Quantcast

NYPD Shoots Dog While Her Owner Has a Seizure

Mark In Irvine 2012/08/22 06:32:44

New York City police shot a dog in the head on Tuesday, reports Gothamist. The pit bull named Star was believed to be protecting her owner as he had a seizure on the sidewalk. When officers came to address the emergency situation, Star ran at them for getting too close to her ailing companion, and they responded by firing a pair of bullets at her.

The gruesome scene attracted a sizeable crowd. Some bystanders cried, while others shouted at the officers for mishandling the situation. More officers arrived on the scene to control the crowd. All the while, Star bled on the street, flopping in pain, while her owner, known to friends as Pollock, lay unconscious on the ground, similarly unattended.

A witness uploaded a video to Youtube that shows how the scene unfolds. Please be aware that the clip is both upsetting and graphic. The video contains footage of Star being shot and writhing in pain.

From the video, it is clear that Star did lunge toward an officer at the time she was shot. Some on the scene thought the gun force, though sad, was appropriate. Witness Johnny Rodriguez said, “It’s a tragedy, but I may have done the same thing that the cop did. If you got a pit bull coming at you, I don’t know if you stand there and get bit or use your gun.”

Obviously, it is a shame to see a dog suffer for being loyal to her companion. Star viewed the officers who were there to help as a threat. However, at least a couple of witnesses told the Daily News that Star’s aggressiveness may have been provoked by how the officers approached Pollock. “Instead of calling the ambulance, they started kicking him,” said Aida Feliciano. “If you kick the dog’s owner, the dog is obviously going to attack,” said Alan Crosby, who also saw the incident.

Furthermore, if the officers’ intention was to remove Star from the situation in order to provide Polluck with medical attention, that does not explain why – as the video shows – he is left on the ground without treatment long after Star was too injured to interfere with any necessary care.

According to friends, Pollock is an elliptic who has seizures semi-regularly. An employee at the adjacent KFC restaurant said Pollock and Star frequented the area, calling them “friendly and harmless.”

Though initial reports suggested that Star had died, the latest news is that she is in serious condition. The medical summary also shows that Star was maced at some point, although it is unclear whether police used the substance on the pit bull before or after shooting her.



Read More: http://www.care2.com/causes/nypd-shoots-dog-while-...

You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

  • rich 2012/08/22 11:26:54
    rich
    +5
    Police need better training as to how to deal with pets. Pitts are protectors, but not that hard to handle when they are gentle pets who can walk the streets like that, and meet the diner help as indicated. Had he approached the dog with understanding, and a clear indication that he was going to help the man, then the dog would have reacted differently more than likely. Kicking the man was not the way to win Star's trust. Where is the Dog Whisperer when you need him! I'm sure if he saw this report, he'd be mortified!

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • MsDianna 2012/09/05 20:30:42
    MsDianna
    +1
    one of those situations that you don't know unless you are there that could have been you the dog lunged at or it could have been you on the ground in pain you just never know until it happens to you
  • donna.robinson.102 2012/08/27 22:15:44
    donna.robinson.102
    +1
    I feel the problem is in the training, i just told this story in another blog, my ex was a k-9 officer, we opted to keep his sheperd at my place than at the kennel, me being used to walking him anytime of the day or night can't deal with a stuffy nose, i barely sleep with it. It was 3 am i knew the air would calm and clear me so i leashed Bruno up andstarted our walk, a guy on the other side was limping, a car drove up beside him trying to coax him in it, i walked faster to get away from the scene and did, as i rounded the corner, these blinding lights were in my eyes, as well as guns Bruno went on instant protect mode meanwhile the cop is shouting i'll shoot the mf i'll shoot him after getting Bruno in a sit position i was furious, i stated angrily what do you mean you'll shoot him he's one of you? after stating he was a canine police dog he looked at me stupidly come to find out the guy was a stabbing victim, why they were all still with me was beyond me it only took one to get my statement, instead i was looking at six cops with flashlights and guns,was beyond me since i had given them the direction to where the guy was and a description of the car! Polluck had introduced Star into society, it is my beleif the reason star was shot is because the police officer was remiss an...
    I feel the problem is in the training, i just told this story in another blog, my ex was a k-9 officer, we opted to keep his sheperd at my place than at the kennel, me being used to walking him anytime of the day or night can't deal with a stuffy nose, i barely sleep with it. It was 3 am i knew the air would calm and clear me so i leashed Bruno up andstarted our walk, a guy on the other side was limping, a car drove up beside him trying to coax him in it, i walked faster to get away from the scene and did, as i rounded the corner, these blinding lights were in my eyes, as well as guns Bruno went on instant protect mode meanwhile the cop is shouting i'll shoot the mf i'll shoot him after getting Bruno in a sit position i was furious, i stated angrily what do you mean you'll shoot him he's one of you? after stating he was a canine police dog he looked at me stupidly come to find out the guy was a stabbing victim, why they were all still with me was beyond me it only took one to get my statement, instead i was looking at six cops with flashlights and guns,was beyond me since i had given them the direction to where the guy was and a description of the car! Polluck had introduced Star into society, it is my beleif the reason star was shot is because the police officer was remiss and panicked in how it was handled in the beginning so therefore Star felt that Polluck needed protectring, and proceede to do so, the breed of the dog was also a problem to the officers as well, its no secret people see a pitbull and automatically think agression however once a dog is entered into society and taught to interact with people they can really be quite submissive and freindly. However they can also feed off of the fear and anxieties of others, there were too many people around his owner as well, which also made it a threatening situation which the police should have secured the area and they themselves stayed calm while soothingly letting Star know everything was going to be alright, and this panicky reaction in police officers needs to be addressed in training not just in the handling of pets but in the handling of all matters.
    (more)
  • Venya 2012/08/24 06:16:37
    Venya
    +1
    Interesting video. Having experienced a number of seizures up close with clients and acquaintances, I can say that there's not really anything the police could have done for the seizure victim. The person in the video is obviously not harming himself or anyone else. As long as he's breathing, he should be fine. To bad the dog was shot. One has to look at it from all sides though. None of us would have done better than the NYPD did here. Get real, and don't toot your own horns folks. Things would have been very different if the dog had gotten a mouthful of leg, or the "unmentionables". :-} A law enforcement officer can't take that chance: his life and career may depend on fending off such attacks. I'm quite impressed he only shot once. And yes, in retrospect I'm sure they wish they had, or could have (what are they trained to do here?), finished it off. It would have been more merciful.
  • jumpboots 187th PIR 2012/08/24 01:31:27
    jumpboots 187th PIR
    +2
    This happen quite offen by the stupidity of some police officers,that do not have a clue of how to handle a simple situation. He should be kicked of the force. Next time it will be a human,over a parking ticket.
  • handeman 2012/08/24 01:06:45
    handeman
    +2
    You can use a tazer on a dog. That would have been better.
  • Swampdog 2012/08/23 15:48:29
    Swampdog
    +2
    The dog is a minority, where's Al Sharpton?
  • Mark In... Swampdog 2012/08/23 18:30:32
    Mark In Irvine
    +2
    you're just prejudiced in favor of dogs ... i like that!
  • Swampdog Mark In... 2012/08/23 18:57:18
    Swampdog
    +3
    There was no need to shoot the dog when they could have tased it. Shooting a dog is typical city folk thinking. Either tase the animal or lasso it and tie it off to a fence post or some similar facsimile. Although we may not see eye to eye on politics, there is something wrong with people who don't like animals!
  • Mark In... Swampdog 2012/08/23 21:44:44
    Mark In Irvine
    +2
    "there is something wrong with people who don't like animals"

    i totally agree ...
  • "OG" 2012/08/23 15:40:00
    "OG"
    +1
    Tough situation there definitively done in to public a place.
  • Cricket 2012/08/23 11:06:52
    Cricket
    +2
    I cannot watch that video.
  • Matt Fo... Cricket 2012/08/28 03:49:53
    Matt Forrester
    +1
    Neither can I, despite my curiosity about the chain-of-events that led to the shooting & what happened after that...I foster dogs that are on "death row" at the pound until we find "forever homes" for them, so I wouldn't be able to deal well with seeing one being shot by over-zealous cops with itchy trigger fingers...
  • Ninjaman 2012/08/23 02:03:25
    Ninjaman
    +2
    This is ridiculous... after shooting the dog, which was totally uncalled for, they let it go in pain instead of killing it quick, THEN DONT EVEN WALK OVER TO HELP THE PERSON LAYING ON THE GROUND... WHAT KIND OF CROCK IS THAT???
  • Cricket Ninjaman 2012/08/23 11:07:33
    Cricket
    +2
    The worst kind I can think of at the moment
  • Piperpc 2012/08/22 20:05:19
    Piperpc
    +2
    Well, that was heart-wrenching to watch. I know of far too many instances of police shooting dogs they 'perceive' as a threat, often in their own yards or houses. All kinds of dogs, not just pit bulls. I see no excuse for it, when supposedly, police are almost always armed with tasers along with guns.
    Star was just 'doing her job', and what happened was sickening and sad. Seems everyone there was afraid they might be shot, if attempting to help or comfort Star or Polluck.........
  • nbarton2 2012/08/22 16:15:59
    nbarton2
    +2
    While the dog may have been "friendly and harmless" the main concern for the police was the individual having the seizure and getting to that individual in a quick manner without being mauled by a protective animal. Then everyone has to get involved in yelling and telling them that "they didn't need to do that" were they watching the dog? The dog lunged at the police and while I don't condone animal cruelty pit bulls can tear a nice chunk of flesh in a matter of seconds especially while protecting; as for the individual on the ground everyone was so focused on the dog not one person could be concerned with him. Good thing the paramedics showed up in a minute.
  • Ninjaman nbarton2 2012/08/23 01:56:06
    Ninjaman
    +3
    they got close enough kick the man, after that the dog starting to respond in a protective manner. i would have done the same. but if they got that close originally, then apparently the dog wasnt being aggressive until it saw its owner attacked...
  • nbarton2 Ninjaman 2012/08/23 21:10:26
    nbarton2
    +2
    Watched the youtube video frame by frame they NEVER kick the guy, the dog goes after a woman trying to help the man @ 5 second, the police officer attempts to get close and the dog; @ 8 seconds it looks like the officer gets close but it is the camera angle nothing more. If you watched more than once you would see the dog acting very aggressive the whole time and I'm sure if the individual filming had been filming the whole time you would have seen the lead up as well.
  • Ninjaman nbarton2 2012/08/28 13:09:53
    Ninjaman
    +1
    with 4 officers, someone couldve used mace or a stun gun... they didnt have to shoot it... and even after they shoot it, not one of the 4 officers did anything to help the person laying on the ground.
  • nbarton2 Ninjaman 2012/08/29 00:26:15
    nbarton2
    +1
    Actually only two officers responded initially, the dog had already attacked a bystander and went after the police, stop Monday morning quarterbacking over an attack dog.
  • Ninjaman nbarton2 2012/08/31 02:06:56
    Ninjaman
    +1
    it wasnt an attack dog. it responded based on its situation... and thats still no reason to kill it, under the circumstances... it could have been tased like they wouldve done a human... are we going to start killing people who attack others? or would they have pulled a taser had it have been a human? the response that was used was excessive.
  • Wiyao Boukpessi 2012/08/22 16:10:36
    Wiyao Boukpessi
    +1
    that's terrible
  • Cuthbert Allsgood 2012/08/22 15:43:59
    Cuthbert Allsgood
    +1
    I'm really too angry to form a decent comment. My respect for the human race has gone down... again.
  • Caedus01 Sith Lord of the P... 2012/08/22 14:52:42 (edited)
    Caedus01 Sith Lord of the PHAET
    +3
    I saw that video. It was sad. He could have pepper sprayed the poor thing....coward!!!! At that range the bullet could have bounced off the pavement and hit someone else
  • pamela 2012/08/22 14:36:29 (edited)
    pamela
    +2
    This is stupid to me, instead of possibly provoking the dog to take it down, to think they could possibly help the owner having the seizure, was not the way this could have been handled. If there was an animal involved, instead of going about it the way they did, why couldn't they have called animal control, they have better methods of restraining animals, instead of putting a bullet into him. I didn't finish watching the video, but even after 6 minutes of shooting the animal, still never bothered to help this man. Almost a dozen cops on the scene, and none of them helped that man. At least half of these cops should have been designated for crowd control, but instead the all stood there, wanting nothing more to do with this situation. Both could be dead right now, all because this was not handled in a better way, then what the police thought or wanted to do. Talk about inhumane.
  • Professor Wizard 2012/08/22 14:24:37
    Professor Wizard
    +1
    I found the YouTube... nobody walked up to the man lying on the sidewalk - - at all - - the police instantly went into "Defensive" mode keeping people away and COMPLETELY ignored the man on the ground. I don't know if the guy was dead.. but he wasn't moving.

    Something to think about if you should feel that police are there to protect or help you... ... .. they are NOT... they will only shoot to protect themselves, not a citizen... and their procedures are designed to clean things up and protect their actions - not to help citizens who are lying helpless on the ground.

    But - do know you will be safe from the crazed pets of injured owners.

    Here is the vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?...
  • Kashee 2012/08/22 13:57:43
    Kashee
    +2
    This is really sad. I think the least the police department could do now is to get this person a seizure response dog since they killed Star. It will never replace Star, but a trained and tagged dog would be a solution for all concerned. It's sad that Star was not trained as a seizure response dog and wearing appropriate garments to identify her purpose.
  • ID51 2012/08/22 13:13:28
    ID51
    +4
    You could not pay me to visit NYC again. That city's gone to hell in a handcart. The police were dead wrong, and I hope Star survives. I wonder if the owner will sue?
  • Temlakos~POTL~PWCM~JLA~☆ 2012/08/22 12:10:56
    Temlakos~POTL~PWCM~JLA~☆
    +2
    Let's see what the IAD has to say.
  • metalmania17 2012/08/22 11:57:24
  • charles... metalma... 2012/08/22 14:21:33
    charles nelson
    +2
    was the dog black?
  • pamela charles... 2012/08/22 14:51:58
    pamela
    +1
    What does the color of the dog have to do with this. So what if the dog was black, yellow, brown, green or any other color of the rainbow. He was protecting his owner, because that is what animals do with there loved owners.

    Now to ask you, was this a simple racist remark, because it sounds like it.
  • charles... pamela 2012/08/22 15:17:23
    charles nelson
    +1
    Thats because we humans have to worry about such silly things.
  • Mark In... pamela 2012/08/22 17:35:07
    Mark In Irvine
    i suspect that charles was trying to make a joke ...
  • charles... Mark In... 2012/08/22 18:14:23
    charles nelson
    +2
    suspect the mark of irvine maybe got it?
  • Mark In... charles... 2012/08/22 18:25:12
    Mark In Irvine
    +1
    mark in irvine suspects that charles nelson may be right ...
  • donna.r... pamela 2012/08/27 21:42:01 (edited)
    donna.robinson.102
    +2
    cute kitten, he's making a joke ignore that when you think about it, pets have no race.
  • Mark In... donna.r... 2012/08/27 22:54:04
    Mark In Irvine
    but pets sometimes DO race!! ha ha ha!!!
  • pamela donna.r... 2012/09/03 21:06:21
    pamela
    +1
    Thank You, and yes I do think that Charles was making a stupid remark.
  • charles... charles... 2012/08/23 23:00:54
    charles nelson
    +1
    sorry about the comment, forgot about where i'm at.

News & Politics

2013/05/19 14:35:56

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals