Quantcast

Immigrants Protest 'ILLEGAL' Label.

zbacku 2012/08/21 17:28:57
Care To Comment?
What Do You Think?
Illegal Is Illegal.
Aw, We're Sorry For Hurting Your Feelings.
You!
Add Photos & Videos

By LAUREN R. HARRISON

A small group of immigrants gathered in Woodbury Monday to protest the use of the word "illegal" to describe those who have entered the United States without documentation.

"By saying illegal, they're assuming that we broke a criminal law," said Jackeline Saavedra, 27, of Bay Shore, a Touro Law Center student who identified herself as undocumented. "Not everybody enters illegally."

Coordinators said they prefer the phrase "undocumented immigrant."

Osman Canales, 23, an immigrant rights advocate in Huntington who organized the protest, said using the word "illegal" criminalizes a whole community. "It's a racist word against our community, so we're just here to raise awareness," he said.

The protest mirrored a larger effort nationwide to push media outlets and people in general to stop using the word "illegal" when referring to immigrants.

The "Drop The I-Word" campaign was organized by The Applied Research Center, a New York City-based racial justice think tank. Its goal, according to its news website, Colorlines.com, is to "eradicate the slur 'illegals' from everyday use and public discourse."

Campaign coordinator Monica Novoa said that in two years, 14,000 people have signed the group's pledge.

"Using a phrase like 'illegal aliens' or 'illegals' . . . reinforces the notion that you could treat another individual as less than a human being," said Alina Das, assistant professor of clinical law at New York University. "One action -- whether it's a crime -- shouldn't be used to define a whole group of people or one individual."

But Gallya Lahav, associate professor of political science at Stony Brook University, said the term "undocumented" has flaws.

"It's a politically correct way of saying illegal," she said. "What you're also talking about in proper form are the real undocumented -- asylum seekers -- people who are fleeing for threats of their life or freedom."

Still, the word "illegal" makes Elias Llivicura, 18, who described himself as undocumented, feel "uncomfortable."

"We also have feelings too," said Llivicura, of Bellport, who came to Long Island from Ecuador at age 8. "It makes me feel like I'm different from everybody else," he said. "It makes me feel like really bad inside."

Read More: http://www.newsday.com/news/nation/immigrants-prot...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • DavidK 2012/09/05 06:14:20 (edited)
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    DavidK
    Notice to liberals and illegals.....
    nmbm
  • SaraBoo 2012/08/26 02:15:49
    What Do You Think?
    SaraBoo
    +1
    The word is UNDOCUMENTED!!

    There are law breakers, sure. Do you call everyone who's in jail "illegals" too? Everyone that shoplifts, speeds, harasses, are they considered "illegals"?
    Not to my knowledge. So immigrants shouldn't have that label too. It's offensive.
  • zbacku SaraBoo 2012/08/27 15:22:14
    zbacku
    If one does not obey the laws of the land, they are doing ILLEGAL things. Thus, those that come to America by not following the laws of the land are ILLEGAL.
  • Bill 2012/08/22 14:33:20
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    Bill
  • XZQZQ 2012/08/22 07:16:21
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    XZQZQ
    +3
    Too bad. ' Illegal ' means that they should not even be in the country......
  • tncdel 2012/08/22 05:27:38
    Care To Comment?
    tncdel
    +4
    You shouldn't call illegal alien invaders immigrants. That's an insult to a foreign who complied with our immigration laws equating them.

    If you call illegals immigrants, then so too were the Nazis who "immigrated" to France during WW II.
  • The Gipper~PWCM~JLA 2012/08/22 05:03:08
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    The Gipper~PWCM~JLA
    +4
    Get legal and we'll stop calling you illegal!
  • schjaz 2012/08/22 04:59:09
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    schjaz
    +1
    That's La Raza!
    Go here... http://www.theycometoamerica....
  • Reggie☮ 2012/08/22 04:08:32
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    Reggie☮
    +2
    Too Bad!
  • Mikel_mad2002 2012/08/22 03:31:46
    What Do You Think?
    Mikel_mad2002
    +3
    If they're here illegally then that makes them illegal
  • JDLogan 2012/08/22 00:58:42
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    JDLogan
    +4
    If you don't want to have the "illegal" label, follow the law; simple as that. They need to stay in their home country or fill out the correct paperwork, and we should use the precise same immigration process as the home country of the person wanting to come in to our country.
  • eyeballz 2012/08/22 00:33:07
    Care To Comment?
    eyeballz
    +5
    If it bothers them that they are ILLEGAL, let them take the appropriate steps, like my and your grandparents did , to become citizens and not stay ILLEGAL ALIENS!!!! Otherwise too bad!!!!!
  • MichaelDillon 2012/08/21 23:49:18
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    MichaelDillon
  • ed 2012/08/21 23:41:39
    Aw, We're Sorry For Hurting Your Feelings.
    ed
    +8
    We're sorry we hurt your feelings and called you an illegal.OOPS MY BAD.
  • jay 2012/08/21 22:28:08
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    jay
    +8
    What do they want us to call them "undocumented democrats"

    Is a rapist an undocumented sexual partner?

    Is a robber an undocumted houseguest?

    Is a drug dealer an unlicensed pharmacist.
  • zbacku jay 2012/08/22 04:05:50
  • Dave Sawyer ♥ Child of God ♥ 2012/08/21 22:23:40
    Care To Comment?
    Dave Sawyer ♥ Child of God ♥
    +4
    I agree, we should just call them criminals. People are not illegal, acts are illegal.
  • munda 2012/08/21 20:48:37 (edited)
    What Do You Think?
    munda
    +5
    Instead of illegal maybe they would prefer criminal.
  • Risk 2012/08/21 20:38:21
  • dick Risk 2012/08/21 21:44:53
    dick
    +2
    Great cartoon!
  • Risk dick 2012/08/22 12:12:15
    Risk
    +1
    I see SH took out the w--b--k name I used. Gotta be political correct ya know !
  • No nonsense NanC...don't BS... 2012/08/21 20:25:39
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    No nonsense NanC...don't BS me!
    +5
    So what do they think you call someone here illegally?
  • Striker 2012/08/21 19:57:38
    What Do You Think?
    Striker
    +6
    Don't like to be called illegal? It's fine with America if you simply enter thru the legal doorway.
  • IndyLinda 2012/08/21 19:51:25
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    IndyLinda
    +6
    Illegal is what they are -- kick their sorry butts back to where they came from.
  • Hula girl - Friends not Fol... 2012/08/21 19:43:38
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    Hula girl - Friends not Followers
    +6
    Then they should go back home where they aren't ILLEGAL!
  • fuzzy Ken "In G-d We Trust" 2012/08/21 19:41:12
    Aw, We're Sorry For Hurting Your Feelings.
    fuzzy Ken "In G-d We Trust"
    +6
    Since we hurt your feelings by calling you ILLEGAL are you now going to leave?
  • Drummerboy 2012/08/21 19:17:47
  • Ozzyboy 2012/08/21 19:09:28
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    Ozzyboy
    +6
    Breaking the law is illegal no matter what you call it. A rose by any other name is still a rose. You don't like feeling different? Stay home and clean up your own country. I might change my mind on the illegal name if there are NO government handouts being used. Pay for all your own programs and stop using the American taxpayers money!
  • sammanilla 2012/08/21 19:03:39
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    sammanilla
  • dick 2012/08/21 19:00:49
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    dick
    +8
    The government needs to round them up and show them what ILLEGAL means! They are uninvited guests that have worn out their welcome! illegal aliens
  • jimih67 2012/08/21 18:40:45
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    jimih67
    +8
    We need to go down to the protests and round em up and ship em out.
  • Sgt Major B 2012/08/21 18:23:04
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    Sgt Major B
    +9
    The term is "Illegal Alien"; consult Title 8, USC.
  • Rick 2012/08/21 18:22:11
    Aw, We're Sorry For Hurting Your Feelings.
    Rick
    +7
    Try sneaking into any other nation in the world. They'll do more than hurt their feelings.
    Chop Chop Square
  • cinbadl 2012/08/21 18:12:38
  • minniehaha 2012/08/21 17:57:55
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    minniehaha
    +8
    we will never stop using the term so the illegal [...] can forget it hell i am teaching mine thats the only term allowed in this house to discribe the law breaking illegals
  • cmdrbnd007 2012/08/21 17:42:53
    Illegal Is Illegal.
    cmdrbnd007
    +8
    Pure insanity.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/19 22:15:41

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals