Quantcast

Should someone's wrong opinion trump the Constitution just because they were appointed to the Supreme Court by a guy with a fake birth certificate?

tncdel 2012/07/10 11:23:23
You!
Add Photos & Videos
+1
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • tncdel 2012/07/10 11:25:14
    NO [explain why not].
    tncdel
    +3
    Any opinion that fails to comport with the Constitution should be deemed invalid.
    >> See Replies

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • George Romney 2012/07/10 15:50:35
    YES [explain why you think so].
    George Romney
    Roberts, the deciding vote, was appointed by Bush. Unless you were implying that George W. Bush was actually born in Mexico rather than the United States.

    I can say I dislike this Law. But I also can say I respect the opinions of the Court empowered by the Constitution itself, the Judiciary Act of 1787 and Marbury v. Madison (1803). Justice Roberts nailed it when he said it wasn't his job to protect the people from their own bad laws made by their Representatives. A bad law can be legal. It's up to the people to make sure bad laws don't get passed.
    reply
  • Mike 2012/07/10 12:58:04
    NO [explain why not].
    Mike
    The appointed ones don't care about the constitution
    reply
  • Waldorf 2012/07/10 12:42:07
    NO [explain why not].
    Waldorf
    +1
    This same sort of thing, and far worse, has been conveniently going on for a couple centuries now. Only lawyers can divine the truth from plain enough language.
    reply
  • Tasine 2012/07/10 12:23:37
    NO [explain why not].
    Tasine
    +2
    Because they are not Constitutionally in that position. They got there via a scam, via dishonesty. I totally agree with the article's stance that the idea of the "living" Constitution has any validity - were it indeed "living and evolving" it would be a worthless sheet of paper, just like this crowd in DC now want it to be.

    A great article with which I totally agree in all aspects.

    A superb post!
    reply
  • tncdel 2012/07/10 11:25:14
    NO [explain why not].
    tncdel
    +3
    Any opinion that fails to comport with the Constitution should be deemed invalid.
    reply

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/25 07:30:27

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals