Is America turning into a place that immigrants came here to get away from?
Drue-AFCL
2012/09/02 17:56:03
|
|
|||||
|
39 votes
|
|
66% | |||
|
10 votes
|
|
17% | |||
|
10 votes
|
|
17% | |||
Top Opinion
-
Heptarch 2012/09/02 22:01:25no





















America has forgotten its roots, yes this nation has many dark pasts but it is also a good country, the Framers and Founders gave to us responsibility and we gave it to the lieing politicians who just go for the benefits, salaries and say the hell with the Constitution!
When Benjamin Franklin stepped out on the porch of Independence Hall a woman come up to him and asked, "What kind of government did you give us?" Franklin replied," A REPUBLIC if you can keep it!"
My way of thinking.
No, it was not. It was built on a secular foundation. That's the fundamental error in right wing thinking. This country may be predominantly Christian in the religious beliefs of its people, but it is ALWAYS... FOREVER... a mistake to try to force secular law to adopt Christian principles. There is a separation of church and state for a reason. One of the many things our Founding Fathers got right was to vehemently stress the secular nature of the nation.
"No morale values in the Rule of law - disaster! "
AMerican law is based on English common law, not the bible. It has never been based on the bible.
The underlying argument that without religious dogma there can be no morality is flawed, as well. Morality is entirely dependent upon the set of social mores that any society adopts. In other words, what is moral to you may be immoral to someone who does not share your beliefs. Neither of you are wrong. In fact, as long as your beliefs are shared by the majority of your society, you are probably both right. There is no such thing as universal, or objective, morality.
British Common law was based on Christanity- how could it not have been. The Laws were not drafted actually using the bible, but by men who read the bible and their faith influenced the outcome of the laws they drafted..
"but it is ALWAYS... FOREVER... a mistake to try to force secular law to adopt Christian principles. There is a separation of church and state for a reason. One of the many things our Founding Fathers got right was to vehemently stress the secular nature of the nation."
Anyway, you will be happy to know that "Case Law" is fast taking over "Common Law"
Thanks for the back and forth - it's great!
The point is that our nation was founded to be secular, as expressly stated by the Founding Fathers. You cannot, in good conscience, claim otherwise.
I know where it came from- you just disagree lol no problem. More and more people are not following any moral code. It is all too evident. We can follow any religion we want to in this country and that is what's great about America. You stick to the Dems - I would't vote for them if a gun was pointed at my head.
If your answer isn't "even older sources", you're lying to yourself. Or being intellectually dishonest. One of the two. The entire Old Testament, including the foundations of Judaic law, are "borrowed" from even older religions and documents with new flavor attached.
"You stick to the Dems - I would't vote for them if a gun was pointed at my head."
I will for this election. Maybe next election the Republicans will be a little more worth voting for.
Listen - I don't know if what you say is true. I'm not an academic I've worked for 45 years with my hands, in all types of weather and all over the globe. I have seen and experienced much. I would never portray myself as something I'm not - like a scholar. I do however know what works and what does not work. In an intellectual battle with you on this subject I have little experience. This subject is interesting to me - but I have little time to persue it as you have. Perhaps I will some day. But for now my belief in God and Country will suffice.
I don't lie to myself or anyone else. One of my redeeming Christian values.
But the truth remains the same: The Old Testament of the Christian bible, the rock upon which your conceptions of universal, objective morality reside, is pretty much a blatant plagiarization of earlier works.
There's nothing wrong with that from a literary standpoint, but once you start deifying the words in it, that's when I have to stand up and say "Ok, now wait a minute..."
In any case, that's only a tangent to the real point, which is that the Founding Fathers did not base this country on Christianity.
TO ME we are the sick birds for letting it get out of control!