Quantcast

Should America Adopt a Fat Tax?

SodaHead News 2012/05/21 16:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Several months ago, Denmark became the first country in the world to adopt a "fat tax." The tax increased the price of certain fatty foods based on the fat content, kind of like the excise taxes on alcohol and tobacco that are already in place. Don't worry, there's currently no legislation in America threatening to tax fatty foods, but researchers are making a case for it in terms of fighting obesity.

Dr. Eric Wright, head of Indiana University School of Medicine's Department of Public Health, told RTV6, "We've applied tax to alcohol and tobacco and that has definitely shown through very many studies that it actually decreased use. So, the logic has been applied to fatty foods and preliminary evidence in Europe is that it’s very effective." The study suggests a 20 percent tax on cheeseburgers, but doesn't give any other examples. It expects to cut obesity rates by 3.5 and prevent 2,700 deaths. Do you think America should adopt a "fat tax"?

in n out
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Cyan9 2012/05/21 17:29:12
    No
    Cyan9
    +1
    I doubt it would alter consumption patterns very much. There seems to be more effective and direct ways to lower obesity than taxing the fat content of food. Maybe we can start by eliminating all our inefficient and counterproductive agricultural subsidies. Our flawed agricultural policy is as much to blame for our health problems than consumers.
  • the judgebigdogeagle 2012/05/21 17:26:34
    No
    the judgebigdogeagle
    I control what I eat.Do not need no "f" in tax
  • taitaFalcon23 2012/05/21 17:23:32
    No
    taitaFalcon23
    +1
    That would lower the deficit and leave us with a surplus - and get President Obama reelected
  • Cyan9 taitaFa... 2012/05/21 17:26:05
    Cyan9
    All horrible things. :P
  • taitaFa... Cyan9 2012/05/21 17:33:34
    taitaFalcon23
    lowering the deficit would be horrible!?
  • Cyan9 taitaFa... 2012/05/21 17:37:46
    Cyan9
    No, I was being sarcastic. I very much wouldn't mind Obama's reelection or the structural deficit being fixed.
  • taitaFa... Cyan9 2012/05/21 19:28:13 (edited)
    taitaFalcon23
    +1
    heh... sorry for being slow on the uptake. But back to the question at hand... what people have to understand is that healthcare, medicare, medicaid and social sec are tied into our state of health across this nation. Chronic disease and/or conditions are killing people in particular but killing this nation in general. Want to lower the cost of healthcare over the long-term? Teach or encourage people how to live better. That begins in our youth - not after you get type 2 diabetes from too many red bean and rice ho-downs...
  • Cyan9 taitaFa... 2012/05/21 21:54:25
    Cyan9
    +1
    Absolutely agreed. One of the worst aspects of the US health care is that it absolutely discourages preventive care(not as profitable and most insurances had no reason to provide for such care).
  • taitaFa... Cyan9 2012/05/25 00:39:11
    taitaFalcon23
    why should they - cancer and heart disease pays... why limit the cash cow?
  • Max Power 2012/05/21 17:20:53
    No
    Max Power
    I eat fast food semi-regularly, but I'm not fat.
  • Biki 2012/05/21 17:19:40
    No
    Biki
    +3
    no! The "experts" can kiss my ass! This is America! Land of the free, home of the brave and the hamburger. Get over it azzholes!
  • Opinions4Free 2012/05/21 17:19:32
    No
    Opinions4Free
    +3
    Hello, slavery to the state.
  • cm 2012/05/21 17:19:02
    No
    cm
    No, but if there is a fat tax it should be for liberals only since they want a fat government.
  • Kozmo cm 2012/05/21 20:47:35 (edited)
    Kozmo
    Over the last third of a century in both Canada & the States, the Conservates (Reagan, Mulrooney, Bush, Harper) have been worse spendthrifts than the Liberals.

    The 2008 finance crisis (happened pre-Obama) was executed by shady banking practices. Offering loan to folks who can't pay while paying insurance for the inevitable SNAFU and a getting bailouts while their boards get bonuses. This spanned régimes so the politicians were spared (some) blame. But they got too cozy with banks running this Ponzi Scheme on the World.

    establishing a wealth & windfall tax could help.
  • flyingseaturtle BN 2012/05/21 17:16:39
    No
    flyingseaturtle BN
    +3
    I want a smaller government...
  • JCLadybug 2012/05/21 17:15:36
    Yes
    JCLadybug
    Dang it....clicked the wrong one. No I do not think we should adopt a fat tax. No problem with eating these foods every now and then and why should something be taxed based on the government's opinion of what is healthy.
  • intolerantrwj 2012/05/21 17:04:55
    No
    intolerantrwj
    +1
    ...... wow, another Tax, there's what we need !


    Fighting Obesity ..... will the fool out there who thinks the Government really gives a sh*t about the dimensions of our waistlines, Please Stand Up !


    .................... they're damned sure doing an all out assault on keeping my wallet as thin as possible.
  • kar 2012/05/21 17:04:42
    Yes
    kar
    Yes as long as the tax collected goes to programs to help treat the obesity issues in the U.S. I believe people make choices based on their wallets and fatty foods are cheap foods. Mostly because they are over-processed and barely food. Real food that is healthy costs more than the junk we are shoving down our throats. If that becomes reversed, I think we will be a healthier nation. Obesity costs us all, the tax will help cut those costs.
  • FromJesus'sPerspective 2012/05/21 16:59:55
    Yes
    FromJesus'sPerspective
    And most of the money will be collected from fatcat Republicans

    fatcat republicans
  • intoler... FromJes... 2012/05/21 17:08:09
    intolerantrwj
    +3
    .... like Barney ' I can't button my shirt ' Fwank ?
  • intoler... FromJes... 2012/05/21 17:21:39
    intolerantrwj
    ..... whoops, diseased link
  • FromJes... intoler... 2012/05/21 17:25:38
    FromJesus'sPerspective
    +1
    that s lame animation

    That was so lame you are like a fish out of water
  • intoler... FromJes... 2012/05/21 17:29:16
    intolerantrwj
    .... I suppose so .... like yeah dude, if you say so

    .......................... but what did you do with the dead link dude .... it like beeeezz gone dude ?
  • Opinion... FromJes... 2012/05/21 17:21:58
    Opinions4Free
    +1
    Bla bla bla...
  • john Kills 2012/05/21 16:59:46
    No
    john Kills
    +3
    The government needs to stay out of people's business.
  • Wahvlvke 2012/05/21 16:58:20
    No
    Wahvlvke
    +3
    Why don't we adopt a libertard tax? (or progressive ... or socialist)
    Why don't we adopt a tax on people who do not mind their own business?
    Why don't we adopt a tax on people who stick their noses in other peoples business?
  • Gunner 2012/05/21 16:47:09
    No
    Gunner
    +1
    Ridiculous and insulting to many people!
  • Bigbrowneyes 2012/05/21 16:39:53
    Yes
    Bigbrowneyes
    +3
    I wish these foods just would not be created in the first place...If you want to harm your body, why not pay for it?
  • john Kills Bigbrow... 2012/05/21 17:03:06
    john Kills
    Eat what you want dumbass and so will I. I eat these foods all the time. I am a grandfather and have a body most 25 year old would love to have.
  • Bigbrow... john Kills 2012/05/21 19:06:46
    Bigbrowneyes
    I'm sorry if I offended you by wishing people were healthier. I'll try to not care about anyone and try to insult people over the Internet instead of having logical debates from now on.
  • john Kills Bigbrow... 2012/05/21 22:25:14
    john Kills
    I am not offended, I have very think skin. I am tired of people telling others what they should or should be doing. This country is supposed to be free and everyone is supposed to be responsible for their own decisions weather they be good or bad. Be free mean being free to succeed or fail based upon decision making and effort.
  • Bigbrow... john Kills 2012/05/21 23:46:52
    Bigbrowneyes
    Do you believe there should be any laws at all?
  • GLaDOS Bigbrow... 2012/05/21 18:36:29
    GLaDOS
    +2
    Fair enough. Then people who skateboard, bungee jump, skydive, surf, play sports, etc. should probably pay extra insurance amounts since they're more likely to be injured as well.
  • Elementer GLaDOS 2012/05/21 18:46:58
    Elementer
    That actually makes sense.
  • Bigbrow... GLaDOS 2012/05/21 19:08:53
    Bigbrowneyes
    That's a good idea, actually...

    I'm not trying to impose on people's rights, I just think that higher risk things should be acknowledged as high risk.
  • GLaDOS Bigbrow... 2012/05/21 19:14:52
    GLaDOS
    Only problem with the "fat" thing, is that fat isn't what is making people obese, but over-consumption of the wrong, and in some cases right, carbs.
  • Bigbrow... GLaDOS 2012/05/21 19:27:49
    Bigbrowneyes
    I just like the basic principle behind it. You're right, it may not cut down on obesity, but I think there may be a better way to apply limitations that will. And thank you for approaching this situation logically and calmly...
  • GLaDOS Bigbrow... 2012/05/21 19:45:35
    GLaDOS
    In that case, we should probably tax carbs, such as sugars, rice, corn, and potatoes, which are really some of the biggest offenders.
  • Bigbrow... GLaDOS 2012/05/21 19:51:40
    Bigbrowneyes
    *sighs* Good point.

    I suppose even broccoli could get you fat if you ate enough of it. However, some foods just are "higher risk"...It's something to consider, not an ultimate decision.
  • john Kills Bigbrow... 2012/05/21 22:38:50
    john Kills
    I love asparagus and broccoli but I float them in butter so.... I love spinach and kale greens also but I fix them with bacon grease. I eat healthy foods but the way I eat them would not be looked at as healthy. I love red meat too. I do not eat fast food often though. That stuff is a heart attack.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/06/20 06:22:41

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals