Quantcast

Did you Expect This??

Andy 2012/04/06 14:15:26
You!
Add Photos & Videos

WASHINGTON — Maryland's
highest court is poised to hear arguments in a precedent-setting case
involving two women who married in California but were denied a divorce
in Maryland, which does not currently allow same-sex weddings.

The
Court of Appeals of Maryland in Annapolis was set to hear arguments
Friday from lawyers for the lesbian couple who are seeking to end their
marriage. A Maryland judge declined to grant their divorce in 2010,
basing his decision on the conclusion that the women's marriage is not
valid under Maryland law.

But lawyers for the women disagree,
saying the state should recognize gay marriages performed elsewhere even
though Maryland does not allow same-sex weddings at the present time.
As a result, the couple should be allowed to divorce in the state, the
lawyers say.

The high court's ultimate decision may have limited
effect since same-sex weddings, and by extension divorces, are set to
start in the state in January 2013 under a law passed this year. But
opponents of the new law are seeking to overturn it in a potential voter
referendum.

Meanwhile, judges in Maryland are inconsistent about
granting divorces for gay couples who married in another state. Lawyers
involved in Friday's case say they believe judges have granted about a
half a dozen divorces for gay couples, but their clients, Jessica Port
and Virginia Anne Cowan, and at least one other couple were recently
denied that.

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Someone Else 2012/04/07 05:17:23
  • J 2012/04/06 19:44:12
    Other thought...
    J
    +3
    They got married in California, let them divorce in California. Why do they need to get a divorce anyway? Virginia doesn't even consider them married. Me thinks this is only for attention!
  • Edensasp 2012/04/06 19:34:55
    Maryland Should Grant Divorce
    Edensasp
    +1
    The dissolution of contract laws is not the same as issuing a license,,, Whats the problem?
  • Louisa - Enemy of the State 2012/04/06 18:18:45
  • darlene 2012/04/06 17:16:43
    Other thought...
    darlene
    +1
    Have the lesbians go back to California and cough cough....divorce.  gay marriage lol
  • Ken 2012/04/06 16:55:03
    Other thought...
    Ken
    +2
    Should have to get a divorce in the state you were married in homosexual marriages, or other states that accept homosexual marriages.
  • Murph 2012/04/06 16:18:19 (edited)
    Proves Homo-Marriages are Wrong
    Murph
    +1
    California is three thousand miles away, and most states have a residency requirement. But they could drive to Massachusetts or New York and stay there for however long it takes, or they could just ignore an idiotic law that has no meaning outside of
    homo-fantasies and shack up with the next lesbo they hook up with.
  • geegee 2012/04/06 15:27:09
    Proves Homo-Marriages are Wrong
    geegee
    +4
    I think it is a bunch of hog wash.
  • Reggie☮ 2012/04/06 14:56:00
    Other thought...
    Reggie☮
    +4
    I was wondering when this would happen.
  • Andy Fletcher 2012/04/06 14:42:07
    Maryland Should Grant Divorce
    Andy Fletcher
    +2
    While I disagree with gay "marriage" for reasons I have discussed in other threads, it is my firm belief that the "The Full Faith and Credit Clause" of Article IV, section 2 of the constitution should be in full force.
  • Andy Andy Fl... 2012/04/06 14:45:02
    Andy
    +1
    What does that clause say??
  • Andy Fl... Andy 2012/04/06 14:45:47
    Andy Fletcher
    +1
    look it up
  • Andy Andy Fl... 2012/04/06 15:10:44
    Andy
    +3
    I did...but, it would be easier for some to state the clause. So you feel that the divorce should be granted in Maryland, even though the wedding was in Calif, based upon this clause...
  • Andy Fl... Andy 2012/04/06 15:38:16
    Andy Fletcher
    Yes. If the states have to recognize a hetero marriage from another state, they should have to for all marriages. That doesn't mean they have to convey full benefit as if the marriage was performed in state, but certainly, if they will grant a divorce to a hetero couple married out of state, then they should for a gay marriage as well.
  • Andy Andy Fl... 2012/04/06 15:42:31
    Andy
    +1
    While I agree with this... what about states that grant Medical Marijuana permits?? If Billy gets his permit in one state, should another state allow it, even if they don't have it as a law?? The same with concealed weapon laws... not arguing with you, there seems to be several laws that dont jive from state to state.
  • Andy Fl... Andy 2012/04/06 16:33:56
    Andy Fletcher
    In my opinion, qualifying it with the fact that I am not a jurist, lawyer, or true constitutional scholar, I don't think the type of laws are the same.
  • Starman 2012/04/06 14:32:41
    Maryland Should Grant Divorce
    Starman
    And recognize same sex marriage.
  • Mr Wayne 2012/04/06 14:25:56
    Other thought...
    Mr Wayne
    +2
    Yes, I expected this.
    Why don't they file for divorce in California?
  • Murph Mr Wayne 2012/04/06 16:14:54 (edited)
    Murph
    +1
    Probably because it's three thousand miles away, and most states have a residency requirement. But they could drive to Massachusetts or New York and stay there for however long it takes, or they could just ignore an idiotic law that has no meaning outside of homo-fantasies and shack up with the next lesbo they hook up with.
  • Mr Wayne Murph 2012/04/06 16:57:09
    Mr Wayne
    +1
    Or, like many straight marriages, dispel with a hearty "F**k YOU!" and then they never speak again.
  • Mr Wayne Murph 2012/04/06 17:22:30
    Mr Wayne
    +1
    Since CA recognizes gay marriage and so many other states don't, why don't they put a provision in place allowing gays from any state to file for divorce there?
  • Murph Mr Wayne 2012/04/06 18:01:53
    Murph
    +1
    Allowing homosexual divorce implies that the state recognizes homosexual marriage, which has never been voted into law in any state.
  • Mr Wayne Murph 2012/04/06 18:04:49
    Mr Wayne
    +1
    Well, yeah. Despite what Hollywood would like you to believe, it's NOT the norm and they are a much smaller minority than they believe.
  • ID51 2012/04/06 14:25:43
    Proves Homo-Marriages are Wrong
    ID51
    +3
    This is something I don't believe gay couples thought out very well when they got married in states that allowed it. They never thought they'd want a divorce... But like heterosexual couples have known for decades, sometimes things don't work out. They either need to get their divorce in California (or some state that recognizes gay marriage) or wait until (if) Maryland changes their law.
  • Kat 2012/04/06 14:22:01
    Other thought...
    Kat
    +4
    Should be a non-issue, I agree with the court. How can you grant a divorce when you don't consider them legally married. As far as MD is concerned they aren't married so therefore don't need a divorce. They are wasting taxpayers money and valuable court time that would be better spent on issues of MD. law. They'll turn it into a circus though.
    Always do when they don't get their way. They need to go back to where they were married and file there or somewhere else that allows it.
  • lstl5 2012/04/06 14:20:33
    Other thought...
    lstl5
    +4
    They need to go to California and get the divorce. If it is not yet law in Maryland, then how can they lawfully end the marriage that the state doesnt yet acknowledge?

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/19 21:06:30

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals