Quantcast

Should Every State Ban Indoor Smoking?

SodaHead News 2011/04/22 18:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
"I'll give you my cigarettes when you take it from my cold, (cough, cough) dead hands."

That might be the rallying cry of smokers everywhere after Nanny Nation takes control of your cancer stick habit. According to The New York Times, federal health officials predict that by 2020, every state might have smoking bans in restaurants, bars and workplaces.

"It wouldn't surprise me if they prevailed," Gary Nolan, of a smokers' rights group Smoker's Club, told the Times. "It's just a little bit more liberty slipping away at the hands of big government."

The number of states with indoor smoking bans went to 25 in 2010 from zero in 2000. Nearly half of U.S. residents are covered by comprehensive state or local indoor smoking bans, the Center of Disease Control estimated

"It is by no means a foregone conclusion that we'll get there by 2020," Dr. Tim McAfee, director of the CDC's Office on Smoking and Health, told the Times. But "I'm relatively bullish we'll at least get close to that number."

It's too early to make definite assessments of the bans. But some studies show declines in adult heart attack rates and in childhood asthma attacks after smoking bans were adopted in some communities, according to the Times.

Read More: http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2011/04/21/health/...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Woolite 2011/04/22 18:49:32
    No
    Woolite
    +37
    I despise smoking, but am really concerned that when something exists that we don't like, we automatically and reflexively turn to government to "control" it. How does one select which cause is noble and which intrusive? By what one personally likes or dislikes? And if you and I can do that, then certainly others can so do, at our cost. Where is the line?

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • This is W³ 2012/10/10 06:51:50
    No
    This is W³
    Only in public places, not private ones. It would be pretty impossible to do, anyway.
  • flyingseaturtle BN 2012/05/30 17:07:56
    No
    flyingseaturtle BN
    I think it up to the states to decide.
  • Smitty 2012/02/12 23:33:46
    No
    Smitty
    I do not smoke,but this was an early law by the Federal Government to start telling people how to live.Note to the Govt.GET OUT OF PEOPLES LIVES!
  • waynelaboy 2011/06/15 16:17:01
    Yes
    waynelaboy
    kill yourself, not the rest of us or make bars for smokers and if non smokers want to kill themselves then that's their choice, you see freedom. freedom to walk in and commit a slow suicide.
  • Ken123 waynelaboy 2011/10/01 15:46:05
    Ken123
    If you are so afraid of shs then you should exercise your freedom of choice, not try to impose your choices on me. Take your business to a restaurant or bar where the owner restricts smoking on his private property. My property does not belong to government and as long as activites are legal it's my business to conduct as I see fit.
  • waynelaboy Ken123 2011/10/02 11:33:09
    waynelaboy
    any idiot would automatically that i'm not refering to personal property. go inside and blow your brains out.
  • Ken123 waynelaboy 2011/12/17 12:16:17
    Ken123
    Since when is my restaurant public property? It's my business, my investment and my city has not provided a single penny in its establishmment. I've taken all the risk and I should be able to run it the way I see fit. Take your socialism and stick it where the sun don't shine.
  • Ken123 waynelaboy 2012/03/03 17:53:06
    Ken123
    You need to to pay closer attention to whatis written. My restaurant is my personal property and my clientelle is what keeps me in business. Idon't need any level of governmentt to tell me how to run my business, whether my customers can smokr or not or how much salt they can eat and if they can have steak or green beans. Get a life and exercise your freedoms before someone takes them away from you.
  • Smitty Ken123 2012/02/12 23:39:12
    Smitty
    You are 100% right Ken!
  • Ken123 waynelaboy 2011/12/17 12:08:30
    Ken123
    How can his be, smoking rates decline and asthma rates increase:
    http://online.wsj.com/article...
  • Ken123 waynelaboy 2012/02/11 16:22:32
    Ken123
    One thing for sure, losing your freedoms of Private property rights assures government control over your entire life. It started with smoking bans in the name of health and now they want to tell you what you can and cannot eat what you can and cannot do.about your health and how much you will pay for it. Like I said before, when it's your ox that is being gored your position will change.
  • hobo 2011/06/04 14:30:38
    No
    hobo
    +1
    Smoking shouldn't be banned as long as tobacco products are taxed.
  • Intelic KA 2011/05/27 20:44:49
    Yes
    Intelic KA
    thats such a weirded question.
    it should be regulate-able.
    but you can't control everything, especially in dealing with People.
  • Miss Bela Rae 2011/05/15 05:13:40
    Yes
    Miss Bela Rae
    +1
    i absolutely cannot STAND it when people smoke inside it is the worst smell in the world
  • Ken123 Miss Be... 2011/10/01 15:49:12
    Ken123
    Then you should stay away from me, its your choice to take your busiiness elsewhere. Don't try to impose your will on me and my customers.
  • Miss Be... Ken123 2012/01/05 22:37:35
    Miss Bela Rae
    i seriously didn't mean to be rude to people who smoke. i'm just stating my opinion. i don't mind if people smoke inside just not around me.
  • Ken123 2011/05/14 14:29:19
    No
    Ken123
    Check the deficits of all those aforementioned states, then ask yourself, on whose back wll your legislature will they make up the difference?
  • deerichards 2011/05/10 01:04:22
    No
    deerichards
    Any place that is an optional visit by customers should be left to make their own decision. Customers will help the business decide. Places that service all citizens should either ban smoking in their establishment or provide smoke/smoke-free service centers. Those that have said yes should consider the next dictate by the government...and the next...and the next. Be careful to note that every time the government steps in, it gets easier for their next 'good for you' legislation.
  • Ken123 deerich... 2011/10/01 15:54:46
    Ken123
    Anyone that thinks for one second the government is interested in your health is smoking funny rope. If government senses any money in a cause, they'll jump on it like stink on deficate.
  • Ken123 Ken123 2012/04/28 16:43:50
  • AlanMooreJr 2011/05/08 08:23:45
  • OUTrageous 2011/05/06 02:13:57
    Yes
    OUTrageous
    How about some compromise here... Just ban the exhaling part.
  • waynelaboy OUTrageous 2011/06/15 16:17:26
    waynelaboy
    lol!
  • Gabby Grandchamp 2011/05/06 02:01:45
    Yes
    Gabby Grandchamp
    uh duh!
  • Jayne 2011/05/05 10:16:41 (edited)
    Yes
    Jayne
    I'm a smoker and have no problem going outside but don't get crazy here. Second-hand smoke may be a very small factor in getting someone else sick but consideration should be given to other environmental causes. Vehicle exhaust, in my opinion, plays a bigger role. How about where you live? The food we eat is filled with chemicals. The list could go on. Right now the heat is on smoking. Tomorrow it may be red meat. Personal freedom is something that can be erroded very slowly over time. One day we all may wake up and find out that the life we live is no longer ours.
  • Ken123 Jayne 2011/05/14 14:34:29
    Ken123
    While we're on the subject, which of your freedoms are you willing to give up next, whether you use it or not?
  • Ken123 Jayne 2012/03/18 23:08:39
    Ken123
    You must be physic, the red meat vemdetta started this week, I just haven't figured out yet who is set up to gain from it.
  • tornadoxxx 2011/05/05 02:54:12
    No
    tornadoxxx
    Take away my cig.., and i will cut you're wind pipes.
  • adios 2011/05/04 04:04:49
    Yes
    adios
    i am smoker but i used to show respect to my non-smoker roomates...easy right???
  • Myrle Hulme 2011/05/03 10:24:26
    No
    Myrle Hulme
    I presume you are meaning shopping malls and offices. Yes ban it but not in your own home
  • Ken123 Myrle H... 2011/10/01 16:02:57
    Ken123
    It's fine with me if the owner of the mall wants to ban smoking in his mall, I just won't go there. In my city they banned smoking and unconstitutional imposed the ban on most businesses so I don't shop in my city anymore and now the city is raising sales tax but everyone is paying it.
  • Myrle H... Ken123 2011/10/05 06:43:16
    Myrle Hulme
    Its banned here, the people just stand outside the door and have their cig. Now they want to stop drinking for people under 21 years
  • Ken123 Myrle H... 2012/01/22 01:30:34
    Ken123
    Check this out by letting governmment ger away with passing smoking bans on private property invites other actions such as the following:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?...
  • BurntOffering 2011/05/02 21:08:07
    No
    BurntOffering
    +2
    and stay away from outside smoking too. Either make cigarettes illegal; or get off people's backs about it.
  • PilarHernandez 2011/05/02 07:23:33
    Yes
    PilarHernandez
    +1
    Ugh, smoking. If I wanted to have stinky smoke around me, I'd go OUTSIDE and smoke a cancer stick myself; don't need your secondhand smoke.
  • Ken123 PilarHe... 2011/06/12 00:58:56
    Ken123
    Just keep your butt away from businesses that allow smoking, when it's banned the business losses its clientele and, subsequently its business and lays off its employees and you pick up the tax burden for unemployment compensation and the lost revenue to SCHIP.
  • Ken123 PilarHe... 2012/02/11 16:36:30
    Ken123
    I have large signs on my doors that read "Smoking allowed in designated areas only" and signs which mark those areas. If you can read English, stay out of the smoking areas, Problem solved.
  • TaylorSwift Fan 2011/05/02 06:27:19
    Yes
    TaylorSwift Fan
    glad tennessee is all green:)
  • Ken123 TaylorS... 2011/10/01 16:08:29
    Ken123
    Aw yes Tennesee, what happened to all your Waffle Houses and the people they employed?
  • nefertari 2011/05/02 00:44:44
    Yes
    nefertari
    +1
    Why should we be victim to some one else' smoke leaving us open to second hand smoke cancer? I have lost three friends to second hand smoke that they got at work. If they want to get cancer, keep it to themselves, don't give it to us.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 64 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/24 00:50:43

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals