Quantcast

Do You Think States Should Be Allowed to Mint Their Own Currency?

ABC News U.S. 2013/02/07 21:00:00
Related Topics: Currency
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Will Virginia start minting its own currency? It’s an idea worth considering, according to the state’s House of Delegates.

The lower chamber passed a bill Monday to study the possibility. The legislation, proposed by Manassas Republican Del. Robert Marshall, would create a new joint subcommittee made up of lawmakers, plus two outside experts, to “study the feasibility of a metallic-based monetary unit.”

The committee could spend up to $17,440 and would present its recommendations before the legislative session starts in 2014. Translation: Ten people would advise Virginia on whether to start making its own currency on a gold or silver standard.

minting currency

Read More: http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2013/02/virgi...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Transquesta 2013/02/07 21:30:32
    No
    Transquesta
    +36
    Article 1, Section 10, The U.S. Constitution:

    "No state shall enter into any treaty, alliance, or confederation; grant letters of marque and reprisal; coin money; emit bills of credit; make anything but gold and silver coin a tender in payment of debts; pass any bill of attainder, ex post facto law, or law impairing the obligation of contracts, or grant any title of nobility."

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Popeye Alexis ... 2013/02/08 23:17:45
    Popeye
    The Virginia plan is to have a backup to the dollar in case of a total economic collapse of the dollar.

    It isn't replacing the dollar unless it has a total collapse.
  • THUNDERBOLT 2013/02/08 00:05:32 (edited)
    No
    THUNDERBOLT
    +2
    not really..... but its pretty cool that around a thousand people did this question and only 5 raves!
  • Chrissi 2013/02/08 00:01:56
    No
    Chrissi
    +3
    What,then, is the 'United States' all about?
  • lurch 2013/02/08 00:00:29 (edited)
    No
    lurch
    +2
    One more way for the commodity/currency traders to make a fortune, on the backs of US Citizens. We struggle as it is with oil speculators. Do we want another means to diminish our buying power?
  • Popeye lurch 2013/02/08 23:21:43
    Popeye
    http://www.inquisitr.com/5121...

    The Virginia plan is to have a backup to the dollar in case of a total economic collapse of the dollar.

    It isn't replacing the dollar unless it has a total collapse.
  • (▪‿▪)DoctorWhoGuru(▪‿▪) 2013/02/07 23:58:35 (edited)
  • RoyJLores 2013/02/07 23:52:51
    Yes
    RoyJLores
    +6
    Anything even good old bartering would be better than the worthless fiat currency we use....
  • Idiot r... RoyJLores 2013/02/08 00:49:58 (edited)
    Idiot repubs
    +2
    You can send me yours then, bunker man.
  • RoyJLores Idiot r... 2013/02/08 02:11:53
    RoyJLores
    +3
    Typical liberty hating Statist authoritarian/fascist sheeple gibberish.
    typical liberty hating statist authoritarianfascist sheeple gibberish
    typical liberty hating statist authoritarianfascist sheeple gibberish
    typical liberty hating statist authoritarianfascist sheeple gibberish
    typical liberty hating statist authoritarianfascist sheeple gibberish
    typical liberty hating statist authoritarianfascist sheeple gibberish
    typical liberty hating statist authoritarianfascist sheeple gibberish
    typical liberty hating statist authoritarianfascist sheeple gibberish

    Now go back to your insipid reality show sheep...
    typical liberty hating statist authoritarianfascist sheeple gibberish insipid reality sheep
  • Idiot r... RoyJLores 2013/02/08 13:17:12
    Idiot repubs
    I don't know what you're trying to say Bunker man!
  • RoyJLores Idiot r... 2013/02/09 00:07:36
    RoyJLores
    +1
    Off course you don't you are a braindead sheep and will always be...

    braindead sheep


    And just FYI I don't live in a bunker that's just a reflection of the propaganda and indoctrination from all the Establishment Koolaid you have deposited on your cranium where your brain once long ago used to be...
  • Chest R... RoyJLores 2013/02/18 19:53:25
    Chest Rockwell
    +1
    Amen, brother.
  • joe mauro RoyJLores 2013/02/08 23:02:21
    joe mauro
    true
  • Popeye RoyJLores 2013/02/08 23:16:16
    Popeye
    The Virginia plan is to have a backup to the dollar in case of a total collapse.
  • Dj Gill 2013/02/07 23:13:04
    No
    Dj Gill
    +5
    I don't really want to convert my money every time I leave the state.
  • Chest R... Dj Gill 2013/02/18 19:55:50
    Chest Rockwell
    The alternative is to allow inflation to sap the value of the dollars you hold, eventually to the point that they are worthless pieces of paper. Ever heard of Weimar Germany? History repeats itself.
  • bob h. 2013/02/07 23:08:08
    Yes
    bob h.
    +2
    Yes; as soon as they secede.
  • illinoyed bob h. 2013/02/08 03:05:29 (edited)
    illinoyed
    +1
    So, what nation are you working for? Russia? Iran? North Korea? You sure are anxious to have the states secede and for the United States to break apart and cease to exist.

    I know--China! You're working for China! If the U.S. falls, China takes it's place as the world leader.

    Freaking commie.
  • bob h. illinoyed 2013/02/08 23:47:17
    bob h.
    Whoa whoa, if the states secede, as Rick Perry is threatening to, the red states drain on the economy, which is kept afloat by the blue states, will continue to prosper for about 10 minutes. China right? How about looking at the money going to the cretin bible belt.
  • illinoyed bob h. 2013/02/10 02:30:47 (edited)
    illinoyed
    You were being sarcastic, I missed that. Sorry.

    Rick Perry has already reneged on his secession comments. He was pandering to the RWNJs during the GOP primary. Once he went back to being governor, he announced secession was off the table. He knows Texas would become a third world country overrun by Mexico without the largesse and protection of the federal government.
  • Popeye bob h. 2013/02/08 23:22:32
    Popeye
    +1
    http://www.inquisitr.com/5121...

    The Virginia plan is to have a backup to the dollar in case of a total economic collapse of the dollar.

    It isn't replacing the dollar unless it has a total collapse.
  • bob h. Popeye 2013/02/08 23:49:39
    bob h.
    Good idea. How about taking some Alabama bucks and spending them in NY. How about $900 to get on the subway?
  • CrimsonSeraph 2013/02/07 23:00:21
    No
    CrimsonSeraph
    +1
    No, it was already done in this country before the constitution we have now was in effect and look how well that worked. Article 1 section 8 gives congress the power to coin money.
  • Popeye Crimson... 2013/02/08 23:22:46
    Popeye
    http://www.inquisitr.com/5121...

    The Virginia plan is to have a backup to the dollar in case of a total economic collapse of the dollar.

    It isn't replacing the dollar unless it has a total collapse.
  • bob h. Popeye 2013/02/08 23:52:01
    bob h.
    The reason it might collapse is the Bible belt sucking the life out of the $US. Your patron saint Bush, cost the $US 47cts.
  • Popeye bob h. 2013/02/09 00:40:11
    Popeye
    +1
    Oh brother. The Fed is printing money like it is going out of style, when that happens it weakens the dollar and devalues it. The dollar has been sliding against all other currencies and it will continue and until this Government quits spending money it does not have and stop this idiotic notion of printing more and more money the slide will not stop and it will end it total economic collapse.
  • bob h. Popeye 2013/02/09 03:09:59
    bob h.
    Obama has ADDED 13 cts to the $US. and 7,000 pts to the DJ. Meanwhile, SC, MS, AL, LA, KS, GA, OK, TN, AR, ND, SD, all received 2x as much back as they paid in taxes. Meanwhile, Bush gave Wells Fargo 17B, AT&T 14B, Verizon 12B, GE 8B, Exxon 4B, IBM 8B, DHL 3B, GoldmanSachs 3B, proctorGamble 3B etc, etc. So tell me, where's this money going?
  • Popeye bob h. 2013/02/09 04:20:41
    Popeye
    Do you have a brain in that head of yours? You obviously have no idea how currency works, do you realize that our so called money is back by nothing more than the government saying it has value?

    Since 1971, U.S. citizens have been able to utilize Federal Reserve Notes as the only form of money and for the first time had no currency with any gold or silver backing.

    This is where you get the saying that U.S. dollars are backed by the “full faith and credit” of the U.S. Government. In other words, Nixon implied take our paper dollars or don’t.

    The U.S. at this time was a world super power having been victorious in WWII and there really wasn’t much anyone could do about the decision by the U.S. government to abandon metal backing.
    What does a dollar or Federal Reserve note represent now that gold and silver no longer back any of the currency printed in the U.S.?
    A dollar bill used to say “This note is legal tender for all debts, public and private, and is redeemable in lawful money at the United States Treasury or at any Federal Reserve Bank.” Look at a dollar bill today. It simply says; “This note is legal tender for all debts, public and private.” In other words, you can’t redeem it for “lawful money.”
    Guess what folks? A dollar bill is not lawful money, but rather “legal tender.”

    Fro...

    Do you have a brain in that head of yours? You obviously have no idea how currency works, do you realize that our so called money is back by nothing more than the government saying it has value?

    Since 1971, U.S. citizens have been able to utilize Federal Reserve Notes as the only form of money and for the first time had no currency with any gold or silver backing.

    This is where you get the saying that U.S. dollars are backed by the “full faith and credit” of the U.S. Government. In other words, Nixon implied take our paper dollars or don’t.

    The U.S. at this time was a world super power having been victorious in WWII and there really wasn’t much anyone could do about the decision by the U.S. government to abandon metal backing.
    What does a dollar or Federal Reserve note represent now that gold and silver no longer back any of the currency printed in the U.S.?
    A dollar bill used to say “This note is legal tender for all debts, public and private, and is redeemable in lawful money at the United States Treasury or at any Federal Reserve Bank.” Look at a dollar bill today. It simply says; “This note is legal tender for all debts, public and private.” In other words, you can’t redeem it for “lawful money.”
    Guess what folks? A dollar bill is not lawful money, but rather “legal tender.”

    From the Treasury;

    “Federal Reserve notes are not redeemable in gold, silver or any other commodity, and receive no backing by anything. Redeemable notes into gold ended in 1933 and silver in 1968. The notes have no value for themselves, but for what they will buy. In another sense, because they are legal tender, Federal Reserve notes are “backed” by all the goods and services in the economy.”
    (more)
  • Anna 2013/02/07 22:17:12
    Yes
    Anna
    +5
    ?? candy coins LOL
  • Lerro DeHazel 2013/02/07 21:47:27
    No
    Lerro DeHazel
    No, that would create a mis-match in the value-of-currency, eventually . . . Some folks in Kansas would probably want to argue that their Dollar is far more VALUED in their own State than New York's . . . Particularly if you are asking some Ag-Retailer for some Corn-Seed to plant their crops.
  • Popeye Lerro D... 2013/02/08 23:23:08
    Popeye
    http://www.inquisitr.com/5121...

    The Virginia plan is to have a backup to the dollar in case of a total economic collapse of the dollar.

    It isn't replacing the dollar unless it has a total collapse.
  • bob h. Popeye 2013/02/08 23:53:50
    bob h.
    Replace w/ what? What's Mississippi going to back up it's money with, sugar cane? get real.
  • Popeye bob h. 2013/02/09 00:41:16
    Popeye
    Virginia will back it with gold and silver, I have no idea about Mississippi you might want to ask them.
  • bob h. Popeye 2013/02/09 03:12:39
    bob h.
    The south will starve without NE subsidies.
  • Popeye bob h. 2013/02/09 04:22:55
    Popeye
    I seriously doubt that Bob. This bill is a backup Lawful money with gold and silver not Legal tender, you need to know the difference between the two.
  • Lerro D... Popeye 2013/02/09 21:00:25
    Lerro DeHazel
    +1
    All they have to do is be patient for 59 more cents MORE and they just might have it.
  • flrdsgns 2013/02/07 21:36:15
    No
    flrdsgns
    +3
    No, of course not
  • TuringsChild 2013/02/07 21:35:40
    No
    TuringsChild
    +4
    Not if you understand the Constitution. OTOH, the FED is a private bank and should NEVER have been given that power over us.

    rothschild quote care
  • Transquesta 2013/02/07 21:30:32
    No
    Transquesta
    +36
    Article 1, Section 10, The U.S. Constitution:

    "No state shall enter into any treaty, alliance, or confederation; grant letters of marque and reprisal; coin money; emit bills of credit; make anything but gold and silver coin a tender in payment of debts; pass any bill of attainder, ex post facto law, or law impairing the obligation of contracts, or grant any title of nobility."
  • burning... Transqu... 2013/02/08 00:32:58
    burningsnowman
    +6
    It is technically unconstitutional. But on the other hand why follow rules your opponent doesn't? Why not support something that will let states distance themselves from the corrupt banking establishment and even more frequently unconstitutional federal government?

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/19 03:42:53

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals