Quantcast

Should the Government Impose a 'Christmas Tree Tax'?

SodaHead News 2011/11/09 23:28:26
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Whether you want to call this a "tax" or not is really up to your interpretation, but the government is considering a mandatory 15-cent fee on fresh Christmas trees in order to fund a commodity brand ad campaign, sort of like the "Got Milk?" commercials that have been running since the '90s. Officials hope an ad campaign will improve the public's perception of the fresh Christmas tree industry, which has suffered in recent years. But will a Christmas tree tax make things better or worse?

christmas trees

The Heritage Foundation is critical of the proposed fee. David Addington, a former top aide to Dick Cheney, wrote an article for the conservative think tank claiming, "Nobody is saying President Obama doesn't have authority to impose his new Christmas Tree Tax -- his Administration cites the Commodity Promotion, Research and Information Act of 1996. Just because the Obama Administration has the legal power to impose its Christmas Tree Tax doesn't mean it should do so."

White House spokesman Matt Lehrich explains, "I can tell you unequivocally that the Obama administration is not taxing Christmas trees. What's being talked about here is an industry group deciding to impose fees on itself to fund a promotional campaign, similar to how the dairy producers have created the 'Got Milk?' campaign."

Betty Malone, an Oregon tree farmer with Christmas Tree Promotion Now, said, "We have good reason to believe it will be successful for our industry. We looked at what other industries have done, and how successful they've been."

Still, the administration has put the measure on hold to decide whether or not it would be a good idea. Some are worried the industry will shift the tax to consumers, charging them the extra 15 cents instead of taking the hit themselves, but the biggest argument against the fee is the fact that tree sellers would not get a choice in the matter.
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Idiot repubs 2011/11/10 00:51:12 (edited)
    No
    Idiot repubs
    +18
    It's not the government doing it.

    This is a lie from fox "news" it's the tree growers association for marketing.

    You people may be the most gullible on the planet, did you even read the article?

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Bocephus 2012/01/06 16:42:39
    No
    Bocephus
    List of Taxes We Pay in the USA
    The List was so big I had to shorten it.


    Cigarette Tax
    Corporate Income Tax
    Court Fines (indirect taxes)
    Dog License Tax
    Federal Income Tax
    Federal Unemployment Tax (FUTA)
    Fishing License Tax
    Food License Tax
    Fuel Permit Tax
    Gasoline Tax (42 cents per gallon)
    Hunting License Tax
    Inheritance Tax
    Interest Expense (tax on the money)
    Inventory Tax I
    RS Interest Charges (tax on top of tax)
    IRS Penalties (tax on top of tax)
    Liquor Tax
    Local Income Tax
    Luxury Taxes
    Marriage License Tax
    Medicare Tax
    Sales Taxes
    School Tax
    Septic Permit Tax
    Service Charge Taxes
    Social Security Tax
    State Income Tax
    Telephone State and Local Tax
    Telephone Usage Charge Tax
    Toll Bridge Taxes Toll
    taxes
  • BARRY0619 2011/11/23 22:17:07
    No
    BARRY0619
    +1
    It's ridiculous, but they should permit the "yes" voters to pay more since they love being taxed more...
  • NatAlex23 2011/11/23 07:26:25
    No
    NatAlex23
    That tax would bring in a total of maybe $1, right? Who uses a real Christmas tree? Everyone I know has an artificial one.
  • Birthpangs NatAlex23 2011/12/27 13:13:49
  • DSSSD94 2011/11/14 19:20:49
    Yes
    DSSSD94
    Are you going to cry for 15 cents? It makes a difference for them not for you.

    That is if they're honest about what they are doing.
  • Birthpangs DSSSD94 2011/12/27 13:13:23
  • TasselLady 2011/11/14 18:49:44
    No
    TasselLady
    +1
    That's pretty sad if they are trying to tax anything to do with Christmas. Anything to make a quick buck off the American people.
  • wgossett99 2011/11/14 18:29:48
    Yes
    wgossett99
    If the Xmas Tree Industry wants to do this to themselves, they should.

    And yes, the cost will get passed on to the consumer. But, really, most trees cost over $20. Are you not going to buy it because it costs $20.15?
  • Birthpangs wgossett99 2011/12/27 13:14:32
  • wgossett99 Birthpangs 2011/12/27 15:25:50
    wgossett99
    That sounds like "It's not the money, it's the principal!"

    Wake up, Pal. It's the money.
  • Birthpangs wgossett99 2011/12/27 15:33:50
  • wgossett99 Birthpangs 2011/12/27 15:58:16
    wgossett99
    I stand by my comment.
  • Birthpangs wgossett99 2011/12/27 16:24:07
  • Buhbye Sodahead! 2011/11/14 18:23:33
    No
    Buhbye Sodahead!
    +2
    I have a fake. But even still, I'm against any new taxes. We're taxed more than enough as is.
  • nightcrawler2005 2011/11/14 18:10:01
    No
    nightcrawler2005
    +1
    I think maybe they should start taxing politicians as they are the real wasters of tax money.
  • voice_m... nightcr... 2011/11/14 18:12:16
    voice_matters
    +1
    and yet the tree farmers want the tax on their product
  • Larry Kyle 2011/11/14 14:44:44
    No
    Larry Kyle
    +1
    Just another tax to pay for the national deficit they keep growing
  • LittleBrothers_Better 2011/11/14 08:18:14
    No
    LittleBrothers_Better
    +1
    ... Really?

