Quantcast

School Uses Shock Therapy on Autistic Students: Constructive or Cruel?

SodaHead News 2012/05/23 13:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
The Judge Rotenberg Center, a special needs school in Massachusetts, is facing major controversy this week as information about the school's shock therapy program come to light. According to CNN, a student was treated for post traumatic stress disorder after receiving 31 electric shocks in a seven hour period. Officials were apparently trying to hide video footage of the shocking treatment, but was recently required to reveal it.

Other parents say the school is saving lives. One mother claims the shock treatment helped her son immensely, and calls the school a "godsend." Critics aren't so sure. Some call it torture. A group of opponents are even organizing a protest called Occupy JRC, to be held on June 2. It will include a wide range of speakers, from parents to disability advocates. But do you think shock therapy could be constructive?


Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Rave 2012/05/23 14:05:40
    Cruel
    Rave
    +11
    Shock therapy has been known to CAUSE post-traumatic stress disorder in some patients. I feel it is outdated and we have better treatments available these days.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • mechgogo diane RN 2012/05/24 04:01:46
  • diane RN mechgogo 2012/05/24 04:04:39
    diane RN
    i am not here to judge....what do you attribute your recovery to?
  • VaginaD... mechgogo 2012/05/24 05:45:25
    VaginaDentata
    +1
    It is admirable that you have been successful in life while battling "severe mental illness". You have knowledge of your own unique personal experience. Assuming that Diane is a medical professional from her screen name here, and my own knowledge of being a medical professional for 20 years....we do know what we're talking about when a potentially controversial medical treatment comes under the judgement of sensational media and lay-persons. The treatment in question becomes fodder for attacks and outrage by the community at large...most of whom "had an uncle who was mentally ill" or some other source of knowledge gained by either proxy or osmosis.
  • VaginaD... VaginaD... 2012/05/24 05:46:47
    VaginaDentata
    +1
    ...and the latter part of that statement is my own educated and experienced opinion, as I do not claim to know what other medical professionals think.
  • just me mechgogo 2012/05/24 20:14:57
    just me
    Thanks, mech, for speaking up. My professional life was committed to doing everything in my power to ensure that there are positive, life-enhancing, services and living conditions for children with special needs. Part of what drove me to earn the necessary degrees and training was advocating for one of my children with learning and emotional challenges, whom I saw battered and abused through the system. He also is in his 40s and I believe you speak for him and thousands of others.
  • Mr.Hood... diane RN 2012/05/29 13:31:35
    Mr.Hoodz the Truth Troll
    The kid didn't want to remove his coat. Not a reason to get electrocuted.
  • iamparrot 2012/05/24 00:46:14
    Cruel
    iamparrot
    +4
    I thought we got rid of shock therapy when the nazis were chased out of europe.

    it doesn't help and any gains are short term.
  • Uranos7 2012/05/24 00:39:57
    Cruel
    Uranos7
    +7
    I have a nephew that is autistic and there would be hell to pay if someone tried that on him.
    I have also read a few books on the subject and every one of them says negative reinforcement techniqes produce negative results with autistic patients.
  • bluelady 2012/05/24 00:31:02
    Cruel
    bluelady
    +6
    shock therapy to anyone is cruel
  • Bill 2012/05/24 00:21:31
    Cruel
    Bill
    +3
    If that were my child, when I arrived at the school. All involved would be walking around with their butt's kicked, badges be damned.
  • joe mauro 2012/05/24 00:12:42
    Cruel
    joe mauro
    +3
    a step backwards,and yet another indicator of how modern america is not only ok with but is encouraging humiliating and bulling the physichally and mentally challenged
  • Snow 2012/05/23 23:51:07
    Cruel
    Snow
    While I checked cruel, I wish we could hear from the "patients" themselves before we make a decision.
  • Birthpangs 2012/05/23 23:37:10
  • Laura 2012/05/23 23:31:44
    Cruel
    Laura
    +2
    While I think their could be SOME instances where shock therapy could be useful, generally I feel it is abusive. In schools where it is allowed, such as The Judge Rotenberg Center, it is often not closely monitored which easily leads to misuse and abuse.

    I did some research on The Judge Rotenberg Center a while back and while some people swear by it, there are also many stories of the horrors children have faced. There have even been a few death associated with the school.
  • ed 2012/05/23 23:28:11
    Cruel
    ed
    +5
    any school or any person using this type of treatment on kids needs to be dealt with in a big way.
  • Bibliophilic 2012/05/23 23:22:59
    Cruel
    Bibliophilic
    +6
    It should not be practiced on people who can not agree to undergo treatment. Also, shock therapy has not been proven to be of benefit to autistic people.
  • bobthewelder 2012/05/23 23:18:24
    Cruel
    bobthewelder
    +2
    I have a better idea How about doing a "shock" treatment on the teacher or who ever is doing it to the student...But turn it up full blast....
  • Cameryn 2012/05/23 23:15:11
    Constructive
    Cameryn
    +3
    Hey, it works. If it didnt then it could be called cruel, but it did work and it helped someone.
  • iamparrot Cameryn 2012/05/24 00:44:46
    iamparrot
    +3
    check back in a few weeks/months/years to see if it really helped.
  • Golanv ... Cameryn 2012/05/24 16:03:10
    Golanv (Raven) BN0
    Who? Earnest Hemmingway shot himself after having shock therapy. It does NOT work and is extremely cruel. Ever seen someone after shock therapy? It is not pretty.
  • darkfeary474 2012/05/23 23:12:40
    Cruel
    darkfeary474
    +3
    these people should be brought up on charges!!!!! could you imagine if the parents were to do this to there kids what would happen to them!!! There is no Difference! if the parents would go to prison then so should these people! this is ABUSE PLAIN AND SIMPLE!!!!
  • PokerFace 2012/05/23 23:07:46
    Cruel
    PokerFace
    +6
    they are human not animals, even animals should be treated with care why should poor humans not be, they don't choose to be autistic
  • Jerry McGlothlin 2012/05/23 23:03:34
    Cruel
    Jerry McGlothlin
    +6
    To shock a child 31 times sounds like laboratory experimentation done on animals, which is also very cruel. These are human beings, not guinea pigs for scientific research.
  • FunnyLittleNightmare 2012/05/23 22:57:39 (edited)
    Cruel
    FunnyLittleNightmare
    +1
    Unless it works. It's hard to say really. It sounds as though there's no proof it works and the fact that a child was put through this 31 times tells me maybe it doesn't work. in which case its like animal testing.
  • DonnaMartin 2012/05/23 22:56:51
    Cruel
    DonnaMartin
    +4
    They should be put in jail. If I were the child parent ,you better believe there would be hell to pay.
  • huttyputt 2012/05/23 22:54:17
    Cruel
    huttyputt
    +2
    The school administrators need to be connected AND LEFT THAT WAY. That filth deserves to thae its shared brain fully fried.
  • BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROC... 2012/05/23 22:46:58
    Cruel
    BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROCK-N-R
    +4
    This is in direct violations of acts of Congress, federal laws. I am surprised that they found even one parent to present themselves as forerunner and poster child of cruel and unusual punishment. this is not something we vote on, my friends I sincerely hope that advocates Will take the steps necessary to educate the parents about the ADA AND ALSO, WHY DOES NOT THIS PARTICULAR STATE OBSERVE THE CORRECT EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES FOR CHILDREN AND STUDENTS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES? so, here we are in the year of our Lord, 2012, and here I am still reading these ridiculous articles about these educators, who, if they had the brains of a snake, would go around biting people.
  • joe mauro BOOGIE-... 2012/05/24 00:37:07
    joe mauro
    +1
    congress pays not attention to the repeated abuse of the mentally and ohyiscally challenge d even obama laughs at us on international tv
  • BOOGIE-... joe mauro 2012/05/24 02:28:54
    BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROCK-N-R
    +1
    I wonder, when was the last time, thatNac did a report on this fine institution of learning?
  • Cookie BOOGIE-... 2012/05/24 11:17:34
    Cookie
    +1
    Probably never.
  • BOOGIE-... Cookie 2012/05/24 13:18:40
    BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROCK-N-R
    +1
    I agree with you, and it would be my opinion that's any achievement or certificate that school would have to offer would not be worth the paper it was written on.
  • Cookie BOOGIE-... 2012/05/24 15:24:27 (edited)
    Cookie
    +2
    It's a form of child abuse regardless of how they try to clean it up!
  • BOOGIE-... Cookie 2012/05/24 17:15:28
    BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROCK-N-R
    +1
    Yes, oh yes, these state agencies and institutions, get filthy nasty and dirty, in defense of their victimizing tactics.
  • Cookie BOOGIE-... 2012/05/24 23:17:10
    Cookie
    Oh yeah,for real.
  • BOOGIE-... joe mauro 2012/05/24 12:34:03
    BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROCK-N-R
    +2
    Well, Congress receives free medical care for themselves and their family members. I imagine they would be so obtuse, that they would consider this shock treatment saying nothing but government healthcare. I hope they get a warm fuzzy feeling inside of their self-righteous brains, can literally choke on their steak dinners, as they make presentations to the public sector as to how wonderful they think they are.
  • BOOGIE-... joe mauro 2012/05/24 13:53:14
    BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROCK-N-R
    +2
    Hey Joe thank you for bringing this to my attention because I didn't know O'Bama had said that.I'm 58 yrs.old and it has been my life long experience that since the invention of the T.V. and radio these so called polictical geniuses have used the air waves as a platform to belittle the physically and mentally challenged.I think that they should all stand on a street corner with Rush Limbaugh and tell everybody how wonderful THEY THINK THEY ARE.
  • joe mauro BOOGIE-... 2012/05/24 17:10:01
    joe mauro
    he said on david letterman that he was such alousy bowler he was ready for the special olimpics,i wonder what the EUNICE would have said.
  • BOOGIE-... joe mauro 2012/05/24 18:34:42
    BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROCK-N-R
    He may soon discover that he is such a lousy president that he is ready to put in his application for dog catcher hey man, I am totally blind but I really enjoy bowling.. thank you for sharing the information with me, I am very open and observant I am very willing to learn all I can about the true attitude and performance of any presidential candidate who would ask me for my valuable time and support hard work and money in the year 2012 presidential...
  • joe mauro BOOGIE-... 2012/05/24 23:12:27
    joe mauro
    thanks check your mail i sent you a request
  • unicorns vs narwhals 2012/05/23 22:44:25
    Cruel
    unicorns vs narwhals
    +2
    Shock therapy isent just cruel for autistic students, it's cruel for anybody.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/06/19 11:05:41

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals