Quantcast

School Uses Shock Therapy on Autistic Students: Constructive or Cruel?

SodaHead News 2012/05/23 13:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
The Judge Rotenberg Center, a special needs school in Massachusetts, is facing major controversy this week as information about the school's shock therapy program come to light. According to CNN, a student was treated for post traumatic stress disorder after receiving 31 electric shocks in a seven hour period. Officials were apparently trying to hide video footage of the shocking treatment, but was recently required to reveal it.

Other parents say the school is saving lives. One mother claims the shock treatment helped her son immensely, and calls the school a "godsend." Critics aren't so sure. Some call it torture. A group of opponents are even organizing a protest called Occupy JRC, to be held on June 2. It will include a wide range of speakers, from parents to disability advocates. But do you think shock therapy could be constructive?


Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Rave 2012/05/23 14:05:40
    Cruel
    Rave
    +11
    Shock therapy has been known to CAUSE post-traumatic stress disorder in some patients. I feel it is outdated and we have better treatments available these days.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Racefish 2012/05/23 17:27:49
    Cruel
    Racefish
    +2
    What has PTSD to do wirth Autism? Absolutely nothing. Ther is a book called the DSM-V you might wanbt to read.
    What really angers me is people throwiong something against the wall and hoping it creates controversy. Of course the author didn't bother to find out the difference. But then it's like they always say, you can't fix stupid.
  • Torchy Racefish 2012/05/23 17:36:25 (edited)
    Torchy
    +2
    You're right, it has nothing to do with autism. However, closer reading of the article will indicate that it never suggested that it did. These kids had autism or other mental disorders (hence the mention that this was a special needs school), and were treated for it with shock therapy (which is mentioned -- the school had a shock therapy program), and now are being treated for PTSD because shock therapy is kind of bad. You don't need a DSM for that, and you shouldn't criticize the author for your inability to read and comprehend.
  • Racefish Torchy 2012/05/23 17:47:33
    Racefish
    It is still way beyond the pale when you know one treament could make the other far worse.
  • nighttrain8 2012/05/23 17:25:38
  • VintageLys 2012/05/23 17:14:39
    Cruel
    VintageLys
    +3
    are you serious?! one flew over the cuckoos nest shock return to oz shock
    ....yah don't think so!
  • Revolution 2012 2012/05/23 17:11:01
    Cruel
    Revolution 2012
    +6
    Autism is a genetic condition; Shock therapy has, historically, been used to combat mental and behavioral problems (But having actually made them worse instead). You can't treat a genetic condition as curable, because it isn't. Your genetics define who you are and cannot be altered by any kind of surgery or therapy, especially something as cruel as shock therapy (which is now considered a form of torture in many places).
  • kobidob... Revolut... 2012/05/23 17:35:08
    kobidobidog
    It is not genetic at all. Those warlocks in the medical field on par with the humans in medieval torture chambers. All now www.upcspine.com.
  • Revolut... kobidob... 2012/05/23 17:38:05
    Revolution 2012
    +3
    Autism is genetic, as proven through a more recent breakthrough in its study, not to mention the Autism Genome Project (AGP): http://www.independent.co.uk/...
  • Racefish Revolut... 2012/05/23 17:50:20
    Racefish
    +2
    I think his post graduate diploma in Clinical Psychiatry has gone missing.
  • kobidob... Racefish 2012/05/23 19:40:40
    kobidobidog
    Psychiatry is insanity.
  • StanK 2012/05/23 17:09:17
    Cruel
    StanK
    +1
    I thought it was just little shocks, but watching that video was just disturbing. The guy is begging for help while screaming in pain. Worst of all? It was just because he refused to take off his coat.
  • Tony Bensley 2012/05/23 17:03:05
    Cruel
    Tony Bensley
    +2
    I thought that shock treatments went out with the Dark Ages (Or at least with "One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest")! As a high functioning Autistic, I personally find this very alarming! There simply has to be better calming methods than this!!
  • kobidob... Tony Be... 2012/05/23 17:38:31 (edited)
    kobidobidog
    Like I have said over, and over.The medical field is filled with a bunch of sorcerers, witches, and warlocks cackling around their bubbling caldron making their next toxic stew to parlay it off as a cure for something.
  • MLU103169 2012/05/23 17:00:18
    Cruel
    MLU103169
    +2
    I'm the mother of a 19 year old autistic boy. They wouldn't want to mess with this Mom. If they even thought of using such a device on my child, they would find themselves receiving shock therapy...that is, after I owned half of the free world in a law suit.
  • kobidob... MLU103169 2012/05/23 17:41:28
    kobidobidog
    Now. www.upcspine.com. Good for you too.
  • Aksana 2012/05/23 16:57:16
    Cruel
    Aksana
    +2
    This is ridiculous
  • kobidob... Aksana 2012/05/23 17:41:58
    kobidobidog
    That is saying it lightly.
  • scubagal 2012/05/23 16:56:54
    Cruel
    scubagal
    +2
    I cannot stand the feeling of being shocked. It is scary and I cannot see ~how~ it could be considered constructive!
  • Dagon 2012/05/23 16:56:13
  • Max Power Dagon 2012/05/23 17:36:48
    Max Power
    +6
    Because obviously electrocuting special needs children is fine as long as the parents consent to it!
  • Dagon Max Power 2012/05/23 19:12:21
  • Max Power Dagon 2012/05/23 21:28:23
    Max Power
    +1
    You're right. Hell, let's rebuild the Roman patriarchy while we're at. The men will have complete control over the life (and death) of their family. As long as the law says so, it will be fine.
  • Dagon Max Power 2012/05/23 22:20:23
  • kobidob... Dagon 2012/05/23 17:48:24
    kobidobidog
    +2
    How can barbarism not be a problem? Consent to have their child to obviously be tortured not called a problem?" This world is all screwed up. Then have sex with a younger human or another species as in zoosexuality or public nudity to be called bad? Whats wrong with humanity!
  • Dagon kobidob... 2012/05/23 19:14:58
  • tobe Dagon 2012/05/23 18:01:31
    tobe
    +1
    how can a person other than the patient make the final decision about a procedure where electric shocks are sent into a persons brain?
  • Fashionable60s 2012/05/23 16:55:49
    Cruel
    Fashionable60s
    +3
    This is beyond cruel. Shock therapy is outdated since there are better treatments available for autism.
  • kobidob... Fashion... 2012/05/23 17:52:17
    kobidobidog
    Treatment that being ignored www.upcspine. com. All ages now.. Even if you think you are fine should be evaluated anyway. If you don't need an adjustment to the Atlas it will not be given.
  • Tommy 2012/05/23 16:54:13
    Cruel
    Tommy
    +5
    These school officials should be given Shock Treatment. This is a very stupid idea. How would the officials like to have their scrotum hooked up to 220 volts and see how they like it.
  • Kevin 2012/05/23 16:53:48
    Cruel
    Kevin
    +2
    Down right cruel.
  • Joyce Brand 2012/05/23 16:51:56
    Cruel
    Joyce Brand
    +5
    Barbaric is a better word. Even if some parents think it makes their children "better."
  • kobidob... Joyce B... 2012/05/23 17:56:11
    kobidobidog
    +1
    Insidiously, calculatingly, premeditatively, sadistically, horrifically, demiomiclly barbaric.
  • Cindy Ellen 2012/05/23 16:51:33
    Cruel
    Cindy Ellen
    +5
    Given the fact that officials were trying to hide video footage of the treatments tells me a different story. Anything GOOD is never hidden. Hasn't anyone learned anything from history? History has proven shock treatments do not work... it can cause stress disorders though. I feel so sorry for the victims of shock treatments.
  • kobidob... Cindy E... 2012/05/23 18:00:01
    kobidobidog
    +1
    The humans that do bad will get their reward count on it. Gods light will do to their soul equal to what they did to whoever.
  • caius madison 2012/05/23 16:46:31
    Cruel
    caius madison
    +6
    The hostory of shock therapy use hasn't earned it any points. It typically produces effects counter to why it's being administered. It should be outlawed.
  • scubagal caius m... 2012/05/23 16:58:46
    scubagal
    +1
    Absolutely! I assumed that it was already - this is just horrible.
  • caius m... scubagal 2012/05/23 22:49:16
    caius madison
    Yeah, it has routes in torture too, so to be honest, it should just plain be banned. Put it this way, if your computer was having issues, and you decided to shock it, do you think that'd produce a desired effect?
  • Inquisi... caius m... 2012/05/24 04:30:07
    Inquisitve Kat
    It should be used in some special instances. My grandmother volunteered to undergo treatment for depression and it helped immensely. But it's incredibly wrong in this instance.
  • caius m... Inquisi... 2012/05/24 08:09:20
    caius madison
    I cannot believe they suggested it for that; is she still same minus the depression? I am glad that it actually worked this time.
  • Inquisi... caius m... 2012/05/24 16:09:04
    Inquisitve Kat
    It didn't seem to have any negative effects... she's still the same. This was years ago, however, which might explain why it was suggested.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/25 17:48:01

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals