I can assure you of that !
Question US
Obama's justice department denies constitutional rights to enemy combatants in Afghanistan. Will leftists show consistency in their criticism?
FanOreilly February 22, 2009 19:53:12
- 61 answers
- Read all 121 comments
- +11 raves
Obama Department of Justice: Enemy Combatants In Afghanistan Have 'no constitutional rights'
I remember many leftists accusing George W. Bush of being a war criminal for denying enemy combatants ACLU lawyers in foreign detention centers.
I remember hearing from leftists how George W. Bush had 'shredded' the constitution for not giving jihadis caught in battle against US troops in Kandahar the full spectrum of constitutional rights as a shop-lifter caught in Minneapolis.
Now that Barack Obama's justice department (once again) carries-on a Bush policy, will leftists attack Barack Obama with the same fervor they attacked George W. Bush?
I remember many leftists accusing George W. Bush of being a war criminal for denying enemy combatants ACLU lawyers in foreign detention centers.
I remember hearing from leftists how George W. Bush had 'shredded' the constitution for not giving jihadis caught in battle against US troops in Kandahar the full spectrum of constitutional rights as a shop-lifter caught in Minneapolis.
Now that Barack Obama's justice department (once again) carries-on a Bush policy, will leftists attack Barack Obama with the same fervor they attacked George W. Bush?
Loading... 

Top Comment
-
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
View thread
SodaHead Hot Trends

No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
Yes, most leftists are principle based and will show consistency by criticizing Barack Obama just as they criticized George W. Bush
Yes, most leftists are principle based and will show consistency by criticizing Barack Obama just as they criticized George W. Bush
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
George Bush took people from foreign lands and dropped them on an island with no tribunal of any kind.
Afghanistan is NOT inside the US and they are not entitled to ANYTHING under the US Constitution. Enemy Combatants would fall under the Geneva Convention, which we *try* to abide by but are NOT signatories of.
No, POW's are subject to the Geneva Conventions.
When Al Qaida signs the Geneva Convention then perhaps.
Yes, most leftists are principle based and will show consistency by criticizing Barack Obama just as they criticized George W. Bush
I don't see Israel as being a theocracy, whereas the Palestinians are ruled by their clerics and their interpretation of the Koran, which includes as a plank vowing the destruction of Israel. I actually see that as the biggest roadblock to peace and stabilization in that region. I have been to Israel and to the area of Bethlehem ceded to the Palestinians. It is like night and day. I've seen the checkpoints. One could feel the tension. The day before I went to Jerusalem and Bethlehem, a tourist bus with Western Europeans was attacked by Palestinian "freedom fighters". Not a great way to get sympathy for your cause. I saw no religious trappings in Tel Aviv, nor Jaffa; of course I did in Jerusalem. It's a given,since all three major religions have deep roots there. In Bethlehem, however, the Mosque of Omar dominated the area of the Church of the Nativity and we were just in time for noon prayers. Your perception of Israel fighting because of the "eye for an eye" business in the Torah is false. Israel is pretty much a secular state:
"The organs of government and state power neither derive their legal authority from religion or church nor their legitimation from any divine source. It cannot be claimed with any semblance of realism that state and church are coequal partners in the governance of the state. Indeed, all legal powers of the religious institutions and organs are ultimately devolved upon them by the state. " (Emanuel Gutman, A Religion in Israeli Politics,@ in Jacob Landau, ed., Man, State, and Society in the Contemporary Middle East, NY: Praeger, 1972, p. 123.)
You cannot separate Islam from the state in the Islam world. All governance derives from the Koran. The Israeli Knesset has an Arab party (United Arab List-Ta'al, 4 members). How many Jewish or Israeli parties are represented in each of the Muslim nations? Given, Judaism is the prevalent religion in Israel, but I've not heard of any public stonings for adultery or hangings for being gay. There were bans against those in the Torah. Wish I could say the same for Iran, Afghanistan, or those other theocracies embracing Islam. Oh, I'm not Jewish by the way, although my daughter is married to the son of a holocaust survivor. She was in Dachau from 1943 to 1945, and was liberated at 15 years old. God, how could a conservative right wing bigot allow that to happen? Oh, and I collect WWII German militaria. Guess you got me figured out, right? Like I always say, "liberals aren't."
Have fun stewing in your hate, Lance.
it is a compliment if he does not like you.
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
As with the way they dictate policy, you must ask, which way is the wind blowing today? That determines the fervor to which they are committed to an idea.
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
Does that mean I don't think Pres. Bush made any mistakes? I think he made several. No president, no matter how good their intention, is going to please everyone.
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
No most leftists will reveal their hipocrisy by only attacking Republicans
Anyone that supports the torture of terror suspects is a complete fool. There are few more effective ways to make it easier for extremists find more recruits.
Can you read? I clearly said "MOST rightists", not all.
You must believe that "they hate us for our freedoms".
What sides are there, may I ask?
There are far too many people that think it is okay to stereotype Muslims and Arabs.
Conservatives have been criticizing Bush for years.
>Anyone that supports the torture of terror suspects is a complete fool.
So Barry Obama is a complete fool?