Quantcast

Is legalizing marijuana really the best option?

Natasha 2012/02/25 19:56:19
You!
Add Photos & Videos
First of all, I don't believe that marijuana is the harmful or dangerous substance society makes it out to be and don't understand the enormous stigmas associated with it. Quoting Pineapple Express, "weed makes everything better."
Its illegal status is an archaic remnant of times when paper companies didn't want to be driven out of business with hemp production. Society is already undergoing a paradigm shift with an acceptance and, at times, (media) glorification of its use. I'm partially for legalization, saying the the government should tax and regulate its use and distribution and set guidelines, but also take into account the consequences of legalization. I'd also advocate decriminalization which would make possession and use of weed in reasonable quantities, usually around 3g, legal. (Not that the government would ever go for an option where people get to smoke weed legally without the gov profiting) For those who use marijuana, legalization is a terrible option. Yes the government won't be able to prosecute us for lighting a joint anymore, but are all of the taxes and regulations worth it? With the FDA guidelines that would be placed in marijuana growers, bud quality would go down and almost everything you buy will be generic. You can say goodbye to that killer kush you can get from your local dealer at a relatively decent price. The government will tax the shit out of marijuana, putting a luxury tax on top of whatever state tax you have to pay already, driving prices up, leading to a proliferation of bad weed because that's the only thing people will be able to afford. So next time you or one of your stoner friends advocates legalization, remind them that it would only lead to bad quality weed and ridiculous prices for the good stuff. It's so much easier to just get it from your local dealer. But disregarding the effect that it will have on people who do smoke weed, legalization would provide economic stimulus (through taxation) and help curve problems associated with the illegal drug trade (prohibition of alcohol in the 20s led to speakeasies and moonshiners but when it was abolished illegal trade of alcohol ceased). It may also curb use of other drugs. In Holland, the (partial) legalization of marijuana has lead to an overall decrease in hard drug use. Benefits of legalization overall outweigh the costs. Society is waking up already and so should the government.
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Mamaknows 2012/02/25 21:53:08
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Mamaknows
    +10
    As far as I am concerned we should legalise it, regulate growing, preperation for sale, and taxe the crap out of it.
    For myself I have seen what illegal grows can do land and streams and have been shot at while hiking by illegal mexicans(mexican cartel) that grow illegally on public lands.
    Yes that cheap dime bag of skunk you bought was grown on land that became TOXIC because of the chemicals they laid down to grow it....and the garbage they left behind.
    I can see a whole host of problems that would come from it but I think regulating/taxing it is the best option.
    All that being said I do not smoke it. I was raised around pot heads and have seen what a few years(let alone MANY years) does to people.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Attila the Hun 2012/02/26 16:57:59
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Attila the Hun
    +1
    I think marijuana should be decriminalized *and* taxed. Just look at how well our current policy has worked.
  • Max 2012/02/26 16:50:50
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Max
    +3
    The prison industrial complex and bigpharma must have some powerful lobbying teams standing in the way of legalization; otherwise, the government would love to get their hands on that tax money, along with alcohol, cigarettes, prostitution and gambling etc.
  • Jane 2012/02/26 15:49:20
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Jane
    Good to see the majority vote like me.
  • John Storz 2012/02/26 15:43:07
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    John Storz
    +3
    We should just legalize ALL illegal drugs. We'd have the 1-2 year mass culling of all the abusers as they OD, then we could tax the hell out of the quality stuff. Prohibition NEVER works.
  • britbiker 2012/02/26 15:33:37 (edited)
  • myhouseinthewoods 2012/02/26 15:25:58
    No, marijuana use and possession should just remain illegal.
    myhouseinthewoods
    for the dealers, for the dealers
  • jacob crim 2012/02/26 15:23:17
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    jacob crim
    +2
    Anyone who has actually smoked it knows it is not dangerous. I used to be part of the sheeple who bought into the marijuana propaganda. The danger is the user having an addictive personality or no will power. I only smoke a few times a year due to my job, always the possibility of random testing.
  • Master 2012/02/26 15:12:59
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Master
    Im sorry to the the moron's out there that thank marijuana plant should be illegal you have been brain washed by bs goverment propaganda against a plant..... that wouldve put the logging industry out of business an all the newly formed cop groups like the dea an such wouldve been out of the job cause alcohol went legal an they wouldve all lost there jobs so they needed a new target lol
    dea wouldve job alcohol legal wouldve lost jobs target lol
  • gaylehelen 2012/02/26 14:48:30
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    gaylehelen
    +1
    Yes, and also collect a tax, a la the cigarette tax, and put those funds toward the National Debt. If you have ever lived next door to an alcoholic, you would understand my point of view. Alcohol is so accepted, but destroys so many more lives because it is cheaper and also accepted. I see nothing wrong with marijuana, but I have to admit I am a child of the '70's so what else can you expect? It is not addictive, like alcohol, and does have medicinal purposes. I wish I could legally acquire some during my battle to gain weight.
    I can't be a hypocrite and get some because I have my 11 year old granddaughter to think about.
    The current laws are archaic indeed.
  • lm1b2 2012/02/26 14:47:40
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    lm1b2
    Its like Alcohol,so many people use it that it does not make sense to continue making it illegal!
  • Elementer 2012/02/26 14:15:47
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Elementer
    +1
    If alcohol is legal, so should marijuana.
  • Saye Saye 2012/02/26 14:05:08
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Saye Saye
    treat it as a class I drug & FDA regs.
  • Leonidas 2012/02/26 13:48:57
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Leonidas
    +4
    Legalizing marijuana will have some rough spots but so did legalizing the sale and distribution of alcohal products (ending Proibition)
  • Saye Saye Leonidas 2012/02/26 14:05:37
    Saye Saye
    you nailed it. good comment
  • Marian 2012/02/26 13:41:36
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Marian
    +2
    No one has ever died from a pot Overdose, They may of eating everything under the sun and got goofy but never has there been a issue with it. Every LEO will tell you; they would rather deal with a pot head than deal with a drunk
  • peter.g.mackie 2012/02/26 13:28:15
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    peter.g.mackie
    +1
    It seems to me that legalisation would be the only way to stop the violent crime and shootings (often of teenagers) that go on everywhere. There would also be more space in the jails to put the most serious criminals, i.e. paedeophiles and child pornographers, who are really the biggest threat to our children and to the next generation.
  • Someone Else 2012/02/26 13:23:48
    No, marijuana use and possession should just remain illegal.
    Someone Else
    I say that because the non taxable income levels (so far anyway),
    It generates are tremendous for now. Marijuana is illegal on the Federal level but In Colorado much like many other states it has been de-criminalized to the point it's not worth the paper work and time it takes to prosecute 2 oz. or less $50.00 fine.Those with a medical card can have up to 5 plants in their possession at home and carry 2 oz. or less on their person for personal use without fear of prosecution on the state level. On the Federal it is still illegal but that amount will never be prosecuted, confiscated perhaps but there again not enough of a return to warrant an all out assault for 2 oz. of pot.

    Whether it is ever legalized or not those who choose to use it will. Not everyone that uses it becomes addicted I use it on occasion for pain management and only when necessary. As a gateway drug to other drugs I say the same for alcohol and these days kids are more apt to be getting high off Mommy and Daddy's prescription drugs than marijuana since those drugs are readily available right in the home. The best thing any parent can do is talk to their children and stop belting out orders to them try and remember they're as much a part of you as you are to them being a parent isn't easy and neither is being a kid love and respect your children and in return they will give it back.

    PEACE!!!
  • tablecrawler89 2012/02/26 13:05:40
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    tablecrawler89
    Choices, choices.. Again the government meddling in peoples lives.. Just like they do drunks.. Hey drunks pay alot of taxes when they buy alcohol, whether it's a bottle of cheap wine or high dollar fine wines. And not only that after a few times caught they get to see the big house. Then the tax money is not there..
    So, really if the government starts taxing these pot heads and start to put them away it's no use. Why don't the government just resell what they have confiscated from the drug cartels. That way they don't have to plow under American soils. Besides there is always the dealer that will charge less then the government. That has alway been the case. in a free enterprise..
  • Edensasp 2012/02/26 12:47:01 (edited)
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Edensasp
    +2
    We are gonna need the prison and jail space for women who use contraceptives.and that cure STD acquired unwanted pregnancies through consent or rape.



    But In all honesty, I do not particularly like or use marijuana... I also dont like or drink Tequila, but that is no reason to criminalize either one and I fully support & concur with your general summary statement as posted. Legalize and Regulate and tax to support its regulation only, dont tax it to subsidize other programs, tax it to pay for its regulation. (State/locally imposed Sales tax on the other hand is an entirely different situation and should be determined by the voters).
  • Mr.Hoodz the Truth Troll 2012/02/26 12:46:49
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Mr.Hoodz the Truth Troll
    +3
    Its a plant. Leave it be. Aren't people tired of EVERYTHING being taxed? Your damn property is taxed. Life long rent to the government. I just don't understand people always screaming to be taxed more.

    Its even more surprising some thinK the FDA should be involved. LoL. The same FDA that allows wood pulp for filling in some foods? Aspartame in your diet sodas? No thank you. I'd just grow it myself.
  • Steve Nixey 2012/02/26 12:22:26
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Steve Nixey
    +2
    EVERYTHING that comes out of commercial drug companies is dangerous and toxic, just look how many famous people die from commercial prescription drugs and how many overdoes on these every single year!!! How many people has CANNIBIS killed? none... you simply can't overdoes on the stuff it makes you sick or you fall asleep....

    CANIBANIODS are phsycoactive that's all and if you want to be in 100% control of your senses then do not take it... it's that simple... What our gvernments hide from us is the revenue they earn from copyright protected drugs.... Flowers and Weeds cant obtain copyright as it's a naturually occuring process :-) money is what is truly behind this scam.....

    Weed (The Good Herb) is mentioned in the bible several times and it always mentioned as a healing, clearing sort of herb.... What kills is greed of drug pushers and our governments in black operations allow the movement of this substance for there own means to control...

    Weed is a CANCER and CARBON block in the body, weed helps us relax, weed can be used in manufacturing without the need to destroy trees. The model 'T' ford was mainly bild using HEMP which is CANNIBIS in it's purest form.. It was fueled on hemp oil.... A prime influecial government connected corporation spread roumours and made bad film...

    EVERYTHING that comes out of commercial drug companies is dangerous and toxic, just look how many famous people die from commercial prescription drugs and how many overdoes on these every single year!!! How many people has CANNIBIS killed? none... you simply can't overdoes on the stuff it makes you sick or you fall asleep....

    CANIBANIODS are phsycoactive that's all and if you want to be in 100% control of your senses then do not take it... it's that simple... What our gvernments hide from us is the revenue they earn from copyright protected drugs.... Flowers and Weeds cant obtain copyright as it's a naturually occuring process :-) money is what is truly behind this scam.....

    Weed (The Good Herb) is mentioned in the bible several times and it always mentioned as a healing, clearing sort of herb.... What kills is greed of drug pushers and our governments in black operations allow the movement of this substance for there own means to control...

    Weed is a CANCER and CARBON block in the body, weed helps us relax, weed can be used in manufacturing without the need to destroy trees. The model 'T' ford was mainly bild using HEMP which is CANNIBIS in it's purest form.. It was fueled on hemp oil.... A prime influecial government connected corporation spread roumours and made bad filmes about it as this corporation would have suffered... they won and now after a mear trillions trees, petro chem industry that has destroyed our planet later we are all happy with them yes? NO, they work in an attempt to hold up an old paradigm that was broken during roman times... come on governments liven us up do something for mankind instead of filling own pockets with prower and greed.

    Do the research everyone your governments are not who they appear to be (Look at the current movement towards war not peace) who do we follow truely? im lost on that one still :-)
    (more)
  • Natasha Steve N... 2012/02/26 17:46:53
    Natasha
    +1
    I agree completely.
  • Thomas Olson 2012/02/26 11:03:46
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Thomas Olson
    +1
    Aside from the money that could be raised from taxing cannabis there are other potential economic benefits as well:
    Making cannabis legal would allow several industries to use HEMP (a cousin of cannabis, and therefore also illegal) which is a sane, sustainable source for natural fibers and a potential fuel source.
    Making cannabis legal could also potentially reduce prison populations by as much as 50%, thereby saving billions of dollars currently being spent to house, clothe and feed hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of people whose ONLY crimes are cannabis related.
  • Aahz_OneAndOnly 2012/02/26 10:24:54
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Aahz_OneAndOnly
    +5
    “Make the most you can of the Indian Hemp seed and sow it everywhere.”
    - George Washington, U.S. President quote on Hemp
  • A.Oscar 2012/02/26 10:20:53
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    A.Oscar
    The best way legalizing drugs; that way more people could use to kill themselves to control population. Humans not that smart when could do what they want
  • 2sly 2012/02/26 10:16:08
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    2sly
    +1
    Make it leagal tax it and keep the FDA out of it as they don't know what the hell they are doing anyway.
    I like my WEED.
  • Pinball Wizard 2012/02/26 09:15:00
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Pinball Wizard
    I believe it has benefits for the terminally ill but, I'm not a fan of it. I smoke cigarettes but, do not promote them.The brand I smoke are $3.19 + tax. Liquor should be taxed more to help the economy because more people drink alcoholic beverages,then smoke. PI's & DUI's sure help our county in fines.
  • Tom Degan 2012/02/26 08:43:00
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Tom Degan
    +4
    DISCLAIMER:

    I don't smoke pot. Nor do I advocate its usage - unless for medicinal purposes of course. I haven't touched the stuff since my nineteenth birthday - August 16, 1977 - which, coincidentally, was the day that Elvis Presley died. I always tell people that Elvis and I quit drugs at the very same moment, the only difference being that I did so voluntarily.

    Having said that, let me say this:

    Nearly three-quarters-of-a-century after it was made illegal; a half-a-century after it was proven to be practically harmless - why is it still a crime to possess and smoke marijuana?

    Here is a list of ten famous people - heavy smokers all - who died too soon of lung cancer or other diseases related to their addictions to nicotine:

    Humphrey Bogart
    Edward R. Murrow
    Nat King Cole
    George Harrison
    John Huston
    Noel Coward
    Betty Grable
    Walt Disney
    Gary Cooper
    Peter Jennings

    Here is another list. Ten famous people who died from alcoholism:

    Tennessee Williams
    Jack Kerouac
    Truman Capote
    Lorenz Hart
    Veronica Lake
    Bix Beiderbecke
    Montgomery Clift
    Dylan Thomas
    John Barrymore
    Errol Flynn

    Now I'm going to ask you to name for me one celebrity who has died from too much grass.

    Go on, I'm waiting.....

    You couldn't do it, could you? Don't feel bad, neither could I. Not only have I never hear...







    DISCLAIMER:

    I don't smoke pot. Nor do I advocate its usage - unless for medicinal purposes of course. I haven't touched the stuff since my nineteenth birthday - August 16, 1977 - which, coincidentally, was the day that Elvis Presley died. I always tell people that Elvis and I quit drugs at the very same moment, the only difference being that I did so voluntarily.

    Having said that, let me say this:

    Nearly three-quarters-of-a-century after it was made illegal; a half-a-century after it was proven to be practically harmless - why is it still a crime to possess and smoke marijuana?

    Here is a list of ten famous people - heavy smokers all - who died too soon of lung cancer or other diseases related to their addictions to nicotine:

    Humphrey Bogart
    Edward R. Murrow
    Nat King Cole
    George Harrison
    John Huston
    Noel Coward
    Betty Grable
    Walt Disney
    Gary Cooper
    Peter Jennings

    Here is another list. Ten famous people who died from alcoholism:

    Tennessee Williams
    Jack Kerouac
    Truman Capote
    Lorenz Hart
    Veronica Lake
    Bix Beiderbecke
    Montgomery Clift
    Dylan Thomas
    John Barrymore
    Errol Flynn

    Now I'm going to ask you to name for me one celebrity who has died from too much grass.

    Go on, I'm waiting.....

    You couldn't do it, could you? Don't feel bad, neither could I. Not only have I never heard of any famous person dying in that matter, I am not aware of it happening in all recorded human history! Why in 2012 are we still having this same, idiotic conversation?

    Is it a "gateway drug" as they never tire of reminding us? Yeah, it probably is. But so is Miller High Life - the Champagne of Bottled Beer. Let's get a grip here.

    http://www.tomdegan.blogspot.com

    Tom Degab

    Tom Degan
    (more)
  • norman Tom Degan 2012/02/26 17:24:56
    norman
    In regards to "gateway drug" status;: didn't everybody start on milk?
  • Natasha norman 2012/02/26 17:49:42
    Natasha
    +2
    Yeah, marijuana is not a gateway drug. The "gateway" is created as a result of current drug laws which force a lot of people to get their weed from shady black market dealers. Its through the black market that people become exposed to harder drugs when all they want to do is buy their weed!
  • doc1st 2012/02/26 08:39:06
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    doc1st
    +2
    What about everyone that went to prison for marijuana related crime? Just let them out?
  • Stoner doc1st 2012/02/26 09:49:43
    Stoner
    +5
    If non viloent crime then dont deserve to be in jail..
  • SicFux651 2012/02/26 08:37:45
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    SicFux651
    +1
    its a racist law. it was started just because Blacks and Mexicans where smoking it
  • Guido SicFux651 2012/02/26 14:56:55
    Guido
    That’s awesome
  • Natasha 2012/02/26 08:19:31
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Natasha
    +2
    When I posted this question I never imagined that I'd get so much feedback. I'm having a lot of good discussions with you guys though :) It's good seeing everyone's opinions and knowing that there are a lot of people out there who would also like to see reform in our nation's drug laws.
  • Ev Rom 2012/02/26 07:49:59
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Ev Rom
    +3
    there are so many more benefits, it could replace a lot of things, Do some research on the versatility of this plant.
  • Natasha Ev Rom 2012/02/26 07:53:57
    Natasha
    +1
    Exactly, its versatility and the usefulness of hemp is what made it illegal in the first place!
  • Ev Rom Natasha 2012/02/27 07:33:26
    Ev Rom
    I tried to research but you cant always believe what you read here. I read they can mix it to make constructions type cement, clothes, replace plastics and even make fuel. If alll of that is true, I figure its the oil industry how is keeping this plant from being used to improve our lives and save this planet.
  • GM England 2012/02/26 07:45:30
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    GM England
    +2
    The way I see it. Drinking to much makes you goofy, to some people it makes them happy, some sad, to some people they can conquer the world. But pot just makes you calm & sleepy ..
  • Stoner GM England 2012/02/26 09:51:32
    Stoner
    Dont forget the munchies lol

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/25 10:23:37

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals