Quantcast

Does 'Stand Your Ground' Law Need to Be Amended?

SodaHead News 2012/03/20 23:29:30
You!
Add Photos & Videos
George Zimmerman, 28, shot and killed 17-year-old Trayvon Martin in a gated community on February 26. The details of the shooting are vague and more than a little suspicious, but the case was thrust into the public forum when Zimmerman called upon Florida's 2005 "Stand Your Ground" law, claiming he shot the boy in self-defense. Now the case is going before a grand jury, and Zimmerman is still a free man.

Zimmerman was a neighborhood watch volunteer, and had called the police several times over the last few months to complain about break-ins and kids playing in the street. In a police recording from the day of the shooting, Zimmerman reported a "suspicious black male" whom he was following. Police told him not to follow, to which Zimmerman replied, "These a------s always get away." A lawyer for the Martin family says there was a 16-year-old girl on the phone with Martin just before the shooting, and claims the boy expressed concern about being followed.

Jeffrey Bellin, who teaches law at Southern Methodist University, described the "Stand Your Ground" law to NPR: "As long as you are somewhere you have a lawful right to be, if someone attacks you, the words of the statute are you can meet force with force, including deadly force, if you reasonably believe that that is necessary." What do you think about the "Stand Your Ground" law?

zimmerman martin
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • wilsonmja 2012/03/21 00:27:54
    No
    wilsonmja
    +48
    The stand your ground law is fine. The crime stats in Florida prove that. This man's actions are not protected under the stand your ground law. He wasn't attacked.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Lana critter171 2012/04/02 00:41:59
  • critter171 Lana 2012/04/02 01:10:23
    critter171
    +1
    too bad it take them forever to change those laws but the laws now we need to stop profling people. we need to judge base off a person action not color of skin or what sex there under. even if they had an "opreation"
  • Lana critter171 2012/04/02 01:13:54
    Lana
    +1
    Very true and I couldn't agree with you more. I would like to see everybody get a fair shake. Even if we find it goes the other way, people just need to cut the crap and do the right thing.
  • Lisa 2012/03/20 23:42:53 (edited)
    No
    Lisa
    +6
    well some people can tend to lack common sense
  • critter171 Lisa 2012/03/20 23:47:24
    critter171
    why only america? what about that shooting that killed two young kids i believe? common sense is lack all over the world not just america your making a sterotype out of americans
  • Lisa critter171 2012/03/21 00:01:04
    Lisa
    +2
    I'm very sorry, that was an ignorant thing for me to say
  • critter171 Lisa 2012/03/21 02:08:08
    critter171
    +2
    It happens no hard feelings there a lot of that
  • cutter'... Lisa 2012/03/21 00:30:09
    cutter's falls
    +1
    especially in America
    I resent that remark
    have you seen the whole sale slaughter in Seria?
    here is some Common Sense
    but it came with price
  • Lisa cutter'... 2012/03/21 00:33:44
    Lisa
    +3
    I know, again I'm sorry for saying that.
  • cutter'... Lisa 2012/03/21 00:42:28
    cutter's falls
    +2
    young lady,
    your apology is welcome news :)
    here this is for you

    tips my hat..mam
  • Lisa cutter'... 2012/03/21 00:44:01
    Lisa
    +1
    lol why thank you
  • Gracie - Proud Conservative 2012/03/20 23:42:29
    No
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    +3
    It was either self defense or it wasn't and that will be determined in the legal system. Do you think someone should be able to defend themselves or just be prey?
  • critter171 Gracie ... 2012/03/20 23:48:02
    critter171
    +1
    there no self defense that is in this story and it needs to be updated
  • Gracie ... critter171 2012/03/21 00:06:07
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    +1
    Then he'll be arrested and charged but it doesn't have anything to do with the law. I've seen people arrested and charged for defending themselves in their own homes. That is what this law is trying to eliminate. I just saw where an old man was charged for shooting a warning shot to stop an invader! If someone threatens me great harm, I'm shooting them.
  • critter171 Gracie ... 2012/03/21 02:09:46
    critter171
    +1
    yes he has to do with the law since he said it was self defense if this law was not in there book he would and should of been charged on the spot. he should of been arested go ahead and shoot you have a right to protect yourself under the consutution you don't need a state law to say that.
  • Gracie ... critter171 2012/03/21 02:31:47
    Gracie - Proud Conservative
    You're contradicting yourself.
  • critter171 Gracie ... 2012/03/21 15:00:49
    critter171
    not really
  • Geenie ... Gracie ... 2012/03/21 20:37:03
    Geenie Nabottle
    Well in this case looks like the kid who got shot was they prey and this Zimmerman whacko was hunter!
  • JMCC 2012/03/20 23:41:49
    Yes
    JMCC
    +2
    Many that live deserve death. And some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them?
  • Blunder... JMCC 2012/03/27 19:25:49
    BlunderWoman ~ FTGOP~ BN 0
    +1
    No, Gandalf. I can't!
  • JMCC Blunder... 2012/05/23 21:38:46
    JMCC
    +1
    :)

    Well done for identifying the quote!!!
  • Blunder... JMCC 2012/05/23 21:40:42
    BlunderWoman ~ FTGOP~ BN 0
    Well, it is among my favorite books. :)
  • Mog of War 2012/03/20 23:41:42
    No
    Mog of War
    +3
    Not just yet. The claims have not yet gone in the man's favor, and the case he's trying to build against the victim will only prove that this murder was premeditated. If this guy's gambit backfires, he could end up getting charged in a capitol case, and the death penalty would be on the table.
  • KLTLUVRLT1 Mog of War 2012/03/20 23:44:56
    KLTLUVRLT1
    +2
    Capital murder, yes. Life in prison, yes. Death penalty, no. The death penalty has no place in a civilized society. Justice for Trayvon Martin!
  • critter171 KLTLUVRLT1 2012/03/20 23:48:52
    critter171
    so your fine with being able to defend yourself but not death plenty?
  • KLTLUVRLT1 critter171 2012/03/20 23:56:45
    KLTLUVRLT1
    +2
    The bastard that murdered Trayvon Martin was not defending himself. The SOB is a cold-blooded murderer, and should be held accountable. However, I am adamantly opposed to all forms of murder, including state's sanctioned murders.
  • critter171 KLTLUVRLT1 2012/03/21 02:11:02
    critter171
    i don't agree death plenty is needed to stop cold killers will zimmerman get that no way in hell....
  • KLTLUVRLT1 critter171 2012/03/21 02:44:47
    KLTLUVRLT1
    How will the death penalty stop Zimmermann more effectively than lifetime incarceration? The bastard has already committed murder. The death penalty is not a deterrent. The sole purpose of the death penalty is to exact revenge. The government should not be in the revenge business. The government role in these matters is to protect society from violent criminals. We can accomplish that objective without resorting to murder - albeit legalized murder.
  • critter171 KLTLUVRLT1 2012/03/21 15:02:22
    critter171
    there no soul porouspe of gettin revegae with the death plenty its for people who show no caring for other lifes and could care less about there faith those people derseve to be sentence to death. your jumping to assumption that is when many states don't have those type of laws anymore. But i guess its ok.... since you what every damn murder to be alive even he pose a threat to the peopel.
  • KLTLUVRLT1 critter171 2012/03/22 00:08:08
    KLTLUVRLT1
    The predmeditated killing of a human being - any human being - is a cold-blooded act of murder. Would you feel safe living next door to an executioner? He, too, is capable of murder.
  • critter171 KLTLUVRLT1 2012/03/22 02:09:44
    critter171
    legal by law no i wouldn't be worried murder is not murder when its legal
  • KLTLUVRLT1 critter171 2012/03/22 05:45:13
    KLTLUVRLT1
    Killing in self defense to protect yourself from being killed is not murder.
    Killing when there is a real and clear imminent threat to the lives of others is not murder.
    Killing in defense of your country is not murder.
    Killing because someone angered you, or you don't like their looks is murder.
    Killing because of religious or political beliefs is murder.
    Killing for the sole purpose of revenge or vengeance is cold-blooded murder.
    Killing (voluntaraily) for profit (executioners) is murder.
  • Mog of War KLTLUVRLT1 2012/03/21 00:00:09
    Mog of War
    +3
    A society that will not kill to defend itself will be killed by those who will seek its destruction. Those who will kill until they are killed themselves will inevitably destroy any nation unwilling to kill self-defense. Would you not put to death men who perpetrate acts of genocide or mass murder? Does the scale of an offense actually decide the severity of the punishment? What is an apt way if dealing with these people if they are allowed to live, and potentially be let go? These are not easy questions to answer, nor do I care to impose my answer upon you, but you must be willing to spare the lives of genocidal madmen, pedophile rapists, and torturous sadists of all other walks of life to truly oppose the death penalty. This is not to impugn your morals in the slightest, but simply posit that such is a harder road.

    Besides, It is not you or I who dictate whether the death penalty is on the table, but the State of Florida. My statements here are more often pragmatic than ideological.
  • KLTLUVRLT1 Mog of War 2012/03/21 02:50:28
    KLTLUVRLT1
    Leading Death Penalty countries: China, USA (primarily in TX), Iran, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Iraq, North Korea, Nigeria, Sudan, etc.

    Countries that abolished the death penalty: Russia, Great Britain, Germany, France, Italy, Spain, South Africa, Canada, Australia, etc.

    America is on the wrong side of this issue. It is time that we re-join the civilized world.
  • Che Guevara - Hero 2012/03/20 23:41:34
    Yes
    Che Guevara - Hero
    +12
    George Zimmerman is a Coward that needs to be in prison.
  • Ron 2012/03/20 23:41:34
    Yes
    Ron
    +11
    It is a license to kill, all you have to do is make sure there are no eye witnesses.
  • *Mahoga... Ron 2012/03/20 23:45:38
    *Mahogany Goddess of P.H.A.E.T
    +4
    Good point.
  • CTF 2012/03/20 23:40:49
    Yes
    CTF
    +2
    Actually... More like, repealed.
  • LORROL 2012/03/20 23:39:20
    Yes
    LORROL
    +2
    The events of this case make this clear.
  • Red_Horse 2012/03/20 23:37:04

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/19 05:36:34

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals