Quantcast

Should America Split Apart?

☆WILLIAM☆ 2012/09/22 23:42:01
Yes, We Should Go Our Seperate Ways And Live Our Own Lives
We Should Continue With The Current Government Structure
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Given that the country hasnt been this polarized since pre-civil war periods, isnt it time the regions of America Went their own seperate ways? I have an idea on how this can be done effectively, and without all the sacrifices that would come from a normal secession.
First, we need to establish a government system that gives people powr over their own communities. For instance, the culture of one town in Mississippi wont look like the culture of a town in California. The people are different, and their values are different, and that should be okay.In this new system of government, communities would be able to govern themselves without fear of federal or centralized government, or some foreign political group coming in and dictating their livelyhoods based on the opinions of people who are 1000 miles away and will never live there. Then, we need to create a binding document that recognizes individual liberties that are natural to every human being, so that everyone, regardless of what region theyre in, is free to pursue life as they wish.

The end result will be a nation where the people have direct influence on their livelyhood, communities dictate to themselves how to do things instead of answering to a governing body foreign to the area, State governments represent its many communities, and the national government doesnt have authority over states, but instead protects the principals that give states, communities, and people power over their own lives.

WAIT, isnt that what we had to begin with? WTF happened to America?




Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • nbarton2 2012/09/23 00:15:56
    We Should Continue With The Current Government Structure
    nbarton2
    +9
    Our Government works although we need to get back to the Constitution and the Founders intent.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Red 2012/09/23 03:38:56
  • Ledford 2012/09/23 03:22:04
    None of the above
    Ledford
    +1
    Never split but give us people that will actually represent the majority. If you do not he people will split but not in the way you want it. There will be an uprising and not a nice one
  • Undecided
    ☆The Rock☆ * AFCL* The Sheriff!!
    +5
    I am afraid the with Obama and an overbearing federal government, state will sucede from the Union..It could happen because history does repeat itself..I have heard that states are trying to start their own gold standard to be self sufficient..With Obama no telling what is going to happen in America!

  • Dahlia 2012/09/23 02:55:00 (edited)
    Yes, We Should Go Our Seperate Ways And Live Our Own Lives
    Dahlia
    +2
    I think it be better to just have small nations the size of states world wide. That way if you don't like how your nation is run it won't be hard to find one you do like. Seeing how their will be tons of them to pick from.
  • jubil8 BN-0 PON 2012/09/23 02:33:54
    None of the above
    jubil8 BN-0 PON
    +1
    Over 300,000,000 people, often with family far away, aren't going to split apart easily no matter how much one faction despises another.

    Personally, I can think of several states I wouldn't miss and wouldn't mind needing a passport to visit.

    The current outcry against increasingly big gov. is the best hope we have imo.

    What makes you think the country hasn't been this polarized since before the Civil War? In fact it's been DEEPLY polarized MANY times -- before entering WWI; before entering WWII; McCarthyism; the late 60's and early 70's. Not to mention the entire political structure in the "Deep South" morphing from Dem to Repub starting in the early 60's.
  • ☆astac☆ jubil8 ... 2012/09/23 10:02:45
    ☆astac☆
    +1
    The dems did not morph into the repubs in the 60's
  • jubil8 ... ☆astac☆ 2012/09/23 15:29:08
    jubil8 BN-0 PON
    I didn't say they did. Get back to me when you learn to read.
  • ☆astac☆ jubil8 ... 2012/09/23 16:41:02
    ☆astac☆
    But you did, and you are wrong. the dems in the south stayed dems, and they are still racists
  • Mark Ma... jubil8 ... 2012/10/13 05:49:08
    Mark Marchionni
    +3
    But there had always been Progressives and conservatives in each party. Now that is no longer true (give or take). The press has taken sides. Debates don't occur. It is assumed that the other side are idiots, racists, or wanna be dictators. As the parties drift farther left and farther right, where is the compromise supposed to come? If I think a business needs vast new regulations and you believe there should be fewer regulations what happens? Keeping the status quo will not do. If you give in to new regulations you are farther from your goal. If I give in to less regulations I'm farther from my goal. The two sides are mutually incompatible.
    A house divided cannot stand.
  • jubil8 ... Mark Ma... 2012/10/13 17:22:39
    jubil8 BN-0 PON
    Sure there are progs and cons in each party -- just don't let the label-makers shine you on. :) I agree about debate, and I'd go a lot farther -- stifled creativity and/or no more encouraging climate for invention and ideas.

    I didn't say we should keep the status quo -- I said I don't think splitting apart is likely, at least in the foreseeable future. That doesn't involve any value judgment about whether splitting would be good or bad.
  • tommyg - POTL- PWCM-JLA 2012/09/23 02:31:34
    We Should Continue With The Current Government Structure
    tommyg - POTL- PWCM-JLA
    +1
    We've been down that road.
  • Temlakos~POTL~PWCM~JLA~☆ 2012/09/23 02:21:22
    Yes, We Should Go Our Seperate Ways And Live Our Own Lives
    Temlakos~POTL~PWCM~JLA~☆
    +6
    What if all the citizens of Flyover Country went on strike against the Leftist Coasts? How long would the Leftists last?
  • Swampdog Temlako... 2012/09/23 14:41:58
    Swampdog
    +1
    Damn right!
  • DemonChild 2012/09/23 02:10:35
    None of the above
    DemonChild
    +4
    Not split, but should we create a new government out of ours? YES!
  • Catch224u 2012/09/23 02:00:39 (edited)
    Yes, We Should Go Our Seperate Ways And Live Our Own Lives
    Catch224u
    +2
    But we tried that, and was forced back into the Union at gun point. Y'all want to help us out, we'll try it again. " Sic Semper Tyrannis"
  • Lerro DeHazel 2012/09/23 02:00:29
    None of the above
    Lerro DeHazel
    +3
    NOT by Area, or Region, established by some Geographical Map, etc.; but by Political Beliefs . . . Yes, we should split and have a Revolution and kill some people . . . If not then the future and mostly to save future generations; which are going to suffer; or else not even know how it could have been. THAT is what I fear the most . . . I have grand-children and I want them to not have to suffer . . . Am I willing to give my own life for them; YOU BETCHA!!
  • ConLibFraud 2012/09/23 01:53:59
    Yes, We Should Go Our Seperate Ways And Live Our Own Lives
    ConLibFraud
    +3
    You are on to something but first a couple of item you have missed ...

    - How do we throw off the NWO chains that currently grip the nation?
    - How would America have a military to fend off any other nation?
  • mary E ConLibF... 2012/09/23 04:02:12
    mary E
    +2
    I truly don't know how we can throw off the NWO chains, but if not done soon it will be too late to do it!
  • ConLibF... mary E 2012/09/23 20:57:35
    ConLibFraud
    +1
    It is simple ... a nationwide tax revolt with stopping payments on all bank loans. But the sheeple have been programmed and prefer to live in fear and slavery.
  • mary E ConLibF... 2012/09/24 06:11:09
    mary E
    I think you are right about the fear. I wouldn't have the nerve to be the first, say, to refuse to pay my income tax in protest. We sheeple need a leader. I wouldn't hesitate to do that if I knew there would be enough participants to cause a great stir. It would take a strong leader to bring enough people in to make a difference.
  • ConLibF... mary E 2012/09/24 08:56:16
    ConLibFraud
    +1
    One or two individuals cannot make it happen. It would have to be a nationwide effort or not at all and we know what the odds are of the dumbed down sheeple coming together and doing this.
  • mary E ConLibF... 2012/09/26 06:33:03
    mary E
    +1
    I think you are right. But, if we wait until we crash and people are hungry and desperate, there will be rioting, burning and looting in the streets, and stealing from neighbors. Not the kind of revolt that would solve problems.

    Then we will wish that we had put forth greater effort to effect change in a non-violent way.

    And we will remember that it would have only taken wise voting by the American people.
  • ConLibF... mary E 2012/09/26 07:16:05
    ConLibFraud
    +1
    The elections are fixed. The people need to take a stand now.
  • unicorns vs narwhals 2012/09/23 01:43:09
    Undecided
    unicorns vs narwhals
    +2
    If things don't get better than there are a few states that would benifit from this.
  • Tennyson James 2012/09/23 01:27:20
    We Should Continue With The Current Government Structure
    Tennyson James
    What you described in red is what we already have. God forbid should the people come together and work to unite our country. Let's just have all the states divorce themselves from each other b/c life after divorce is always so much better than maintaining a committment of unity. Sheesh, what an assinine idea.
  • ConLibF... Tennyso... 2012/09/23 01:49:11
    ConLibFraud
    +1
    As if you libs and cons will ever unite! Get a big lunch!
  • Tennyso... ConLibF... 2012/09/23 03:27:56
    Tennyson James
    +2
    Do you even realise the irony in what you just said? Here's a hint: You are perpetuating the divisiveness with your attitude.
  • ConLibF... Tennyso... 2012/09/23 21:00:53
    ConLibFraud
    You live in denial. If you don't know by now that the left and the right will never come together, you probably think cows graze on the moon. You may awaken when starving in a fema camp. Even then you will still think you can vote out the bad guys.
  • Tennyso... ConLibF... 2012/09/23 21:29:26
    Tennyson James
    With so little hope why do you even get out of bed in the morning?
  • ConLibF... Tennyso... 2012/09/23 21:33:40
    ConLibFraud
    +1
    The only way you can be right is when America collapses and then the sheeple will be forced to come together.
  • mimi 2012/09/23 01:23:06
    None of the above
    mimi
    +5
    Not crazy about the words "current Govt structure" unless it means the Constitution, and NOT Obama.
  • dubbie 2012/09/23 01:18:34
    None of the above
    dubbie
    +4
    No need to do that , We have free trade agreements with Mexico and beings they`ve already sent their people over here It`s our turn to send libby`s over their , You Know , Giving our fair share
  • ☆WILLIAM☆ dubbie 2012/09/23 01:35:37
    ☆WILLIAM☆
    +5
    I completely agree. Maybe if we strat drilling off the coast of California theyll all run to Mexico.
  • jubil8 ... dubbie 2012/09/23 02:13:03
    jubil8 BN-0 PON
    +2
    Why not just give them their own back? That's not even "trade," it's just finding missing persons.
  • my2cents 2012/09/23 01:13:24
    Undecided
    my2cents
    +2
    We could, but then the United States of America, our Founders great experiment on self-governance, would prove a failure.
  • ☆WILLIAM☆ my2cents 2012/09/23 01:15:50
    ☆WILLIAM☆
    +3
    read context please.
  • my2cents ☆WILLIAM☆ 2012/09/23 02:22:24
    my2cents
    I did. So?
  • ☆WILLIAM☆ my2cents 2012/09/23 04:00:38
    ☆WILLIAM☆
    +2
    My point was that weve moved away from self governance. States are dictated by the federal government. communities are dictated by the federal government, and soon people will be dictated by the federal government
  • my2cents ☆WILLIAM☆ 2012/09/23 04:09:04
    my2cents
    +1
    Maybe, maybe not . . . but Americans have abdicated their individual vote to party loyalty. I see that as the problem, not the government.
  • ☆WILLIAM☆ my2cents 2012/09/23 04:10:48
    ☆WILLIAM☆
    +2
    Party loyalty is also a problem.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/21 09:32:24

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals