Quantcast

Is legalizing marijuana really the best option?

Natasha 2012/02/25 19:56:19
You!
Add Photos & Videos
First of all, I don't believe that marijuana is the harmful or dangerous substance society makes it out to be and don't understand the enormous stigmas associated with it. Quoting Pineapple Express, "weed makes everything better."
Its illegal status is an archaic remnant of times when paper companies didn't want to be driven out of business with hemp production. Society is already undergoing a paradigm shift with an acceptance and, at times, (media) glorification of its use. I'm partially for legalization, saying the the government should tax and regulate its use and distribution and set guidelines, but also take into account the consequences of legalization. I'd also advocate decriminalization which would make possession and use of weed in reasonable quantities, usually around 3g, legal. (Not that the government would ever go for an option where people get to smoke weed legally without the gov profiting) For those who use marijuana, legalization is a terrible option. Yes the government won't be able to prosecute us for lighting a joint anymore, but are all of the taxes and regulations worth it? With the FDA guidelines that would be placed in marijuana growers, bud quality would go down and almost everything you buy will be generic. You can say goodbye to that killer kush you can get from your local dealer at a relatively decent price. The government will tax the shit out of marijuana, putting a luxury tax on top of whatever state tax you have to pay already, driving prices up, leading to a proliferation of bad weed because that's the only thing people will be able to afford. So next time you or one of your stoner friends advocates legalization, remind them that it would only lead to bad quality weed and ridiculous prices for the good stuff. It's so much easier to just get it from your local dealer. But disregarding the effect that it will have on people who do smoke weed, legalization would provide economic stimulus (through taxation) and help curve problems associated with the illegal drug trade (prohibition of alcohol in the 20s led to speakeasies and moonshiners but when it was abolished illegal trade of alcohol ceased). It may also curb use of other drugs. In Holland, the (partial) legalization of marijuana has lead to an overall decrease in hard drug use. Benefits of legalization overall outweigh the costs. Society is waking up already and so should the government.
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Mamaknows 2012/02/25 21:53:08
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Mamaknows
    +10
    As far as I am concerned we should legalise it, regulate growing, preperation for sale, and taxe the crap out of it.
    For myself I have seen what illegal grows can do land and streams and have been shot at while hiking by illegal mexicans(mexican cartel) that grow illegally on public lands.
    Yes that cheap dime bag of skunk you bought was grown on land that became TOXIC because of the chemicals they laid down to grow it....and the garbage they left behind.
    I can see a whole host of problems that would come from it but I think regulating/taxing it is the best option.
    All that being said I do not smoke it. I was raised around pot heads and have seen what a few years(let alone MANY years) does to people.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • johnpaul 2012/08/09 21:54:26
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    johnpaul
    Yes, Where does man have the right to out law God's creation. Marijuana is an herb that yielding seed!! see Genesis 1;

    11 And God said, Let the earth bring forth grass, the herb yielding seed, and the fruit tree yielding fruit after his kind, whose seed is in itself, upon the earth: and it was so.

    12 And the earth brought forth grass, and herb yielding seed after his kind, and the tree yielding fruit, whose seed was in itself, after his kind: and God saw that it was good.
  • Mejink 2012/05/04 01:07:34
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Mejink
    +1
    Intelligent question.
  • YOMOMMA 2012/04/27 06:49:19
    No, marijuana use and possession should just remain illegal.
    YOMOMMA
    leave it alone. Just don't get caught!
  • Jrogers 2012/04/25 01:40:54
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Jrogers
    +1
    I dont see why we should let the government tax the American people for yet another item that can be found grown in the wild. It is absolutely ridiculous - what is next - tax the air we breathe or the water we drink? This is a weed that used to grow wild - allw them to tax us for it? No
  • Kalayaan 001 2012/04/23 21:04:47
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Kalayaan 001
    Actually, in the case of the U.S. with the Constitutional restrictions on its Federal Government, I would have the Federal Goverment repeal its laws against the herb and allow the States to regulate and tax it.
  • BeautifulSoul 2012/04/23 16:28:17
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    BeautifulSoul
    People do it anyway, might as well.
  • thermoguy 2012/04/23 05:46:54
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    thermoguy
    Regulation is required and it is a really big industry that should be taxed. It is safer than alcohol or other drugs.
  • Johnny 2012/04/23 04:03:33
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Johnny
    To be forbidden on restaurants and/or anywhere you can eat, cause you will die from intoxicatiom from bad using. But it should be used as a cigarettes and alcohol are IMO
  • mama sew,gung ho 2012/04/23 03:35:58
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    mama sew,gung ho
    Dear Natasha,Thank You for your passionate speech!I've heard my kids tell me the same thing,but never in such an eloquent manner.Well spoken argument,and Me thinks you have a future as an arbitrator,an advocate,attorney or debater!(You make a damn good argument!)
  • Steve ☮ R ☮ P ☮ 2012 ☮ 2012/04/23 02:35:24
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Steve ☮ R ☮ P ☮ 2012 ☮
    +1
    Don't agree with everything in this answer, but since options were limited...

    People who want weed will get it anyway. Making it illegal (besides being an affront to liberty) simply creates a black market which leads to real crime and violence.

    It's a no brainer!
  • me being me 2012/04/23 00:52:58
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    me being me
    Anything ingested in excess can be harmful.
  • SemperRick 2012/04/23 00:31:05
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    SemperRick
    I firmly believe the benefits outweigh the risks.
  • Brandi Angela 2012/04/23 00:23:27
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Brandi Angela
    While if you are right and legalizing it and taxing it will bring down the quality (which if so I'll just grow it myself) legalization will mean you can still get a job if your piss test comes back positive for pot. Decriminalization I don't think would allow for that. And that fact is the only reason I don't smoke that much anymore because my job does random drug testing.
  • raine 2012/04/22 23:11:39
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    raine
    +2
    I don't know many adults who smoke weed. I have heard much can be done with the hemp fibers. It would be good to have that r renewable resource to use.
  • RTHTGakaRoland 2012/04/22 23:00:24 (edited)
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    RTHTGakaRoland
    +1
    Actually all drugs should be legalized, and no greater tax or regulatory burden should be imposed on their production and sale these than any other OTC drugs.

    Only strict penalties for being under the influence at work or when operating equipment or vehicles potentially dangerous to others, and for those drugs smoked for doing so only in private spaces so as not to involuntarily expose other need be put in placer and vigorously enforced.

    Why should I as a non-user have to pay in both dollars and liberty for abusers' irresponsibility and Nanny Statists' Leviathon fantasy?

    Legal drugs.

    Cheap drugs.

    Strong drugs.

    Let the bureaucrats starve.

    Let the abusers kill themselves more quickly.

    Let the rest of us reclaim some prosperity and liberty.
  • ZB 2012/04/22 22:36:58
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    ZB
    Tax the hell out of it, just like tobacco.
  • Temlakos~POTL~PWCM~JLA~☆ 2012/04/22 22:20:13
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Temlakos~POTL~PWCM~JLA~☆
    +3
    Ultimately I want the FDA and other agencies to go away. Letting marijuana become legal again will likely be the price I'll have to pay for a higher value, which is: freedom.
  • Denny 2012/04/22 21:29:59
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Denny
    I don't see where it makes any sense at all. You have a legal substance that everyone with no balls is fighting to take away from everybody else by telling you where tobacco can be used. They are now complaining that school kids are missing millions of days at school because of second hand smoke. See they don't have the balls to just ban the stuff and get rid of the taxes and jobs. Now you want another substance legalized that again "the rich" can doctor it up to make people adicted, make it so that second hand smoke.....blah blah blah. The Womb to the Tomb is really going to let that happen?? Maybe because it's the drug of their choice??? hmmmmmmm
  • TerryAgee 2012/04/22 20:59:37
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    TerryAgee
    I am biased because I was my Dad's caretaker.
  • animelover123 2012/04/22 20:54:07
    No, marijuana use and possession should just remain illegal.
    animelover123
    I dont see why it matters people will still ise it
  • 24FilmProStudio 2012/04/22 20:07:40
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    24FilmProStudio
    +2
    Like we really need the government to get involved with its usage again...
  • cin 2012/04/22 20:07:22
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    cin
    Yes.
  • SebaTheSociallyAwkwardPenguin 2012/04/22 19:56:37
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    SebaTheSociallyAwkwardPenguin
    +1
    making it legal will make the government produce it then brainwash us even more.
  • gregaj7 2012/04/22 19:01:13
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    gregaj7
    +1
    I "vote" for a fourth option of absolutely NO regulation of any kind over seed-bearing plants.
  • Honeybuns 2012/04/22 18:03:19
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Honeybuns
    +2
    Yes because a lot of people and i mean a lot use marijuna. So why not just legalize it.
  • Ahrtal 2012/04/22 16:59:05
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Ahrtal
    I can't operate my own still in the back woods, so why should other mind altering drugs be exempt? And will taxing and guidelines really decrease weed quality, and make buying more complicated? C'mon! You can go to Safeway in many parts of the West and Southwest and buy hard liquor next to the vegetable section. Yeah, I've done it in Cali. So maybe pot could be sold in the vegetable aisle? Other states have private liquor stores or state-operated stores (ABC stores). What is the big deal? Actually guidelines could actually improve the quality of pot because of competition (I know, that G**d***ed Free Enterprise System and Capitalism, and prevent adulteration of the product with extenders, fillers, and potentially dangerous "enhancements". Remember, that was one of the arguments against cigs: All the unnatural ingredients that probably were more dangerous that the natural tobacco leave.
  • Stacy Martin 2012/04/22 16:17:13
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Stacy Martin
  • cheshirewayne 2012/04/22 15:52:44
    No, marijuana use and possession should just remain illegal.
    cheshirewayne
    legalizing it will just create another illegal market for the "good" stuff that the government does not control.
  • Kane Fernau 2012/04/22 15:05:59
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Kane Fernau
    +1
    What are the chances the government will screw it up? 98%
  • bob 2012/04/22 15:04:39
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    bob
    +1
    Yes It would stopped the Cartels from making billions off it and allow the Government to make lot of Money by taxing it. I have never seen anyone get mean smoking Pot and you cannot Overdose on it. The Morons want to say it leads to Harder Drugs, That is only because it is Illegal and the People that sell it sell other Illegal Drugs if you Legalize it that connection is Gone. We have bigger problems to deal.
  • JaknHarely 2012/04/22 10:35:00
    No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    JaknHarely
    +1
    I don't smoke it and I don't advocate smoking it, but the law right now just gives police excuses to overreach. This isn't the only place the government should but out either.
  • Crime Time 2012/04/22 08:30:18
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Crime Time
    +1
    Most arrests I see on COPS has to do with it. Or some kinda other drug, but mainly weed
  • cuzzbuzzla 2012/04/22 07:18:53
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    cuzzbuzzla
    +1
    this is my civic hobby. ideally, i agree with Jerry (Iron Priest). The government is infringing on our personal liberties and that is crushing the creative and entrepreneurial spirit that limited government gave the people, eroding out competitive edge. They are chocking us with rules and laws and we need to reverse that. On the other hand, pragmatically, with the government now broke offering the taxation angle to them is our best chance to return a civil liberty to the people, a civil liberty taken from them on a foundation of outright lies in the 30s, and possibly ushering in a new era of enhanced liberties for our children and grandchildren.
    http://images.sodahead.com/pr...
  • Gumdrop 2012/04/22 06:28:11
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    Gumdrop
    +1
    Alcohol is more dangerous and is legal! There shouldn't be any crime using herb!!!
  • nothingbutthetruth 2012/04/22 06:19:56
    Yes, the government should tax it, allow FDA regulation, and set age requirem...
    nothingbutthetruth
    +1
    This will help combat other illegal drugs from populating.
  • No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    ☆The Rock☆ * AFCL* The Sheriff!!
    +2
    I think it is no worse then FDA regulated drugs!!
  • nothing... ☆The Ro... 2012/04/25 07:05:51
    nothingbutthetruth
    +1
    If that's your opinion, I respect it becasue I respect people opinions.
  • ☆The Ro... nothing... 2012/04/25 13:11:56
    ☆The Rock☆ * AFCL* The Sheriff!!
    Marijuana is a lot more safer then the crap they perscribe from Doc!
  • nothing... ☆The Ro... 2012/04/30 06:18:28
    nothingbutthetruth
    Well, I don't know about that because I never use it.(: but I heard it's a natural medicine. The problem is, some people will it as a way to multiply the ones that are not good. And you know what I mean.
  • No, decriminalization is the way to go. Taxing and guideline will only lead t...
    Jerry (Iron Priest)☮ R ☮ P ☮ 201
    +8
    Actually, the government just needs to stay right the hell out of all things involving personal liberty.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 9 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/06/18 21:43:30

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals