Quantcast

Should the FDA Regulate E-Cigarettes Like Tobacco?

SodaHead News 2011/04/27 19:57:28
You!
Add Photos & Videos
E-Cigarettes, in case you're unfamiliar, are battery-powered vaporizers shaped like cigarettes that convert liquid nicotine into a smooth, breathable vapor.

After much debate, the FDA has decided that it will need to regulate e-cigarettes, but will monitor them as they would tobacco products, as opposed to medical products such as marijuana, WebMD reports.

The FDA says it decided not to appeal a federal appeals court ruling asserting that e-cigarettes could be regulated as tobacco products and “are not drugs or devices” unless specifically marketed for therapeutic purposes, such as purporting to help people quit smoking.

It is widely believed that e-cigarettes are safer than cigarettes, but little research has been done outside of the e-cigarette companies themselves. The product does not contain tobacco, but the nicotine it contains is derived from it.

Read More: http://www.webmd.com/smoking-cessation/news/201104...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • wpsark_BN_0 2011/04/28 17:38:25
    No
    wpsark_BN_0
    +4
    FDA, you mean the thugs who allow drug companies to sell drugs with harmful side effects such as hemorraging, cancer and...oh yeah, death.
    It's all about the money, the FDA is useless and should be dissolved

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • skroehr 2011/04/28 20:12:18
    No
    skroehr
    +2
    I answered no, but my views on this aren't simple. I don't think REAL cigarettes should be regulated either. BUT, since they are, and since nicotene is a drug that the FDA is apparently bent on controlling, then in fairness, e-cigarettes ARE a nicotene delivery system, so my answer in the real world is yes, but only because the real tobacco products ARE regulated, and E-cigarettes are simply a newer way of getting a controlled substance. I don't care if the FDA wants to leave tobacco alone. i don't even care if they want to leave marijuana alone. It doesn't effect me one way or the other, but since they've decided that nicotene and THC need to be controlled substances, then that should apply across the board for all manner of delivery.

    So....schizophrenic answer for me.

    No....because I don't personally give a crap
    Yes... because you can't discriminate based on delivery. Nicotene can't be a controlled substance in some instances and not in others. It either is or isn't.

    Good luck to both the pros and the cons. You're both right in a sense. It's the government that's kind of hypocritical, out of step and inconsistent.
  • Matt skroehr 2011/04/29 18:13:45
    Matt
    Have Electronic Cigarettes Gained Royal Focus? - http://www.thevaporrevolution...
  • clasact 2011/04/28 19:58:03
    No
    clasact
    what are you going to regulate it a vapor mist ya know water ????
  • wingman 2011/04/28 19:43:19
    No
    wingman
    You want to TAX water vapor, what is next, SEX?
  • Matt wingman 2011/04/28 20:03:37 (edited)
    Matt
    When Obama serves his second term, ...which has already been decided, they'll need to tax orgasms. You're in BIG trouble there ladies!! Having the multiples! LOL
  • AIC fan 2011/04/28 19:32:29
    No
    AIC fan
    The government is slowly taking away our rights. I say let them smoke e-cigarettes
  • ih8uf 2011/04/28 19:10:21
    No
    ih8uf
    seems to me nicotine is a drug, and should be treated as such...
  • wingman ih8uf 2011/04/28 19:49:29
    wingman
    It is regulated just like alcohol, Ha Ha. What a world we live in. That industry has more money than a train could pull.
  • ih8uf wingman 2011/04/29 21:56:42
    ih8uf
    I'll drink to that...
  • melanie ramos 2011/04/28 18:28:25
    No
    melanie ramos
    +2
    Love me some E-Cigarettes! I just got the Tornado from Totally Wicked. Winning! But in all seriousness, we can't trust the FDA since they decide what is "healthy" vs "unhealthy" according to corporate interests.
  • Ben 2011/04/28 18:22:43
    Yes
    Ben
    +1
    I've gone 2 weeks without any nicotine! no cigarettes, patch, gum, etc! Cold turkey baby!!!!
  • Matt Ben 2011/04/28 18:33:35
    Matt
    ...and getting FAT!!
  • Ben Matt 2011/04/28 18:38:17
    Ben
    +1
    Food likes me. But I AM working out like crazy, though.
  • Matt Ben 2011/04/28 18:51:31
    Matt
    What non smokers fail to see is that nicotine is not the hardest part of the habit to kick. It's the physical, hand to mouth part of the habit that is hard to beat. So most people who quit cold turkey, ...now instead of a cigarette in their hand, they have food in their hand and that's where they gain all the weight. People, especially non smokers don't see that and will never understand it.

    The other problem is psychological. During a break at work, after a meal or when you wake up in the morning. Your body isn't SCREAMING out that it's needs you to light a cigarette up for some nicotine. It's all been programmed in your mind. After a meal, ...I have a cigarette. After making love to the wife, ...I need a smoke. I am bored to death in this bumper to bumper, rush hour traffic moving along at 3 mph. That's when people grab the pack, pull one out and light it up.

    All of it has nothing to do with nicotine.
  • Ben Matt 2011/04/28 19:14:06
    Ben
    My struggles were always with nicotine. For many, its the habit. I seriously was addicted to the nicotine and still am. Thats why one puff from a cigarette is enough to make me break.
  • Robbb Matt 2011/04/28 19:55:34
    Robbb
    You make a rely good point there I gave it up after a few false starts and found that getting the nicotine addiction under control was not a big problem, It was all the little habits dissociated with it that was the hardest to shake.
  • melanie... Matt 2011/04/29 16:42:35
    melanie ramos
    This is true.
  • Hebertprime 2011/04/28 18:19:13
    No
    Hebertprime
    But why the hell not! They regulate everything else.
  • Bulldog 2011/04/28 18:18:08
    No
    Bulldog
    The FDA should be dismantled anyway along with over 1/2 the Federal Government anyway.
  • Matt Bulldog 2011/04/28 18:35:41
    Matt
    The best way to cut back the wasteful spending this sorry government has never been able to manage. Now we have one who is not a Natural Born Citizen in the white house and he's spending your money faster than they can print it.
  • wingman Matt 2011/04/28 19:44:57
    wingman
    +1
    Not HE, but the FEDS
  • Stan Kapusta 2011/04/28 18:07:11
    No
    Stan Kapusta
    +1
    Just another money sucking agency that does next to nothing.
  • WickedPippy 2011/04/28 17:57:27
    No
    WickedPippy
    +3
    The FDA is twisted. Nicotine isn't what causes all the issues when you smoke. It is the smoke its self and all the chemicals in the cigarettes. Why does the FDA stick their noses in places they have no business in. For F*** Sake soon we won't be able to wipe our a$$es unless the FDA approves the toilet paper.
  • Matt WickedP... 2011/04/28 18:05:42 (edited)
    Matt
    +2
    LOL!!! Love that last line! While the toilet paper they did approve would probably increase the chance of getting colon cancer.
  • wpsark_BN_0 2011/04/28 17:38:25
    No
    wpsark_BN_0
    +4
    FDA, you mean the thugs who allow drug companies to sell drugs with harmful side effects such as hemorraging, cancer and...oh yeah, death.
    It's all about the money, the FDA is useless and should be dissolved
  • DANNY_B0i♛ 2011/04/28 17:32:56
    No
    DANNY_B0i♛
    +1
    Its not like a real cigarette. They can't kill you as fast and all that.
  • bob h. 2011/04/28 17:31:59
    Yes
    bob h.
    I know for sure there's one guy in Des Moines that smokes one. He's totally demented but he still pays taxes.
  • Johnnyknowvote 2011/04/28 17:23:32
    No
    Johnnyknowvote
    +2
    But they will, if only to get some tax money lost by not smoking the real thing. Reagans words are more true now than ever before, In speaking about how the government interacts with the economy, Ronaldus Magnus said, "If it moves, tax it, if it keeps moving, regulate it, if it stops moving, subsidize it".
  • MxkxB 2011/04/28 17:22:02
    Yes
    MxkxB
    Not on the side of any regulatory agency, however the packages are readily available for kids, and that's quickly becoming the new "IN" thing to do.
    It's a very addictive drug, no matter how you look at it. Smokers are addicts.
  • Matt MxkxB 2011/04/28 17:34:31
    Matt
    Do you drink coffee? ...Soda? If so, you are an addict as well. That would be like the pot calling the kettle black.
  • MxkxB Matt 2011/04/28 17:48:03
    MxkxB
    Smokers are extreme drug addicts!

    I rarely drink coffee and soda is just bad for you!
  • WickedP... MxkxB 2011/04/28 18:01:37
    WickedPippy
    +1
    It is not the nicotine that harms you...yes it is addictive but it is no more harmful to you than coffee. The smoke and chemicals in real cigarettes is what truly harms people. and unless you give your kids credit cards to order things off the internet, it's not like you can buy them in the corner store. They are not cheap either. It is just another form of control and has nothing to do with health risks.
  • MxkxB WickedP... 2011/04/28 18:14:28 (edited)
    MxkxB
    Nicotine is 166 times more deadly than caffeine!
    http://whyquit.com/pr/021606....
    The kids are not buying them in the stores or using credit cards to get them.
    They are getting them on the streets. And now there's a new twist on the street, "designer cigs".

    Comparing Addictive Qualities of Popular Drugs

    (Higher score indicates greater effect)

    Substance Withdrawal Reinforcemt Tolerance Dependnce Intoxictn
    ----------- ---------- ----------- --------- --------- ---------
    Nicotine 6 4 5 3 2
    Heroin 5 5 6 5 5
    Cocaine 4 3 3 6 4
    Alcohol 3 6 4 4 6
    Caffeine 2 2 2 1 1
    Marijuana 1 1 1 2 3

    Withdrawal: Presence and severity of characteristic withdrawal
    symptoms.

    Reinforcement: A measure of the substance's ability, in human and animal
    tests, to get users to take it again and again, and in preference to other
    substances.

    Tolerance: How much of the substance is needed to satisfy increasing
    cravings for it, an...








    Nicotine is 166 times more deadly than caffeine!
    http://whyquit.com/pr/021606....
    The kids are not buying them in the stores or using credit cards to get them.
    They are getting them on the streets. And now there's a new twist on the street, "designer cigs".

    Comparing Addictive Qualities of Popular Drugs

    (Higher score indicates greater effect)

    Substance Withdrawal Reinforcemt Tolerance Dependnce Intoxictn
    ----------- ---------- ----------- --------- --------- ---------
    Nicotine 6 4 5 3 2
    Heroin 5 5 6 5 5
    Cocaine 4 3 3 6 4
    Alcohol 3 6 4 4 6
    Caffeine 2 2 2 1 1
    Marijuana 1 1 1 2 3

    Withdrawal: Presence and severity of characteristic withdrawal
    symptoms.

    Reinforcement: A measure of the substance's ability, in human and animal
    tests, to get users to take it again and again, and in preference to other
    substances.

    Tolerance: How much of the substance is needed to satisfy increasing
    cravings for it, and the level of stable need that is eventually reached.

    Dependence: How difficult it is for the user to quit, the relapse rate,
    the percentage of people who eventually become dependent, the rating users give
    their own need for the substance and the degree to which the substance will be
    used in the face of evidence that it causes harm.

    Intoxication: Though not usually counted as a measure of addiction in
    itself, the level of intoxication is associated with addiction and increases
    the personal and social damage a substance may do.
    (more)
  • Matt MxkxB 2011/04/28 18:38:39 (edited)
    Matt
    +2
    ROTFL!! So I should smoke a joint with my morning coffee?
  • MxkxB Matt 2011/04/28 19:12:09
    MxkxB
    Not recommended but it is less addictive.
  • Matt MxkxB 2011/04/28 19:49:45
    Matt
    Were you aware that Tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) cures cancer?
  • MxkxB Matt 2011/04/28 20:18:36
    MxkxB
    In studies only.
    Tetrahydrocannabinol can aid to inhibit some tumor growth in mice. It increases the autophagic nature of some cancer cells to eat themselves(apoptosis). In other words it can activate a cell signaling pathway that leads to cell death. It's use is limited and the chemical Marinol is the mainly used ingredient instead.
    By the way: You'd overdose before you in inhaled enough to get a useful dosage of that compound.
    It is currently being tested in mice. And the bad part is:
    "Marijuana Smokers Face Rapid Lung Destruction -- As Much As 20 Years Ahead Of Tobacco Smokers"
    http://www.sciencedaily.com/r...
  • Matt MxkxB 2011/04/28 21:00:19
    Matt
    Which is why many who use marijuana now, especially for medicinal purposes do not smoke it. They get the THC through the process of using a vaporizer.

    HEY! I'm not catching a buzz off this weed you sold me! "That's because I already used it in a vaporizer."
  • MxkxB Matt 2011/04/28 21:21:08
    MxkxB
    I get my buzz just enjoying you guys here on SH.
    You have to admit, it's fun chatting with hundreds of smart people.
  • cellophane MxkxB 2011/05/13 23:06:13
    cellophane
    Of which, of course, I am the smartest... :p

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/18 16:32:45

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals