Quantcast

Cops Lift 6-Year-Old Girl By Her Hair: Should the U.S. step in?

Marilyn 2009/08/25 23:25:00
Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old girls by their hair...
No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is their issue to resolve...
I think the India police force that lifted the 6-year-old girl by her hair...
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Indian cops lifted a 6-year-old girl by the hair under the notion that she had stolen the equivalent of 6 dollars. One officer was fired and another suspended. The 6-year-old who was lifted by her hair had the charges against her dropped.

In a CNN Human Right Watch report, journalists explored police brutality in India.

In another report from India, an accused thief was beaten by a crowd, and then dragged by a police motorcycle. Two officers were fired, but then reinstated.

Should the U.S. step in and help reform India's police force?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Avadot 2009/10/25 20:24:20
    Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old gir...
    Avadot
    Gosh! What is wrong with these cops? The darn girl is 6! She doesn't know any better than that!
  • Charles E 2009/09/04 14:08:58
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    Charles E
    We would have 20 kinds of anger if another country told us how to run our local police forces.

    Set a good example, and comment privately. Do not insult the worlds largest democracy.
  • Eliza SHTHO NOB. 2009/09/01 23:42:20
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    Eliza SHTHO NOB.
    They already resolved it, and the police who did it were fired. There is no reason for the US to do anything.
  • p31woman 2009/08/31 19:44:58
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    p31woman
    No. We need to focus on our own issues.
  • zandra 2009/08/31 01:23:04
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    zandra
    But that police officer is a jackass.
  • JDF 93 2009/08/30 18:16:23
    I think the India police force that lifted the 6-year-old girl by her hair...
    JDF 93
    i would prolly laugh...and then say thats fucked up and im going to hell for laughing at something like that...
  • Angel3 2009/08/29 20:42:45
    Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old gir...
    Angel3
    yea i think they should step in cuz nobody deserves that escpecially a 6 year old
  • Cookie-chan ~Love Like This~ 2009/08/28 19:09:10
    Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old gir...
    Cookie-chan ~Love Like This~
    We always stick our nose in dirty business when it comes to other countries, so why don't we do something GOOD for once?
  • HOLLYWAY 2009/08/28 01:04:32
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    HOLLYWAY
    We can't afford to be the world's police but new coverage alone will have a profound effect on what happened there. Remember the cutting off of a thiefs' hand thing? Let them progress. The whole world is watching anyway.
  • Common Sense Conservative 2009/08/27 23:44:36
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    Common Sense Conservative
    if she stole it she should pay. if not, figure it out
  • Aleanor 2009/08/27 23:07:35
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    Aleanor
    +1
    The US is not the worlds police men. Let India resolve their own ethics and own morality. But food for thought...do we want people who allow this kind of behavior from police officers to also be 'ethically" handling much of the worlds banking technology??
  • AlchLegend 2009/08/27 20:13:32
    I think the India police force that lifted the 6-year-old girl by her hair...
    AlchLegend
    +1
    Doing that is simply pathetic and cruel, lifting a girl by her hair and beating up an ACCUSED thief, who could, by all means, be innocent.
  • alice 2009/08/27 16:28:21
    I think the India police force that lifted the 6-year-old girl by her hair...
    alice
    yes and no because she only stole 6 dollars but india should step i and do somthing about that.
  • maggie 2009/08/27 13:00:28 (edited)
    I think the India police force that lifted the 6-year-old girl by her hair...
    maggie
    I do not think the USA should step in, what could we do? Make more enemies? I think it would be most inappropriate for us to act as the world's leaders. The officers who participated should be strongly repremanded and perhaps loose their jobs. We have enough on our hands with Iraq, Iran, Afganistan with out buying more trouble. If anything we could remind India as a growing nation, that most people find that type of behavior completely inappropriate
  • Aleanor maggie 2009/08/27 23:04:29
    Aleanor
    I whole heartedly agree. It is none of the US business to step in on this situation UNLESS the child was a US citizen at the time. If the people of India have the know how to run much of the worlds technology, banking and credit card call centers, then they should also be capable of speaking out and stopping the police from treating a child this way regardless of what she did. Should we be trusting our money, banking and technology centers to a group of people that do not speak out against their own police treating their own children with this kind of brutality??? In the US you would be reprimanded for treating a dog this way let alone a child..........but yet we trust them with our finances??? Bring US jobs back to US people and ethics.
  • Julia 2009/08/26 22:57:04
    Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old gir...
    Julia
    i am amazed that they did that for 6 dollars!
  • alice Julia 2009/08/27 16:31:43
    alice
    in india that six dollars could have been a kind of alot amount of money. but they still had no right to do that to a little girl.
  • Elizabeth 2009/08/26 22:18:06
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    Elizabeth
    If she were an American, we should step in, especially since she is a minor, but the Indian police disciplined the officers involved. The U.S. cannot police the world.
  • Brit,,sexy ninja's,,dotdotc... 2009/08/26 21:19:01
    Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old gir...
    Brit,,sexy ninja's,,dotdotcurve,,
    yes tht brutallity will soon kill and they should never be reinstated they should be fired for good!
  • Chancey 2009/08/26 18:42:43
    Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old gir...
    Chancey
    yes they need to step in that is beyond messed up i dont care how old u r u dont deserve to b pulled by ur hair a 6 year old really! Wat is happeneing in this world today!!!
  • luv bird 2009/08/26 17:07:38 (edited)
    Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old gir...
    luv bird
    yes do think that the U.S. should step in but she is a shoplifter and we need to stop that. http://diary.typepad.com/.a/6...
  • David (oYo) 2009/08/26 16:02:28
    Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old gir...
    David (oYo)
    It's pretty disgusting, they're treating this girl no better than a bunny rabbit. This girl doesn't look very Indian. She looks white to me. Is there a racist element there.
  • Princess Eeyore 2009/08/26 15:36:21
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    Princess Eeyore
    They need to crack down on shoplifters! Give her the chair! THE CHAIR! step incident 6-year-old girl issue resolve crack shoplifters chair chair
  • Brit,,s... Princes... 2009/08/26 21:20:53
    Brit,,sexy ninja's,,dotdotcurve,,
    she is effing six years old tht is not right
  • daany Boy 2009/08/26 15:24:16
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    daany Boy
    let me see.uhmmm In America, the Doctors of Doom, decapitate a live fetus, pull her head out then dismember the rest of her...I weep at this vain question about the 6 year old
  • spikeby289 2009/08/26 15:13:39
    Yes, the U.S. should put a stop to the police that are lifting 6-year-old gir...
    spikeby289
    i guess.....
  • Ronbo 2009/08/26 14:45:03
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    Ronbo
    +1
    issue for Indian authorities to deal with, UNLESS IT INVOLVES AN AMERCIAN CITIZEN.............. sounds like over zealous cop attitude to me but there again ... its in their culture to react a lot different than what we do in America. Let them deal with it. We have enoguh on our plate already with crime in USA!!!
  • ladypuppylove 2009/08/26 13:12:14
    I think the India police force that lifted the 6-year-old girl by her hair...
    ladypuppylove
    A good butt whipping these cops of today are getting out of control
  • eath 2009/08/26 12:32:00
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    eath
    We need to mind our own business more and other peoples less
  • papag38 2009/08/26 10:12:09
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    papag38
    Stay out of other countries business unless it envolves an American.
  • Lady Whitewolf 2009/08/26 08:35:24
    I think the India police force that lifted the 6-year-old girl by her hair...
    Lady Whitewolf
    they need a good ass-kicking!
  • Dennis C Latham 2009/08/26 06:40:12
    I think the India police force that lifted the 6-year-old girl by her hair...
    Dennis C Latham
    are like most crooked cops ...... cowards.
  • Lynn 2009/08/26 05:37:49
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    Lynn
    We (the USA) have no right, or business butting in every time some urchin is treated in a way we would not tolerate in our society. We are not the savior of the world.
  • bleueyed 2009/08/26 03:23:56
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    bleueyed
    We can't go play savior to every country. We have enough problems in America that our government won't take care of. What about police brutality here? African-Americans get shot by police all the time because "they had guns".
  • Hales 2009/08/26 03:08:24
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    Hales
    I don't think it's the US's business to get into India's law enforcement. They have their ways of running the laws and we have our's, but I really hope that no one would pull a young girl like her by her hair, even if she stole $6, not $600.
  • moomoof 2009/08/26 02:53:55
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    moomoof
    wtf wow
    oo no you can't enter that
    then we be seen as the police to the world and we are not
    i think we have cops that we have to handle on our own country than go enter anothers
  • EchoPsychotic 2009/08/26 02:28:40
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    EchoPsychotic
    +1
    The Us should not step in. Its Cruel, yes, but not of our concern. We have other issues of out own to deal with. And we really DO NOT need another-even a small, easy to win-war.
  • Keen Tojones 2009/08/26 02:26:50
    I think the India police force that lifted the 6-year-old girl by her hair...
    Keen Tojones
    +2
    Ought to be shot.
  • hows my aim? 2009/08/26 02:21:42
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    hows my aim?
    +1
    india is its own country and should be ruled by themselves, america has its own problems to deal with.
  • norma 2009/08/26 02:21:15
    No, the U.S. should not step in. The incident with the 6-year-old girl is the...
    norma
    No we shouldnt, india handled the problem correctly but dont get me wrong i do feel the way they treated the girl was wrong!!!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/18 08:51:07

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals