Quantcast

Is 'Slut Walk' an Effective Message?

SodaHead News 2011/04/25 18:27:34
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Back in the day, the events used to be called "Take Back the Night." But some women in Dallas, inspired by their sistren in Toronto, held the city's first "Slut Walk" on Saturday to bring attention to the prevailing issue of sexual violence against women.

A "slut walk?" Yeah.

You see, a police chief in Toronto recently told a group of female students that in order to avoid be raped, "women should stop dressing like sluts." Okay, thanks dad.

That message didn't go over well with some of the women of Toronto, who decided to fight back with their slutty protest. That movement spread to Dallas, where some lingerie-wearing ladies and their male supporters took to the streets toting signs that read "clothes does not make the victim," "end victim blaming" and "How I dress is not an invitation," with chanting "hey, hey, ho, ho, we understand that no means no."

"I want to end victim blaming," said participant Britt Shulte. "This is still a really prevailing concept and idea in our society that our apparel dictates the kind of treatment we receive and it dictates the respect that we receive."

The goal of the event was to end victim blaming, and reclaim the power of the word "slut" in much the same way that the phrase "queer" was reclaimed by gays and lesbians of an earlier generation.

"You know, it doesn't matter how old you are or what you're wearing or where you're at or how much you had to drink," said walker Stephanie McMurry. "It doesn't matter what happens, it's never the victims fault. Ever."

Is a "slut walk" a good idea?


Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Gregory Lopez 2011/04/25 19:51:38 (edited)
    No
    Gregory Lopez
    +81
    If I go to the Bronx dressed as a member of the KKK, and some black people beat the crap out of me, who is to blame? Well, technically they are, but I'm also an idiot.



    If you go out to venues where people are trolling for sex, and you dress like you're looking for sex, and some person with with no self-control rapes you, he is to blame. But you're also an idiot.

    We can assign blame where it belongs while still telling people to not act like idiots and take proper precautions in sketchy situations.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • thomas Finch 2011/04/27 14:12:43
    No
    thomas Finch
    The message is good, but the name will make people think otherwise.
  • Unique 2011/04/27 14:02:05
    Yes
    Unique
    +2
    Remove the power from the word and it means nothing! much like the
    'n' word an a few other select words in which the power has been or is being removed.
  • elaine 2011/04/27 14:00:49
    Yes
    elaine
    +3
    Two-edged sword! Because, many people will not "get it!" You have to remember your audience when you go out on a limb like this, using the word slut! MOREOVER--someone please tell the "Chief" than rape is about power, not sex. He needs to know!
  • WOODMAN34 2011/04/27 13:37:25
    Yes
    WOODMAN34
    +6
    Yes, dress as you want to. It is still a free country isn't? Just be sure that when you put on that little black dress with the 6' heels that you also put on your .40 cal S&W; or that .45 cal ACP. THEN if you should have a problem, Then instead of pulling your cell phone to call a cop, Just pull that little Colt and shoot that *&%#* and go on down the road. A cop can respond in 5 to 20 minuets but a .40 cal responds in less than a blink of an eye. Its also faster than the courts.
  • Nezkeys79 WOODMAN34 2012/06/02 22:04:06
    Nezkeys79
    That's your advice? commit murder if someone attempts rape or actually succeeds. Good job you're not in a position of authority
  • WOODMAN34 Nezkeys79 2012/06/09 04:12:32
    WOODMAN34
    Its not murder it is called self defiance. How would you like to be raped? Or are you one of those people that like things like that?
  • Babalejo 2011/04/27 12:42:52
    Yes
    Babalejo
    +2
    A woman, just like a man, has the right to dress as she wishes. If the fashion she chooses disturbs a male...well then let the male get used to it and not get all hard up (if you'll excuse me). Most men would be surprised how seldom women go out of their way (or out of their clothing) to catch the attention of a male..(Oh, a male is what I am, and all of me loves women). Why don't we have a male equivalent for "slut", and so many other +fem derogatory words I can think of...let's face it a "bitch" is much worse than a man born out of marriage. We should love them, and understand how much they have to teach us...regardless of the dress
  • borikenlibre 2011/04/27 12:30:37
    No
    borikenlibre
    +2
    A better question might be, "why do European countries have far fewer rape problems even though their women dress even more scantily than Amerikan women?"

    "Is it because of Amerika's ridiculously religious puritanism?"

    "Is it because Amerikan's are just plain stupid?"
  • TimJung boriken... 2011/04/28 05:18:44
    TimJung
    You sure about that? The numbers I have seen show the exact same levels of violent sexual crime recapita in north America, Europe and Asia. They are all pretty darn close to the same. If you want to make such a claim give the citation to support your claim. Otherwise it's a wild ass guess based on emotions of what you want to be true or wish was true. The number of mentally disturbed is about the same level all over the world psychologists say, the difference is how public or secretive some countries are about it. The US tends to be very open and public about these thing. Asian culture is very different about these issues and Europe tends to be similar also that they don't like to talk about it generally. Asia culture says you never mention it or talk about it.
  • gilbert 2011/04/27 12:27:27
    Yes
    gilbert
    +3
    Every one is free to dress the way they feel them selfs the best. If we are going to justify crimes with stupit excuses then we can kick the law completly away because then we can say to..... well that guys had was terrible, so i bluw his had clean off. Where is the end then?
    Dress the way you like and let the world be colorfull as it is ment to be!!!
  • PICK 2011/04/27 12:23:41
    No
    PICK
    They should "take back the name." Calling yourself a slut gives too much credibility to the stupid police chief and the predators they are protesting against.
  • Alfred 2011/04/27 11:48:17
    No
    Alfred
    +1
    There are some things government just cannot do. If society in general is immoral, no amount of legislation will make them moral; if society in general is moral, no amount of legislation can take it away. Government is responsible for basic civic services, people on the other hand are responsible for how they behave toward their fellow man. However history shows no civilization has outlasted greed, lawlessness, and decadence.
  • crossboy56 2011/04/27 11:21:42
    Yes
    crossboy56
    +4
    A women should be able to walk down the street naked as a jay-bird and not be raped.
  • crossboy56 crossboy56 2011/04/27 11:25:35
    crossboy56
    +3
    "NO"! means "NO"! even if you are married or single.It do not matter if you have cloth on or half naked or naked.
  • FUS RO ... crossboy56 2011/04/27 14:56:23
    FUS RO DAH!
    +1
    I wish women could walk down the street naked as a jay-bird be something to look at
  • MichaelJ crossboy56 2011/04/27 15:55:30
    MichaelJ
    crossboy, I am completely in favor of your plan to have the babes start walking around naked. I can't wait for the marathons!
  • Nezkeys79 MichaelJ 2012/06/02 22:21:51
    Nezkeys79
    +1
    I bet all the girls voting yes are like "why is our message having the opposite effect" after reading this post
  • Nezkeys79 crossboy56 2012/06/02 22:16:05
    Nezkeys79
    Stating the obvious. Unfortunately there are sick people out there so women cannot really do this
  • Lestat de Vladimir 2011/04/27 11:05:42
  • Sookie 2011/04/27 10:24:28 (edited)
    Yes
    Sookie
    +10
    Oh good god. Get a grip and a life.

    The ignorance and sheer stupidity on this poll is sad, disgusting and disturbing. Yet again, Sodahead News and the many brilliant minds on this site have missed the point entirely.

    I support slut walk. I support the sluts in my city and sluts all over the world who send a message (loud and clear) that what I do (or do not) wear does not give anyone permission to rape, harass or touch me and that the violence committed against victims of these sorts of crimes are rarely (if ever) about the victim or his/her actions.

    Blaming a woman for being raped based upon what she pulled out of her closet that morning is like blaming a murder victim for not being dead enough.
  • RedCharli Sookie 2011/04/27 11:03:14
    RedCharli
    +4
    I'm with you there
  • WOODMAN34 RedCharli 2011/04/27 13:41:16
    WOODMAN34
    +1
    Go Sookie, I'm with you too!
  • Nezkeys79 Sookie 2012/06/02 22:26:48
    Nezkeys79
    I take it you are young and don't have children of you're own or else you wouldn't be saying things like this. If you do have a daughter how would you feel if she was dressing like a slut to high school, and a slut outside of high school
  • Sookie Nezkeys79 2012/06/02 23:39:51 (edited)
    Sookie
    Actually, Neil, I'm as old time itself but that's neither here nor there. What you have done however, is to illustrate my point, which is to say, that you are missing the point. Entirely.
  • Dixie Boy 2011/04/27 10:04:53
    No
    Dixie Boy
    +1
    Now days, some women ask for it - without talking. I was born in Atlanta and now live two counties away. I drive to Atlanta about four to five times a month for meetings and when I leave to go home around 10 to 10:30 PM it's nothing to see at least a couple of young girls, in different locations, out jogging. They usually have on skimpy little shorts and their tits are flopping around inside their t-shirts. I'm sure that this practice goes on in many large cities around the country. I just wish these young ladies would do their jogging at an earlier time of day.
  • boriken... Dixie Boy 2011/04/27 12:27:05
    borikenlibre
    You sure wouldn't like living in Europe.
  • Cleaver62 Dixie Boy 2011/04/27 14:38:06
    Cleaver62
    +3
    So just because a woman is health conscious and jogs in shorts, she is asking to be raped? Sir I think you are part of the problem not the women.
  • PlatonicBagTwo 2011/04/27 09:58:36
    No
    PlatonicBagTwo
    No, I think it will attract the wrong sort of attention. I think they should just call it "Women Against Violence" to make it clear just what they want.
  • AvengedSevenfold 2011/04/27 09:23:37
    No
    AvengedSevenfold
    I think it's not the way they dress, and I don't really think anyone is gonna rape them soon since they're so damn ugly.
  • wuonbi 2011/04/27 08:51:15 (edited)
    No
    wuonbi
    +2
    Not unless your message is that you are a low life immoral person.

    But what I get from this is America has fallen so low -- that sluts are now proud to be sluts, and that many of us think that is OK !
  • Medicated 2011/04/27 08:42:13 (edited)
    Yes
    Medicated
    Let the sluts alone. Its obvious they cant and wont understand how bass ackwards they are.
  • snail 2011/04/27 08:13:29
    Yes
    snail
    +2
    I would have participated.
  • Medicated snail 2011/04/27 09:21:15
    Medicated
    So you would wear slutty clothes to keep women safe? Are you insane?
  • snail Medicated 2011/04/27 23:25:13
    snail
    +1
    I am not insane. I would dress in a manner that would be unusual for me in order to make a statement against victim blaming attitudes, in order to show that I believe women should be safe from sexual violence regardless of how they choose to dress. I would do it to show my support for other rape victims, many of whom have been falsely accused of being partly to blame for what happened to them.

    I would have to make something new to wear to it, because all of my dresses cover my ankles. It would still be worth it, because as someone who has experienced rape, I take such matters very seriously.

    One of the reasons I never went to the police was the fear of having something so traumatic taken lightly, or of being asked accusatory questions about my lifestyle as though a person could possibly deserve something so horrible simply by not conforming to other people's expectations of what a "good girl" should be like.

    My lifestyle was modest and cautious, and the violence was committed by someone I knew and trusted, but that should never be the point. Even if I had been wearing something more revealing, I would not have deserved what happened to me. Nobody ever deserves to be raped. I fully support the slut walk and everything it stands for.
  • Medicated snail 2011/04/28 01:54:21
    Medicated
    I have served on jury duty in an abuse case of a 12 year old girl. You should have went to the police. Not reporting him will make him confident enough to do it again sometime. You have let other women down by not reporting it. Being involved in this rediculous organization makes me think your trying to make up for your lack of action on your own behalf. You can still report him to authorities so he will appear on a list of suspected rapists for future reference if he attacks someone else. Stop HIM and you save your own self respect in that matter.
  • salemslot9 2011/04/27 08:00:39
    No
    salemslot9
    too negative
  • neon messiah 2011/04/27 07:13:33
    No
    neon messiah
    +3
    I'm all for women marching against rape but "slut walk"? That really sends the wrong message out and can be interpretted in a negative way.

    I not sure the maxim "all publicity is good publicity" really works here.
  • SavageS0ul 2011/04/27 07:11:28
    No
    SavageS0ul
    I'm sorry but, what other reason is there to dress like a sleaze than to get perverts to drool all over U & get horrible nasty ideas about U? For example, a girl wearing an extremely low cut top is basically saying, "Hey! Over here! Undress me with your eyes & keep this image for tonight!" It gives many men ideas. Though, no woman, no matter HOW sleazy she dresses deserves to get raped. That's just completely horrid.
  • Medicated SavageS0ul 2011/04/27 09:29:12
    Medicated
    +1
    My observations lead me to believe 50% of all women want you to stare at them over most or all other women around. Beauty is a power trip to them.
  • DICK 2011/04/27 07:05:44 (edited)
    Yes
    DICK
    It is human biolidgy,it's like hunting or fishing, what bait to use or tactic's to ues.Do you want truth or a passive answer to passify you with a generic answer.Commen sence is,you already know and just looking for some one to justiffy your beleave's.Why do you dress a certain way, to atract attention,it;'s just true,and we can arque till the cow's come home.'nothing sexist in that' But it's human and animal in nature,but all truth's have one thing in common,they are all true.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/22 23:47:20

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals