Quantcast

The Pope Shuts Down Monastery for 'Lack of Discipline': Harsh or Just?

SodaHead News 2011/05/26 19:12:02
You!
Add Photos & Videos
The BBC reports that Pope Benedict XVI has shut down the Santa Croce in Gerusalemme church in Rome because of questionable goings-on that were rumored to take place there.

Il Messaggero reports that Simone Fioraso transformed the church, renovating its crumbling interior and opening a hotel, holding regular concerts, a televised bible-reading marathon and regularly attracting celebrity visitors with an unconventional approach.

One of the nuns at the monastery, Anna Nobili, a former lap-dancer, reportedly took part in dance performances with other nuns during religious ceremonies.


There were also reported to be financial problems with the church, but the Pope labeled its fault "liturgical and financial irregularities."

Read More: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-13559219

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • What'sIT 2013/01/16 06:49:39
    Harsh
    What'sIT
    Women have always been a different class of person in the Catholic church. There are no female priests in their churches.
    pope john paul smile
  • Michael 2011/06/19 02:58:53
    Just
    Michael
    The occupants of the monastery weren't treating it as a monastery it seems.

    Since the monastery was no longer used for what it's supposed to be used, His Holiness was right to shut it down.

    Maybe The Supreme Pontiff will reopen the monastery and place it under the control of more trustworthy custodians.
  • Charlie 2011/06/16 22:19:01
    Just
    Charlie
    It is their church after all and can decide what to do with it.
  • Jay0Byrd 2011/05/31 13:20:31
    Harsh
    Jay0Byrd
    From what I've heard and read, if he was to be just, he would have to shut down about 70% of the Catholic churches and such because of the pedefile priests and the Bingo orgies`
  • Myst 2011/05/27 20:24:14
    Harsh
    Myst
    The Vatican needs to bring its self into the 21st Century and see things as they truly are in the "real" world. Here was an order of nuns who transformed a run down church with a poor congregational attendance into a thriving place of worship.

    The Vatican; the Pope, want the Catholic's around the world to adhere to doctrine that is outdated, is against birth control, and abortion. Priests can't marry, yet find time to molest children. Pope Benedict get your house in order. Set priorities that will mean something to the everyday Catholic.
  • freddy 2011/05/27 13:56:43
    Harsh
    freddy
    +1
    And what the Catholic Church has been doing has worked so well at keeping a strong congregation.
    I can remember when it was a sin to eat meat on any Friday, now it is only during Lent.
    Losing too many members so things changed. It will change again.
    Hang in there Progressive Catholics, some day you will be able to dance in church, probably even be able to let out a loud halleluiah. Instead of sitting,standing and kneeling like a bunch of lemmings you will be able to participate in praising God.
  • ««zamboni»»Hellsoldier-BN0 2011/05/27 13:31:34
    Harsh
    ««zamboni»»Hellsoldier-BN0
    +1
    Actually, non of that. Who cares about the pope?
  • ally 2011/05/27 13:24:27 (edited)
    Just
    ally
    +1
    But Sunday Mass was a he// of a good time. sunday mass nuns  dancing in chuech
  • SEAL76 2011/05/27 13:00:26
    Harsh
    SEAL76
    He sure moved quickly on this one. Where was the pope and his colleagues when children were being molested.
  • baboula SEAL76 2011/05/27 15:17:22
    baboula
    he wasn't pope then
  • JWoods0417 2011/05/27 12:41:43
    Harsh
    JWoods0417
    They don't shut down churches when children are molested and raped by priests.
  • Michael JWoods0417 2011/06/19 03:00:52
    Michael
    Shutting down the church in such a situation would punish the parishioners more than the priests. Instead what the Church does is put the priest on a canonical trial.
  • Charlied169 2011/05/27 12:13:36
    Just
    Charlied169
    +1
    This is a question I wish there were more answer options to.

    Do I agree with the Pope's decision, no, I think the Catholic Church needs some reforms. However, as a Catholic Church they agree to abide by certain rules and if they were operating outside of those rules, it is fair and just for the Pope to take his actions.

    What we don't have here is more information such as did the Pope try working with the Parish to bring them back into the fold? And I would think more importantly was the Mass being celebrated appropriately and the Word of God preached in accordance with Catholic doctrine? These should be the issues focused on, not the sensational stuff like the concerts and the nuns dancing.
  • RebornRepublicanBigot 2011/05/27 12:04:22
    Harsh
    RebornRepublicanBigot
  • Dr. Ingbert 2011/05/27 12:03:06
    Just
    Dr. Ingbert
    We just can't have dancing nuns!

    dancing nuns
  • G 2011/05/27 11:43:40
  • ELLIE 2011/05/27 10:42:29
    Just
    ELLIE
    At least he can't be done for not doing anything
  • Eloka 2011/05/27 09:48:12
    Harsh
    Eloka
    But what do you expect from a man that tells everyone homosexuality is wrong while walking around in a dress?
  • Michael Eloka 2011/06/19 03:02:01
    Michael
    It's not a "dress". It's called a soutane.
  • wolfshadow 2011/05/27 09:00:15
    Harsh
    wolfshadow
    +1
    I guess raping kids is better? Me thinks the Catholic church and the Democratic Party should get together and have a going away party...
  • Eloka wolfshadow 2011/05/27 09:49:48
  • wolfshadow Eloka 2011/05/27 19:49:51
    wolfshadow
    Okay... your a gay republican pedophile... so join the Catholic church.
  • ItsYaFace 2011/05/27 07:42:53
    Just
    ItsYaFace
    Good, one down, a few more million to go.
  • Estick 2011/05/27 07:34:40
    Just
    Estick
    +1
    The corporation does not approve.
  • val 2011/05/27 07:06:27
    Just
    val
    I think he's just covering his ass,god forbid the Catholic church should be exposed to big Dyke Nuns like Sister Rose Carmel I had to deal with as a kid in Detroit..
  • Cimz 2011/05/27 06:41:10
    Just
    Cimz
    +1
    where is the option saying Undecided?
  • Anna 2011/05/27 06:29:17
    Just
    Anna
    Both.
  • Colbert 2011/05/27 06:12:29
    Just
    Colbert
    +3
    Remember Catholics, the Pope is infallible.
  • JenSemPa 2011/05/27 06:12:29
    Just
    JenSemPa
    +3
    He's the boss.

    And I bet you dollars to donuts, too, that the convent was asked by the Vatican to cease and desist first. And that they probably ignored the warnings.
  • Daedalus JenSemPa 2011/05/27 07:55:00 (edited)
    Daedalus
    +2
    And this week on nuns gone wild. :-)

    week nuns wild
  • Charlie... Daedalus 2011/05/27 12:16:07
    Charlied169
    +1
    too funny!!!! I can see the commercials on late night cable channels already!!!!
  • Michael JenSemPa 2011/06/19 03:03:34
    Michael
    Generally speaking that's what happens. The Holy See makes numerous requests, the offenders don't listen and the Apostolic See is forced to react and assert its authority.
  • Myrle Hulme 2011/05/27 06:00:41
    Harsh
    Myrle Hulme
    He is jeolous that he was not invited
  • Charlie... Myrle H... 2011/05/27 12:16:53
    Charlied169
    I'm not sure dancing nuns are his thing
  • Myrle H... Charlie... 2011/05/30 07:16:33
    Myrle Hulme
    Obviously
  • Sexuallobster 2011/05/27 05:56:35
    Harsh
    Sexuallobster
    +1
    Child molestation? Naaaah.

    Rumours of innapropriate behaviour? ACTION MUST BE TAKEN.
  • JenSemPa Sexuall... 2011/05/27 06:15:43
    JenSemPa
    +2
    If you think the Church takes no action against child molestation, then you are very much living in the past.

    Did the Church have a lax attitude toward that problem 20 or 30 years ago? Yes, it did. So did every other institution that works with kids.

    THESE DAYS, though, the Church does not take the issue lightly at all. In fact, it is probably more serious about the issue than anyone else who works with kids is.

    That's certainly true of the public school systems. Its track record was horrible then, and it's still horrible now -- but all we hear about is the priests.

    Stop. Living. In. The. Past. The "priest-pedophile" thing is OLD news. Most of it happened years, even decades, ago. It's not happening nowadays. You can count the number of incidents that occurred in 2010 on two hands. Literally.
  • Eloka JenSemPa 2011/05/27 09:52:27
    Eloka
    +1
    http://www.time.com/time/worl...

    They are never EVER sanctioned for their actions, tell people to stop living in the past? You stop supporting a cult of evil men who get off on their own corrupt power.
  • Shigyrl... Eloka 2011/05/27 12:09:21
    Shigyrl but outspoken on my future
    Really time magazine is your source.
  • Eloka Shigyrl... 2011/05/27 12:15:19
    Eloka
    +1
    No it's not my source, it was the first page I picked when I googled I found this in an article of New Science in Australia on the effects of religiousity. Thanks :)

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/20 16:26:46

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals