Quantcast

Do 4th of July Festivities Turn Children Into Republicans?

SodaHead Living 2011/07/01 22:36:51
You!
Add Photos & Videos
According to a new study, published by Harvard University, July 4th-themed celebrations, such as fireworks, parades, political speeches, and barbecues, "energize Republicans, turn children into Republicans and increse GOP voter turnout."

Simply put: "Fourth of July celebrations in the United States shape the nation's political landscape by forming beliefs and increasing participation, primarily in favor of the Republican Party," says the report.

Republicans, the authors say, consider themselves more patriotic than Democrats and have been more successful in "appropriating" the symbols of American patriotism during the 20th century.

The authors also argue that Independence Day celebrations have the greatest impact on children.

"Fourth of July celebrations in Republican dominated counties may thus be more politically biased events that socialize children into Republicans," say Yanagizawa-Drott and Madestam.

"We were surprised to find that childhood experiences of Fourth July celebrations could have such persistent effects."


These researchers may work at Harvard, but do you think they are correct?

Does celebrating the 4th of July really turn children into Republicans?

Read More: http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20076125-50...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Astro-Boy PHAET 2011/07/01 22:40:47
    No
    Astro-Boy PHAET
    +25
    Been celebrating the 4th with family since I can remember. I'm far from being a Republican. I don't see why it has to be politicized.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Seonag 2011/07/02 15:17:06
    Undecided
    Seonag
    NEITHER --- It makes them AMERICANS.

    *** Note: Why is SodaHead baiting discourse? There is enough on this site without SH starting up things! Unless this is what some members of the staff wish to do!
  • WolfEyes Seonag 2011/07/02 17:05:26
    WolfEyes
    +2
    they're masters at baiting ;) hehehe
  • sal 2011/07/02 14:49:22
    Yes
    sal
    +2
    You mean loving America? Not saying there aren't liberals that love American, just Republicans love America for what it is meant to be.
  • Jon 2011/07/02 14:22:40
    No
    Jon
    +5
    I voted no.
    BUT
    Republicans ARE indeed God and country(people)loving while Democrats are represented by the atheistic, deviant, anti-America socialist minded HATERS

    (watch the comments prove this point exactly) ha hehehheee


    anti-america socialist minded haters watch comments prove ha hehehheee welfare recipient
  • Jon Jon 2011/07/02 14:45:33
  • hooda Jon 2011/07/02 15:54:53
    hooda
    +1
    What a great story....really shows what's going on in this country.
    Ayn Rand called them the producers and looters, I believe. Looks like the looters in this story decided to throw a little arson into the mix. Somehow I'm not surprised.
  • Julio Jon 2011/07/02 15:48:59
    Julio
    By ignoring that Republicans do the exact same thing, you've basically just shown us that you're nothing more than a close minded hater yourself.

    Congrats on being a hypocrit.
  • Jon Julio 2011/07/02 22:34:49 (edited)
    Jon
    You need an education and this is the teachable moment I was hoping for; the incendiary comment of 'parasite' is not a hatred of people but rather indignation for what those people DO to ruin this great nation.
    America originally offers an equal opportunity for all by rewarding productivity; not penalizing productivity with the failed policies of socialism.

    SO

    What is more loving? Creating a permanent underclass of parasitic citizenry by a ruling elite class in government who exempt themselves from the oppressive, restrictive laws they place on us but not on themselves..
    OR
    ..the protecting and preserving of a REPUBLIC under God; a rule of equal protection under the law of God protecting private property from big government and guaranteeing the pursuit of happiness for all?

    .. GET IT YET Junior ?!?

    god protecting private property government guaranteeing pursuit happiness junior American flag and the constitution
  • dave b 2011/07/02 13:53:19
    Undecided
    dave b
    +4
    I doubt it, but boy, doesnt this "study" really prove how dispicable and fearful the Leftwingers really are? They just cant help but to try to demonize their opposition at every chance. So what if it were true?
    I suppose they think its ok to turn your children into Liberals by indoctrinating them while they attend public schools, huh? A-holes.
  • Flash,aka,Mr.Lightning 2011/07/02 13:51:56
    No
    Flash,aka,Mr.Lightning
    +6
    Boy scouts, Girl scouts, Campfire Kids, etc.,, and any other organization that teaches patriotism is loathe to liberals.
  • dave b Flash,a... 2011/07/02 13:57:06
    dave b
    +5
    The Libs dont want our children to grow up learning to be honest, reliable, respectful, self sufficient young people.
  • hooda Flash,a... 2011/07/02 15:57:26
    hooda
    +1
    Yes but even those organizations have been infitrated but the Left. Think what the Boy Scouts have gone throught.
  • Wahvlvke 2011/07/02 13:40:02
    Undecided
    Wahvlvke
    +2
    It would be better for the country they did!
  • Justin.Long 2011/07/02 13:37:43
    Undecided
    Justin.Long
    +2
    no but learning personal responsibility helps in that
  • Tom Standard 2011/07/02 13:36:49
    No
    Tom Standard
    And if you go to a gay pride fest you are a demwit?
  • zkittle06 2011/07/02 13:30:30
    Undecided
    zkittle06
    +1
    I wouldn't say Republicans are more patriotic, just more obnoxious and flamboyant with their patriotism. Don't they know all those flags, fireworks, and american flag clothing are all made in China?
  • hazel zkittle06 2011/07/03 06:25:38
    hazel
    Dont cha just hate people who so love their Country and are willing to stand up and shout about it.......just disgusting..... cha hate people love country shout disgusting snicker
  • zkittle06 hazel 2011/07/05 16:59:03
    zkittle06
    I like my country a lot better when its not shouting.
  • wise up 2011/07/02 13:28:46
    No
    wise up
    why would they!
  • Watermusicranger 2011/07/02 13:16:41
    Undecided
    Watermusicranger
    +3
    I Sure Hope So.
    God Bless America.
  • Stacie 2011/07/02 12:56:47
    No
    Stacie
    +1
    That is absolutely absurd.
  • BystroffC 2011/07/02 12:51:44
    No
    BystroffC
    BS. The main characteristic of the Republican party is selfishness, not patriotism. The 4th is about patriotism, not tax cuts for the rich.
  • Tom Sta... BystroffC 2011/07/02 13:35:51
    Tom Standard
    +3
    And the demwits just want to take all of our money and spend it on BS! You are a phucking idiot if you think they are not selfish too.
  • BystroffC Tom Sta... 2011/07/03 11:57:20
    BystroffC
    In all likelihood you are a recipient of the "demwits'" largess.
  • lester1 BystroffC 2011/07/02 16:46:50
  • NarcolepticGoat 2011/07/02 12:49:17
    No
    NarcolepticGoat
    correlation =/= causation
  • Bothergirl 2011/07/02 12:39:27
    No
    Bothergirl
    +2
    That author sounds like he needs therapy. My Dad is a lifetime Dem. (Only God knows why.), but he served our country for decades in the Air Force and reserves. No, one is more Democrat than he. He always loved July 4th parades. Independence Day is for all Americans.


    Please say a pray for my father. It is his 84th birthday today and he just found out he has a tumor in his lung. He never smoked other than second hand.

    Since when is celebrating ours, the greatest and most free county in the world, wrong. Dems. need to get their heads out of their butts if this is how they feel.
  • BystroffC Bothergirl 2011/07/02 12:54:06
    BystroffC
    +1
    I pray for your dad. He sounds like someone I would like.
  • Reach130 Bothergirl 2011/07/02 13:25:50
    Reach130
    +1
    I'm so sorry about your dad... I hope he gets better.
  • LisaSmith Bothergirl 2011/07/02 15:57:02
    LisaSmith
    My prayers for your dad. prayers dad my prayers for you
  • tea for you 2011/07/02 12:24:38
    No
    tea for you
    democratic republic chicken or egg
  • Concerned Voter 2011/07/02 12:22:39
    No
    Concerned Voter
    +1
    What a stupid f*** statement. While it is true that Republicans are vary patriotic. it is also true that there are Democrats that are patriotic too. It is just that the one in the white house has a checkered record on that.
    The great thing about the 4th of july is that it reminds us who we are, where this country came from and how far it has to go. I say God Bless it!
  • tea for... Concern... 2011/07/02 12:26:08
    tea for you
    the republicans in my opinion seem to want to destroy American traditions
  • Concern... tea for... 2011/07/02 12:38:14
    Concerned Voter
    +2
    No, Obama is doing that all by himself.
  • Steve King 2011/07/02 12:10:03
    Yes
    Steve King
    +1
    and I would like to celebrate this day with my son more often than just July 4th, like this year, it is all about July 4th from July 1-4.
  • Jeb Roberts 1 %'er - POTL -... 2011/07/02 12:08:57
    Undecided
    Jeb Roberts 1 %'er - POTL - JLA
    I don't know, but it sure sounds like a solid idea.
  • Grizzle 2011/07/02 11:57:29
    Undecided
    Grizzle
  • tea for... Grizzle 2011/07/02 12:27:04
    tea for you
    +1
    Capitalism destroyed the economy twice in less than 100 years
  • hooda tea for... 2011/07/02 16:03:08 (edited)
    hooda
    Too many rules and regs favoring one law maker's friends over another has ruined our economy......
    In other words, it is corrupt politicians. Not capitalism.
  • kc2dtp hooda 2011/07/03 12:38:20
    kc2dtp
    +2
    No, greed and greed and deregulation has destroyed our economy. But this thread is not about that. happy 4th of july!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/23 18:59:11

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals