Quantcast

Should There Be More ‘Made In America’ Policies?

AdriHead 2012/08/03 21:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Finally! Something we can all agree on! A recent survey shows that both Democrats and Republicans agree that there should be more "Buy America" policies instilled by the U.S. government.

In fact, an "overwhelming majority" said that they would even support something from the government that mandated that taxpayer money be used on goods that are made in the U.S. Do you think there should be more "Made in America" policies instilled by the government? Or should individuals have the utmost freedom to buy whatever they want to buy... even if it ends up hurting their country's economy?

ABCNEWS.GO.COM reports:
While President Obama and Mitt Romney bicker over whose policies will send more jobs overseas, there is one side of the job creation coin that both candidates agree on: that the government should do its darndest to keep manufacturing jobs in America.

Unlike many of the job proposals both candidates are pushing, “Buy America” policies that encourage the government to buy products that are made in the U.S. whenever possible are hugely popular across party lines, according to a national survey commissioned by the Alliance for American Manufacturing and the United Steelworkers.

made in america

Read More: http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2012/07/made-...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Mike luigi1-... 2012/08/06 16:08:35
    Mike
    +1
    germans are full of red tape and they do very well, because the red tape prevents jobs from leaving . with unfettered capitalism it requires you to throw your friend under the economic bus, and it has reached its pinnacle and now needs to be curbed so the economy can absorb the damage already done due to stealing too much too fast. fuel prices is a good example. before all this crap happened, when a corp did a 5% profit for the year thru wallstreet, it was considered a good year, now they are do 80 to 200% profit every year. who do you think is paying for that??? research this yourself and then try to talk about regulations
  • luigi1-... Mike 2012/08/06 22:57:01
    luigi1- in god we trust
    +1
    Germany will do anything& everything to protect German jobs. The USA hasn't advanced to that point yet.
  • Mike luigi1-... 2012/08/16 22:16:27
    Mike
    well spoken
  • Mike Hula gi... 2012/08/06 16:02:36
    Mike
    lol, you seem to be missing the point. it is for wallstreet, that they take it over seas, not the politics. it is so a person with a piece of paper in his hand can get rich at the expense of the american people . please feel free to learn about economics and how unfettered capitalism requires people to throw their neighbors under the economic bus
  • jcadla Hula gi... 2012/08/06 19:17:27
  • Hula gi... jcadla 2012/08/06 19:21:49
    Hula girl - Friends not Followers
    +1
    No dear....much less. Obama has been adding over 2000 per MONTH SINCE HE GOT INTO OFFICE.
    http://www.regulations.gov/#!...


    ANOTHER REASON BUSINESSES ARE NOT HIRING.
  • T Hula gi... 2012/08/06 23:03:13
    T
    +1
    If I wanted to live in a country that didn't protect its workers and majority citizens, then I would move to Sudan.

    I live in THE U.S.A. I am proud of the skilled craftsmen and laborers we have. I am disgusted by the companies that get a tax exemption for the cost of moving jobs overseas. I am sick of hearing them blame the regulations that protect me and you from living in 3rd world conditions. I am appalled by the amount of money the elite of this country keep in foreign accounts just to avoid paying 15% capital gains taxes on money they don't even need.

    We used to aspire to intelligence, not belittle it or let it make us feel inferior. We used to wage wars on poverty, not poor people. We used to be the home of the brave. Now, we scare so easily.

    I am an American, and I know that we have the capability of making this nation the best nation in the world again. I will not settle for anything less, and I will not compromise the progress we have made so far, just to line the pockets of those who already have everything.

    We need to make incentives for doing what is right. We need to bring jobs back to this country so that we can have more producers. We need to make incentives for education so that we can supply the engineers, scientist, and technicians who would support that produc...

    If I wanted to live in a country that didn't protect its workers and majority citizens, then I would move to Sudan.

    I live in THE U.S.A. I am proud of the skilled craftsmen and laborers we have. I am disgusted by the companies that get a tax exemption for the cost of moving jobs overseas. I am sick of hearing them blame the regulations that protect me and you from living in 3rd world conditions. I am appalled by the amount of money the elite of this country keep in foreign accounts just to avoid paying 15% capital gains taxes on money they don't even need.

    We used to aspire to intelligence, not belittle it or let it make us feel inferior. We used to wage wars on poverty, not poor people. We used to be the home of the brave. Now, we scare so easily.

    I am an American, and I know that we have the capability of making this nation the best nation in the world again. I will not settle for anything less, and I will not compromise the progress we have made so far, just to line the pockets of those who already have everything.

    We need to make incentives for doing what is right. We need to bring jobs back to this country so that we can have more producers. We need to make incentives for education so that we can supply the engineers, scientist, and technicians who would support that productivity. We need to give those that are the least of us the OPPORTUNITY to become the best of us instead of tearing them down with insurmountable barriers of cost.

    What part of this seems to need less of anything?
    (more)
  • Don Leuty 2012/08/04 05:04:00
    No
    Don Leuty
    +8
    Let the consumer decide what is best for the consumer. Trade "policies" lead to trade wars, an nobody wins with that.
  • Whyputa... Don Leuty 2012/08/04 05:28:18
    Whyputaname
    Hey, why not, U.S. Corporations would rather pay a $1.00 a day and no benefits then pay you a decent wage....
  • Don Leuty Whyputa... 2012/08/04 05:39:36
    Don Leuty
    +4
    You will get the value of your labor, not what you think it should be. The demand for any product drops with increasing prices. Product include work product. Skilled trades will be more in demand than unskilled.
  • SW Don Leuty 2012/08/04 21:17:37
    SW
    +1
    What if the consumer decides he wants stuff made by child or slave labor? Basic human rights shouldn't be decided by the "consumer."
  • Don Leuty SW 2012/08/05 10:08:58
    Don Leuty
    Good point. Child labor is like polio.
    Slave Labor? Check your license plate.
  • SW Don Leuty 2012/08/04 21:18:28
    SW
    ...then when the consumer's job gets shipped to China they can have fun in the last cheap shirts they could afford and then blame over-regulation and Obama or whatever. Good plan.
  • Don Leuty SW 2012/08/05 10:10:12
    Don Leuty
    +1
    Blame the Union that priced your wages above market demand.
  • Mike Don Leuty 2012/08/06 16:10:06
    Mike
    unions did get greedy, but mostly jobs were shipped over seas and now we cannot keep up demand due to everyone being broke
  • Don Leuty Mike 2012/08/06 16:30:04
    Don Leuty
    +1
    Funny how it always works that way when someone prices themselves out of the market. At that point, it is time to exit that market and enter a new one.
  • DoxieDad 2012/08/04 04:54:20
    Yes
    DoxieDad
    +3
    You know we don't need Congress for this. Buying American is something that should be a grass roots movement by the American people.
  • Centuri... DoxieDad 2012/08/04 21:35:12
    Centurion~PWCM~JLA
    +2
    Yep. The hard part is finding the American made merchandise on the shelf or hanging on the rack. I was shopping for a suit some months ago. Some were made in Honduras. Others made in Mexico. One brand was made in England (about 12X the cost of the one made in Mexico). I couldn't find one made in this country.
  • Kat 2012/08/04 04:53:01
    Yes
    Kat
    For some things
  • Heisenberg 2012/08/04 04:50:01
    No
    Heisenberg
    +5
    No. Protectionism hurts the economy.

    We should instill a pro-USA culture so that people voluntarily become US biased and make US businesses competitive so we make the best products at competitive prices.
  • Digman14 Heisenberg 2012/08/04 04:53:19
    Digman14
    +1
    A pro-USA culture can also lead to extreme nationalism, much akin to the likes of Hitler's Third Reich and the Japanese Empire.
  • Soot Th... Digman14 2012/08/04 04:56:40
    Soot The Fallen
    But a lack of it could lead to the dismanteling of the US as an superpower or even a nation.
    So how about we dont have a completly Pro-usa culture and have it slightly golbalized.
  • Korgull Soot Th... 2012/08/04 12:19:26
  • Soot Th... Korgull 2012/08/04 19:06:28
    Soot The Fallen
    But I do belive we should be united as a world and not be so closed minded and well lead by an Supreme leader who cant feed his own people that recently died in december....
    We shall stand separated in names and policies but we shall be united as a species in a perfect world in my eyes.
  • Whyputa... Digman14 2012/08/04 05:30:24
    Whyputaname
    Yeah, and the Chinese wouldn't be making their $1.00 a hr wage.....
  • Katherine Digman14 2012/08/04 05:34:50 (edited)
    Katherine
    +1
    That's one hell of an overstatement - reductio ad Hitlerum, appeal to fear. Being pro-USA isn't comparable to their regime. It's trying to repair our country. We've given enough money to countries with horrible human rights records who hate us.

    Hitler took supremacy of the State to the extreme degree of doing away with all individual freedom. He nationalized everything and controlled all industries through a centralized, autocratic government.

    Government needs to get out of the way of business. We aren't robots, we're human beings. Human beings will only tolerate abuse for so long. THEY built their business, not government. THEY don't need government, government needs THEM.
  • Heisenberg Digman14 2012/08/06 01:08:21
    Heisenberg
    +1
    Unlikely.

    We have fascism in the USA and it's not the right.
  • Digman14 Heisenberg 2012/08/06 12:03:36
    Digman14
    Fascism in itself is a right-wing ideology, it's incredibly difficult to be both fascist and progressive/liberal at the same time, because many of their ideals conflict. The "consent of the governed" versus "serve or perish" is a major source of contradiction. There are those who support authoritarianism on the left, who believe people are incapable of making choices. Although this is a small, radical sect of left-wing ideology, I do agree with them to a very minor extent, some people aren't knowledgeable of policy and do not understand it.
  • Katherine Digman14 2012/08/06 18:53:08
    Katherine
    +1
    Right wing according to whom, the KGB?

  • Digman14 Katherine 2012/08/06 20:56:25
    Digman14
    A Republican explaining why conservatism is better will really prove your point to me.
  • Katherine Digman14 2012/08/06 21:03:52
    Katherine
    What's "better" is interpreted by the individual. I can't help that you might support the same behavior and policy.
  • Heisenberg Digman14 2012/08/06 20:43:31
    Heisenberg
    +1
    Sorry but no. This is a lie sold by the left.

    Liberals are modern fascists. Read the definition...it is another version of totalitarianism.

    American conservatism was born by limiting the power of government.

    Left wing politicians are violating the 1st amendment, not righties.
  • Digman14 Heisenberg 2012/08/06 21:04:03
    Digman14
    American liberalism was born by limiting the power of government over the people directly. John Locke, the father of liberalism, was the primary inspiration for Declaration of Independence and the constitution.

    Conservatism was born from the preservation of ideologies that worked in the past but cannot keep up in an constantly changing world. America is seriously lagging behind because of this.

    Liberalism came before conservatism. The liberalism of today will be the conservatism of tomorrow. It's a neverending cycle. We see this now with the increasing number of gay right supporters, when 30 years ago, America was decently anti-gay. There was a time in the 1900s where this country was proud to call itself progressive, and the people equally prideful. This was when America became the richest nation in the world, even though it wasn't even 150 years old. When people were put before profit to the point that Standard Oil was broken up into 30 different companies to protect citizens from rising prices. It's time to do it again, but this time, with banks. It's time to restore Glass-Steagall, and break up the ones that are too big to fail. They're a liability to the American taxpayer, and it is not our responsibility to bailout companies that made risky decisions that inevtiably cost America trillions of dollars and millions of jobs.
  • Heisenberg Digman14 2012/08/06 22:38:52
    Heisenberg
    Yes and modern liberals are 180 degrees away from the founders.

    Big government nanny state socialism is exactly what the Founders were worried about.

    If they were alive today they would fix bayonets and charge the Democrat party.
  • ben 2012/08/04 04:21:05
    No
    ben
    +4
    Hmmm... A long time ago I heard stories of a strange consept called... What was it again? Oh yeah!! Capitalism!!!! I don't think this was it. Weird, I heard that Americans supported it... Oh wait we do! By the looks of it, we only do in theory. Wow, maybe next time we can consider switching from presidents to warlords and kings.
  • Seiryuu ben 2012/08/04 05:15:25
    Seiryuu
    *concept
  • T. James H ben 2012/08/06 02:15:31
  • 2cool4skool<3 2012/08/04 04:05:09
    Yes
    2cool4skool<3
    +2
    I'm tired of so many things made in china. It is not that i'm racist but some made in china have really bad quality. US tends to make way better stuff and more quality made things. So yes please there should be more "made in America" policies. :)
    :)
  • john Kills 2012/08/04 04:03:52
    Yes
    john Kills
    This is one of the very first things barry the idiot should have done upon taking office. No better way to bring everyone together than by installing a sense of patriotism and pride and a sharing of responsibility in turning things around.
  • Whyputa... john Kills 2012/08/04 05:32:27
    Whyputaname
    Oh geez, here we go with the patriotic BS...Spoken like a true parrot.....

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/25 23:24:42

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals