Quantcast

Obama Eligibility Challenge Spreads To 6 States

Birthpangs 2012/01/31 13:36:47
You!
Add Photos & Videos

An administrative law judge in Georgia could decide as early as this week whether voters in the state convinced him Barack Obama’s name should be removed from the 2012 presidential ballot because he is not qualified to hold the office.

But win, lose or draw, the fight isn’t going to be over, as other cases are erupting across the nation, with challenges being raised anew even in Obama’s own adopted political network in Illinois.

The Georgia hearing was before Judge Michael Malihi, and while none of the lawyers who appeared in the proceedings was willing to predict what the decision will be, several did confirm that Malihi had considered simply granting them a default victory, because Obama and his lawyers expressly stated they would not participate in a hearing to provide evidence that he is qualified to be on the ballot.

A default presumably would have meant a recommendation from the judge that Obama’s name be stricken from the ballot, a decision which would head for review immediately by Georgia Secretary of State Brian Kemp.

He, however, was the one who warned Obama of the “peril” of not participating in the hearing when Obama and his attorney had asked that the event be canceled.

Discover what the Constitution’s reference to “natural born citizen” means and whether Barack Obama qualifies, in the ebook version of “Where’s the REAL Birth Certificate?”

Whatever the outcome in Georgia, the issue is gaining traction in other states, too, including Alabama, Tennessee, Arizona, New Hampshire, and even Illinois, Obama’s home political base.

There, in a complaint recently filed by Stephen F. Boulton of McCarthy Duffy LLP and Gary Kreep of the United States Justice Foundation, their client is asking for a change in state law to allow the vetting of political candidates.

Obama isn’t even mentioned by name, but don’t think for a minute that the requested change wouldn’t include his candidacy.

The plaintiff is Sharon Meroni, who long has fought inside the system for a way to challenge the candidacies there. In her new case, filed in the Circuit Court of Cook County, she is petitioning for a judicial review of the state’s election procedures as they exist now.

Targeted are the state Board of Elections, members of the board, several county clerks and others, including candidates Dan Duffy and Amanda Howland.

Meroni, a registered voter in the 27th Legislative District in the state, said her concern is that “only candidates qualified for office under the Illinois and United States Constitutions appear on the ballot.”

The state’s primary is in March.

The case alleges the candidates did not provide sufficient proof that they are U.S. citizens as required to hold the office being sought “as is required by the Illinois Constitution of 1970.”

State officials refused to remove the names from the ballots, so Meroni has gone to court. Granting ballot access, she said in the complaint, “is contrary to law, against the manifest weight of the evidence, arbitrary and capricious, and a denial of the rights of the petitioner.”

Kreep told WND the way the system is established in Illinois it essentially allows political parties to determine who runs for office, and unless voters find out about a filing and can assemble a formal objection within five days, their concerns are dismissed.

And the system has no procedure for verifying the eligibility of candidates, he said.

That particular issue has been in the headlines for the past four years, since before Obama’s 2008 election victory, because of the questions that remain over his eligibility. The U.S. Constitution demands a “natural born citizen” be president and the Founders probably thought that to be the offspring of two citizen parents when they wrote the term.

But Obama’s father never was a citizen. There also are those who contend he was not even born in the United States.

Kreep said the Illinois procedures make it virtually impossible for candidates to be challenged for their eligibility.

He said there likely will be raised in other states concerns similar to those in Illinois, where “barriers now in existence … bar voters from reasonable investigation of the citizenship of a candidate.”

That’s simply a deprivation of the constitutional right to due process, he said. The case seeks a declaration that the political maneuvers are unconstitutional.

There also have been assembled campaigns specifically to encourage voters to file eligibility complaints about candidates with states. One such effort is the Obama Ballot Challenge, which lists contacts for state elections offices across the country.

It is, of course, the states that actually run elections; a national election is just the compilation of the results from the 50 states.

“A candidate that is not legally qualified to be on the ballot, such as Barack Obama, steals votes from other candidates who are legally on the ballot,” the site advises.

WND previously reported that cases already have been begun in New Hampshire, where state officials rejected the claims; Alabama, Tennessee and Arizona.

The newest round of court actions do not try to have a judge determine Obama is not qualified for the Oval Office and remove him from it, they simply challenge his eligibility for the 2012 election.

Many of the cases cite Minor v. Happersett, a U.S. Supreme Court opinion from 1875 that said a “natural born citizen” would be a person whose parents both were citizens.

“This complaint does not request any injunction against any state or federal government official. Instead this complaint asserts that the private entity, Defendant Democratic Party, intends to act negligently or fraudulently in a manner that will cause irreparable harm to the plaintiffs, to the states, and to the citizens of the United States,” said one of the filings.

It continued, “Because Mr. Obama has admitted that his father was not a U.S. citizen, and because this fact has been confirmed by the U.S. State Department, any reasonable person with knowledge of these facts would doubt Mr. Obama’s constitutional qualifications. Therefore, any representation by the Democratic Party certifying said qualifications would be negligent, absent further evidence verifying Mr. Obama’s natural-born status.

“Plaintiffs further request an injunction prohibiting the Democratic Party from making any representation to any state official asserting, implying, or assuming that Mr. Obama is qualified to hold the office of president, absent a showing by the party sufficient to prove that said representation is not negligent.”

Van Irion, lead counsel for Liberty Legal Foundation, also is working on several of the issues, and has brought the question in court in Arizona.

“We picked the Arizona court for several reasons, but the main one being that it is part of the 9th Circuit. The 9th Circuit has indicated in dicta that an FEC-registered presidential candidate would have standing for this type of suit,” he said. The organization is working with John Dummett, a Liberty Legal Foundation member who is a candidate for the office of president in the 2012 election.

Irion said the other lawsuit was filed in state court in Tennessee.

“The focus of the state-court suit is to prevent certification to the Tennessee Secretary of State. This suit puts greater emphasis on the negligent misrepresentation/fraud aspects of a certification from the DNC. It includes more facts regarding Obama’s Indonesian dual citizenship and fraudulent Social Security Number,” he said.

He said if the cases succeed, the Democrats would not be able to list Obama as their candidate for 2012.

“Neither lawsuit discusses Obama’s place of birth or his birth certificate. These issues are completely irrelevant to the argument. LLF’s lawsuit simply points out that the Supreme Court has defined ‘natural-born citizen’ as a person born to two parents who were both U.S. citizens at the time of the natural-born citizen’s birth. Obama’s father was never a U.S. citizen. Therefore, Obama can never be a natural-born citizen. His place of birth is irrelevant,” Van Irion’s group said.

WND also has reported that Maricopa, Ariz., County Sheriff Joe Arpaio has launched a formal law enforcement investigation into concerns Obama may submit fraudulent documentation to be put on the state’s election ballot in 2012.

Other attorneys involved in the Georgia case are J. Mark Hatfield and Orly Taitz.

Hatfield has told WND that the goal is for a court determination on the definition of “natural born citizen,” which then could be applied directly to Obama’s candidacy.

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Cliff 2012/01/31 13:48:42
    Hopefully, more states will take action to eliminate this parasite.
    Cliff
    +7
    Before you know it, his name will be off the ballot in all 57 states.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Viet Era medic 2012/01/31 20:24:49
    Hopefully, more states will take action to eliminate this parasite.
    Viet Era medic
    +1
    Thank God... And I hope it spreads like an Arizona wildfire.. It's about time. I only wish it would have come to a head in 2009 after he took office and perhaps we could have thrown him out then.
    He always acted like he was above the law and you cannot accept that whether you are Dem or Rep. If you accept that then you are part of the problem. I hope the $hit hits the proverbial fan.
  • BackWoodsMike 2012/01/31 19:03:07
    Other
    BackWoodsMike
    +1
    It's not too late for the democrats to replace Obama as their nominee, and if they were smart they would.

    Pat Caddell, who knows what it was to be a part of the Carter disaster, and Doug Scone, a democrat pollster, are just about pleading that Obama step asside.
    http://online.wsj.com/article...
  • darcie lamar 2012/01/31 15:26:03 (edited)
    Hopefully, more states will take action to eliminate this parasite.
    darcie lamar
    +2
    This is part of a report from The Western Center for Journalism
    ( http://www.westernjournalism....



    It kind of makes you wonder. Remember on Obama's first day of office he signed an executive order to have his records sealed.



    "Federal law requires all American males to register for the Selective Service (the draft) in case a major war broke out. Blogger Debbie Schlussel has discovered solid evidence that Obama’s Selective Service registration form was submitted not when he was younger as required, but rather in 2008 and then altered to look older. Indeed, the forgers forgot to alter the “Document Location Number” which shows that it is clearly a 2008 form. This is fraud and it’s a felony and Schlussel’s allegations are backed up by Stephen Coffman, a former high-ranking Federal agent. Moreover, the document shows a September 4th, 1980 date and the location of the transaction as Hawaii, but at that time Obama was thousands of miles away attending Occidental College in Los Angeles.

    The real reason why Obama probably did not submit this form as a teenager is that he assumed his Kenyan or Indonesian citizenship exempted him from this requirement. But clearly, as he grew older and entered politics, he saw that any documents revealing a foreign birth – Selective Service registration, b...

    This is part of a report from The Western Center for Journalism
    ( http://www.westernjournalism....



    It kind of makes you wonder. Remember on Obama's first day of office he signed an executive order to have his records sealed.



    "Federal law requires all American males to register for the Selective Service (the draft) in case a major war broke out. Blogger Debbie Schlussel has discovered solid evidence that Obama’s Selective Service registration form was submitted not when he was younger as required, but rather in 2008 and then altered to look older. Indeed, the forgers forgot to alter the “Document Location Number” which shows that it is clearly a 2008 form. This is fraud and it’s a felony and Schlussel’s allegations are backed up by Stephen Coffman, a former high-ranking Federal agent. Moreover, the document shows a September 4th, 1980 date and the location of the transaction as Hawaii, but at that time Obama was thousands of miles away attending Occidental College in Los Angeles.

    The real reason why Obama probably did not submit this form as a teenager is that he assumed his Kenyan or Indonesian citizenship exempted him from this requirement. But clearly, as he grew older and entered politics, he saw that any documents revealing a foreign birth – Selective Service registration, birth certificate, school applications, etc – would be problematic if he ran for the presidency. Thus, it is not a coincidence that every document which contains information about his birth or citizenship is either missing, sealed, or has been altered.

    Indeed, everywhere one looks into Obama’s background, we find sealed records, scrubbed websites, altered documents, deception and unanswered questions. Can anyone imagine for a second if John McCain or George Bush had blocked access to his school, medical, and birth records? It would have been headlines in their case, but as with everything else concerning Obama, the media has given him a pass on this".
    (more)
  • captainquiggle 2012/01/31 14:27:13
    Other
    captainquiggle
    +1
    If you could draw a case to say this wasn't all partisan politics at work, I'd give a damn, but this is obvious GOP strategy at work and it's disgusting. How stupid do they think the public is? Do they think they can force the issue to revisit and beat a dead horse? Grow up, GOP.
  • Birthpangs captain... 2012/01/31 20:08:47
  • captain... Birthpangs 2012/01/31 22:07:51
    captainquiggle
    In your mind, I guess.
  • MichaelJ 2012/01/31 13:51:01
    Other
    MichaelJ
    +1
    Hopefully other states will investigate the President's eligibility and this can be brought to a close, not by people shouting down those that legally can challenge that eligibility.
  • Birthpangs MichaelJ 2012/01/31 13:53:28
  • pizzaman7 2012/01/31 13:50:22
    Hopefully, more states will take action to eliminate this parasite.
    pizzaman7
    +4
    WOW !! Six states already ! Good. It's about time. He is not qualified to be president. It's the law. He should of been properly vetted from the get go.
  • Birthpangs pizzaman7 2012/01/31 13:54:15
  • Cliff 2012/01/31 13:48:42
    Hopefully, more states will take action to eliminate this parasite.
    Cliff
    +7
    Before you know it, his name will be off the ballot in all 57 states.
  • Birthpangs Cliff 2012/01/31 13:50:09
  • Karen E 2012/01/31 13:45:29
    Hopefully, more states will take action to eliminate this parasite.
    Karen E
    +3
    glad to see tenny in this-
  • captain... Karen E 2012/01/31 14:31:37
    captainquiggle
    Yes, Tennessee, the land of the bread and honey; they have not failed on all their promises to properly disappoint me at every turn. What an intellectual waste that place and Kansas is. Horrible. They should be ashamed of themselves for getting in on this obvious partisan slander.
  • BackWoo... captain... 2012/01/31 19:15:35
    BackWoodsMike
    +1
    That's funny, I happen to enjoy Tennessee ever since I moved here from the north east in the mid 90's.

    So tell me, captain, what do you (or your parents) pay in property tax, State income tax and on top of that, sales tax? What do you pay for an acre of property (or in the case of your State NY, a square foot of property)?

    I was born and raised in the north east, and you couldn't drag me back there to live again.
  • Birthpangs BackWoo... 2012/01/31 20:10:29
  • BackWoo... Birthpangs 2012/01/31 21:34:12
    BackWoodsMike
    I have lived in several States and Cities either on my own or relocation by the Company I worked for, and because of my previous profession, have traveled extensively throughout the United States. There is a world of difference between the north and the south.

    I was born in the City of Wilmington Delaware, was brought up in the Little Italy section of the City (the same Little Italy Joe Biden lied about visiting all the time) until the age of 12 when my Parents moved out of my Grandparent's home, and purchased a home in north Wilmington. We were 80 miles south of Philadelphia, just across the river from New Jersey, and four hours from New York City, so I know what it's like living and working in the north east.

    Tennessee is where I'm going to spend the rest of my life. We have made more friends (real friends) and have a better quality of life here than any other place we have lived.
  • Birthpangs 2012/01/31 13:38:05
  • captain... Birthpangs 2012/01/31 14:32:15
    captainquiggle
    He's got big shoes to fill considering the whole reason we were in Iraq in the first place had nothing to do with WMDs, right? Or did you forget that one?
  • T1 captain... 2012/01/31 15:17:07
    T1
    +1
    tt syria before you make such uninformed comments pal.
  • captain... T1 2012/01/31 15:43:33
    captainquiggle
    Wait, Syria was in control of the Bush administration? I didn't know that. Thanks, for such the informed view on what REALLY took place, there, guy.

    Even when the past administration admits there were no WMDs there, we still have asshats like you that thinks they know better. GREAT. Continue to wrap your tinfoil hat on super tight.
  • T1 captain... 2012/01/31 16:51:19
    T1
    +2
    and continue with your lack of balls
  • Birthpangs captain... 2012/01/31 20:11:05

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2014/11/25 00:53:16

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals