Quantcast

PUBLIC OPINION > Felons Should Not Be Allowed to Vote

SodaHead News 2012/01/04 14:00:00
Voting rights are a huge issue, and can sometimes be the most controversial. This time is no different. Senator Ben Cardin is trying to restore voting rights to disenfranchised felons in 11 states with the Democracy Restoration Act, but it's not going to be easy. The results we got asking SodaHeads about the issue are evidence of that. There's plenty of heat on both sides, but in the end Cardin's bill was voted off SodaHead Hill. (Assuming none of the voters were felons.)

Should Felons Be Allowed to Vote?

felon voting

46% Think Felons Should Be Allowed to Vote

This was a close call for a couple of reasons, but in the end the majority voted against giving felons the right to vote. The reason this was such a divisive issue is that both sides seemed to have deep-seated reasons for their opinions. Those who voted in favor of felon voting rights were concerned about individual freedom: "If you deny Any Adult the right to vote, you open a Pandora's box of other freedoms [being] taken away." Those who opposed it were either concerned about the state's right to limit a criminal's freedom. Many opponents also emphasized the idea that felons have essentially given up their rights.

chart

Cut Off By Conservatives

There was really one demographic that drove the entire question, and whether this is causation or merely correlation is kind of beside the point. Only 21% of conservatives voted in favor of allowing felons to vote, while 79% (the exact inverse) of liberals supported it. Clearly, political leaning has a strong relation to the question.

Women Give Felons a Second Chance

Female voters were only 5% more likely than men to vote in favor of felon voting rights, but it was the 5% that made all the difference, bringing the average up to 51%, a majority vote. You could blame it on the margin of error, or on that fabled female sympathy.

Sympathetic Singles

The age demographic did show a pattern, but it was a little too nuanced to get into here. Instead, we opted for the simpler married and single statistics. Singles, often young than married voters, were 24% more likely to support felon voting rights -- very close to the difference between voters younger than 35 and voters older than 35.

If you'd like to vote on this question, dig deeper into the demographics, or engage in existing discussion about the topic, visit our original poll about felon voting rights. We'd love to hear from you!
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

  • Wyveryx 2012/01/04 18:22:10
    Wyveryx
    +10
    it amazes me to see how many people think that they are the best of society because they are smart enough to have never made a mistake or have never broken a law.

    “You can be discouraged by failure or you can learn from it. So go ahead and make mistakes. Make all you can. Because, remember that's where you'll find success; on the far side.” – Thomas Watson

    We can't just say that you have made a mistake or broken the law but you will never learn and you will never be good enough to rejoin society.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Puddinhead 2012/01/17 03:30:28
    Puddinhead
    +2
    Next topic for discussion="Should dead people have the right to vote?" "Should illegal aliens have the right to vote five times each election ?"
  • Puddinhead 2012/01/17 03:23:07
    Puddinhead
    Our founding fathers were all criminals/felons.....who would deny them of their right to vote ? Better to vote by secret ballot,than vote by a bullet,although the later may be more perminant.
  • Allen911 2012/01/14 21:45:50
    Allen911
    +1
    Most people shouldnt be allowed to vote. 70% of the people have no idea where Washington D.C. is let alone the the issues at hand.
  • lm1b2 2012/01/14 14:16:10
    lm1b2
    +2
    They lost their right to citizenship when they became felons,they should not be allowed to vote!
  • banzaib... lm1b2 2012/01/15 08:25:16
    banzaibuckaroo
    for how long shoud they lose that right? for the rest of their life or until their off probation or parole.
  • Bill 2012/01/14 12:54:14
    Bill
    +1
    First offenders after finishing their punishment should be allowed. Repeat offenders, NO.
  • Slamdunk 2012/01/13 10:22:27
    Slamdunk
    +2
    Felons should not be allowed to vote until they have served their time. Nor should felons be allowed to be a candidate for the Presidency. Barack Obama has been using a stolen SSN since 1977. That is identity theft. You don't believe it? When you enter the number he is using, 042-68-4425, into the Government E-Verify System, it rejects it as a "mismatch." That is a signal that the number is stolen. To use E-Verify you must enroll into the program. Also, Obama has allowed two forged birth documents to be placed on line and his website. Forgery is a felony. But his worst crime is the usurpation of the Presidency. The constitution requires the President and VP to be "natural born citizens." Obama is not. First, the forgered birth certificates show that he is lying about where he was born and, most importantly, his father was never a U.S. citizen.

    There will be a court hearing today (1-13-12) in Hawaii in which Obama's birth certificate has been subpoened.
  • txtumlin Slamdunk 2012/01/25 05:27:23 (edited)
    txtumlin
    Technically, I agree with your stand, however, because he IS the POTUS, he doesn't have to appear. 1/26/12, day after tomorrow, President Obama is SUPPOSED to appear in an Atlanta, Georgia court to PROVE his eligibility - but I shan't hold my breath.

    The way I understood all this impeachment business is that the HOUSE of REPRESENTATIVES is the entity that initiates that proceeding. I just pray they get all their ducks in a row and REMOVE the lawbreaker BEFORE November 2012.

    Georgia's jurisdiction goes only to the borders of the state, not beyond. out at home
  • Drummerboy 2012/01/09 02:55:06
  • OhSoNiceMe 2012/01/08 02:40:16
    OhSoNiceMe
    +1
    it's bad enough they have to spend time for what they've done, let them have their cake people gosh!!
  • Angry Congressman 2012/01/07 19:59:31
    Angry Congressman
    +2
    When they crossed the line into crime, they gave up their rights, and turned their backs on society. Actions have consequences, and in those respects I have no pity for the felons.
  • jabir.green 2012/01/07 09:02:01
    jabir.green
    +2
    Hey, why stop at their voting rights? lets take away their freedom of speech and freedom of religion too... While we're at it.. lets not even give them a trial, just lot them up on suspicion alone..(sarcasm) Oh wait, the president can do that now under the new defense authorization act 2012. This is a slippery slope when we start saying who can vote and who cant.... Other nations allow their citizens to vote after their sentences are complete... This is racist.... period..
  • katy.isodo jabir.g... 2012/01/08 04:48:03
    katy.isodo
    +1
    I'm not sure if I agree on the part about it being racist since this crosses over any type of ethnicity line and covers ANY felons, not just certain specific ones. I think there could be issues with racism involved considering that people of minorities can at times be short changed in court, I don't think that's the point of the argument however.
  • BUD LITE jabir.g... 2012/01/20 18:14:56
    BUD LITE
    Spoken like a true felon !
  • Peewee 2012/01/07 05:22:38
    Peewee
    +1
    Not while they are in prison.
  • JULIE 2012/01/06 02:27:07
    JULIE
    Every American should be allowed to vote!
    None of us have the prison or jail experience of most felons, they see how things run in our courts and government & should have a say.
  • merlin 2012/01/06 01:40:19
  • Ians Mommy 2012/01/05 22:38:37
    Ians Mommy
    +2
    What about the people that committed the same crimes be were not "caught"?
  • J 2012/01/05 21:19:04
    J
    Perhaps we should take a look at the "felonies" convicted of. ANYBODY convicted of murder, manslaughter, forcible rape, aggravated assault or robbery, arson, attempted murder, and counterfeiting should NEVER be allowed to vote again. Those who have committed crimes such as vandalism, burglary, larceny, motor vehicle theft, disorderly conduct, public drunkenness should have to do their time and then stay out of trouble, work and pay-taxes for 10-20 years and then they should allowed to vote again (and own a weapon).
    Driving while intoxicated is a felony and I think that a person who is convicted of this 3 times or more should be treated as a hardened criminal.
  • katy.isodo J 2012/01/08 04:50:42
    katy.isodo
    You think people who commit armed robbery should be able to own a gun again.. ever? Really? The damage caused by this is devastating on various levels, and they've abused the right. Voting isn't something that was abused in any of these crimes, and while they are serious crimes.. we has US citizens should have a certain amount of basic rights, and voting should in my mind be one of them.
  • J katy.isodo 2012/01/10 00:16:19
    J
    If they can vote, they can might as well be able to own a gun. And I think SOME people learn. And like I say, it depends on the crime.
  • katy.isodo J 2012/01/10 19:25:28
    katy.isodo
    How is voting anything at all in relation to owning a weapon that for all intensive purposes they used to most likely threaten or take someone else's life? I think the standards for both are a bit different.
  • J katy.isodo 2012/01/11 21:17:28
    J
    Voting can not only open the door to take someone's life, but everything they have.
  • katy.isodo J 2012/01/12 00:15:41
    katy.isodo
    This is true, and if one persons vote had that much power to change extreme decisions I'd agree, but as much power as voting has it's mostly because of mass numbers, not individuals on a rage.
  • jeanne Blue 2012/01/05 21:17:09
    jeanne Blue
    +3
    Don't be ridiculous. Of course they should vote. People do dumb things especially when they
    are young. they pay their price but they don't give up their rights as citizens. Human beings are not perfect and we all have a lot to learn. We need to stop being such a punishing nation and learn compassion and help those who are in the learning process with our acceptance.
  • jackolantyrn356 2012/01/05 19:24:25
    jackolantyrn356
    +1
    Haven't read it yet, but this feels like it is in the words of the Articles of the US Constitution.
  • Drifter 2012/01/05 18:26:49
  • overdog001 2012/01/05 16:12:53
    overdog001
    +2
    No. Not only no, but there should be other groups who are also forbidden. Anybody who flunks a civics test... anyone who scores too low on an IQ test... It's time to stop Pollyanna from destroying us all: all men are NOT created equal.
  • katy.isodo overdog001 2012/01/05 18:23:39
    katy.isodo
    And how would we go about giving such tests? At what age? What about people who become disabled through no fault of there own? What about people caught in situations in which they are charged for something they are innocent for? To be honest if you really believe that not everyone is created equal, perhaps you just need a new country (oh and by the way, take a civics test) - We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. - If you don't agree, grab a ship, Cuba would love to have you.
  • overdog001 katy.isodo 2012/01/06 19:36:55
    overdog001
    Why would quoting the Gettysburg Address have any bearing? Those were the public posturings of a politician, and are not law, and not in any of the founding documents of this country. Congratulations, you found a politician you agree with. So what?

    Thank you; your answer proves that you and I are not equal.
  • katy.isodo overdog001 2012/01/06 22:53:45
    katy.isodo
    I agree, we aren't. Some of us have an understanding and acceptance that human beings make mistakes, and others like yourself have probably never found themselves in a compromising situation and thus have never had to face such circumstances, so don't care what happens to that group of people. I think your ideas and logic would change dramatically if you, yourself were ever stuck in such a situation, hopefully for your own benefit you won't be, let's just say, you wouldn't get much sympathy.
  • overdog001 katy.isodo 2012/01/09 19:28:43
    overdog001
    I have already been in "those compromising situations". That's right; drugs, violence, racism, assault, broken home, peer pressure, economic hardship, disabling medical issues, and ghetto life. I have lived through them all, multiple times and in multiple places.

    One's character is not defined by what situation we find ourselves in; one's character is defined by how we resolve and deal with that situation.

    I will never want sympathy, or understanding, or acceptance from my government. Countries cannot be successfully run on emotions; "Hope and change" has proven that nearly as well as the Occu-tards. Feelings have nothing to do with what is rational.

    One shouldn't get the right and responsibility to participate in the process of running a nation because somebody felt sorry for some poor disadvantaged group of people. One should get that right when demonstrating the capacity and propensity to make rational decisions.
  • katy.isodo overdog001 2012/01/09 22:49:02
    katy.isodo
    I don't have sympathy for actual crime, nor do I feel the need to forever punish someone for one mistake. Very few crimes deserve anything that lasts a lifetime in my opinion, people change and grow. I want progress, not revenge.
  • Fitfly 2012/01/05 15:43:11
    Fitfly
    +1
    Drugs should be decriminalized felons for violent or sexual crimes should not be allowed to vote.
  • Chris0623 2012/01/05 14:53:53
    Chris0623
    +2
    I think once they have done their time ect they should be allowed to vote.
  • bob 2012/01/05 14:37:37
    bob
    +3
    If you Choose to commit a Felony you choose to give up your Right to Vote.It is a Consequence of your Actions you can still right your life you just cannot vote.
  • merlin bob 2012/01/06 01:46:17 (edited)
    merlin
    Not All people choose to commit a felony! Some are framed! And the way they are changing the laws, before u know it! you'll get a felony for jay walking;-]
  • wtw 2012/01/05 14:30:38
    wtw
    +1
    They should be allowed to vote!
  • Sunnydaydreamer 2012/01/05 14:26:05
    Sunnydaydreamer
    +2
    More and more petty crimes are being upped to felonies. As they keep adding laws and not removing laws here in this country in another 2 decades there will be more felons than ever with no american rights... When a man serves his sentence he should not be allowed to be punished more and forever
  • katy.isodo Sunnyda... 2012/01/05 18:14:23
    katy.isodo
    +1
    So true, there are many felony crimes that people are being charged with which do not in anyway inhibit people from being having the right to say what happens in government.

News & Politics

2013/05/23 03:27:59

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals