Quantcast

Was Harvard's Decision to Divest Its Israel Investments Politically-Based?

SodaHead News 2010/08/16 20:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Was this a political move or purely an economical one?

That is the question that has surfaced this weekend with the news that Harvard divested itself of holdings in Israel, according to the Globes, a business website that covers Israel. The Harvard Management Company, which manages the university's endowment, notified the Securities and Exchange Commission on Friday that it had sold all its holdings in Israeli companies during the second quarter of 2010.

Groups opposed to Israel's "occupation" of the Palestinian territories have long advocated, along with boycotts, disinvestment of Israel companies to put press on the government.

“We welcome Harvard’s decision, and encourage all academic institutions in the U.S. and elsewhere to follow its lead, to invest in socially responsible investments, and divest from Israeli war crimes,” Hind Awwad, Coordinator of the BDS National Committee in Palestine told The Media Line. “After Israel’s war of aggression on Gaza in 2008/2009, and its recent attack on the Freedom Flotilla, the Global BDS campaign has gained great momentum.”

But maybe, according to others, the selling of its Israel holdings has a simpler, banal reason: it makes good economic sense.

"This is pure economics and I don’t think it was because of the Arab boycott,” Dr. Gil Feiler, founder of Info-Prod Research and director of the Middle East Business and Economic Research Institute at Interdisciplinary Center Herzliya told The Media Line. “They didn’t eliminate their investments in Israeli stocks. They still have tens of millions of dollars invested, and if you are going to boycott Israel you sell all your stocks.”

Was Harvard's Decision to Divest Its Israel Investments Politically-Based?

Read More: http://www.globes.co.il/serveen/globes/docview.asp...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Red Branch 2010/08/16 21:21:42
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    Red Branch
    +8
    Why would Harvard or the bulk of the rest of the universitite support Israel? They don't even support the USA.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • TombstoneJim 2010/09/15 18:05:45
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    TombstoneJim
    Just another example of elitist Ivy League pandering to the Isama-narcissism popular in the nation among themselves.....I would NEVER let a child of mine attend one of these institutions (and yes they could academically and financially).
  • chaoskitty123 2010/08/18 01:06:18
    I'm not sure
    chaoskitty123
    Depends as the political left clearly thinks it was political yet attacks the political right when they also agree it was political then claiming it is economic. Lol, I have seen leftwing commenters pull a 180 on this since the news first emerged revealing that if Harvards actions weren't politically biased... Obama's supporters and the anti Jew crowd most certainly are since they first say Yahooooo when they heard it and then dropped it to base economics when the political right agree it was political lol.

    If you guys on the right say it was just economics next week, the same people this week attacking you for saying it was political will attack you for saying it... their opinions are based on being the opposite of what you think, nothing more nothing less.
  • bones327 2010/08/17 17:59:50
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    bones327
    +1
    Harvard is populated by leftists and Muslim appeasers.
  • Clark 2010/08/17 17:44:58
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    Clark
    Why havent I heard anything about Harvard being anti-semite? Is it posssible they have confused education with indoctrination? Are all communists anti-semites?
  • bones327 Clark 2010/08/17 18:04:55
    bones327
    +1
    You know it. Just google "leftist anti-semitism Stalin" you'll be inundated with hits. Stalin himself created the concept of anti-Zionism
  • davyd god loving patriot 2010/08/17 17:31:20
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    davyd god loving patriot
    It's great how the people that claim to be the smartest are always the dumbest and most bigoted
  • GoddessMother 2010/08/17 17:24:45
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    GoddessMother
    +1
    I am actually shocked to learn they had any to begin with. The elitist Ivy league has always had a problem with Isreal.
  • intolerantrwj 2010/08/17 17:24:36
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    intolerantrwj
    +1
    ..... if I was a Jew who had contributed to Harvard, I'd send Legal Documents requesting a Refund of my contributions.

    I sincerely hope the J D L announces a Boycott of Harvard ! ! !
  • Isma'ila (God has heard)! 2010/08/17 17:17:47
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    Isma'ila (God has heard)!
    +1
    Screw them! Israel is God's country!
  • LittleMissPatriot 2010/08/17 17:16:54
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    LittleMissPatriot
    +1
    It proves how useless Ivy league schools really are.
  • srini 2010/08/17 16:40:04
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    srini
    +2
    Harvard supports totalitarianism and one-worldism--which Israel is a strong argument AGAINST!
  • ««Gingey, the Master Debate... 2010/08/17 16:14:52
    No, Harvard just made a sound economic choice
    ««Gingey, the Master Debater of Þ|-|Дэ†»»
    Dr. Gil Feiler said, “They didn’t eliminate their investments in Israeli stocks. They still have tens of millions of dollars invested, and if you are going to boycott Israel you sell all your stocks.”

    I think that covers it. Move along, people.
  • BenjaminUrria 2010/08/17 15:39:23
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    BenjaminUrria
    +2
    I sure am glad I did not go to Harvard. What a bunch of pro-terrorist Nazis.
  • justfred 2010/08/17 15:21:04
    I'm not sure
    justfred
    Wow...just another mountain out of a molehill to elicit the desired knee-jerk reaction from the neocon, knee-jerk reactionaries. They didn't divest all their holdings in Israel...and the story doesn't say how much of which holdings.

    This reminds me of the year the talking heads at Faux News were raging about the 'war on Christmas' while their golden boy, GW Bush, sent out cards saying 'Happy Holidays'.

    This isn't even a story.
  • Lanikai 2010/08/17 15:15:44
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    Lanikai
    +2
    It was a show of support of obamao and his merry band of commie islamis, however, it was incredibly stupid since Israel has a good economy and a highish rate of return on investment. But it seems anyone associated with ivy league anything bends over backeards to accomodate obammie and his islamis.
  • PapaBC 2010/08/17 15:11:46
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    PapaBC
    +1
    Damn those Jack Ass people.
  • Alex Catgirl 2010/08/17 14:51:39
    I'm not sure
    Alex Catgirl
    Universities did the same thing to South Africa in the 1980s in an attempt to pressure them into abandoning Apartheid. The pro-isreal scum is too strong in the US, but I'll be pressuring my university to divest from and boycott all things Israeli next year when I'm attending grad school in England.

    Just say NO to colonialism/Zionism. PS gawd is imaginary, so he won't be rewarding those who support douchebags.
  • Red Branch Alex Ca... 2010/08/17 15:28:49
    Red Branch
    Another spoiled, little rich girl whose family has made a fortune in the western world now seeks to destroy what gave her the best life has to offer.

    I am sure that you would be much happier in the University of the Sudan or University of Saudia Arabia.

    It is very telling when you don't say no to jihad or a world dominated by Islam.
  • littleb... Alex Ca... 2010/08/18 19:20:19
    littlebuffalo55TBA
    This means you're for Muslim Arabs exercising Genocide on Black Muslims and Christians in Sudan?

    Ah.....you'll be a Student in England NOT a Citizen!
  • fuzzy Ken "In G-d We Trust" 2010/08/17 14:29:37
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    fuzzy Ken "In G-d We Trust"
    +3
    Could the millions that the Saudis are pumping into Harvard and other colleges have any influence on the schools policies? YA THINK?!?!?!?!??????
  • Philadelphia Freedom 2010/08/17 14:00:10
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    Philadelphia Freedom
    +3
    Good like it will hurt the Jews they have been around thousands of years before Harvard and will be around long after the school goes belly up from bad financial judgment .Rule one don't let your politics interfere with making money if you do you will go broke and the world will laugh at you .
  • GINGERBREAD 2010/08/17 13:56:25
    I'm not sure
    GINGERBREAD
    I'm thinking that Harvard knows what's going to happen in the middle east. I think that there will be a war in that part of the world and we will be sucked in. I will advice everyone to get ready for one hell of a ten year period. We are not going to be unscathe this time.
  • Lanikai GINGERB... 2010/08/17 15:17:09
    Lanikai
    +1
    If you read a bible, all of this is spoken of, Israel WINS.
  • GINGERB... Lanikai 2010/08/17 21:54:17
    GINGERBREAD
    Yes I've read the bible, and I know who will win in the end, but there will also be one hell of a carnage before there is a victor. I don't want to be part of that carnage, if I can help it.
  • Pat 2010/08/17 13:38:24
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    Pat
    +3
    Harvard, along with many, or most colleges and universities have been anti American, anti anything or anyone that even smells of democracy. Why am I not surprised.
  • fuzzy K... Pat 2010/08/17 14:31:43
    fuzzy Ken "In G-d We Trust"
    +3
    Harvard, along with many, or most colleges and universities is getting millions from the Saudis. Any school that has an MSA (Muslim Student's Association) is a recipient.
  • Lanikai fuzzy K... 2010/08/17 15:17:41
    Lanikai
    +2
    So will our new government be a commie sharia law style?
  • fuzzy K... Lanikai 2010/08/17 16:10:12
    fuzzy Ken "In G-d We Trust"
    Nope.
    Communism is far left while Sharia is far, far right.
    The Saudis have more money than the Commies. Guess who'll win?
  • Lanikai fuzzy K... 2010/08/17 16:57:27
    Lanikai
    +2
    The Saudis? Ugh, is it all such a grim picture for our future?

    I know the Church will be raptured, I just sincerely hope it is long before sharia law takes over America.
  • kmay 2010/08/17 13:05:12 (edited)
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    kmay
    +4
    P.C. nonsense. They hate America.
  • ChrisK1969 2010/08/17 12:36:18
  • fuzzy K... ChrisK1969 2010/08/17 13:51:50
    fuzzy Ken "In G-d We Trust"
    +2
    We support Israel for a number of reasons not the least of which is the fact that they are a legitimate country created by the UN just like many other Middle Eastern countries but she is surrounded by other countries that wish to destroy her. If Germany wanted to take over France would we let that happen? (Again)
    Another reason is that we, the world benefit so much from that tiny nation in terms of agriculture, science, medicine and technology.
  • Lanikai ChrisK1969 2010/08/17 15:19:17
    Lanikai
    Most of the best stuff comes from there. They are our friends and longtime allies. bibilically we are (well, Christians) admnished to support and pray for ISrael and we used to have leaders that followed that. But then, with a muslim in command, America may cut Israel off.
  • SaltySodahead7 2010/08/17 12:18:56
    I'm not sure
    SaltySodahead7
    +1
    I'm still trying to understand why we should support the Isreali government. No one ever seems to address this issue or give a valid reason that is based in facts or reality. When Israel starts World War III with Iran for developing Nuclear energy-while Israel has illegally developed nuclear weapons for years, will Americans happily pay the $10 dollars a gallon for gas that results? And will they still love this racist government that kills its own cousins?
  • Red Branch SaltySo... 2010/08/17 15:31:30
    Red Branch
    Iran will launch nukes at us before Israel.
  • jnl72 2010/08/17 12:00:51
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    jnl72
    +4
    I have no doubt that this is a dis to Israel, plain and simple. The US will be making a big mistake if we discontinue our support of Israel. We've always been strong allies, and it would behoove us to keep a good relationship with that country. Israel is just trying to protect it's borders, something that we've clearly forgotten how to do.
  • Shredderofmass 2010/08/17 11:24:54
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    Shredderofmass
    +2
    Republican candidate for congress, Harvard Physicist says he would not want a mosque in his neighborhood. Featured at this great pro-Israel blog
    http://llphfreedom.blogspot.c...
  • regdawgformerusmc 2010/08/17 11:22:27
    Yes, Harvard clearly doesn't support Israel
    regdawgformerusmc
    +2
    didn't most of our libs/progressive leaders went to Harvard!
  • lurx: the soda jerk 2010/08/17 10:59:43
    No, Harvard just made a sound economic choice
    lurx: the soda jerk
    Any institution or organization has the right to divest themselves from Israel, much in same way as many of the same institutions divested from countries like South Africa years ago.
  • KittyC 2010/08/17 09:30:01
    No, Harvard just made a sound economic choice
    KittyC
    +1
    Israel has had its fair share of troubles, sure, but with the bullying way the Israelis have been conducting themselves lately, I feel it was the right thing to do for the Ivy league to disinvest in Israeli companies.
    After all, when it comes to the realm of international business, reputation - and who you associate yourself with - is everything.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 11 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/06/19 01:10:30

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals