Quantcast

Mitt Romney's core of Vulnerabilty is his lack of a tax plan, Don't you agree?

BIG BAD JOHN R. 2012/07/19 17:25:02
Yes, his lack of a great tax plan is hurting his credibility.
No, he does not need a great tax plan, he is rich and his credibility is fine.
Undecided
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Conservatives fear that President Obama’s wave of attacks on Mitt Romney’s business record and tax returns are succeeding at defining the Republican nominee. A key reason this is working, they say, is that Romney has failed to define himself — and his tax platform offers a compelling window into this phenomenon.

If only Romney emulated the conservative candidate they’ve long yearned for, they argue, he could insulate himself from attacks on his business record, unreleased tax returns, and anything else Obama might throw his way.

At a glance, these might appear to be unrelated issues. What do Romney’s personal finances and private sector career have to do with his social and economic policy bona fides?

Directly, very little. But an obvious tension between Romney’s desire to appeal to conservative power players without alienating the middle- and working-class voters he needs to win in November underscores their point. if he can’t rebut attacks on his business career and his finances, and he can’t tout his key gubernatorial achievement ‘Romneycare’, he ought to have at least one issue to champion. Yet even when it comes to the right’s top issue — taxes — Romney’s hedging has left him friendless; middle class voters see him championing tax breaks for the wealthy, and conservatives aren’t sure he’ll follow through on their goals of forcing major cuts to the safety net and other domestic programs, while preventing significant cuts to defense spending.

Under persistent pressure from the right during the GOP primary, Romney released a revised tax plan late in February pledging to reduce all tax rates by 20 percent, establishing a top individual rate of 28 percent. A campaign spokesperson tells TPM the plan remains current.

The presumptive Republican nominee’s chief economic adviser Glenn Hubbard told CNBC the plan would slash each of the six tax brackets from their Bush-era rates — 10, 15, 25, 28, 33, and 35 percent — down to 8, 12, 20, 22.4, 26.4, and 28 percent, respectively. He also wants to cut the corporate tax rate to 25 percent.

At the same time, he claims his plan will be deficit neutral, and that he’ll close out longer-term deficits by cutting unspecified federal programs over time.

Add a comment above

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • InoYamanaka 2012/08/18 00:12:01
    Undecided
    InoYamanaka
    "Does not need a great tax plan". I think cutting cooperate taxes by 25% is a great tax plan.
  • DuncanONeil 2012/07/20 02:25:22
    Undecided
    DuncanONeil
    Sorry John he has a plan.

    http://taxpolicycenter.org/ta...
  • Kane Fernau 2012/07/19 20:25:52
    Undecided
    Kane Fernau
    Obama only has a poor record. Obama has created more poverty than jobs.
  • Lady Whitewolf 2012/07/19 19:19:08
    Undecided
    Lady Whitewolf
    Oh, he's got a "tax plan" alright....

    MORE taxes on the poor and middle class

    LESS OR NO txes for the wealthiest!
  • Aurora 2012/07/19 18:30:48
    Undecided
    Aurora
    We fear nothing, after living in Obamaville I am not afraid of anything. You guys are desperate I can smell it.
  • Greg 2012/07/19 17:50:07
    Undecided
    Greg
    +1
    I won't vote for him regardless what his tax plan is. He is just a neocon big government crony corporatist RINO. I will be voting for Gary Johnson, the Libertarian candidate
  • Outta' Here. 2012/07/19 17:41:07
    Undecided
    Outta' Here.
    Romney's core of vulnerability, in my opinion; is that he hasn't come out publicly and said, "That lying son of a bitch has screwed us all almost to a point beyond repair! Unemployment, realistically, is at 15% or higher. The economy's in the toilet. He tells OUR oil companies "No! You can't drill!" then goes to Venezuela to tell a damned dictatorial government, "Drill away! We look forward to being you best customer!" MY ASS! Throw that son of bitch out on his way too big for his head ear!"
  • greatwhyte2 2012/07/19 17:39:14
    Undecided
    greatwhyte2
    Obama has ways of faking out the people hes very good at it and this is one of those tricks.Obama is now showing how truly crooked he is.
  • Bronar 2012/07/19 17:34:41
    Undecided
    Bronar
    NO, we have the highest corporate taxes in the industrialized world, then we wonder why jobs are being shipped overseas? It's so the conglomerates (read huge employers) can continue to compete on a global level.

    Now what about this isn't a plan?:

    Individual Taxes

    America’s individual tax code applies relatively high marginal tax rates on a narrow tax base. Those high rates discourage work and entrepreneurship, as well as savings and investment. With 54 percent of private sector workers employed outside of corporations, individual rates also define the incentives for job-creating businesses. Lower marginal tax rates secure for all Americans the economic gains from tax reform.

    Make permanent, across-the-board 20 percent cut in marginal rates
    Maintain current tax rates on interest, dividends, and capital gains
    Eliminate taxes for taxpayers with AGI below $200,000 on interest, dividends, and capital gains
    Eliminate the Death Tax
    Repeal the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)

    Corporate Taxes

    The U.S. economy’s 35 percent corporate tax rate is among the highest in the industrial world, reducing the ability of our nation’s businesses to compete in the global economy and to invest and create jobs at home. By limiting investment and growth, the high rate of corpor...


    &

    NO, we have the highest corporate taxes in the industrialized world, then we wonder why jobs are being shipped overseas? It's so the conglomerates (read huge employers) can continue to compete on a global level.

    Now what about this isn't a plan?:

    Individual Taxes

    America’s individual tax code applies relatively high marginal tax rates on a narrow tax base. Those high rates discourage work and entrepreneurship, as well as savings and investment. With 54 percent of private sector workers employed outside of corporations, individual rates also define the incentives for job-creating businesses. Lower marginal tax rates secure for all Americans the economic gains from tax reform.

    Make permanent, across-the-board 20 percent cut in marginal rates
    Maintain current tax rates on interest, dividends, and capital gains
    Eliminate taxes for taxpayers with AGI below $200,000 on interest, dividends, and capital gains
    Eliminate the Death Tax
    Repeal the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)

    Corporate Taxes

    The U.S. economy’s 35 percent corporate tax rate is among the highest in the industrial world, reducing the ability of our nation’s businesses to compete in the global economy and to invest and create jobs at home. By limiting investment and growth, the high rate of corporate tax also hurts U.S. wages.

    Cut the corporate rate to 25 percent
    Strengthen and make permanent the R&D; tax credit
    Switch to a territorial tax system
    Repeal the corporate Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)
    (more)
  • George ... Bronar 2012/07/19 17:47:25
    George Romney
    But that simply won't add up. If we cut taxes that significantly, we balloon the deficit. We need to cut spending, first and foremost. If we cut taxes, then we have to cut even more spending. And there's not a single Republican (especially not Romney) that's identified what that spending is.
  • Bronar George ... 2012/07/19 17:52:57
    Bronar
    I don't get it, do you refuse to read or believe:

    Set Honest Goals: Cap Spending At 20 Percent Of GDP

    Any turnaround must begin with clear and realistic goals. Optimistic projections cannot wish a problem away, they can only make it worse. As president, Mitt’s goal will be to bring federal spending below 20 percent of GDP by the end of his first term:

    Reduced from 24.3 percent last year; in line with the historical trend between 18 and 20 percent
    Close to the tax revenue generated by the economy when healthy
    Requires spending cuts of approximately $500 billion per year in 2016 assuming robust economic recovery with 4% annual growth, and reversal of irresponsible Obama-era defense cuts

    Take Immediate Action: Return Non-Security Discretionary Spending To Below 2008 Levels

    Any turnaround must also stop the bleeding and reverse the most recent and dramatic damage:

    Send Congress a bill on Day One that cuts non-security discretionary spending by 5 percent across the board
    Pass the House Republican Budget proposal, rolling back President Obama’s government expansion by capping non-security discretionary spending below 2008 levels

    Follow A Clear Roadmap: Build A Simpler, Smaller, Smarter Government

    Most importantly, any turnaround must have a thoughtful, structured approach t...









    >






    I don't get it, do you refuse to read or believe:

    Set Honest Goals: Cap Spending At 20 Percent Of GDP

    Any turnaround must begin with clear and realistic goals. Optimistic projections cannot wish a problem away, they can only make it worse. As president, Mitt’s goal will be to bring federal spending below 20 percent of GDP by the end of his first term:

    Reduced from 24.3 percent last year; in line with the historical trend between 18 and 20 percent
    Close to the tax revenue generated by the economy when healthy
    Requires spending cuts of approximately $500 billion per year in 2016 assuming robust economic recovery with 4% annual growth, and reversal of irresponsible Obama-era defense cuts

    Take Immediate Action: Return Non-Security Discretionary Spending To Below 2008 Levels

    Any turnaround must also stop the bleeding and reverse the most recent and dramatic damage:

    Send Congress a bill on Day One that cuts non-security discretionary spending by 5 percent across the board
    Pass the House Republican Budget proposal, rolling back President Obama’s government expansion by capping non-security discretionary spending below 2008 levels

    Follow A Clear Roadmap: Build A Simpler, Smaller, Smarter Government

    Most importantly, any turnaround must have a thoughtful, structured approach to achieving its goals. Mitt will attack the bloated budget from three angles:

    The Federal Government Should Stop Doing Things The American People Can’t Afford, For Instance:
    Repeal Obamacare — Savings: $95 Billion. President Obama’s costly takeover of the health care system imposes an enormous and unaffordable obligation on the federal government while intervening in a matter that should be left to the states. Mitt will begin his efforts to repeal this legislation on Day One.
    Privatize Amtrak — Savings: $1.6 Billion. Despite requirement that Amtrak operate on a for-profit basis, it continues to receive about $1.6 billion in taxpayer funds each year. Forty-one of Amtrak’s 44 routes lost money in 2008 with losses ranging from $5 to $462 per passenger.
    Reduce Subsidies For The National Endowments For The Arts And Humanities, The Corporation For Public Broadcasting, And The Legal Services Corporation — Savings: $600 Million. NEA, NEH, and CPB provide grants to supplement other sources of funding. LSC funds services mostly duplicative of those already offered by states, localities, bar associations and private organizations.
    Eliminate Title X Family Planning Funding — Savings: $300 Million. Title X subsidizes family planning programs that benefit abortion groups like Planned Parenthood.
    Reduce Foreign Aid — Savings: $100 Million. Stop borrowing money from countries that oppose America’s interests in order to give it back to them in the form of foreign aid.

    If pursued with focus and discipline, Mitt’s approach provides a roadmap to rescue the federal government from its present precipice. But that respite will be short-lived without a plan for the looming long-term threat posed by the unsustainable nature of existing entitlement obligations. Learn more about Mitt’s proposals for entitlement reform: [links to Medicare and Social Security]
    Empower States To Innovate — Savings: >$100 billion
    Block grants have huge potential to generate both superior results and cost savings by establishing local control and promoting innovation in areas such as Medicaid and Worker Retraining. Medicaid spending should be capped and increased each year by CPI + 1%. Department of Labor retraining spending should be capped and will increase in future years. These funds should then be given to the states to spend on their own residents. States will be free from Washington micromanagement, allowing them to develop innovative approaches that improve quality and reduce cost.
    Improve Efficiency And Effectiveness. Where the federal government should act, it must do a better job. For instance:
    Reduce Waste And Fraud — Savings: $60 Billion. The federal government made $125 billion in improper payments last year. Cutting that amount in half through stricter enforcement and harsher penalties yields returns many times over on the investment.
    Align Federal Employee Compensation With The Private Sector — Savings: $47 Billion. Federal compensation exceeds private sector levels by as much as 30 to 40 percent when benefits are taken into account. This must be corrected.
    Repeal The Davis-Bacon Act — Savings: $11 Billion. Davis-Bacon forces the government to pay above-market wages, insulating labor unions from competition and driving up project costs by approximately 10 percent.
    Reduce The Federal Workforce By 10 Percent Via Attrition — Savings: $4 Billion. Despite widespread layoffs in the private sector, President Obama has continued to grow the federal payrolls. The federal workforce can be reduced by 10 percent through a “1-for-2” system of attrition, thereby reducing the number of federal employees while allowing the introduction of new talent into the federal service.
    Consolidate agencies and streamline processes to cut costs and improve results in everything from energy permitting to worker retraining to trade negotiation.
    (more)
  • George ... Bronar 2012/07/19 17:57:35 (edited)
    George Romney
    You add all those spending cuts you listed and get $300 Billion in savings. That's impressive and I support that. But Romney's tax plan eliminates approximately $340 Billion from the federal revenue leaving us with $40 Billion more in deficit on top of the already mounting $1 Trillion deficit per year. Saying that you're going to "cap spending at 20% of GDP" is an eloquent phrase but vague and has little specifics to back it up. At the very least, Obama's plan to increase taxes is SOMETHING to tackle the deficit. Keep in mind it's not a good plan, but it's at least a plan.
  • Bronar George ... 2012/07/19 17:58:59
    Bronar
    Obama has had three years to come up with something other than stimulus plans. Sorry, time for a real change.
  • none 2012/07/19 17:34:04
    Undecided
    none
    In September when the majority of Americans start to really pay attention to the election process Romney will reveal a tax plan. He's a smart man and I'm sure he has a plan and will pick the best time to reveal it.
    NOBAMA in 2012!
  • CUDDLY BUT STILL CRABBY 2012/07/19 17:32:43
    Undecided
    CUDDLY BUT STILL CRABBY
    +1
    Well, I read this AM from various sources that Obama's campaign has blown through $100 million in ATTACK ADS and doesn't have jack-squat to show for it.

    Obama hasn't had a budget OR a plan for the last 3.5 years, so why does his opponent have to? Mr Romney will disclose his tax records way back to 1912 if and when Obama discloses these:

    1. Occidental
    College records....SEALED

    2. Columbia College records....SEALED

    3. Columbia Thesis paper....SEALED

    4. Harvard College records....SEALED

    5. Selective Service Registration....SEALED

    6. Uses SSN from the State of Connecticut
    even though never a resident of the state....HOW?
    SEALED

    7. Medical records....SEALED

    8. Illinois State Senate schedule....SEALED

    9. Illinois State Senate records....SEALED

    10. Law practice client list....SEALED

    11. Certified copy of original Birth
    Certificate....SEALED

    12. Signed Embossed paper Certificate of
    Birth....SEALED

    13. Baptism record....SEALED

    14. He and Michelle Obama returned law permit to
    Illinois in 1993 and can no longer practice law, why? SEALED

    15. Law School and ACT Test scores....SEALED

    16. Why did he get "Foreign Student Grand Aid" as
    a student? SEALED

    17. How could he travel for weeks with his beau to
    Pakistan ...



















    Well, I read this AM from various sources that Obama's campaign has blown through $100 million in ATTACK ADS and doesn't have jack-squat to show for it.

    Obama hasn't had a budget OR a plan for the last 3.5 years, so why does his opponent have to? Mr Romney will disclose his tax records way back to 1912 if and when Obama discloses these:

    1. Occidental
    College records....SEALED

    2. Columbia College records....SEALED

    3. Columbia Thesis paper....SEALED

    4. Harvard College records....SEALED

    5. Selective Service Registration....SEALED

    6. Uses SSN from the State of Connecticut
    even though never a resident of the state....HOW?
    SEALED

    7. Medical records....SEALED

    8. Illinois State Senate schedule....SEALED

    9. Illinois State Senate records....SEALED

    10. Law practice client list....SEALED

    11. Certified copy of original Birth
    Certificate....SEALED

    12. Signed Embossed paper Certificate of
    Birth....SEALED

    13. Baptism record....SEALED

    14. He and Michelle Obama returned law permit to
    Illinois in 1993 and can no longer practice law, why? SEALED

    15. Law School and ACT Test scores....SEALED

    16. Why did he get "Foreign Student Grand Aid" as
    a student? SEALED

    17. How could he travel for weeks with his beau to
    Pakistan in 1981. SEALED

    18. On what
    passports did he leave US to see Grandma Obama and on which ones did he get
    into Pakistan? PASSPORTS SEALED.

    18. How were the
    tens of thousands of College Years funded?
    SEALED

    19. Where are the
    adoption records of Barry Soetoro?
    SEALED

    20. At Chicago, what did part-time Lecturer Obama
    write, like a path-breaking legal article or a book on jurisprudence that
    warranted a rare tenure offer and has such offer ever been extended to others
    of like stature? ... SEALED

    21. Why did he
    apply for a loan as Harrison J Bounel?
    (more)
  • kir 2012/07/19 17:29:34
    Undecided
    kir
    +1
    Actually the core of his vulnerability is the fact that he is a progressive authoritarian elitist just like Obama. http://politicoid.blogspot.co...

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/23 05:22:49

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals