Quantcast

Libya Asks NATO to Defend Transition to Sharia Law: What Should NATO Do?

Fef 2011/10/27 07:03:02
You!
Add Photos & Videos
The United States and NATO allies (but mostly the United States) helped destroy Moammar Gaddafi's Libyan military leading up to his death last week. Libya's interim transitional government wants NATO to stay and protect the country as it rebuilds as an Islamist nation with Sharia Law.

NATO's 26,000 sorties, including 9,600 strike missions, destroyed about 5,900 military targets since they started on March 31. These included Libya's air defenses and more than 1,000 tanks, vehicles and guns, as well as Moammar Gadhafi's command and control networks.

U.S. Defense Secretary Leon Panetta said Tuesday that some of Libya's leaders had called for NATO to continue its mission "during this interim as they try to establish some new governance."
-- Star News Online

The United States helped decapitate Gaddafi's forces and created the vacuum that the Islamic extremists in the region want to fill with revolution similar to that of Iran's Islamic Revolution in 1979. Iran now leads the world in state-sponsored terrorism and will soon get nuclear weapons that it promises to use. We've created the mess in Libya, and we should help clean it up -- but not by supporting an Islamic Sharia government.
Libya's new leaders said they intend to make Islamic Sharia law the main source of legislation and will nullify any laws that contradict its tenets, giving the country a more Islamist character in the post-Moammar Gadhafi era.
Islamic law, or Sharia, is enshrined as the basis of the constitution in a number of Middle Eastern countries with Muslim majorities. Most Gulf nations' constitutions state that Sharia is a main source of legislation, while Egypt says it is "the source."
-- AP

America got itself caught in the middle -- between supporting civil rights and instituting a theocracy that will abuse civil rights.
[Leon Panetta] said the immediate U.S. concerns in Libya are focused on the possibility of providing medical assistance to Libya's wounded and preventing weapons from falling into the wrong hands. Of particular concern are anti-aircraft weapons.
Questions also persist about the nature of the new Libya and the degree of Islamist influence in a government now led by National Transitional Council leader Mustafa Abdul-Jalil, who said Sunday that Islamic Sharia law would be the main source of legislation, that laws contradicting its tenets would be nullified, and that polygamy would be legalized.
-- Military.com

Panetta refers to the anti-aircraft missiles that have "gone missing" and probably have ended up in the hands of Al Qaeda, who can now use the weapons against passenger airliners and NATO fighters according to this ABC News report:

President Obama supported the regime change -- and now we must follow through with it. We cannot employ the 'strategy' of "Hope and Change" for foreign policy. We need real world solutions, which means hard, mature, tough decisions like influencing another country's future. We cannot abandon the process of an "Arab Spring" and Hope it turns into a democracy. We know Libya won't turn into a democracy on its own -- they've told us so. The interim government said it will institute Sharia law, which means more human rights abuses. Didn't we support the regime change because of human rights abuses? Do we just want to let one regime replace another and continue the atrocities? Worse -- America may support the institution of Sharia law in Libya.
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • MattThomson 2011/11/20 04:09:12
    Intervene to Stop Transition to Sharia Law
    MattThomson
    Forgive my bluntness but the transitional government lied they promised a democracy now they're instituting the most perverse form of legislation there is SHARIA "GOD'S LAW". They need to have their population decimated. One can only hope it could be done humanely.
  • l8rthen 2011/11/01 10:24:26
    Intervene to Stop Transition to Sharia Law
    l8rthen
    +1
    Wish that there had been a Choice of 'Other".
    Unless the Libyan people are willing to stand against those who propose the installation of sharia as 'good', we cannot stop this. Can we just leave? IMO, no because we helped break down the country's support systems, therefore we have some responsibility to restore. Bad situation because of bad policy.
  • Chukroast 2011/10/31 07:30:44
    Intervene to Stop Transition to Sharia Law
    Chukroast
    Bomb the Muslim Brotherhood.
  • Liza Jane 2011/10/29 23:19:45
    Support Libya's Transition to Sharia Law
    Liza Jane
    I don't get how it's O.K. for America to support Saudi Arabia's Sharia law but not the Sharia law in any other country. Let's pull our heads from our collective asses and realize that it's not any of our business how they run their government.

    America shouldn't get to decide how they rebuild their country just because we helped them destroy it.
  • Child of light 2011/10/29 22:20:24
    Abandon Libya
    Child of light
    Helping a country rebuilt itself as an islamist nation with sharia law goes against our laws of freedom and rights. Maybe if they wanted a Constitution Republic, I'd be more willing to support them
  • Glen 2011/10/29 18:52:48
    Abandon Libya
    Glen
    T5 is the any path that the Baathisrs do nor conrerol
  • S. Gompers 2011/10/29 14:20:48
    Abandon Libya
    S. Gompers
    We should, but we won't. Politicians and oil men will keep their eye on the carrot.
  • Andrew 2011/10/29 06:09:47
    Abandon Libya
    Andrew
    Abandon ship!
  • Rick from Overland Park 2011/10/29 03:59:41
    Abandon Libya
    Rick from Overland Park
    +1
    No Brainer!
  • Quazimoto 2011/10/28 23:18:41
    Abandon Libya
    Quazimoto
    Another wrong move by the Obama administration, same for Egypt. Obama will be eligible to run Libya after he gets the boot in 2012.
  • CMackley ~POTL~PWCM~JLA 2011/10/28 22:54:43
    Abandon Libya
    CMackley ~POTL~PWCM~JLA
    +1
    We never should have been there in the first place.
  • Crazy Bill 2011/10/28 21:22:50
    Abandon Libya
    Crazy Bill
    We need to eliminate a religion.
    Nothing less will ensure long term peace.
  • Fef Crazy Bill 2011/10/28 22:29:21
    Fef
    +3
    Mass murderers like the Soviets and Red Chinese said the same thing.
    communism murder
  • Crazy Bill Fef 2011/10/29 01:34:39
    Crazy Bill
    Me too, me too.
    NEVER GONNA HAPPEN!
    I am going by one simple rule. The needs of a few do not outweigh the good of many.
  • Pieter Joubert 2011/10/28 14:17:19
  • CMackle... Pieter ... 2011/10/28 22:53:50
    CMackley ~POTL~PWCM~JLA
    +1
    It is in Egypt. They have declared Israel an enemy and are killing Christians.
  • Rick fr... CMackle... 2011/10/29 04:02:05
    Rick from Overland Park
    +1
    The GOP has nothing to do with this. Most comes from CNN. You need to get out more.
  • CMackle... Rick fr... 2011/10/29 04:49:09
    CMackley ~POTL~PWCM~JLA
    +1
    I believe you may have replied in the wrong comment box and meant to reply to Pieter. I'm on your side, Sir.
  • Pieter ... Rick fr... 2011/10/29 06:50:34
    Pieter Joubert
    How is life in the trailerpark watching Fox???
  • Pieter ... CMackle... 2011/10/29 06:49:23
    Pieter Joubert
    Stop looking at headlines in News, they take one incident and pretend it is widespread..
  • CMackle... Pieter ... 2011/10/30 02:31:02
    CMackley ~POTL~PWCM~JLA
    +1
    Thousands of Christians fleeing Egypt isn't 'one' incident. And you are a complete ass to insult a veteran and senior citizen (Rick). You must be very proud of yourself.
  • Pieter ... CMackle... 2011/10/30 05:20:50
    Pieter Joubert
    Being a war vet does not give you a free pass to be stupid and neither does being a senior citizen, I am also a "veteran" that spent 5 years in a war.and I'll be 50 next year.

    Your info about "thousands" of christians fleeing is bull.
  • CMackle... Pieter ... 2011/10/31 20:03:33
    CMackley ~POTL~PWCM~JLA
    +1
    The number of Christians to have fled Egypt since March is approaching 100,000, and could reach 250,000 by the end of 2011, a Coptic NGO has reported. An estimated 93,000 have left already, the head of the Egyptian Federation of Human Rights told the daily Al-Masry Al-Youm.

    Numbers were based on information gathered from churches within Egypt and from Coptic communities abroad.

    The most popular destination for fleeing Christians was the United States, which took in an estimated 42,000 of the Egyptian Copts. Other destinations included Canada, Australia and western Europe.

    Federation of Human Rights head Naguib Gabriel said Christians were leaving over threats from Salafi groups seeking to implement Sharia (Islamic law) as national law, and over the government’s failure to bring attackers to justice in attacks on churches.

    Some voiced skepticism regarding the report, saying it was unlikely that Christians could have migrated so quickly, due to the bureaucracy involved in immigration. However, they told Al-Masry Al-Youm that they agree anti-Christian persecution is a serious issue.

    Harassment of Copts in Egypt has included attacks on churches, the kidnap of teenage Christian girls and their forced conversion to Islam, and the massacre of Christian families in the north of the country. Minority Christian groups are under threat elsewhere in the Muslim world
  • Pieter ... CMackle... 2011/10/31 20:29:17
    Pieter Joubert
    Would love to see which "impartial" source came up with this info. Do not believe everything you read. If 100,000 people were displaced the UN would have been all over this, so I am telling you it is crap
  • CMackle... Pieter ... 2011/10/31 20:31:38
    CMackley ~POTL~PWCM~JLA
    +1
    This has been reported by many news outlets of varying background. If you don't want to believe it then fine, but this discussion is over. Have a good one.
  • Pieter ... CMackle... 2011/10/31 20:48:35
    Pieter Joubert
    I have checked, all the news networks, unless there is a huge coverup by all the news networks your info is purely based on christian blog reports.

    A suicide bomber blew up a church and 3 weeks later the coptics went on the rampage because they believed the government was not protecting them. 23 were killed in clashes with the police and military.
    Thats all it was, 7 million coptics live in Egypt.
  • Pat 2011/10/28 08:31:24
    Abandon Libya
    Pat
    +2
    If the people, the rebels, who did most of the fighting and who killed Gahdafi, cannot stop this from happening, we should abandon them and the U.N. and NATO should take a strong stand against imposing Sharia law. If this is what they do, it's up to their own people to overthrow those now taking power. We must stay out of it and begin a policy of containment so that it doesn't effect our interests and spread even further in the region.
  • Maj. C. D. Hardy 2011/10/28 07:37:34
  • Myrle Hulme 2011/10/28 06:05:25
    Abandon Libya
    Myrle Hulme
    +3
    Leave them to solve their own problems
  • Bureauc 0webama 2011/10/28 00:20:38 (edited)
    Intervene to Stop Transition to Sharia Law
    Bureauc 0webama
    +3
    Carpet bomb and leave
    I told you it would turn out this way.
  • DixieGirl 2011/10/27 23:44:15
    Abandon Libya
    DixieGirl
    +5
    Libya needs to do this on their own. US needs to pull out of NATO and screw the UN.
  • miller51550 2011/10/27 23:31:08
    Abandon Libya
    miller51550
    +2
    If OBAMA or NATO LEADERS decide to HELP establish them and country with Sharia LAW.

    The leaders should be removed from office and tried in an International Court of Law for Treason against the World.

    Let the scum cut fish, or die believing in Sharia Law.

    Obama and NATO said this was about Civil Rights of the individuals...and they LIED.. this is and was about oil and the Muslim Brotherhood taking over Libya and introducing Sharia Law to a people that could be controlled and killed as needed.

    Congress should be looking at IMPEACHING Obama for declaring/creating a war to Reward his Muslim Brotherhood 'BROTHERS'.
  • Doug King 2011/10/27 22:52:42
    Abandon Libya
    Doug King
    +4
    NATO should go home, remember no good deed goes unpunished! If NATO stays they will end up getting blamed for anything that goes wrong.
  • hari 2011/10/27 22:27:55
    Intervene to Stop Transition to Sharia Law
    hari
    +2
    establish peace and harmony what for their purpose is
  • Tuna 2011/10/27 20:58:38
    Abandon Libya
    Tuna
    +5
    OTHER was not a choice; what should the U.N. do? pack up and leave the USA.

    UN building at night

    How's that carbon footprint, U.N.???
  • john brenni 2011/10/27 20:29:33
    Abandon Libya
    john brenni
    +2
    we would not defend in the U,S, or europe so why defend it elsewhere ?
  • Elizabeth_MC 2011/10/27 19:55:47
    Abandon Libya
    Elizabeth_MC
    +4
    Our men and women are done here. Sharia law is inhumane. These people are insane. They want what they want from us and would just as easily turn around and kill us after we helped them
  • Caroline - fan of Audubon 2011/10/27 19:45:27
    Support Libya's Transition to Sharia Law
    Caroline - fan of Audubon
    +2
    They have the right to Sharia Law. Not to be confused with Taliban type Sharia that did not recognize human rights.

    Speaking on CBC's Power & Politics with Evan Solomon, Ali Aujali, Libyan ambassador to the U.S., said there's no need to worry that Libyan-based Shariah law will be anything like Sharia law practised by the Taliban in Afghanistan.

    "Libya, first of all, is not Afghanistan," Aujali said. "Secondly, the interpretation of the scholars in Afghanistan is completely different from the interpretation of the scholars in Libya. Libya is a very modern society. It is a conservative society, it's true, but it is a society which is based on logic and human issues. I'm not worried about this at all."

    http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/...
  • Elizabe... Carolin... 2011/10/27 19:59:12
    Elizabeth_MC
    +2
    They have the right to their laws, but not at the expense of the lives of our men and women.
    These people will never change. They haven't for a thousand years.In fact, they have regressed over the past thousand years from a culture that used to contribute to civilization in the fields of science.
  • Carolin... Elizabe... 2011/10/27 20:16:11
    Caroline - fan of Audubon
    +1
    Thank you for your skewed opinion.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/21 14:44:21

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals