Obama says only women .should decide womens' health care issues- is this a l;ogical statement?.

by den Posted 2012/08/24 12:32:47

Related Topics: Obama, Health Care, Rights, Issues, Father, Quote, Health, Unborn, Legislature

12 votes
Read all 21 opinions
View Results and Demographics + View Demographics

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	that is an illogical statement because:	5 votes	42%
	that is logical because:	5 votes	42%
	other ideas.	2 votes	17%

the is another stupid obama quote- what about men docters that care for women? what about legislatures that pass laws made up of men and women? What about the Bibl;e gives man jurisdiction over the womaan. What about the rights of a father oi over the unborn?

Add a comment above

KingdomNow 2012/08/24 13:54:26

that is an illogical statement because:

+3
...that would also mean only women should pay for women's health care issues. Right now, most of the tax burden is carried by men.
>> See Replies

More polls by den

☆ QueenAline 2012/08/25 02:27:58

that is an illogical statement because:

women need doctors to decide about their health care issues..if they have them...women should take responsibility of their own reproductive needs...weather its buying their own birth control, or paying for their pregnancy.., and not depend on society to pay their way.

reply
Cameleon 2012/08/24 20:50:37

that is logical because:

Doctors should not decide the health care issues for anyone. They are consultants only. Every individual is ultimately responsible for their own health care decisions. They consult doctors to get information to help them make decisions. Doctors do NOT make the decisions for them. That goes for women as well as men.

reply
Katherine 2012/08/24 14:01:49

that is an illogical statement because:

+1
More of the radical left's attack on women and babies. Abortion is bad for a woman's health and murders the baby. And it took TWO people to make that baby.

reply
Cameleon to Katherine 2012/08/24 20:51:23

There is no evidence at all that abortions has any effect what so ever on the health of women.

reply
Katherine to Cameleon 2012/08/25 00:36:27

Actually you're incredibly incorrect.

reply
Cameleon to Katherine 2012/08/25 05:52:49

Women naturally abort fetuses on a regular basis. There is no scientifically research that suggest there is any medical heath problems with abortion at all.

Only the anti-abortion group has tried to give that kind of mis-informtion to try and discourage women. But it has been determined to be completely false.

reply
Katherine to Cameleon 2012/08/25 07:28:49

A body that selects to expunge the baby also prepares the entire body for it. By terminating a pre-determined life, a baby, when a woman's body was set on a path to carry to term, causes the body that already contains hormones, pre cancerous cells in the breasts, to build inside the body, thus increasing the chances of development breast cancer. Not only that, but a doctor performing the abortion must poison the baby, poke the sack, then pull the baby apart piece by piece (reassembling to make sure the entire baby is out), and scrape her insides to make sure nothing is left behind or she will get an infection and die. It is not my fault that you reject science and hate your own offspring; but every time you interrupt this process, you put lives in danger.

reply
KingdomNow 2012/08/24 13:54:26

that is an illogical statement because:

+3
...that would also mean only women should pay for women's health care issues. Right now, most of the tax burden is carried by men.

reply
Cameleon to KingdomNow 2012/08/24 20:53:17
KingdomNow to Cameleon 2012/08/24 21:08:23

+1
Fine make your own choices but pay out of your own pockets, not out of mine.

The main issue of health care in the US is about whom to rob to pay for it.

reply
Cameleon to KingdomNow 2012/08/25 05:53:41 (edited)

American are the most selfish of all peoples on this planet. I find it incredible that you call yourselves a christian nation.

Interesting that you have changed your argument now that you lost the first one.

reply
KingdomNow to Cameleon 2012/08/25 06:28:40

I haven't changed anything and I'm no Christian.

The issue isn't about women working but failing to pull their weight.

Maybe you haven't been paying attention to American news but the current regime has been trotting out sluts who whine about having to pay for their own birth control, which means they want taxpayers to fund their selfish entertainment.

reply
Schläue~© 2012/08/24 13:17:28

that is an illogical statement because:

+3
It's ridiculous because those decisions affect everyone.

reply
Rebel Yell 2012/08/24 13:07:35

other ideas.

Where's the actual quote?

reply
den to Rebel Yell 2012/08/24 21:22:48

they played a recording of obama saying that on NPR this morning about a dozen times

reply
Rebel Yell to den 2012/08/24 21:26:31

Actual quote that was not altered in any way?

reply
DJPanicDC 2012/08/24 12:47:24

that is logical because:

+1
what about men doctors that care for women?

Doctors have to respect the wishes of the patient, they make diagnosis but in the end it is her choice

what about legislatures that pass laws made u

That's the point! (Note he said should,) It is unjust for them to govern her body

What about the Bibl;e gives man jurisdiction

REALLY?!?! Are you actually using the argument that Obama's statement is illogical because a 2ooo year old book that has talking snakes, virgin births, and people living in whales said that theinvisible man in the sky said so? !?!? You should look up the word logic

What about the rights of a father oi over the unborn?

why would he have rights to a lump of cells in another body?

reply
Katherine to DJPanicDC 2012/08/24 14:03:17

I really ought to finish reading Moby Dick.....

reply
Cameleon to Katherine 2012/08/24 20:51:57

Moby Dick is fiction.

reply
den to Cameleon 2012/08/24 21:23:14

+1
so is obamna

reply
Cameleon to den 2012/08/25 05:54:49

So all you birthers want to believe.

reply