Quantcast

Scott Brown Says We Can't De-Fund Planned Parenthood: Are You With Him or Against Him?

SodaHead Politics 2011/03/24 22:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Republicans rejoiced in 2010 when Scott Brown pulled off an upset in traditionally liberal Massachusetts and took the seat formerly held by the late Ted Kennedy. They praised his bootstraps story of rising up from a difficult childhood that included abuse into a career in modeling followed by a quick rise in politics.

And then … Brown made the cardinal sin of a Republican senator and announced this week that he opposes GOP efforts to de-fund Planned Parenthood.

According to the pro-life site LifeNews.com, Brown released a “carefully-worded” statement on Tuesday that it said was “either designed to deliberately confuse organizations following the de-funding debate in Congress or masterfully tiptoeing around a delicate issue.”

Brown’s statement was interpreted by many pro-life groups as a shift in Brown’s position on de-funding Planned Parenthood, which he recently supported though his vote for the House-passed long-term Continuing Resolution containing the Pence Amendment, which would remove all taxpayer-funded support for PP.

“I support family planning and health services for women. Given our severe budget problems, I don’t believe any area of the budget is completely immune from cuts,” Brown said. “However, the proposal to eliminate all funding for family planning goes too far. As we continue with our budget negotiations, I hope we can find a compromise that is reasonable and appropriate.”

LifeNews later reported that it remained unclear if Brown’s statement referred to just the PP de-funding or if he was referring to the entire House bill, which would wipe out all funding for the Title X family planning program, which doesn’t pay for abortions, but provides aid for family planning and reproductive health.

The confusion angered many in the pro-life community and the website suggested that either Brown’s office was simply confused about the two proposals, or that the senator “deliberately issued a statement that the media would interpret as a comment on Planned Parenthood, while pro-lifers would see it as merely a statement on Title X.”

Brown has never claimed to be a pro-life candidate and he’s the third Senate Republican (joining Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska) to publicly oppose the PP de-funding proposal.

Are you with Scott Brown or against him on the PP bill?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Stratweenie57 2011/03/24 22:34:01
    Against him
    Stratweenie57
    +15
    Scott Brown is the quintessential RINO
    A liberal who decided to run as a conservative so he could be elected,and once in governs just like all the rest of the Libs-ass backwards!

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Roy George Jeok 2011/03/25 18:13:45
    Roy George
    No problem, as you can see by my picture I'm easily confused.
  • strawberry Roy George 2011/03/27 20:24:44
    strawberry
    Your tax money is funding all those illigitimate babies born to ignorant, mothers, or those on drugs. You will be paying huge sums of money for the welfare of these kids all their lives.
  • Roy George strawberry 2011/03/28 14:42:13
    Roy George
    So kill them to save money? I see where your head is.
  • strawberry Roy George 2011/03/29 01:03:03
    strawberry
    Then don't complain what it costs you in tax money. It will cost you plenty with or without abortions.
  • turtledove123 2011/03/25 16:32:05
    With him
    turtledove123
    +1
    They do not get federal funds for abortions in the first place.
  • JP turtled... 2011/03/25 16:35:23
    JP
    +1
    Federal funding allows them to use other monies that may not have been available to fund advanced abortion techniques.

    In other words, yes it does.
  • laura 2011/03/25 16:14:22
    Against him
    laura
    The government should NOT be involved in family planning, period. We should encourage our people to be personally responsible and take care of themselves. No funding for Planned Parenthood, or for any other family planning services anywhere in the world.. Should never have happened in the first place. It's not the government's job to protect us from ourselves. We should take charge of that.
  • Blancmange19 2011/03/25 16:10:35
    With him
    Blancmange19
    +2
    The narrow minded anti-choicers can't see the forest for the trees. The organization is called "Planned Parenthood." They try to prevent unwanted pregnancies so abortions are a last resort.. Why can't the anti-choicers understand that?
  • JP Blancma... 2011/03/25 16:37:13
    JP
    +1
    Why can't narrow minded pro-choicers make up the difference in funding via donation? Then everyone has had the right to a "choice".
  • misterz 2011/03/25 16:00:06
    With him
    misterz
    Planned Parenthood does not get any Fed money for abortion. Besides, it is still a choice!
  • Heather ~Warrior Princess~ 2011/03/25 15:49:34
    With him
    Heather ~Warrior Princess~
    +1
    I think that they should defund the abortion part of planned parenthood. The low cost of clinic visits and birth control pills are a big help to society. I am just uncomfortable with tax payer money going to pay for abortions.
  • John 2011/03/25 15:49:34
    With him
    John
    +1
    The House voted based on a video of the right extemist big nosed punk, James O'keefe. They caught one employee screwing up. Planned Parenthood provides many services for women badly needed which many women can't afford and I don't mean abortion. The right takes it's cues from a Pimp and Whore who have been discredited on numerous occasions.
  • Cordingly 2011/03/25 15:44:43
    With him
    Cordingly
    +2
    I've heard about this guy before, and like what I've heard. It bugs me that some conservatives AND liberals on this board don't understand the word compromise, and can only accept "either/or"
  • Tom 2011/03/25 15:37:25
    Against him
    Tom
    +1
    Sure we can.
    Should be called Plan to Never be a Parent...hood.
    They despise women who choose their child over their own convenience.
  • Dora Rachael 2011/03/25 15:30:59
    Against him
    Dora Rachael
    What do you expect from a RINO!
  • Næthan ... Dora Ra... 2011/03/25 16:59:15
    Næthan Æterna
    Serious question..How is he RINO? He's anti-union anti-abortion from what I see so far, you don't get much more Republican than that. I'm assuming you know what the acronym RINO means.
  • Næthan ... Næthan ... 2011/03/25 17:00:22
    Næthan Æterna
    I should really read the whole article first huh? haha, sorry.
  • PaulaDavelleReevesAnders 2011/03/25 15:25:31
    Against him
    PaulaDavelleReevesAnders
    +1
    If people want to get an abortion as long as it is still legal then so be it, but that doesn't mean I should be forced to help pay for it with my tax dollars when it is something I have strong reservations about.... I do believe that abortion is murder and last I checked murder was still a capitol offense yet our tax dollars are forked over every day to do just that...
  • keliffa 2011/03/25 15:22:24
    Against him
    keliffa
  • highlatte 2011/03/25 15:17:18
    Against him
    highlatte
    +1
    Planned Parenthood, more like planned abortion mills. Taxpayers should not fund pro-murder organizantions. Pay for your own abortion.
  • wpsark_BN_0 2011/03/25 15:07:44
    Against him
    wpsark_BN_0
    +1
    If "everyone's" going to have 'affordable" healthcare through Obamacare, why the need for tax funded women's health facilities in the first place???? HMMMM
  • DeeB 2011/03/25 14:58:45
    Against him
    DeeB
    +1
    He is my senator and I did write to him on the subject. I didn't like the response. I am pro choice but do not believe that the taxpayers should pay for abortions. To me, he's more of a liberal than a republican. I think the ones that voted for him are as sorry as those that voted for Obama. Lesson learned, they are all liars, get that through your heads, they will do what they are told by the powers that be. Except for Ron Paul of course!
  • JingoRex 2011/03/25 14:58:01
    Against him
    JingoRex
    +2
    DEFUND them, they are genocidal murderers.
  • explorer1618 2011/03/25 14:50:01 (edited)
    Against him
    explorer1618
    Even if it was good for america and the sky is blue !
  • zbacku 2011/03/25 14:47:42
    Against him
    zbacku
    +1
    Brown is the perfect RINO. Says all the right things to get elected and then flip flops when when his vote would truly cause 'change'.
  • Isisdron 2011/03/25 14:38:09
    With him
    Isisdron
    +1
    well at least one Republican has a bit of sense, but they still havent won me over, I'm sorry.
  • Steve☮E... Isisdron 2011/03/25 14:47:49
    Steve☮END THE FED☮
    +2
    Ah yes because aborting babies is such a humane procedure where no women have regrets.
  • Isisdron Steve☮E... 2011/03/25 15:28:34
    Isisdron
    +2
    I never said anything about regrets, an unwanted pregnancy can only result in suffering and regrets no matter what you choose. Yet people still get pregnant unintentionally, whether it was an accident or just irresponsibility.
  • Steve☮E... Isisdron 2011/03/25 15:43:14
    Steve☮END THE FED☮
    More women who have them regret them. The others use them as birth control - 40% of abortions are from "repeat offenders" Planned Parenthood PUSHES abortion not choice.
  • Isisdron Steve☮E... 2011/03/28 00:50:00
    Isisdron
    and there are also women that are satisfied with their broad array of services that do not include abortion procedures. They dispense medications, screen for cancer, and offer preventative services like annual exams and Paps. They help a lot of people too. But oh well, we'll see how long it lasts.
  • Steve☮E... Isisdron 2011/03/28 01:10:46
    Steve☮END THE FED☮
    10% of their industry is pregnancy prevention, std treatment, and pre-cancer screenings - 90% of their business is abortion.
  • Isisdron Steve☮E... 2011/03/29 13:04:55
    Isisdron
    dont like abortion? dont get one.
  • Steve☮E... Isisdron 2011/03/31 01:38:23
    Steve☮END THE FED☮
    I don't want to pay for them
    I don't want my child aborted
    I want the women to see what she is aborting
    I want a woman educated before she undergoes surgery

    90% of their business is abortion!Try to ignore it all you want they are in the business of murder!
  • Cordingly Steve☮E... 2011/03/25 15:52:12
    Cordingly
    Zero of the federal funding they receive goes towards abortions.
  • Steve☮E... Cordingly 2011/03/25 18:50:23
    Steve☮END THE FED☮
    You really believe that? Of course it does. It might be considered "indirect' but the government knows when they are allocating funds to Planned Parenthood that it is funding millions of abortions.
  • JingoRex Isisdron 2011/03/25 14:58:40
    JingoRex
    yes because tearing out a living baby from the mothers womd and decapitating it while it writhes in pain makes a ton of sense?

    moron.
  • Isisdron JingoRex 2011/03/25 15:30:28
    Isisdron
    +2
    that would be late term abortion, which as far as I know isnt legal. If it is legal, I dont think that many doctors want to perform those for the reason you mentioned above.
  • Steve☮END THE FED☮ 2011/03/25 14:27:51
    Against him
    Steve☮END THE FED☮
    If Planned Parenthood was in the business of actually helping women, and was not committing crimes on a daily basis I could understand the pro-abortion crowd supporting them, But do you love the idea of aborting babies so much you are willing to ignore that they do not care about what is best for a woman - especially underage and minority women? More black babies are aborted every year then are born!
  • DeeB Steve☮E... 2011/03/25 15:04:04
    DeeB
    +3
    I wish you would not say it that way. Pro choice is the right term. I don't think anyone is pro abortion. I believe it's a womans right to choose, but I would not ever recommend it. But as a woman, I wouldn't want Anyone telling me what I can and cannot do with my own body. Any more than you would like it if someone would say that you had to be fixed!
  • Steve☮E... DeeB 2011/03/25 15:08:01
    Steve☮END THE FED☮
    You are pro-abortion, You want a woman to abort whenever the consequences of her actions are an inconvenience for her. You do not care what "choice" she makes. Nor do you think the man, that baby is composed of his DNA, has a choice.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/06/20 03:33:28

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals