Quantcast

Justice prevails in Wisconsin:Judge strikes down Wisconsin law restricting union rights

Jeff King 2012/09/15 00:29:44
Yes I'm Pro-Union
No I'm Non-Union
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Judge strikes down Wisconsin law restricting union rights

The law championed by Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker prohibited state and local governments from bargaining over anything except cost of living adjustments to salaries.

http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/09/14/13868190-judge-str...

A Wisconsin judge on Friday struck down the state law championed by Gov. Scott Walker that effectively ended collective bargaining rights for most public workers.

Dane County Circuit Judge Juan Colas ruled Friday that the law violates the state and U.S. constitutions and is null and void.

The law took away nearly all collective bargaining rights from most workers and has been in effect for more than a year. Colas' ruling comes after a lawsuit brought by the Madison teachers union and a union for Milwaukee city employees.

For city, county and school workers, the ruling returns the law to its previous status, before it was changed in March 2011, the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel reported. However, Walker's law remains largely in force for state workers, it reported. Walker's law prohibited state and local governments from bargaining over anything except cost of living adjustments to salaries. Haggling over issues such as health benefits, pensions and workplace safety was barred.

Gov. Walker said in a statement Friday that he expected the ruling will be overturned on appeal.

"The people of Wisconsin clearly spoke on June 5th," he said in the statement posted on his Facebook page. "Now, they are ready to move on. Sadly a liberal activist judge in Dane County wants to go backwards and take away the lawmaking responsibilities of the legislature and the governor. We are confident that the state will ultimately prevail in the appeals process."

"We believe the law is constitutional," said Wisconsin Department of Justice spokeswoman Dana Brueck.

Lester Pines, an attorney for Madison Teachers Inc., did not immediately return a message seeking comment.

The proposal was introduced shortly after Walker took office in February last year. It sparked a firestorm of opposition and huge protests at the state Capitol that lasted for weeks. All 14 Democratic state senators fled to Illinois for three weeks in an ultimately failed attempt to stop the law's passage by the Republican-controlled Legislature.

Anger over the law's passage led to an effort to recall Walker from office. More than 930,000 signatures were collected, triggering the June recall election. Walker won and became the first governor in U.S. history to survive a recall.Justice prevails in Wisconsin Judge strikes down Wisconsin law restricting union rights


Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Scalded Eagle 2012/09/15 05:02:58 (edited)
    No I'm Non-Union
    Scalded Eagle
    +1
    These commie judges need to leave America!
  • jgh57 2012/09/15 04:05:16
    No I'm Non-Union
    jgh57
    +1
    Hopefully Wisconsin will appeal and a more intelligent judge will find the right answer.
  • Scalded... jgh57 2012/09/15 05:03:53
  • william raggett 2012/09/15 03:55:20
    Yes I'm Pro-Union
    william raggett
    +1
    I'm not union but they are America's only defense from these blood sucking,keep everyone in poverty but us corporations
  • Scalded... william... 2012/09/15 05:07:11
    Scalded Eagle
    Why does a great portion of their dues go to the commie DNC?
  • ruru 2012/09/15 03:11:32
    No I'm Non-Union
    ruru
    +2
    Unions were a good thing when they first started out, but now their demands have run manufactures overseas. Unions do not belong in the public employees sector. Their demand put too much of a burden on the average tax payer.
  • Scalded... ruru 2012/09/15 05:04:38
    Scalded Eagle
    +1
    Indeed!
  • FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX 2012/09/15 00:41:06
    Yes I'm Pro-Union
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +3
    Democrats were right. Republicans were wrong. Checks and Balances proves you can't buy legislation no matter how much you play with your Koch.
  • The Gov... FAWKES'... 2012/09/15 03:48:49
    The Govenor
    +1
    Didn't the people of Wisconsin vote for this? Are my blind or aren't the "people/taxpayers" tired of getting raped by state/county/municipal employees.
  • FAWKES'... The Gov... 2012/09/15 04:04:40 (edited)
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    Did you SLEEP through 2011? No the people didn't vote for it. It was passed by Walker's Republican State Congress. I guess you forgot about the protests also.
  • The Gov... FAWKES'... 2012/09/15 04:15:25
    The Govenor
    +1
    Well, peyote was cheap last year, maybe, IDK. Anyway, didn't "the people" vote for their representation to vote to protect their interest? Hey, I'm stuck with the muslim in the WH for another 4 months or until they impeach him, stop your bitchin'. As far as the hoodlum gubbment bleeders (teachers in particular), you call them protesters? I call them slime.
  • FAWKES'... The Gov... 2012/09/15 04:20:30
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    The slime won. They were right. Walker and his caucus tried to impose an unconstitutional law and they just got slapped for it. Null and Void. They learned you can't impose a Fascist agenda in a Democracy.
  • The Gov... FAWKES'... 2012/09/15 04:22:25
    The Govenor
    +1
    I think ya got your facts mixed up.
  • FAWKES'... The Gov... 2012/09/15 04:48:41
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    If my facts are mixed up, please tell us your version of what just happened in Wisconsin.
  • The Gov... FAWKES'... 2012/09/15 13:06:48
    The Govenor
    Well, let's back up to the representation the people elected who instituted legislation to protect their states finances and then move along to the ones that neglected to do their elected duty and ran out of state.

    From there we move to a mob of angry people who could not accept reality and acted like a bunch of children.

    After that they go hunt down some tainted liberal judge to change the outcome of the people which will be overturned in short order.

    Does that sum it up for ya?
  • FAWKES'... The Gov... 2012/09/15 14:06:25 (edited)
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +1
    No its not even close.

    1) Union bill presented.
    2) Protests ensue
    3) Union bill passed by Congress
    4) Court strikes down Union bill as unconstitutional.

    The protesters were right in the first place. Everything else that happened - recall, senators in hiding, etc - is all just sideshow.
  • The Gov... FAWKES'... 2012/09/15 18:24:33
    The Govenor
    So back to the municipal unions bleeding the taxpayers.........
  • FAWKES'... The Gov... 2012/09/15 19:19:03
  • The Gov... FAWKES'... 2012/09/15 19:51:12
    The Govenor
    DDT used to be wonder solution as well. Your point?
  • FAWKES'... The Gov... 2012/09/15 20:33:11 (edited)
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    +1
    Are you attempting to compare an insecticide to the Process of Democracy?
  • The Gov... FAWKES'... 2012/09/15 23:12:33
    The Govenor
    Well, now that you bring it up, the pesticide DDT does draw a parallel to gubbment workers choking us for money.
  • Jeff King The Gov... 2012/09/15 21:19:10 (edited)
  • The Gov... Jeff King 2012/09/15 23:13:19
    The Govenor
    What happens?
  • Scalded... The Gov... 2012/09/15 05:00:09
    Scalded Eagle
    +1
    He has no facts.
  • FAWKES'... Scalded... 2012/09/15 14:10:34
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    1) Union bill presented.
    2) Protests ensue
    3) Union bill passed by Congress
    4) Court strikes down Union bill as unconstitutional.

    Fact: Protesters were right. Recall for re-legislation was not necessary. The bill was illegal in the first place. Null and Void. Protesters win.
  • The Gov... FAWKES'... 2012/09/15 04:24:09
    The Govenor
    +1
    BTW- did those run away politicians ever come back to vote and represent their constituents like they were elected/paid to do?
  • FAWKES'... The Gov... 2012/09/15 04:48:05
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    Wow I guess you were asleep huh.
  • The Gov... FAWKES'... 2012/09/15 13:07:26
    The Govenor
    That's your answer? Lame.
  • Al B Thayer 2012/09/15 00:37:38
    No I'm Non-Union
    Al B Thayer
    +2
    Prolly won't stick.
  • cutter's falls 2012/09/15 00:32:46
    No I'm Non-Union
    cutter's falls
    +5
    can't win at the ballot box, so sue to get your way
    ohh such justice eh.
  • FAWKES'... cutter'... 2012/09/15 04:10:15
    FAWKES' NOOSE ~ ΔTX
    The injustice served was Walker and his Republican Congress passing an unconstitutional law. They were stopped by the Wisconsin courts. That is called "Checks and Balances" and is one of the principles on which this country was founded.

    Don't like it? Move.
  • Jeff King 2012/09/15 00:31:59
  • Al B Th... Jeff King 2012/09/15 00:39:04
    Al B Thayer
    +5
    That's the dumbest thing I've seen in a long time.
  • Jeff King Al B Th... 2012/09/15 00:45:42
  • Scalded... Jeff King 2012/09/15 05:11:18
    Scalded Eagle
    +1
    How would you know? Ever heard of commie indoctriation books.
  • Al B Th... Jeff King 2012/09/16 12:22:53
    Al B Thayer
    Unions have been corrupt for years. I don't need to read a book about it. If unions would have stuck to helping the workers they might have lasted. But as it stands they will prolly go by the way side. I find it degrading to a person when they stand behind their union in order to work less and get paid more. I run a business and see a great devide between union and nonunion workers.
  • Jeff King Al B Th... 2012/09/16 15:30:04 (edited)
  • Al B Th... Jeff King 2012/09/16 18:38:43
    Al B Thayer
    Is a 40 hr work week a good thing? I mean you guys don't actually work 40 hrs. You collect pay for 40. But it's the most unproductive 40 hrs of the week.
  • Al B Th... Jeff King 2012/09/16 12:25:49
    Al B Thayer
    BTW How does it feel to not have a choice when you vote for the President? That alone must suck big time. That's about as far from the American way as you can get.
  • Scalded... Al B Th... 2012/09/15 05:09:35
    Scalded Eagle
    Yeppers!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/22 21:03:34

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals