Quantcast

Every president since Woodrow Wilson has sent a wreath to the Arlington Confederate Memorial on or close to Memorial Day. Should President Obama continue this tradition?

Poetic Warrior May 21, 2009 05:14:17
Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
No: The monument is meant to glorify the Confederacy.
Not sure, don't know enough about the memorial.
You!
Add Photos & Videos
The Confederate Memorial was erected in Arlington National Cemetery to honor the Civil War's Confederate dead, who had long been excluded from the graveyard in favor of Union soldiers. It is located on the far east side of the cemetery. The 32-foot memorial features a woman crowned with olive leaves, gesturing to the South to acknowledge the sacrifice made by her fallen sons.


woman crowned olive leaves gesturing south acknowledge sacrifice fallen sons

At the Confederate Memorial
Arlington National Cemetery, Virginia
May 25, 1924


If I am correctly informed by history, it is fitting that the Sabbath should be your Memorial Day. This follows from the belief that except for the forces of Oliver Cromwell no army was ever more thoroughly religious than that which followed General Lee. Moreover, these ceremonies necessarily are expressive of a hope and a belief that rise above the things of this life. It was Lincoln who pointed out that both sides prayed to the same God. When that is the case, it is only a matter of time when each will seek a common end. We can now see clearly what that end is. It is the maintenance of our American form of government, of our American institutions, of our American ideals, beneath a common flag, under the blessings of Almighty God.

It was for this purpose that our Nation was brought forth. Our whole course of history has been proceeding in that direction. Out of a common experience, made more enduring by a common sacrifice, we have reached a common conviction. On this day we pause in memory of those who made their sacrifice in one way. In a few days we shall pause again in memory of those who made their sacrifice in another way. They were all Americans, all contending for what they believed were their rights. On many a battle field they sleep side by side. Here, in a place set aside for the resting place of those who have performed military duty, both make a final bivouac. But their country lives.

The bitterness of conflict is passed. Time has softened it; discretion has changed it. Your country respects you for cherishing the memory of those who wore the gray. You respect others who cherish the memory of those who wore the blue. In that mutual respect may there be a firmer friendship, a stronger and more glorious Union.

When I delivered the address dedicating the great monument to General Grant in the city of Washington, General Carr was present, with others of his comrades, and responded for the Confederacy with a most appropriate tribute. He has lately passed away, one of the last of a talented and gallant corps of officers. To the memory of him whom I had seen and heard and knew as the representative of that now silent throng, whom I did not know, I offer my tribute. We know that Providence would have it so. We see and we obey. A mightier force than ever followed Grant or Lee has leveled both their hosts, raised up an united Nation, and made us all partakers of a new glory. It is not for us to forget the past but to remember it, that we may profit by it. But it is gone; we cannot change it. We must put our emphasis on the present and put into effect the lessons the past has taught us. All about us sleep; those of many different beliefs and many divergent actions. But America claims them all. Her flag floats over them all. Her Government protects them all. They all rest in the same divine peace.
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Gun665 May 21, 2009 05:19:34
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    Gun665
    +5
    moderated...

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Bourne May 26, 2009 17:45:17
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    Bourne
    +1
    another one, it will not end, one thing it does show is racial prejudice and it is divisive, I thought He said He wanted to bring us all together! racial prejudice divisive
  • jim May 25, 2009 23:48:56
    No: The monument is meant to glorify the Confederacy.
    jim
    While I don't think he should, he did because he understood that denying a handful of stupid, racist, knucckledraggers a reason to spew their nonsense is worth the cost of a crappy wreath. Personally, I think the monument should be bulldozed and something more appropriate put in its place that honors the dead but not the evil the sought to defend.
  • Marine Vet May 23, 2009 13:27:14
    No: The monument is meant to glorify the Confederacy.
    Marine Vet
    why honor traitors to this country. The monument should be destroyed along with any vestiage of the traitorous Confederacy. And anyone that still supports the Confederacy should be charged with sedition, put on trial and executed.
  • Poetic ... Marine Vet May 24, 2009 04:17:28 (edited)
    Poetic Warrior
    +2
    Man dude that is kind of harsh. But your opinion is more than welcome here that is why I posted this question.
  • myssabz May 22, 2009 03:37:30
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    myssabz
    +2
    He should, they were Americans fighting for what they thought was right, but he doesnt tend to honor our military so I cannot imagine him starting that now.
  • Poetic ... myssabz May 25, 2009 21:54:41
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    Maybe not, but we can always hope that he will do the right thing by the people of America.
  • bacon bits May 21, 2009 19:34:44
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    bacon bits
    +1
    He should...
  • CampDavid †DEO VALENTI † May 21, 2009 17:33:13
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    CampDavid †DEO VALENTI †
    +2
    What has "O" done yet to bring honor or respect to America or Americans? Can we expect him to start now?
    I Expect him to declare it a hate crime for anyone to show respect for these fallen. And he will add them to his list of domestic terrorists.
    expect declare hate crime respect fallen add list domestic terrorists
  • Poetic ... CampDav... May 25, 2009 21:56:49
    Poetic Warrior
    +2
    Maybe so Camp, but I will say this I have respect for the office that he stands in and therefore I will not bash him in anyway. I am reminded of David, even though Saul sought his life he would not touch the anointed of God. Now I am speaking of the office that he stands is as anointed, because for whatever reason God allowed him to get elected.
  • CampDav... Poetic ... May 29, 2009 04:39:30
    CampDavid †DEO VALENTI †
    +1
    Excellent point. I am just know reading thru 1st & 2nd Samuel for my nightly reading. :)
  • Poetic ... CampDav... May 29, 2009 04:54:07
    Poetic Warrior
    +2
    Great story about that man who was after God's own heart, he respected the office that Saul stood in so much that even when Saul was seeking his life he would not lay his hand of God's anointed. I remember when David cut a piece of Saul's garment, he was very sad about doing so.
  • CampDav... Poetic ... May 29, 2009 19:55:51
    CampDavid †DEO VALENTI †
    +1
    And talk about "killing the messenger"! When Saul died, the poor messenger thought he was bringing good news to David, but he found out different.
  • Poetic ... CampDav... May 30, 2009 05:47:35
    Poetic Warrior
    +2
    You got that right my friend.
  • kalynn May 21, 2009 17:13:42
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    kalynn
    +2
    He should, but don't hold your breath. He has such disdain for anything military.
  • Poetic ... kalynn May 25, 2009 21:58:03
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    Well we really don't know his heart and as such I can not judge him even though it may appear that he does what goes against my beliefs. I don't agree with him on everything but I respect the office that he stands in.
  • Antarctican Pride 101 May 21, 2009 17:03:58
    Not sure, don't know enough about the memorial.
    Antarctican Pride 101
    +1
    No, they fought to keep slavery.
  • Poetic ... Antarct... May 25, 2009 21:59:53
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    The slavery issue was not a factor in the Civil War until the Emancipation Proclamation. The Confederate states seceded from the union over the issue of states rights and the power of state governments to totally rule over its land and decide its own issues.
  • Vnvet May 21, 2009 15:42:31
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    Vnvet
    +1
    It is for those that had a part in making this country what it is but, giving it's Obie he'll just blow it like so many other things in his life.
  • Poetic ... Vnvet May 25, 2009 22:00:42
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    Let us hope that he does the right thing.
  • boneman1 May 21, 2009 14:29:50
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    boneman1
    +1
    I hope he does. I didn't vote for him, but since he is our president I continue to hope he does what's best for the country. So far I'm not feeling very confident that what's best for the country is on his agenda.
  • Poetic ... boneman1 May 25, 2009 22:00:17
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    Amen I hope that he will always do the right thing.
  • loony t May 21, 2009 14:08:30
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    loony t
    +1
    He should but i doubt he will. If by some strange means one winds up there it probably won't be from Obama.
  • Poetic ... loony t May 25, 2009 22:01:14
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    Maybe so, but if it is his representative it will still be, technically from him.
  • Foo Master Angie May 21, 2009 13:46:08
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    Foo Master Angie
    +1
    I'm sure a wreath will be sent, and he will have nothing to do with it. One of his political cronies will make sure it gets done.
  • Poetic ... Foo Mas... May 25, 2009 22:01:39
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    Well let us hope and pray that he does what is best for the healing of our nation.
  • irish --only ron paul 2012 May 21, 2009 13:29:09
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    irish --only  ron paul  2012
    +1
    but coming from someone who is so dishonorable himself it would be a sham wouldn't it? he wouldn't even visit the normandy beach memorial when he was on his grand apology tour! he doesn't respect america or americans. visit normandy beach memorial grand apology tour respect america americans
  • Poetic ... irish -... May 25, 2009 21:53:44
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    Well you are certainly entitled to you opinion, but I will not bash the President, I respect the office that he is in and therefore I will not bash him. Although I don't agree with his views and most of his political stances, I will not resort to saying he is dishonorable or anything like that because I do not know his heart. I would say though that he tends to lean against my views of morality and thoughts.
  • irish -... Poetic ... May 27, 2009 04:38:19
    irish --only  ron paul  2012
    to respect the office you have to respect the person . he deserves no respect after his apology tour.
  • Poetic ... irish -... May 28, 2009 05:47:03
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    No you don't, you respect the office for which he stands in, that does not mean you have to agree with him or even like him. IMO
  • irish -... Poetic ... May 28, 2009 11:14:21
    irish --only  ron paul  2012
    +1
    i don't respect anyone in government anymore office or person.
  • Bourne irish -... May 26, 2009 17:47:58
    Bourne
    He is going to rip this country into pieces by renewing old old bias, what a bigot
  • Israelite May 21, 2009 13:11:04
    Not sure, don't know enough about the memorial.
    Israelite
    +2
    he has no honor and thus it would be a disgrace coming from him.
  • Poetic ... Israelite May 25, 2009 21:51:47
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    I do not support the President's political views, but I still have respect for the office that he stands in, and as having such respect I will not bash him.
  • Extremist Soldier of Christ May 21, 2009 12:53:01
    Not sure, don't know enough about the memorial.
    Extremist Soldier of Christ
    +4
    No...I think we should change the tradition- Let Obama put his birth certificate on it and tell the people that you don't need to be a citizen and die for this great land. Just pay the people and use big black national liberation thugs to scare you at the polls. Let this replace the wreath. pay people black national liberation thugs scare polls replace wreath
  • Poetic ... Extremi... May 25, 2009 21:50:49
    Poetic Warrior
    +1
    I appreciate your views my friend but do me a favor and watch your bashing of the president. I did not post this question to bash him, but rather to find out what people think about honoring the dead confederates who died in the civil war.
  • stillhappytobeinourcountry May 21, 2009 12:18:01
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    stillhappytobeinourcountry
    +1
    Memorial Day is founded on the principles to give honor and to remember all of our veterans who served for our country. This is a respectful tradition that all of our Presidents acknowledged..He is supposed to honor our country and what It represents. This is a part of who we are and It is only showing consideration for our veterans.We must remember and pay tribute and so should he!
  • RON stillha... May 21, 2009 13:51:02
    RON
    +1
    Im a little confused. How did the confederates die for our country? Isnt the opposite, true? I can understand , POLITICALLY, why a president of the United States would send a wreath to a CONFEDERATE war memorial. But LOGICALLY its seems kind of ridiculous,
  • Robin May 21, 2009 11:49:30
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    Robin
    +1
    It's a character issue, really. I'm not sure he has it yet but I'm not convinced he completely lacks it either.
  • Poetic ... Robin May 25, 2009 22:02:27
    Poetic Warrior
    +2
    Yes only time will tell how he really is and I hope and pray that he is/becomes a good president.
  • Tiffany May 21, 2009 11:35:22
    Yes: The tradition honors the dead, it doesn't legitimize succession.
    Tiffany
    +2
    He probally wont though....
    tradition honors dead legitimize succession probally

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.
Loading map...

News & Politics

May 25, 2012 06:20:08