    Who the hell would support this?
  • voice_m... LittleB... 2011/11/14 18:12:37
    voice_matters
    +1
    THE TREE FARMERS
  • DSSSD94 voice_m... 2011/11/14 19:21:52
    DSSSD94
    Agreed.
  • Birthpangs DSSSD94 2011/12/27 13:20:14
  • Chi~Cat 2011/11/14 07:32:56
    Yes
    Chi~Cat
    Sure, if I can impose a big a** kick up their keister...cool with me. I'll pay a 'nominal' tax on a tree as long as I can have a good 'ol kickaroo at a big fat cat pollie; especially those that support this lame-o proposal. First in line, right here: (wait your turn, we'll make sure everyone gets one).

    us government bad santa
  • Rollo Goodlove 2011/11/14 07:08:24
    No
    Rollo Goodlove
    +2
    Further more, I think the Heritage Foundation, The Tea Party, and FOX news should all pool their money, and send a humanoid like robot back into the future to kill Obama's mother ! Keep Obama from ever being born, and the Resistance WINS !!!
  • KingdomNow 2011/11/14 04:57:53
    No
    KingdomNow
    How about a turkey tax?
    How about a Halloween costume tax?
    How about a tax on American flags?

    Taxation is a disincentive -Taxes on alcohol and tobacco are meant to discourage their use.

    Buy a fake tree and you'll have one for decades.

    Me? I don't do holidays. Every day is like the next.
  • ☥☽✪☾DAW... KingdomNow 2011/11/14 15:01:01
    ☥☽✪☾DAW ☽✪☾
    +1
    actually there is a tax on halloween costumes
    and American flag tax
    american flag  made in china
  • DSSSD94 ☥☽✪☾DAW... 2011/11/14 19:22:47
    DSSSD94
    Lmao. This is sad.
  • KingdomNow ☥☽✪☾DAW... 2011/11/16 01:04:37
    KingdomNow
    No, the tax is for generic products -There aren't specific taxes targeting those items.
  • Foothill 2011/11/14 04:34:35
    No
    Foothill
    +1
    Maybe that committee could study the greenhouse gas effect of all the hot air escaping from Washington DC
  • voice_m... Foothill 2011/11/14 18:14:14
    voice_matters
    +1
    why is it libs ignore the facts? so i will post them again and mabe this time it will get through the ass---THE TREE FAFRMERS ASSOCIAITION ASKED THE USDA TO ADD ON THE 15CENTS ON EACH TREE
  • Foothill voice_m... 2011/11/14 23:33:48
    Foothill
    Geez such a toxic little man. It was humor that didn't quite click in your head. You might discern the part making fun of greenhouse gases from DC as probably not a "libby" type of comment. You always so LOUD! Simmmmmerrr down.
  • voice_m... Foothill 2011/11/15 01:49:07
    voice_matters
    another lib with their ignorance has been dealt with
  • Foothill Foothill 2011/11/15 03:17:15
    Foothill
    LMAO! "voice_matters" blocks me so I can't respond to him. You so have little man complex! Guess the block and run didn't work so well. What a little weenie!
  • Birthpangs Foothill 2011/12/27 13:22:20
  • Dy 2011/11/14 04:30:09
    No
    Dy
    i dont care, we use a fake tree :P
  • lionheart 2011/11/14 03:57:19
    No
    lionheart
    There are many taxes already.
  • Larry Kyle lionheart 2011/11/14 14:49:55
    Larry Kyle
    +1
    Which was why we went to war with England and became our own nation.
  • voice_m... Larry Kyle 2011/11/14 18:18:34
    voice_matters
    +1
    another ignorant lib so again here are the facts you decide to ignore- THE COLONIES FOUGHT FOR THEIR INDEPENPENDENCE NOT BECAUSE OF THE NUMBER OF TAXES BUT BECAUSE WE DID NOT HAVE REPRESENTATIVES IN PARLIAMENT. TODAY WE HAVE REPRESENTATION IN OUR LEGISLATURES AT ALL LEVELS. SORRY LIBBY JUST POSTING THE FACTS YOU WANT TO IGNORE
  • Larry Kyle voice_m... 2011/11/14 18:27:57
    Larry Kyle
    Not ignoring anything I know my history, taxes where the last straw. sorry if your blinded by Obama. have a great day
  • voice_m... Larry Kyle 2011/11/14 18:31:50
    voice_matters
    +1
    sorry libby you want to ignore the facts there is no reason to waste anymore time
  • voice_m... lionheart 2011/11/14 18:14:47
    voice_matters
    +1
    and if the tree farmers want 15 cents added to each tree then it should happen.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 19 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/18 09:51:09

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals