NOT AT ALL. The Congress overstepped its bounds, and it knows it, and so does everybody else. Buying something that your don't want, is not Constitutional no matter how far our stretch the Commence Clause.
Patriot Unit
2012/03/27 16:37:53
Poll Question: Do You Think the Individual Mandate is Constitutional?
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/03/27/poll-questio...
Top Opinion
-
__A_YAHOO_USER__ 2012/06/29 00:03:53+3If you read the law regarding using a religious based exemption, the government already guessed people would try this because they require you to not only opt out of the Affordable Health care Act, you must also relinquish any and all present and future participation in social security and Medicare. I have already been working for 30 years of my life and have paid a lot of money into both of those programs so I am screwed, but if I were under 25 years of age, I would opt out of it all and save for my own retirement, and not buy health insurance when young and healthy to save for investments and/or retirement.


















The Constitution was written to protect our INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS. Using mob rule to violate the rights of individuals is NOT CONSTITUTIONAL. Anyone can have health insurance. Those that do not, CHOOSE not to. I did at 18 with just a HS diploma. It was a priority of mine. Their CHOICE to be irresponsible is not my fault.
Maybe instead we make health care bills like student loans where they never go away and you can not de...
The Constitution was written to protect our INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS. Using mob rule to violate the rights of individuals is NOT CONSTITUTIONAL. Anyone can have health insurance. Those that do not, CHOOSE not to. I did at 18 with just a HS diploma. It was a priority of mine. Their CHOICE to be irresponsible is not my fault.
Maybe instead we make health care bills like student loans where they never go away and you can not declare bankruptcy for them. We garnish wages, and go after personal assets (Including trusts and any personal assets transferred to a relative within the past 10 years). If there are actual consequences to not having insurance, many more people will carry it. Health care like anything else is only as important to one as they make it. If it is not their priority, why should everyone else be punished?
Kagan should have recused herself as she was insttrumental in getting the O'care Law passed. So you think she'll go against her own supported idea?
And neither are any of the other fourteen ways that this bill violates the Constitution.
It originated in the Senate, not the House, though it raises revenue.
It raises and supports another army--the Ready Reserve Corps--with a four-year appropriation, not a two-year.
It lays a capitation tax on people without apportionment among the States.
It differentially taxes the exports of the several States.
Obama was never qualified to sign it anyway, for he is not a natural-born citizen.
I could go on, and have gone on elsewhere on SH and off. But you get the idea.
"The new Obamacare legislation that was forced on unwilling Americans this week specifically mandates that we all purchase health insurance. That is, unless you don’t believe in that sort of thing. That’s right, the current health care bill contains a clause which exempts certain individuals form the requirements and penalties set forth in it.
EXEMPTIONS FROM INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY REQUIREMENTS.
In the case of an individual who is seeking an exemption certificate under section 1311(d)(4)(H) from any requirement or penalty imposed by section 5000A, the following information:
In the case of an individual seeking exemption based on the individual’s status as a
member of an exempt religious sect or division, as a member of a health care sharing ministry, as an Indian,
or as an individual eligible for a hardship exemption, such information as the Secretary shall prescribe.”
Senate Bill, H.R. 3590, pages 273-274
There are several reasons why an individual could claim exemption, being a member of a religion that does...
"The new Obamacare legislation that was forced on unwilling Americans this week specifically mandates that we all purchase health insurance. That is, unless you don’t believe in that sort of thing. That’s right, the current health care bill contains a clause which exempts certain individuals form the requirements and penalties set forth in it.
EXEMPTIONS FROM INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY REQUIREMENTS.
In the case of an individual who is seeking an exemption certificate under section 1311(d)(4)(H) from any requirement or penalty imposed by section 5000A, the following information:
In the case of an individual seeking exemption based on the individual’s status as a
member of an exempt religious sect or division, as a member of a health care sharing ministry, as an Indian,
or as an individual eligible for a hardship exemption, such information as the Secretary shall prescribe.”
Senate Bill, H.R. 3590, pages 273-274
There are several reasons why an individual could claim exemption, being a member of a religion that does not believe in insurance is one of them. Islam is one of those religions. Muslims believe that health insurance is “haraam”, or forbidden; because they liken the ambiguity and probability of insurance to gambling. This belief excludes them from any of the requirements, mandates, or penalties set forth in the bill. Other excluded groups include Amish, American Indians, and Christian Scientists".
My pastor could decide next Sunday to preach against health insurance, on the theory that we should "live in faith." And we'd be out of luck.
UH-OHHHHHHHHHHHH!
Muslims will get to not pay, but still get the care.
Far fetched, but there are always a lot of unintended consequences to these broad laws.
The only difference here is that the private sector is making a profit from this one, instead of it coming out of government coffers.
It doesn't happen to individuals because employers take the money before they see it, but a lot of employers have gone to jail or been fined for not complying with the programs.
If they make it stick GM will be happy. You can now only buy a chevy volt and the price just tripled.