for the rut and I will say homosexuals cant be Christian and when they finish reading the entire Bible maybe it will come to them and they will change but until then they are simply throwing out the parts that say a man must be with a woman. Also God wants us to take the whole Bible not just the parts we like.
  • scott_t bob1 2011/07/17 04:04:04
    scott_t
    +5
    The bible also says that men have one fewer rib than women, but you can look at an x-ray and see it isn't true. The bible also says that people should be stoned to death if they work on the sabbath, yet there are "Christians" who work at Walmart every Sunday. Why are they allowed to endlessly sin week after week? Christians like to put down gay people because it's far easier to ignore your own sins--divorce, adultery, working on Sunday, etc. Do you agree with the bible stating that a woman must marry her rapist? Why not? It's in the bible.
  • Jams bob1 2012/05/15 01:09:08
    Jams
    You can tell when someone hasn't read the bible if they claim to accept the whole bible.
  • KenShep... bob1 2012/08/28 20:57:40
    KenShepherd1
    +1
    You are the root of evil, as YOU state God wants us to take the whole bible, yet you only refrred to the parts that satisfy your point of view, which, in my opinion, shows stupidity on your part.
  • Max&Mike bob1 2011/01/16 23:32:34
    Max&Mike
    +3
    Just who in the hell do you think you are to pass judgement on gay people saying something as idiotic as gays can't be devout christians? FYI not all gay people (such as myself a DEVOUT catholic) do not have sex and abstain on account of what GOD wants, not what I want, but I personally choose to follow the teachings of the church. And I'm not the only one, either. I highly suggest you confess what you've written here to a priest, cause, chances are, as judgemental as you are, if you don't you will go to purgatory (if you are lucky) until the end of the world. You obviously have an extremely low Intelligence Quota. I will still pray for you nonetheless, you are a poor lost soul who knows little to nil about christianity. You have NO RIGHT to judge whether someone is a christian or not. Judge not lest not be judged. I'll bet dollars to donuts you also believe in abortion and the death penalty, which we have NO RIGHT
  • bob1 Max&Mike 2011/01/18 06:23:24
    bob1
    +2
    I confess to God directly. I will pray for you also. Leviticus 20:13 – “If a man lies with a man as one lies with a woman, both of them have done what is detestable. They must be put to death; their blood will be on their own heads.” I will pray for you.
  • Dant42 bob1 2011/02/03 06:28:08
    Dant42
    +6
    in Leviticus it also says that if a woman is not a virgin when she marries,she must he stoned to death. I think you should pray for 99.9 percent of the human population.
  • Ashley ... bob1 2011/06/26 19:56:46
    Ashley Vogt
    +2
    THAT is so NOT what Leviticus 20:13 says not even close to what it says or implies it is mans interpretation also the BIBLE was written by and has been EDITED by men, men with sin themselves Go ahead tell me all about its the word from GOD to his special little buddies but hello anyone ever play telephone as a kid the original message is never what gets relayed at the end The Bible is just the oldest of the Best Sellers Let me make it clear I am not claiming to not be a believer or anything but human which is the ONLY thing that unites us all the saddest thing about ALL organized religion is its at its very core hypocritical how can anyone say that they believe in brotherly love and then fight amongst themselves because we are different the way we do (we are speaking of Christianity however feel free to insert your religion of choice in place) Christians are not Christian and you are a prime example of that FACTS are FACTS I'm just calling a duck a duck You don't need to pray for me I will have my day before MY GOD and MY GOD can judge me but I know that in life you get out what you put in so with nothing but negativity coming out maybe you should work on getting yourself right because it seems to me that YOU also choose to only read the parts most convenient to you and your LAME argument written here
  • KenShep... Ashley ... 2012/08/28 21:01:06
    KenShepherd1
    Now, here is an intelligent person, with an intelligent post, FINALLY!!!!
  • scott_t bob1 2011/07/17 04:05:32
    scott_t
    +2
    Leviticus also says that you can't eat shellfish, mix meat and dairy (i.e. no cheeseburgers), and all kinds of other silly things.
  • ArtGuyNYC bob1 2011/08/10 03:34:01
    ArtGuyNYC
    +4
    Dude, I hope you have never eaten shellfish, or worn anything made from mixed fibers....if I'm going to hell, I'll save you a seat!
  • IrishPo... bob1 2011/10/04 22:12:56
    IrishPolishLass
    +2
    That quote is taken out of context. You do realize that Leviticus is a book of rules for priests at the time to follow. It was anulled by Jesus himeself.
  • KenShep... IrishPo... 2012/08/28 21:04:10
    KenShepherd1
    It was for JEWS to follow, not all MANKIND. the New Testament, replaced the old testament laws, and lest we forget, that BIBLE was written by men, who interpreted it as they saw fit, and to fit the current times they were in. that is why it has been rewritten hundreds of times, to fit the current social beliefs and stupidity by a select few religious freaks that have rewritten the words.
  • Curtis bob1 2011/11/23 23:33:34
    Curtis
    +2
    you are a idiot in Christianity before the coming of Christ almost all sins were punishable by death so that is irrelevant! I'm bisexual and yet my faith is in God and his son...Read and you will learn that the law was unmerciful before Christ's death on the cross and it actually gained mercy by his death...GROW UP!
  • Jams bob1 2012/05/15 01:12:38
    Jams
    Don't wear clothing woven from two different kinds of fabric. - Leviticus 19:19
  • KenShep... bob1 2012/08/28 20:59:52
    KenShepherd1
    +1
    and you shall not eat pork, of shellfish, or clotes of more than one fabric-dont pretend to pick one verse and use it to spit your idiotic hate towards gays. Hate is a sin, in fact, as God is love, and he commanded that you love your brother as you love HIM. Learn to teach what you preach and all the real facts, before you show how stupid you really are.
  • Max&Mike bob1 2011/01/16 23:48:01
    Max&Mike
    +3
    Who are you to say that gay people can't be christians. I am a very devout roman catholic are you god? Because it is not a sin to be gay god would have not made people gay if it was a sin. It is a sin to lay with another man and those people that do lay with another will have to confess to god for it so do not say gay people can not be christians because that just makes you look dumb. May God forgive you for adding such an idiotic comment. Why are you so concerned whether buchannan was gay or not? Tell me, in which way does this change your life? Truthfully, it is none of your business to begin with. Try letting the dead rest in peace
  • bob1 Max&Mike 2011/01/18 06:45:03
    bob1
    +3
    It is a sin to be homosexual. I let the dead rest in peace but it is the idiotic people who say things about a truly hardworking and historical man that maybe I look up to that make me comment. I am not God nor will I ever be and I wont ever come close to what Jesus had done. I am not concerened he was gay because I truly know that he was not. That is the biggest claim homosexuals use is that God made you homosexual he did not, I will pray for you. I am not one that takes a piece of the Bible I like, I take the whole thing as one piece. I hope I have opened your eyes and I will continue to pray for you I love the quote " Going to church doesnt make you anymore Christian than standing in a garage makes you a car". I also hope you confess to God and one day you are truly sorry for you sinfull acts.
  • Max&Mike bob1 2011/01/18 20:42:38
    Max&Mike
    obviously you have no grasp of the english language. as I said I DON'T DO SEX. it is not a sin to be who i am. who the f are you to judge me anyway? you will be judged before god for the vile words coming from your mouth. ok i will say it again I AM CELIBATE. do you even know what that means? far as i'm concerned, i've committed no sin. You are judgemental and sick for the things you say. Who the hell cares if President Buchannan was gay or not? Like it affects your life in any way whatsoever. Why don't you just let the dead rest in peace? You will go to purgatory (if you are lucky) for many years for what you are saying to me. And i don't want to hear your funny mentalist crap that there is no purgatory as it's in the bible "no one will enter heaven until the last copper is paid" You should ask god for forgiveness for your intolerance. Funny thing is you don't even know me. i cannot STAND a good 99% of gays, have never voted for gay rights and voted against gay marriage. So don't tell me who i am or what i am. Since you are probably autistic, i will tell you again. I DON'T DO SEX. do you get it now? just leave me alone. You are like satan himself with the filth that comes out of your mouth. BTW if you really read the bible, god did say if you break one commandment, it's as ba...
    obviously you have no grasp of the english language. as I said I DON'T DO SEX. it is not a sin to be who i am. who the f are you to judge me anyway? you will be judged before god for the vile words coming from your mouth. ok i will say it again I AM CELIBATE. do you even know what that means? far as i'm concerned, i've committed no sin. You are judgemental and sick for the things you say. Who the hell cares if President Buchannan was gay or not? Like it affects your life in any way whatsoever. Why don't you just let the dead rest in peace? You will go to purgatory (if you are lucky) for many years for what you are saying to me. And i don't want to hear your funny mentalist crap that there is no purgatory as it's in the bible "no one will enter heaven until the last copper is paid" You should ask god for forgiveness for your intolerance. Funny thing is you don't even know me. i cannot STAND a good 99% of gays, have never voted for gay rights and voted against gay marriage. So don't tell me who i am or what i am. Since you are probably autistic, i will tell you again. I DON'T DO SEX. do you get it now? just leave me alone. You are like satan himself with the filth that comes out of your mouth. BTW if you really read the bible, god did say if you break one commandment, it's as bad as breaking them all. Glad to know you're perfect. One day God will hold you responsible for the vile filth that comes out of your mouth. I bet you also believe in the death penalty and abortion as well, seeing it's probably convienient for you. Murder is ok but homosexuality is not LOL both are sins and one is as bad as the next. Only one man walked this earth that did not sin, and i NEVER (as you implied) said that jesus was gay. that's blasphemy, and why i hate so many gays and lesbians. I am very conservative, both politically and in my life. DO NOT COMPARE ME TO OTHER GAY PEOPLE. you are a true loser who will face god for the vile words that come out of your mouth, To tell you the truth, i feel very bad for you
    (more)
  • Dawn Ja... Max&Mike 2011/07/06 00:09:27
    Dawn Jacquelyn
    +1
    Remain celibate if you feel you must, but personally I think that's rather silly. Sex is supposed to be (in its proper usage) an act of love. If you're that strict about celibacy, I think I can safely assume you believe masturbation is also a "mortal sin". God gave us masturbation for the times we have no partner, and it's no more sinful than nocturnal emissions, which God also designed the male body to perform. Promiscuity is wrong, but complete absence of sex is the other extreme, and sometimes people get carried away. Sex is not "dirty".
  • Dant42 bob1 2011/02/03 06:39:27
    Dant42
    +5
    why is it a sin? i mean love is love isnt it? it doesnt matter who you love. its not like theyre shooting people or making war. what do u have against it. God made everyone equal. So i think it is unfair for you to say that. there are some people that have done everything to change who they are just because it is "sinful" some people have gone trough electric shock treatment, that led to other psychological problems because there was nothing wrong in the first place. and the people that have "changed" and are probably living a life thats a lie, thats all made up.

    just remember, when before you say amen. a child is listening.

    some people take their lives because of people being ignorant and bashing them, making their lives a true living hell. they are not responsible for what they are, and what they are is totally natural.

    so please educate yourself a little more about homosexuality. the bible was written by mortals for mortals and inspired by god, they had different views based on the time period. im not bashing on god however im a firm believer in god, and i too. will be praying for you.
  • scott_t bob1 2011/07/17 04:08:55
    scott_t
    Really? Even using your own quote "... If a man lies with a man as one lies with a woman, both of them have done what is detestable ..." is only referring to an ACT as a sin, not a state of mind. So even in the unlikely event that the ridiculous stuff in the old testament (killing children who talk back to their parents, making a woman sleep a different bed when she has her period, etc.) were true, this statement does not make being homosexual, in and of itself, a sin. P.S. I'm guessing you're probably old given how closed-minded you seem, but in your younger days did you make your wife sleep apart from you when she had her period? Why not? It's in the bible.
  • KenShep... bob1 2012/08/28 21:05:53
    KenShepherd1
    It is a sin to judge another brother, but you seem to be ok as a christian to judge others-so go piss up a christain flagpole-no one needs you religious hate and fake ass prayers
  • KenShep... bob1 2012/08/28 20:55:41
    KenShepherd1
    +2
    A Guy President? I think you meant "gay". Spell check and re-reading your post before you post it might make you sound intelligent. MIGHT!
  • Jaigo 2010/12/20 17:58:47
    Undecided
    Jaigo
    +1
    It really doesn't matter because what most gay people can't comprehend is that what you do in the bedroom is not who you are nor does it have to do with who you are in public. Since most white men are gay or bisexual I would figure that there are a couple of presidents with abnormal sexual desires. And why be happy that there was a gay in office before a person of color or a woman? Does that make you better now? Also Homosexuality is not as american as apple pie just because some people do it. Come on now. Come back to reality.
  • bossmand Jaigo 2010/12/21 02:28:13
    bossmand
    +2
    ". . . what most gay people can't comprehend"? What about public acknowledgement of one's partner in life? Do staight people comprehend that gay people have partners? Would the "straight" world accept a same-sex partner? OK -- and, of course, "most white men are gay or bisexual." Really? Tell me about it!
  • Jaigo bossmand 2010/12/22 02:13:57
    Jaigo
    +3
    I just did. Who are the ones crying out. Matter of fact look at the racial demographic of the "gay" community in america. Who is the largest portion?
  • morgan Jaigo 2011/01/05 16:30:19
    morgan
    +4
    Gay whites are the only ones willing to come out. Most gay minorities are too scared to come out of the closet. In fact, you hear a lot about gay blacks that give their wives STD's because they're secretly having gay affairs.
  • Jaigo morgan 2011/01/06 04:40:23
    Jaigo
    And who are the blacks getting the stds from? White people. Well for the most part. All those ones willing to come out because they can't control it anymore. i've been out on the streets and have seen who the customers are. Most of the blacks giving stds aren't gay they are whoring to get a dollar because what chance do they have to succeed in a business world. There is a true saying out "Only a few at a time or Only a few in a lifetime" Get your facts right. Hiv is higher percentage wise in black communties because the whites are needing their fix of big black d*ck. If there are more white people with HIV than blacks but fewer blacks in the population the statistics will show that it's higher in the black community.
  • scott_t Jaigo 2011/07/17 04:11:30
    scott_t
    Really? What about all the straight people in Africa which is rampant with HIV. They can't all be secretly gay.
  • scott_t Jaigo 2011/07/17 04:14:13
    scott_t
    Look at the last U.S. census data. 76% of gay couples were white (which includes hispanics). That's not much higher than the percentage of white people in the U.S. as a whole.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/22 04:47:00

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals