Quantcast

GOP Wants to Cut EPA Budget by a Third: Is This a Smart Idea?

SodaHead Politics March 04, 2011 23:00:00
Related Topics: Deficit, Obama, NPR
You!
Add Photos & Videos
It’s no secret our nation is overwhelmed by red ink. So what’s the latest Washington brain storm to save us from slipping under the surface of a deficit-drowning pool?

Edging us toward possibly drowning in actual oceans of toxic sludge and rising tides by slashing the budget of the Environmental Protection Agency.

As the White House and House of Representatives face off in a showdown to see who can slash more programs to reduce the deficit, NPR reports that the Republican House majority's big idea is to drastically slash the EPA’s ability to regulate greenhouse gas emissions with spending cuts that the liberal radio network said “steamrolls the Obama administration's environmental policy.”

The House spending bill slashes the EPA budget by almost one-third, more than any other government agency, while gutting its ability to prevent water and air pollution and enforce environmental laws.

"They have essentially unleashed war against the EPA, and in doing so, they are going to hurt the American people. And we have to stop it," said Democratic Sen. Barbara Boxer, head of the Senate Environment Committee.

Republican Rep. Mike Simpson, head of the subcommittee responsible for the EPA's budget, responded that the House bill addresses Republican concerns that the EPA’s actions have cost jobs.

Among the amendments being offered are ones that would block the EPA’s ability to restore the historic Chesapeake Bay and Florida Everglades, clean up toxic coal ash waste and rein in destructive mountaintop coal mining.

It’s worth noting that Kansas Rep. Mike Pompeo, who has close ties to oil and gas giant Koch Industries, is the man behind the amendment to gut the EPA, notable since the cuts would greatly benefit the company that stands to make great gains if pollution regulations are diminished.

Can we afford to cut the EPA this deeply?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Morgan Orlins March 04, 2011 23:36:11 (edited)
    Yes
    Morgan Orlins
    +25
    We need to ELIMINATE the EPA, Department of Education, H.U.D., Department of Commerce, Homeland Security (FBI anyone?) and a number of other giant wasteful bureaucracies that are an enormous lead anchor which drags the bottom and inhibits the American economy.

    The EPA's job of limiting pollution could be done by local and federal law enforcement without increasing staff at all.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • MoonshineMotor53 June 08, 2011 21:10:06
    No
    MoonshineMotor53
    If you want big business to get away with making our environment even more inhabitable, you are an idiot.

    I'll keep my clean air and water.
  • Rotten Apples April 10, 2011 04:40:50 (edited)
    Undecided
    Rotten Apples
    goverment should be more rigorous on harmful waste fines this will prevent companies from slacking off on their toxic disposing, and the money should be used for improved quality of enviorenmental protection services

    its exactly what major industrial corporations wet dreams are made of, ways to eliminate toxic waste or harmful spills clean up spending, do you know how much money oilfield companies alone spend on cleaning and disposing of salt water, radiation, oil spills, etc? there are companies that provide this services. without governmental regulations, lots of people could be left unemployed...
  • georgeB April 08, 2011 16:36:38
    No
    georgeB
    I'm amazed how many people wanna gut the EPA. There are many comments about them being a corrupt agency, Al Gore-esque, etc., etc. What you don't realize is that they fund environmental monitoring projects for a wide range of areas/entities. Imagine all the funding going to monitor and protect Tribal lands. Now take that away, and you have departments that cannot function. Why would one want to cut something so vital to keeping tabs on air and water quality? Maybe we should look into reducing foreign aid or military spending first. Not that I am against those, I just think America needs to get its priorities straight. I certainly care more about the land around us than people in the Middle East or Northern Africa.
  • TheBrown April 01, 2011 00:28:14
    No
    TheBrown
    +3
    Cut EPA, education, NASA, and give the rich a tax break... If you make under 200k a year and vote republican you are out of your mind
  • Judson 3:16 March 25, 2011 13:55:54
    Yes
    Judson 3:16
    Cut it so deep they quit destroying economies the world politicians..Most people would love the EPA if the didn't take a minor truth and build a ginormous lie around it ..
  • easyeduri~PWCM~JLA March 21, 2011 18:09:35 (edited)
    Undecided
    easyeduri~PWCM~JLA
    It should abolish the EPA. Man up and defund it 100 %. Enough of the chicken tango. Defund this and any or all other agencies that are mere obstructionists to economic prosperity.
  • PeterB March 11, 2011 04:59:19 (edited)
    Yes
    PeterB
    A third is a good START! The EPA has been floundering for 20 years or more looking for justification for its own continued existence.

    "Give a small boy a hammer and he will find that everything he encounters needs pounding." ~ Kalan
  • Vicki PeterB March 15, 2011 06:53:29
    Vicki
    +1
    The EPA was floundering during the Bush administration because the GOP did not want them to do their job. Now with President Obama the EPA is back in business and doing good work. I really don't care about you Fox droolers who get no truth and only lies from Rupert's lying channel.
  • PeterB Vicki March 15, 2011 13:35:57
    PeterB
    Who said anything about Republicans or Democrats? Right away you have to inject politics into the discussion? Typical knee-jerk Liberal reaction! WAKE UP!
  • TheBrown PeterB April 01, 2011 00:21:47
    TheBrown
    +2
    The title of this article injected politics into the discussion... You lose
  • RogerRover March 09, 2011 13:19:08
    Undecided
    RogerRover
    +1
    EVERYTHING should be on the chopping block. States need their power back. DECENTRALIZE. STOP duplication, FRAUD, wrongheaded approaches that are killing this country. Dozens of departments have proven their need for ELIMINATION ENTIRELY. Let's get real. Call a spade a spade and go back to policies that really work. We are a great nation with great resources, great people, viable infrastructure. Washington, your approach and policies are flat out selling us down the river. Are their no leaders? We the people are sick and tired of abuse, waste and corruption.
  • USAF Vet March 09, 2011 10:41:51
    No
    USAF Vet
    +1
    Cut it by 90%, perhaps then, and only then, will the EPA will get back to it's original charter; clean air and water; not the control of your toilet.
  • Vicki USAF Vet May 01, 2011 21:55:02
    Vicki
    What a crazy comment. The EPA has to have funds to adequately do the job of protecting us from all the pollution and waste that corporations want in our water, air and land. People are victims of pollution right now with all the ailments that it causes from breathing ailments to heart attacks and stokes. The GOP against our environment and against keeping people healthy.
  • USAF Vet Vicki May 02, 2011 04:53:34
    USAF Vet
    Oh sure thing; you just posted the most moronical statement ever posted on SodaHead; basically you believe corporations are suicidal and want to pollute the water they and their children drink, and the air they breath; and the EPA needs more money, how much more? Enter an idiot like you, and blame it on Republicans, good God all mighty, what are you dolts going to fabricate next?
  • theiceman March 08, 2011 15:24:04
    Yes
    theiceman
    +1
    The best idea would be a total elimination of it!! 1/3 is 2/3's to little
  • Theresa March 08, 2011 01:20:21
    Yes
    Theresa
    +2
    Cut it completely out there is not a need for this all states have their own standards this is a total duplication! Remove it totally!
  • 0webama is Toast March 08, 2011 01:08:30
    Yes
    0webama is Toast
    +1
    Yes, Definitely.
    Another gov't agency that has grown too big for it's britches.
    Put a cap on the EPA before they deem illegal, what I exhale.
  • beavith1 March 07, 2011 21:23:51
    Yes
    beavith1
    +3
    “steamrolls the Obama administration's environmental policy.”

    because he couldn't pass a greenhouse gas law, he was enabling the EPA to do it administratively? and that steamrolls OBAMA's ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY?!?!? i'd call that the only defense the House could use, short of coming to some understanding WITH Obama.

    and then, of course, that ahole Boxer says "They have essentially unleashed war against the EPA,...'. I would ask who fired the first shot? Obama and Lisa Jackson.


    I watched The Untouchables' this weekend. all i can think when i read this story is' just like a dumb _____ to bring a knife to a gunfight.'

    fill in the blank...
  • halee23 March 07, 2011 20:54:15
    No
    halee23
    +3
    Hmm, what's more important? Money or life? Oh yeah, forgot I live in the U.S.
    Money trumps all.
  • Morgan ... halee23 March 07, 2011 21:30:25 (edited)
    Morgan Orlins
    +3
    Another stupid post. This one is argumentation by false choice. You can choose MONEY, or your LIFE. Almost like a carjacking.
    The assumption from Ms. Deep as a Puddle is that if you agree that the EPA is out of control and needs to be reined-in, you are a heartless money grubber who doesn't care if people die from pollution.

    That thinking is fine for Sesame Street, it fails in the real world, where we are AFFLICTED by an out-of-control government that is doing horrendous damage to the America economy. And the EPA is one of the enforcement arms of the Statist assault on our way of life.
  • halee23 Morgan ... March 09, 2011 21:07:21
    halee23
    Ouch, someone's bitter.
  • Morgan ... halee23 March 10, 2011 02:54:03
    Morgan Orlins
    +2
    Stupidity causes MANY "ouches."
  • halee23 Morgan ... March 10, 2011 04:27:10
    halee23
    As does fear and insecurity.
  • Vicki Morgan ... March 15, 2011 06:55:23
    Vicki
    It is fine for any American who has more intelligence than the right wing posters on this site.
  • Vicki Morgan ... May 01, 2011 21:57:49
    Vicki
    God you people are idiots and I mean idiots. The EPA is making sure right now that the billionaires behind the GOP attacks on the EPA do not result in the end of civilization as we know it. Do any of you live near a coal plant? No I do not think so.
  • Morgan ... Vicki May 02, 2011 11:13:27
    Morgan Orlins
    Vicki, you're an IMPRESSIVE poster, a real intellect. LMAO!!
  • PeterB halee23 March 11, 2011 05:03:01
    PeterB
    It's not an either/ or.
  • Ozzyboy March 07, 2011 20:50:00
    Yes
    Ozzyboy
    +3
    But I agree with Gingrich that it should be eliminated completely. If you ever get to DC, go see their building, it would make you sick to your stomach. It is self worshipping that goes beyond imagination. Let the states take care of their problems.
  • Morgan ... Ozzyboy March 08, 2011 13:30:56
    Morgan Orlins
    Many of the monstrous edifices in DC are that way. You know what the Gipper said about eternal life...
  • Vicki Ozzyboy March 15, 2011 06:57:50
    Vicki
    Well I don't and I don't trust one word out of Gingrich's lying rotten mouth. The EPA is going to have continued funding because Democrats will fund it and the right wing fools of the republIcan party will not get their way wrecking and ruining more of America.
  • Ozzyboy Vicki March 15, 2011 14:06:28
    Ozzyboy
    +1
    Whether you trust/like Gingrich or not isn't the issue. He is just proposing the elimination of EPA altogether instead of cutting it down one third. What that self serving disgusting entity is doing to the Republicans. It is about control, greed and squeezing workers to death with stupid rules and permits. Pay attention!
  • claptonluvr March 07, 2011 20:04:39
    Yes
    claptonluvr
    +4
    My only question is why only by a third?! The EPA is nothing more than another corrupt arm of the liberal left. They have imposed ridiuclous limitations and sanctions (many of them based on "global warming" issues that don't exist) on American businesses and forced many to leave the country.
  • Vicki clapton... March 15, 2011 07:00:15
    Vicki
    +1
    You are a nitwit. You have no idea how important the EPA is to our safety. The right wing are dumb, but fortunately there are more intelligent people on a lot of other sites who value government oversight for America.
  • t.eliot, topbard March 07, 2011 19:35:13
    No
    t.eliot, topbard
    +1
    This is a terrible idea. The EPA is flawed, but our world is going to environmental hell and needs all the protection it can find. We are run amok and close to leaving our children a wasteland.
  • Theresa t.eliot... March 08, 2011 01:23:16
    Theresa
    +1
    You do realize that every State has their own standards so that nothing important would be affected if this EPA agency left?
  • Vicki Theresa March 15, 2011 07:02:01
    Vicki
    +1
    Wrong. States do not all have the good sense or the basic humanity to want the EPA doing their jobs. They can be just as corrupt and just as bought by corporate greed to allow the pollution and ruin of all that is necessary for life.
  • Theresa Vicki March 15, 2011 07:10:11
    Theresa
    That is precisely for Class Action lawsuits! If they damage someone!
  • Vicki Theresa May 01, 2011 22:01:10
    Vicki
    No, every state does not have the same standards or the same good ideas or concern for this country's air, land and water. Dream on Faux stooge where the billionaires give their raw sewage to the morons in the republican basement.
  • PeterB t.eliot... March 11, 2011 05:09:48
    PeterB
    +1
    The EPA has been floundering for 20 years or more looking for justification for its own continued existence.

    "Give a small boy a hammer and he will find that everything he encounters needs pounding." ~ Kalan
  • freethinker March 07, 2011 19:11:49
    Yes
    freethinker
    +1
    NPR???? hahahaha!
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 34 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.
Loading map...

News & Politics

May 25, 2012 19:40:33