Quantcast

PUBLIC OPINION > The Zimmerman Controversy Is Going Too Far

SodaHead News 2012/04/02 21:00:00
George Zimmerman fatally shot Trayvon Martin on February 26, and it took about one month for the case to reach the national spotlight. Now it's easily the most controversial item in the daily news, dividing the public at every turn. In addition to the ambiguous details surrounding the shooting, a big part of the controversy concerns its racial implications. Some suspect Zimmerman attacked Martin because of his race, and as a result the case has taken on elements reminiscent of the Rodney King case in 1991. There's even a Twitter movement called #KillZimmerman demanding street justice. We asked the public if this is getting out of hand.

martin zimmerman sodahead

No one is short on an opinion when it comes to this case, but most people can agree that the whole thing is getting just a little out of hand. One thing we noticed from both sides of the argument was a finger pointed at the media. The Top Opinion read, "Newspapers and television news don't care whether or not [Zimmerman] might be innocent or guilty so long as it drives ratings up, they'd dance for joy while America burned if they got ratings." Sadly, it's probably true. Very little has been confirmed about the case, but the media has done an excellent job at recklessly speculating.

The Dividing Line

Obviously, there was a fine political line between the left and the right; liberals tend to give Martin the benefit of the doubt, and conservatives tend to give Zimmerman the benefit of the doubt. However, a third of liberals agreed the opposition against Zimmerman is going too far. It's one thing to take Martin's side, but resorting to further violence will only aggravate tensions further.

College Controversy

One of the only non-political demographics that came close to justifying the level of controversy was college students. It could be that the issue is being tossed around at greater velocity in university classrooms, where debate is generally encouraged. High school students did not feel the same.

More Women Want Resolution

Beyond politics and the classroom, there was very little difference of opinion. We suspected men would be more willing to continue the controversy, and that was true, but only by a small margin. Ultimately, it doesn't matter what side of the fence you're on. Most people just want to take it down a notch.

If you'd like to vote on this question, dig deeper into the demographics, or engage in existing discussion about the topic, visit our poll about George Zimmerman. We'd love to hear from you!
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Brian O... robinsw... 2012/04/03 22:09:29
    Brian Owens
    +3
    I don't think we know if anyone is guilty or not.
  • robinsw... Brian O... 2012/04/03 22:21:28
    robinswebnest
    +1
    That was my point....it is up to the courts to decide, not the news media, race baiters or anyone else....thanks.
  • Nomad58 robinsw... 2012/04/03 22:23:07
    Nomad58
    +3
    Zimmerman has a CCP so the claim that he was carrying a gun when he wasn't suppose to is false.
  • robinsw... Nomad58 2012/04/03 22:24:23
    robinswebnest
    No, that is not what I meant. As a watch captain, he is not supposed to carry a gun while patroling. It has nothing to do with his CCP.
  • Nomad58 robinsw... 2012/04/03 23:33:42
    Nomad58
    +1
    Also, another falsehood spread by ill-informed sources. Actually this one was intentionally put out by USAonWatch an arm of the National Sheriffs Association.

    Not all Florida Neighborhood Watch standards prohibits the carry of firearms. Although, NWs vary from county to county (heck even between towns) any Police Dept that would mention a firearm carry for CCP holders would remind them it is only for self-defense (of course they already know this).

    BTW, most Neighbor Watches are registered with their local Police Department, yet do not bother to register with USAonWatch.

    True, USA0nWatch does emphasis that Watch personnel are not law enforcement and should not carry weapons. However, this precaution alone is probably why registration is so low in right-to-carry States. The rule leaves the Watch defenseless if they are confronted by a threat from which they cannot retreat. Another example of the State telling the Citizen "We know better than you".

    Now this is where it gets tricky the same articles that criticize Zimmerman condemn his Neighbor Watch for not being registered, then try to use the USAonWatch rules against them. That's blaming him for not follow a contract when he never even signed the paperwork.

    The rules for Zimmerman's NW have not been released, yet we have even th...

    Also, another falsehood spread by ill-informed sources. Actually this one was intentionally put out by USAonWatch an arm of the National Sheriffs Association.

    Not all Florida Neighborhood Watch standards prohibits the carry of firearms. Although, NWs vary from county to county (heck even between towns) any Police Dept that would mention a firearm carry for CCP holders would remind them it is only for self-defense (of course they already know this).

    BTW, most Neighbor Watches are registered with their local Police Department, yet do not bother to register with USAonWatch.

    True, USA0nWatch does emphasis that Watch personnel are not law enforcement and should not carry weapons. However, this precaution alone is probably why registration is so low in right-to-carry States. The rule leaves the Watch defenseless if they are confronted by a threat from which they cannot retreat. Another example of the State telling the Citizen "We know better than you".

    Now this is where it gets tricky the same articles that criticize Zimmerman condemn his Neighbor Watch for not being registered, then try to use the USAonWatch rules against them. That's blaming him for not follow a contract when he never even signed the paperwork.

    The rules for Zimmerman's NW have not been released, yet we have even the National Neighborhood Watch Director (guess who - USAonWatch Head) criticizing his actions. Could it be that the rules in Zimmerman Neighborhood authorize carry of firearm by those with CCP's, but the Media doesn't want that to get out?

    In any event, there is a question as to whether he was on official Patrol of just happened to come upon a situation where he saw a stranger on his way to the store. Again this may just be another Media rumor ~ we don't have all the information.
    (more)
  • robinsw... Nomad58 2012/04/04 00:13:52
    robinswebnest
    +1
    Now that is something I didn't know. Thanks for that information. It just seems all the media stations want to paint this as a major crime and Zimmerman as a serious bad guy. I am just so very tired of the media trying to tell the public what they should think.
    If you don't mind, I am going to save your information to use against the hard liner racist on this blog. Not that it will do any good....but, sometimes I like to give the a little tweak....
  • C-ZAR™, Emperor of the PHÆT 2012/04/03 21:25:05
    C-ZAR™, Emperor of the PHÆT
    +7
    It's only "going too far" because he only shot a black kid, had Trayvon been white, Zimmerman's ass would have been thrown in jail by now
  • Nomad58 C-ZAR™,... 2012/04/03 22:21:30
  • C-ZAR™,... Nomad58 2012/04/03 22:25:10
    C-ZAR™, Emperor of the PHÆT
    +4
    That's a lie, you know you all run the world man!--his ass would be ROTTING in a cell had he been white
  • Nomad58 C-ZAR™,... 2012/04/04 00:29:47 (edited)
  • joe mauro Nomad58 2012/04/04 02:27:33
  • joe mauro joe mauro 2012/04/04 02:29:44
    joe mauro
    +2
    local media in central florida always sides with local law enforcement no matter what they do thats why there are more and more pathic incidents like this all the time the rest of the usa doesnt hear about them
  • Nomad58 joe mauro 2012/04/04 02:57:21
    Nomad58
    Really Joe, I would think as a Libertarian you would be more open-minded than these Progressive knee-jerk crooks.

    I was in Bay Co. when I was in FL (okay Panhandle) but the Media was always on their ass. And the Orlando Sentinel has been stirring up the pot by bringing in "audio" experts to listen to second-hands tape to make the Police look like the Keystone Cops.

    In the meantime, we have tons of faked "evidence" floating around the Web calling Zimmerman a racist (based on doctored garbled audio) to low-grain video used as fact he was not injured. These fabricators care nothing for the laws, evidence, or justice they just want a conviction for their "White Hispanic".

    FL had 35 occurrences of Justifiable Homicide last year. I would say a good deal of those were Whites. Consequently there is no evidence to support the claim had Martin been White in this situation that Zimmerman would not have been released.

    However, given there were 35 Justified Homicides in FL and no network Nationally made a peep, I believe there is support for a claim that the Media would not have cared for a White Martin.
  • *Mahoga... joe mauro 2012/04/04 02:59:12
  • Brightsprite62 2012/04/03 21:20:17
    Brightsprite62
    +2
    Yes. When You have public figures i.e. Spike Lee, Rosanne Barr, Jessie Jackson, weighing in and actually causing trouble then yes it's going to far. When you have wanted dead or alive posters showing up it's gone to far. The Mass Mob hysteria currently sweeping this Nation is so stupid.
  • kellendunk 2012/04/03 20:48:10
    kellendunk
    +3
    The question was biased. Of course the results turned out this way. I wonder why people think random death threats are extreme in comparison to actually killing. I wonder why the question as initially posed painted the question as if only the one side is full of crazies. Hell, fox news and that blog run by Tucker Carlson (forgive me forgetting its name) are repeating pretty much everything that's written about this case on stormfront as if its actual news. They're trying to portray the situation as if having had a tatoo or gotten into trouble at school was justification for murdering a child. Sodahead was complicit in this by not also asking about the assault on Trayvons body first and his character second.
  • indianna209 2012/04/03 20:37:46
    indianna209
    Zimmer"mano" has black blood in his veins, raised by a white father and predominately of Hispanic bloodlines, he was hired to protect a mid-upperclass neighborhood which allowed him to vent his anger legally and racially on his divided self. He chose the wrong career to develop his ego. Its hard to find good help these days, that includes the press.
  • *Mahoga... indiann... 2012/04/03 20:54:14
  • C-ZAR™,... *Mahoga... 2012/04/03 21:21:54
    C-ZAR™, Emperor of the PHÆT
    +4
    Great pics Latrice!
  • *Mahoga... C-ZAR™,... 2012/04/03 21:32:48
  • C-ZAR™,... *Mahoga... 2012/04/03 21:43:35
  • *Mahoga... C-ZAR™,... 2012/04/03 21:44:21
  • lola love *Mahoga... 2012/04/04 02:57:41
    lola love
    Does pic's BREAK my heart,,,, :( poor kid i have a son his age, and everytime i hear his name it just brings me to a stand still!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! where i just wonder what if that was my son? that's why...... I HATE ZIMMERMAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Anne Ha... lola love 2012/04/19 01:25:23
    Anne Haseltine
    So u think he was out looking to kill this kid? Your an idiot! The pics you were looking at are from 5 yrs ago !! And people like you fall for it!!?why don't you read his twitters? Then tell me how you feel! The kid was well on his way down the wrong path!!!
  • Anne Ha... lola love 2012/04/19 01:26:27
    Anne Haseltine
    You Hate Zimmerman ? I'll bet your an Obama fan!
  • lola love Anne Ha... 2012/05/30 17:41:26
    lola love
    And I bet you are a bitter white person....:-~
  • COS indiann... 2012/04/03 21:21:36
    COS
    +1
    What the hell does Zimmerman parents bloodlines have do with him being a murder ? Absolutely nothing at all, because murder coming in every color & race. And another thing he was not hired as his neighborhood security officer, but he made himself the one man neighborhood watcher & captain. His real job is or was a mortgage broker,
  • Nomad58 indiann... 2012/04/03 22:32:39
    Nomad58
    +1
    Well my my aren't you a racist little Ayrian hold-over.
    Still missing those days when your eugenics plans had a chance?

    Of course, poor Zimmerman as a sub-class mixed-blood could not develop his own personality. As you Progressive Liberals know only the White Man's Government can care for these disadvantaged minorities.

    BTW, you guys keep calling minorities disadvantaged ~ I personally find that offensive.
  • joe mauro Nomad58 2012/04/04 03:50:55
    joe mauro
    +1
    you enjoy profilling!
  • Nomad58 joe mauro 2012/04/04 04:20:43
    Nomad58
    +1
    Looks like a duck, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck...

    These idiots think Neighbor Watchs are hired ~ they're Volunteer's & no one from the neighborhood has said Zimmerman was not a member of the Neighborhood Watch. Only people making that claim are the fabricators on the Web.

    So forgive me if I have a low tolerance for lynch mobs.
  • joe mauro Nomad58 2012/04/04 17:23:55
    joe mauro
    you got it
  • Leek Ho... indiann... 2012/04/04 01:03:29
    Leek Hototrot
    +3
    Everyone! Stop perpetuating the lie. He was NOT hired to be a neighborhood watch anything! The community group there states that he was not a neighborhood watch captain, nor even a member. That was just his attempt at a cover to excuse the fact that he simply had a desire to be a complete racist murderer and an a-hole.
  • Robin B Leek Ho... 2012/04/04 01:18:01
    Robin B
    You must have a crystal ball.
  • Nomad58 Leek Ho... 2012/04/04 03:06:59
    Nomad58
    +1
    Neighbor Watch is a volunteer position, Noob.

    You just joined a new account 1hr before posting to make this bogus claim.

    The only Neighborhood Watch Group making any statement is the National USAonWatch with which Zimmerman's Group is not affiliated.

    Now, that you have been exposed as part of the racist lynch mob ~ you may delete your phoney account.
  • joe mauro Nomad58 2012/04/04 03:51:16
    joe mauro
    more labels
  • Nomad58 joe mauro 2012/04/04 04:22:36
    Nomad58
    +1
    Don't like it - Don't read it. Are you a moderator?
  • joe mauro Nomad58 2012/04/04 17:26:33
    joe mauro
    no just a nomad
  • Anne Ha... Leek Ho... 2012/04/07 01:42:56
    Anne Haseltine
    And you sir are an IDIOT!!!!
  • Justin Bunting 2012/04/03 20:36:19
    Justin Bunting
    No, definitely not.
  • Captain-Morgan 2012/04/03 20:12:44
    Captain-Morgan
    YES..

News & Politics

2013/05/24 14:32:02

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals