SodaHead Celebrates Green Week

Question US

Every president since Woodrow Wilson has sent a wreath to the Arlington Confederate Memorial on or close to Memorial Day. Should President Obama continue this tradition?

Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!! May 21, 2009 05:14:17

The Confederate Memorial was erected in Arlington National Cemetery to honor the Civil War's Confederate dead, who had long been excluded from the graveyard in favor of Union soldiers. It is located on the far east side of the cemetery. The 32-foot memorial features a woman crowned with olive leaves, gesturing to the South to acknowledge the sacrifice made by her fallen sons.


woman crowned olive leaves gesturing south acknowledge sacrifice fallen sons

At the Confederate Memorial
Arlington National Cemetery, Virginia
May 25, 1924


If I am correctly informed by history, it is fitting that the Sabbath should be your Memorial Day. This follows from the belief that except for the forces of Oliver Cromwell no army was ever more thoroughly religious than that which followed General Lee. Moreover, these ceremonies necessarily are expressive of a hope and a belief that rise above the things of this life. It was Lincoln who pointed out that both sides prayed to the same God. When that is the case, it is only a matter of time when each will seek a common end. We can now see clearly what that end is. It is the maintenance of our American form of government, of our American institutions, of our American ideals, beneath a common flag, under the blessings of Almighty God.

It was for this purpose that our Nation was brought forth. Our whole course of history has been proceeding in that direction. Out of a common experience, made more enduring by a common sacrifice, we have reached a common conviction. On this day we pause in memory of those who made their sacrifice in one way. In a few days we shall pause again in memory of those who made their sacrifice in another way. They were all Americans, all contending for what they believed were their rights. On many a battle field they sleep side by side. Here, in a place set aside for the resting place of those who have performed military duty, both make a final bivouac. But their country lives.

The bitterness of conflict is passed. Time has softened it; discretion has changed it. Your country respects you for cherishing the memory of those who wore the gray. You respect others who cherish the memory of those who wore the blue. In that mutual respect may there be a firmer friendship, a stronger and more glorious Union.

When I delivered the address dedicating the great monument to General Grant in the city of Washington, General Carr was present, with others of his comrades, and responded for the Confederacy with a most appropriate tribute. He has lately passed away, one of the last of a talented and gallant corps of officers. To the memory of him whom I had seen and heard and knew as the representative of that now silent throng, whom I did not know, I offer my tribute. We know that Providence would have it so. We see and we obey. A mightier force than ever followed Grant or Lee has leveled both their hosts, raised up an united Nation, and made us all partakers of a new glory. It is not for us to forget the past but to remember it, that we may profit by it. But it is gone; we cannot change it. We must put our emphasis on the present and put into effect the lessons the past has taught us. All about us sleep; those of many different beliefs and many divergent actions. But America claims them all. Her flag floats over them all. Her Government protects them all. They all rest in the same divine peace.
Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
No: The monument is meant to glorify the Confederacy.
Not sure, don't know enough about the memorial.
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Comment
  • +5 raves Gun665 May 21, 2009 05:19:34
    Gun665

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    He hasn't shown any respect for any of the military so far, so what's one more slap in the face? As far as it being a "Confederate" memorial, please try and remember it was STILL the Confederate States of America (they were STILL Americans).
    View thread
Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Comments
  • +3 raves
    Marlow ~ Let There Be Light May 21, 2009 11:10:49
    Marlow ~ Let There Be Light

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    Sure. If all Presidents have done it, why not. I don't think it condones succession.
  • +2 raves
    Mike May 21, 2009 11:07:14
    Mike

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    moderated...
  • +1 raves
    FloydFreak May 21, 2009 10:43:09
    FloydFreak

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    He should - but I'm sure he WON'T.

    BTW: Not to nitpick...but it is "secession" - not "succession".
  • +1 raves
    Poetic ... FloydFreak May 25, 2009 22:03:42
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    Thanks for correcting that I know it is secession but that answer was copied and pasted and I did not look at it before posting.
  • +2 raves
    Desert Cloud May 21, 2009 08:17:30 (edited)
    Desert Cloud

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    BO snubbed the Salute To Heroes Ball, which honors all the Medal Of Honor recipients, on inauguration day to hang with the MTV party crowd.
  • +1 raves
    Poetic ... Desert ... May 25, 2009 21:49:18 (edited)
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    We need to honor the men who have fallen in our country, the Confederacy did not secede based solely on slavery, but much to the same thing that is happening today where states rights are being trampled upon.
  • +1 raves
    Desert ... Poetic ... May 26, 2009 20:48:59
    Desert Cloud
    My apologies my friend. I'm sorry.
  • +3 raves
    sky blue pink - American May 21, 2009 08:12:37
    sky blue pink - American

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    Keep the Tradition moving.
  • +3 raves
    Dylan "Where's John Galt?" May 21, 2009 07:38:21
    Dylan

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    But I don't think he will....
  • +2 raves
    Poetic ... Dylan "... May 21, 2009 07:39:01
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    you may be right.
  • +2 raves
    bob May 21, 2009 06:49:23
    bob

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    Would it really surprize you if he didn't ??
  • +3 raves
    Poetic ... bob May 21, 2009 07:13:16
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    Would not surprise me at all.
  • +2 raves
    cmdrbnd007 May 21, 2009 05:49:38
    cmdrbnd007

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    Surely he will.
  • +1 raves
    Poetic ... cmdrbnd007 May 21, 2009 05:50:55 (edited)
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    It is hard to tell with this guy man, but hopefully he will.
  • +1 raves
    cmdrbnd007 Poetic ... May 21, 2009 05:54:48
    cmdrbnd007
    That's true but that would really be a break in tradition and many veterans would be offended as well as many regular citizens.
  • +2 raves
    Poetic ... cmdrbnd007 May 21, 2009 05:55:59
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    I agree with you my friend.
  • +3 raves
    RhinoRT May 21, 2009 05:39:45
    RhinoRT

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    They were Americans fighting and dying for for what they believed, But like Gun665 said he hasn't shown any respect so far what makes anyone think he will start now.
    I will be more surprised if he does than if he doesn't.
  • +2 raves
    Poetic ... RhinoRT May 21, 2009 05:44:07
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    Thanks for stopping by and responding rhino.
  • Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    I first thought that this should not be done, but have since thought about this and think that President Obama should honor the fallen men who died in the Civil War that pitted brother against brother and father against son.
  • +5 raves
    Gun665 May 21, 2009 05:19:34
    Gun665

    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.

    He hasn't shown any respect for any of the military so far, so what's one more slap in the face? As far as it being a "Confederate" memorial, please try and remember it was STILL the Confederate States of America (they were STILL Americans).
  • +4 raves
    Poetic ... Gun665 May 21, 2009 05:24:55 (edited)
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    Yes I agree with you Gun. They should be honored they were still Americans and deserve the respect that fallen soldiers deserve.
  • +3 raves
    FloydFreak Gun665 May 21, 2009 10:44:32
    FloydFreak
    Absolutely! Come to think of it, he has shown little respect for the vast majority of patriotic Americans.
  • Marine Vet Gun665 May 23, 2009 13:29:01
    Marine Vet
    you obviously missed his teleconference on inauguration with the troops in Iraq. But of course you are some right wing neo-fascist moron so what can I expect?
  • +2 raves
    Poetic ... Marine Vet May 24, 2009 04:20:05
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    Hey man you don't have to get nasty dude. All views are welcome here, I don't block anybody for saying their opinion, but will block people for nasty comments and vulgarity and such things, so please be respectful.
  • Marine Vet Poetic ... May 24, 2009 12:52:15
    Marine Vet
    most of these people are disrespecting the current President of the United States and you have nothing to say. I identify morons without a clue who are traitors to this country's ideals and are budding fascists and you want to rein me in? Great. I put on a uniform for this country, defended the Constitution, wounded twice, but morons and cowards that avoided service can say anything they want without a peep from you. Hypocrite
  • +1 raves
    Poetic ... Marine Vet May 25, 2009 21:47:13 (edited)
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    When I see comments that are offending or disrespectful to please not do so. So sometimes I don't catch some comments because I am always doing a lot of things when I am online and like I said sometimes I miss stuff so I apologize for that.
  • +1 raves
    Gun665 Marine Vet May 24, 2009 04:46:07
    Gun665
    One knows another, jarhead.
  • +2 raves
    Poetic ... Gun665 May 25, 2009 22:14:49
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    Well one thing is for sure, I love it when they call me Jarhead.
  • +1 raves
    Gun665 Poetic ... May 25, 2009 23:58:44
    Gun665
    I was referring to the Marine. (If you were a Marine as well, feel free to accept the moniker, "Jarhead".)
  • +2 raves
    Poetic ... Gun665 May 26, 2009 07:19:24
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    Sure not a problem served from 81-84, you can also call me leatherneck, or devil dog....the choice is yours....lol...all titles that I proudly wear.
  • Marine Vet Gun665 May 25, 2009 21:25:37
    Marine Vet
    Obama: ‘We Have Failed’ To Give Vets The ‘Support They Need Or Pay Them The Respect They Deserve’
    http://thinkprogress.org/2009...

    Bite me
  • +1 raves
    Poetic ... Marine Vet May 25, 2009 22:16:33
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    Thanks for posting that link it showed me a little bit that he may be coming around to honoring our vets. Oh by the way thanks for your service to our country.
  • Marine Vet Poetic ... May 25, 2009 23:06:26
    Marine Vet
    he has ALWAYS honored our vets you damn fool
  • +1 raves
    Poetic ... Marine Vet May 25, 2009 23:07:10
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    Okay dude if you say so.
  • Marine Vet Poetic ... May 26, 2009 09:43:05
    Marine Vet
    why don't you do your own research and stop depending on the right wing echo chamber
  • +1 raves
    Poetic ... Marine Vet May 26, 2009 09:47:44
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    I do research on everything that I post man, I just posted this question to see how others feel and what they think. That is why we post questions here isn't it.
  • Gun665 Marine Vet May 25, 2009 23:59:12
    Gun665
    No thanks, no telling where you've been.
  • -1 raves
    Marine Vet Gun665 May 25, 2009 22:13:31
    Marine Vet
    Obama observes Memorial Day at Arlington cemetery
    By Darlene Superville, Associated Press Writer
    WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama avoided a racial controversy on his first Memorial Day in office by sending wreaths to separate memorials for Confederate soldiers and for blacks who fought against them during the Civil War.
    http://content.usatoday.net/d...

    So you hateful bastards got it wrong AGAIN!! Ain't reality a bitch!!
  • +2 raves
    Poetic ... Marine Vet May 25, 2009 22:27:56
    Poetic Warrior is back with a vengeance!!
    I am glad that he has done so, shows that he has some respect for the dead at least.
  • Marine Vet Poetic ... May 25, 2009 23:10:13
    Marine Vet
    yeah he honored traitors to this country. He should be ashamed. but what can you expect from someone willing to ignore the crimes of the last Administration. I am so disappointed in Obama. Just shows we are not a nation of laws, only us ordinary folks have to obey the laws, if you are rich and powerful you can get away with anything. And don't tell me they were protecting us. And don't tell me those traitors that wore the uniform of the Confederacy were Americans or heroes, they betrayed this nation and those that honor them continue that betrayal.
or
Cancel