Quantcast

In many states a rapist has parental rights. Should a woman be forced to carry her rapist's baby to term?

Diane 2012/08/22 15:06:24
You!
Add Photos & Videos

When asked about abortion and rape, Republican Todd Akin said:



"Well you know, people always want to try to make that as one of those things, well how do you, how do you slice this particularly tough sort of ethical question. First of all, from what I understand from doctors, that’s really rare. If it’s a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down. But let’s assume that maybe that didn’t work or something. I think there should be some punishment, but the punishment ought to be on the rapist and not attacking the child."



Doctors say this is absolute hogwash. Women who are raped can, and often do, get pregnant.



And, in many states, a rapist has parental rights and the victim could be tied to her rapist for eighteen years, shuffling her child to and from his residence. This is true even in the case of incest!



http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/blog/2008/04/10/parental-rights...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • gumybare69 2012/08/24 17:57:31
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    gumybare69
    +7
    People can be against abortion if they want, but Rape isn't a choice for a woman that is Raped! I'm not a woman and I couldn't even imagine the thought of having to carry a baby to term that was caused by being Raped, every time she looks down at her belly she is constantly reminded of the fact that some POS man took advantage of her and there is nothing she can do about it because someone she doesn't even know decided that her baby is a good thing and shouldn't be aborted. Interfering with a woman's right over her own body in this case is just sicking to me!

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • gfreeman BN-0 2012/10/29 20:04:25
    Yes, a rape victim should be forced to carry to term.
    gfreeman BN-0
    And the father should get visitation rights also. Maybe even marriage. Yeah, the relationship started out rough, but hey, give it a chance. You have a baby with that man!
  • Alexander T Steward 2012/10/29 15:18:18
  • Peewee 2012/10/29 14:18:16
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    Peewee
    +1
    No. I don't like abortions but it still needs to be a choice. I wouldn't want to carry a baby who's father was a psycho. No need to add that to the gene pool.
  • wedge56 2012/10/29 13:36:14
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    wedge56
    +1
    It is ridiculousness in its highest form to think anyone, but the rape victim can make this decision. Party of smaller government, my ass. More like party of smaller government until you want to do something WE disagree with.
  • Jesterz 2012/10/29 12:57:58
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    Jesterz
    +2
    It's preposterous...
  • MercuryZero 2012/10/29 07:02:16
    Yes, a rape victim should be forced to carry to term.
    MercuryZero
    Why should the baby suffer because of someone's stupidity?
  • classic Mercury... 2012/10/29 14:14:31
    classic
    +1
    why should the woman spend a lifetime of looking at the result of that rape and reliving it everytime she looks at that "Baby"

    How many babies have you had from being raped??
  • Rodimus Knight 2012/10/29 06:39:11
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    Rodimus Knight
    +2
    but at the same time a rapist should have no parental rights, because the pregnancy come as a result of a violent crime
  • Marlow ~ Let There Be Light 2012/10/29 06:26:18
    Yes, a rape victim should be forced to carry to term.
    Marlow ~ Let There Be Light
    +2
    The child committed no crime. Why kill an innocent being? Why have a second violent act and kill the child? One violent act is enough.
  • ☆The Ro... Marlow ... 2012/10/29 06:52:15
    ☆The Rock☆ * AFCL* The Sheriff!!
    +3
    I agree with you!! What has happened to the idea of adoption. 2 wrongs don't make a right!
  • Miss Kris 2012/10/29 06:01:26
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    Miss Kris
    +2
    Not at all. It was something forced upon her.
  • SIMPATTYCO 2012/10/29 05:17:01
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    SIMPATTYCO
    +2
    You go too far ...you should not try to legislate this issue. I am very conservative, but I have a Libertarian streak. Keep your nose oit of peoples personal rights,,,
  • The River Rat 2012/10/29 05:14:35
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    The River Rat
    +3
    No woman should be forced to indure this indignity.
  • fearlessldr 2012/10/29 04:51:50
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    fearlessldr
    +2
    No one should be forced to carry a baby they do not want to carry.
  • Gracie - Proud Conservative 2012/10/29 04:31:19
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    +1
    I don't think the rapist has any rights, but with that said, I think as you do, the baby should not be punished. Why does a child, by means of their conception, have lesser rights to life? Imagine, as many people have, that you were conceived by rape...do you become a less valuable person?
  • Marlow ... Gracie ... 2012/10/29 06:28:54
    Marlow ~ Let There Be Light
    +1
    Totally agree. I do think you checked the wrong answer. The question wasn't if the rapist should have rights.
  • Gracie ... Marlow ... 2012/10/29 14:48:24
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    +1
    I only checked it because it did say that a rapist had parental rights, which I don't agree with. I needed a different answer! LOL!
  • Diane Gracie ... 2012/10/30 15:51:31
    Diane
    +1
    You do think the rape victim should be forced to carry to term, so you should have checked the other answer.
  • Gracie ... Diane 2012/10/30 21:06:41
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    Yep, you're right...sorry!
  • Diane Gracie ... 2012/10/31 01:34:28
    Diane
    That's okay. So, if your twelve year old daughter is raped, and gets pregnant as a result, she should be forced to carry the pregnancy to term. I see.
  • Gracie ... Diane 2012/10/31 01:40:51
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    Or, I make her live with the guilt for the rest of her life for killing it? Abortion isn't like some healing salve, it's adding another injustice on top of the other one. You should talk to children who were born out of rape and tell them they have no right to life, you on the other hand by terms of your conception, do.
  • Diane Gracie ... 2012/10/31 02:12:11
    Diane
    Your twelve year old daughter should be allowed to decide for herself.
  • Gracie ... Diane 2012/10/31 02:18:56
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    12, really? I find it ironic that I couldn't give a 12 year old an aspirin to take by herself at school, but you think she should decide whether to have an abortion or not. Do you guys have any common sense whatsoever?
  • Diane Gracie ... 2012/10/31 04:16:51
    Diane
    If a twelve year old girl gets pregnant as a result of rape, she should not be forced to bear the child. If you think otherwise, then you are a child abuser.
  • Gracie ... Diane 2012/10/31 17:35:25
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    Since this is your hypothetical question, the perversion and abuse lies on you. Your insistence on abortion is vile beyond words. Why do people champion death?
  • Diane Gracie ... 2012/11/08 03:35:17
    Diane
    I remember what it was like before Roe v. Wade. Young women were killing themselves with coat hangers and knitting needles. Or they were getting slaughtered by back alley abortionists. I never want to see those days again.
  • Gracie ... Diane 2012/11/08 22:43:32
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    Let's look at the truth of that statement. The last time more than 1,000 women died from illegal abortion was before penicillin was discovered in 1942. Since then the average has ranged from 90 to 150 per year. Before Roe v Wade, abortion was legal in some states so it wasn't that abortion was illegal everywhere.

    In 1972, 39 women died from complications of illegal abortion and 24 women died from legal abortions. Since 1980 that number has dropped because of medical technology. In 2007, 6 women died from legal abortions. How many babies have died from abortion, millions!

    So, you remember nothing like what you're implying. In 2000, 68 people died by falling into their own bathtubs. We didn't outlaw bathtubs.
  • Diane Gracie ... 2012/11/08 23:17:01
    Diane
    +1
    We'll just have to agree to disagree.
  • Diane Gracie ... 2012/11/09 05:56:54
    Diane
    One more thing. I checked your figures, and they are misleading.

    A statistic perhaps more typical of the pre-Roe era was reported in a 1969 Scientific American article cowritten by Christopher Tietze, a senior fellow with the Population Council: "The National Center for Health Statistics listed 235 deaths from abortion in 1965. Total mortality from illegal abortions was undoubtedly larger than that figure, but in all likelihood it was under 1,000."

    Self-induced and back-alley abortions were becoming a thing of the past long before Roe: sex researcher Alfred Kinsey estimated in the 1950s that around 85 percent of illegal abortions were performed by physicians, even if the physicians weren't all in good standing. The fact is that prior to legalization abortion had become relatively safe and easy to obtain — for those who could afford it. Studies done at the time show that the risks were borne disproportionately by those who couldn't, mostly minorities. Were abortion to be recriminalized, that would likely be the case again.

    http://www.straightdope.com/c...

    So, in other words, if abortion was recriminalized, poor women would die.
  • SuckerPunch 2012/10/29 04:27:50
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    SuckerPunch
    +3
    No. It's her body.
  • Morgan 2012/10/29 04:10:58
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    Morgan
    +3
    It's bad enough that the woman got raped but now she has to be reminded of it even longer. Sure she can adopt the baby off. But 1) the rape will just have that much more of an impact on her and 2) if the baby ever found out that not only did their mom not want them but that they were a rape baby? I really can't imagine how that kid would feel. I met someone on here who was a mistake, his mother was a teen mom. He was in his 60s and spent all his life believing that he didn't belong here, that his whole life was just a mistake. It made me feel really sad.
  • Morgan Morgan 2012/10/29 04:13:02
    Morgan
    +2
    Quick question..what's a legitimate rape??
  • Mel 2012/10/29 04:07:04
    No, a rape victim should not be forced to carry to term.
    Mel
    +5
    A rapist has NO right to anything but have his penis amputated.
  • janice.... Mel 2012/10/29 20:51:57
    janice.heartbriggs
    +2
    Hmmm i think i have a dull rusty knife around here somewhere
  • Mel janice.... 2012/10/29 20:54:16
    Mel
    +1
    I was thinking of this instead:

    chainsaw
  • janice.... Mel 2012/10/29 20:58:48
    janice.heartbriggs
    +2
    that'll work
  • Mel janice.... 2012/10/29 21:01:59
    Mel
    +1
    Or perhaps????

    battle axe
  • janice.... Mel 2012/10/29 21:53:53
    janice.heartbriggs
    +2
    or just put him in a prison cell with a bunch of large men who would do the same thing to him he did to the girl... After being deprived of his "things"
  • Mel janice.... 2012/10/29 21:55:32
    Mel
    Now now, let's not be cruel. *LOL* *hugs*
  • janice.... Mel 2012/10/29 21:58:01
    janice.heartbriggs
    +1
    i have a passion for ... well let me just say i had a very dear freind who had some very bad things happen to her... The assailant is now doing four life sentences

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/20 11:46:50

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals