Here We Go Again. Arizona Bill Would declare Pregnancy 2 Weeks Before Conception

ὤTṻnde΄ӂ 2012/04/04 22:38:05

Arizona bill would declare pregnancy 2 weeks before conception

By David Edwards
Wednesday, April 4, 2012 12:25 EDT

Pregnant woman receives ultrasound/sonogram (Shutterstock)

A measure passed Arizona’s Senate claims that it
would ban abortions after 20 weeks of pregnancy, but experts say that
the bill is far more restrictive, effectively banning abortions after 18
weeks and declaring that a woman could be pregnant 2 weeks before she
even had sex.

Arizona’s HB 2036
takes Nebraska’s 20-week abortion ban one step further by starting the
clock on pregnancies at the woman’s last last menstrual period, which
could be two weeks before fertilization.

Specifically, the bill would “[p]rohibit abortions at or after twenty
weeks of gestation, except in cases of a medical emergency, based on
the documented risks to women’s health and the strong medical evidence
that unborn children feel pain during an abortion at that gestational
age,” where gestational age is defined as “age of the unborn child as
calculated from the first day of the last menstrual period of the
pregnant woman.”

Guttmacher Institute’s State Issues Manager Elizabeth Nash
told Raw Story that obstetricians start the clock on pregnancies after
the “last menstrual period” to “be on the safe side.”

“Certainly, they are trying move the gestational cutoff from what had
been over the last two years a 20-week gestational cutoff to an 18-week
gestational cutoff,” Nash explained. “At the same time, they are trying
to say, ‘Oh, this is a 20-week abortion ban.’ And they get away with
that with the definition of gestational age that’s in the bill.”

RH Reality Check’s Amanda Marcotte noted that this means legislators are arguing women could be pregnant before they even have sex.

“Think about the implications down the road,” she wrote. “If a woman
is ‘pregnant’ two weeks before she becomes pregnant, than any fertile
woman—including those currently menstruating!—should really be
considered pregnant. After all, we don’t know the future. We don’t know
that any non-pregnant woman couldn’t be pregnant two weeks from now,
making her retroactively pregnant now.”

“Considering that it’s anti-choice nuts we’re talking about, it’s
safe to assume that they’d simply prefer a situation where all women of
reproductive age are considered to be pregnant, on the grounds that they
could be two weeks from now,” Marcotte added. “Better safe than sorry,
especially if that mentality means you get to exert maximum control over
the bodies of women of reproductive age.”

At this point, Nash said the Arizona bill has “very good chances of passage” because it is largely misunderstood.

“The media has been talking about this as a 20-week abortion
ban without, I think, really looking into the definition,” she observed.
“Two weeks is a long time. … [The bill] does not talk about any sort of
fetal impairment. In this time frame is when you would have an
[amniocentesis] done or other tests and it takes away women’s options if
there is a problem with the pregnancy.”

Because clinicians use the definition of “last menstrual period” to
determine the start of the pregnancy, Nash did not expect any legal
challenges on those grounds — but the bill has other problems.

“What the Supreme Court has said is that states have the right to ban
abortion after viability, but that any ban on abortions after viability
must protect a woman’s life or health,” she told Raw Story. “So, a law
like this would be in conflict with those decisions in the sense that it
bans abortion much earlier than viability and does not take into
account the full ramifications of life and health.”

“This is a very dangerous bill,” Nash concluded.


I just mailed the icon I used for this poll to my senator along with my feelings on what the republicans are trying to do. My senator is a republican.

Add Photos & Videos

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest

  • Níl mé leat 2012/04/04 23:24:22
    Níl mé leat
    Someone didn't pass basic health and sex ed. in school.
  • Prog~Exterminator 2012/04/04 23:12:23
    Here we go again. Another misleading headline on SH.

    Since there is no way to establish the exact moment of conception, this bill sets the maximum legal abortion at 20 weeks past the last menstrual cycle. Seems like a pretty good way to remove the argument over what that day should be, which still allows abortions during the 20 week period after that date,.... which is still pretty disgusting if you've ever seen how far developed a fetus is at 20 weeks.
  • ὤTṻnde΄ӂ Prog~Ex... 2012/04/05 00:25:17
    Not misleading. You're reading into it what you want it say. I know the difference. I live in this state.
  • Prog~Ex... ὤTṻnde΄ӂ 2012/04/05 00:35:06 (edited)
    I don't care if you live on the moon, the bill is still written in English and all it does is establish a time-frame for those who want to murder their own flesh & blood.
  • Rusty Bubbles 2012/04/04 22:43:10
    Rusty Bubbles
    What the big deal with abortions, is it the "Thrill-of-the-Kill" for you supporters?

    abortion Thrill of the Kill
  • ὤTṻnde΄ӂ Rusty B... 2012/04/04 22:57:18
  • Rusty B... ὤTṻnde΄ӂ 2012/04/04 23:04:11
    Rusty Bubbles
    Not really, you're just too blinded by ideology or downright stupidity not to understand that Abortion as a medical procedure is like bloodletting, it's barbaric, outdated, and unnecessary.

    Roe vs Wade was 30 some years ago and medical science has come a long way since then giving women a large list of choices.....Why does abortion need to be one of them in today’s world....unless it's The-Thrill-of-the-kill

    Abstinence Birth Control Implant (Implanon)
    Birth Control Patch (Ortho Evra)
    Birth Control Pills Birth Control Shot (Depo-Provera)
    Birth Control Sponge (Today Sponge)
    Birth Control Vaginal Ring (NuvaRing)
    Breastfeeding as Birth Control Cervical Cap (FemCap)
    Female Condom
    Fertility Awareness-Based Methods (FAMs)
    Morning-After Pill (Emergency Contraception)
    Sterilization for Women
    Withdrawal (Pull Out) ~ not the best method

    and let's not forget the sexual education that is pushed starting in grade school

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2016/02/07 15:17:16

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals