Quantcast

'Bully' Documentary Currently Rated R: Should It Be Changed to PG-13?

SodaHead Film 2012/03/12 01:02:59
You!
Add Photos & Videos
A new documentary about bullying, appropriated titled “Bully,” is currently rated R by the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA). However, the people behind the film, as well as thousands of others around the country, are calling for the rating to be changed to PG-13 in order to make it more accessible to young people.

The MPAA decided to give “Bully” the R mark primarily because of a scene where a bully describes what he will do to a victim using variations of the F-word. Use of the F-word more than once, or only once when used to describe sexual intercourse, almost always results in an automatic R rating.

Last month, The Weinstein Company, which created the film, petitioned to have the rating changed to PG-13. TWC Co-Chairman Harvey Weinstein and Alex Libby, one of the bullied children in the film, argued that the R rating would prevent the film from reaching young audiences. In particular, the R rating prevents the documentary from being shown in schools. (The studio was planning on screening the film at various middle and high schools.) Additionally, many teens prefer to go to the movies with their friends instead of their parents, but you must be at least 17 years old to see an R-rated film without a parent or guardian.

The Weinstein Company lost their appeal. They were one vote short of the two-thirds required to overturn an MPAA rating. However, a ratings change doesn’t seem to be completely off the table. On Thursday, MPAA and Weinstein will be hosting an invitation only screening and panel event for Washington D.C. educators, to discuss “the challenges educators face in dealing with bullying in the classroom.” However, it seems likely that the rating itself will also be a topic of discussion.

What do you think SodaHeads? “Bully” is currently rated R, but should it be changed to PG-13?



 Bully

 Bully

Read More: http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/movies/2012/03/bul...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Depsycho 2012/03/12 02:00:25 (edited)
    Yes
    Depsycho
    +31
    ... at first I was going to say "Yes" because I thought it would be over a graphically violent scene.

    But over some "F" bombs? Sorry, but no.


    Face it, everyone: Children have heard the "F" word and figured out what it means by age 13.

    This isn't the 60s anymore where kids watch their mouths and are raised by picture-perfect parents. This is documentary, and thus must stick to reality, and bullies DO use these words.

    And this IS something that is APPROPRIATE for kids age 13 and up to watch as a glimpse of reality, and unfortunately a film some kids may be able to relate to; AND LEARN FROM.


    Still don't agree? How about this: "The Dark Knight" got a PG-13 rating, and even though it was clean language-wise, it had TONS of violence and even death in it. If THAT can get a PG-13 rating, so can this movie.



    It's time to stop bubble-wrapping our kids anyway.



    bubble wrapping kids

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Common ... LOU 2012/03/13 03:06:04
    Common Sense Conservative
    Who's causing pain?
  • LOU Common ... 2012/03/13 03:25:43
    LOU
    You.
  • smitty Beat Ma... 2012/03/12 18:28:31 (edited)
    smitty
    "isn't being bullied in the first place." Aye mate.
  • Jiorgia Common ... 2012/03/12 09:41:15
  • Common ... Jiorgia 2012/03/12 23:04:41
    Common Sense Conservative
    I'm not afraid of any word. In fact my favorite word is f$ck. But that doesn't mean I have to use it around young kids.

    I teach my kids that if EVER someone keeps hitting on them, they need to get a 2x4 or a bat or whatever and fight back. It's really that simple. BTW, I've been on the other end of a "BULLY" Big bad "BULLY" wasn't so bad after the 2x4 hit across his skull. As of today, that person is a friend of mine. It's called gaining respect.
  • Inquisi... Common ... 2012/03/12 15:13:45
    Inquisitve Kat
    How about addressing the actual issue and not letting kids, who might not be able to defend themselves against a group of other kids, continue to suffer?
    If your kid popped mine, I'd put you in your place.
  • critter171 Inquisi... 2012/03/12 16:25:00
  • Inquisi... critter171 2012/03/12 16:30:56 (edited)
  • critter171 Inquisi... 2012/03/12 16:44:43
    critter171
    +1
    yea my emotion where high i apgolize man glad to see you don't care though
  • Inquisi... critter171 2012/03/12 16:58:56
    Inquisitve Kat
    +1
    No worries... it's easy to run on high emotion in here. :-)
    I just think it's funny that this person seems to be so against swearing, but is okay with his kids fighting.
  • critter171 Inquisi... 2012/03/12 17:34:35
  • Untouched critter171 2012/03/12 18:53:51
    Untouched
    +1
    :) agree
  • Common ... Inquisi... 2012/03/12 23:06:22
    Common Sense Conservative
    My kid would never pop your kid because my kids are taught properly. . And if you ever popped mine, you'd get an @ss whooping like never before.
  • Inquisi... Common ... 2012/03/12 23:46:49
  • Common ... Inquisi... 2012/03/13 03:09:35
    Common Sense Conservative
    +1
    I've never tried, I've always succeeded. That is truth.

    Keeping it real is not allowing it in the school.

    I teach my kids to refrain from violence unless they are hit on, then it's game on.

    I could never use foul language around kids that don't understand WHY it is being used.
  • Inquisi... Common ... 2012/03/13 06:19:22
    Inquisitve Kat
    Well that much I agree with, but I believe if a child is over 13, they're old enough to engage in a discussion about what they heard. For example, if I was teaching eighth grade students and bullying was a problem and I thought this was a good documentary, I would send home a permission slip, but urge parents to accept as I would make it a point to discuss, before the film, that there would be foul language and that it was being used to intimidate and demean the person being bullied. After the film, I would discuss what was viewed with the children and get their input, in order to make sure they understood what they saw.
    I believe children over the age of 13 (if this was rated PG-13) are old enough to understand why a bully would use foul language, or at least understand that it's something that's wrong (seeing it paired with the bully).
  • Common ... Inquisi... 2012/03/13 07:28:09
    Common Sense Conservative
    As a parent, I would never sign that slip for permission. It's your opinion and opinions are not what school is about.
  • Inquisi... Common ... 2012/03/13 08:41:02
    Inquisitve Kat
    And as a parent, that would be your right. The majority of parents, however, would... luckily, schools are set up so children who do not obtain permission are given an alternate activity.
    I do wonder though, do you assume your kids don't regularly hear explicit material in the school yard? You'd be amazed at the things children say... and even the best behaved, most open children, don't repeat what they hear to their parents so the words and topics can be addressed. I've found the children who aren't sheltered tend to handle things much better, whereas those who were sheltered either rebel or struggle with life's small hurdles.
  • Common ... Inquisi... 2012/03/13 20:17:18
    Common Sense Conservative
    You said...do you assume your kids don't regularly hear explicit material in the school yard?

    I could care less what they hear in the school yard, it's what is heard and taught IN the classroom that I am concerned with. Kids know about sex as well, should we allow porn in the classroom as well to talk about rape?

    BTW, my kids are FAR from sheltered. School is not the time or place for any of this.
  • critter171 Common ... 2012/03/12 16:26:03
    critter171
    your not helping the cause you people seriously think its ok to hit and fight? the problem with this is the person who stands up gets punish while the bully gets away with everything.
  • smitty critter171 2012/03/12 18:29:46
    smitty
    "ok to hit and fight" yes sometimes it is appropriate.
  • critter171 smitty 2012/03/12 19:52:19
    critter171
    no its not ok.. lets say you were fighting in the real world man vs man your both be arrestd and charged for assult. the only time you can defend yourself if its life threating. a swear word is a swear word it does NOT HURT ANYOEN BUT MAYBE FLEEINGS ON HOW IT USED. using a fist is going to hurt someone.
  • smitty critter171 2012/03/12 21:23:04
    smitty
    "be arrestd and charged for assult" Sometimes you have to make that decision in life.

    "a swear word is a swear word it does NOT HURT ANYOEN BUT MAYBE FLEEINGS ON HOW IT USED. using a fist is going to hurt someone." See now you are just talking in circles. If there is mental and physical bullying, then why can't words also be painful? Hearing an F-Bomb hurts my ears. I can argue physical pain is much easier to get over than emotional.
  • critter171 smitty 2012/03/12 22:01:48
    critter171
    i never said words couldn't be use or hurt people. i said its better than getting arrested and charged with assult. and i have xpereince with running into a law which i did NOTHING WRONG.
  • Untouched critter171 2012/03/12 18:52:37
    Untouched
    yeah...i just hate when that happens to someone...it's so unfair because it was self defense
  • critter171 Untouched 2012/03/12 19:53:47
  • critter171 Untouched 2012/03/12 19:55:16
    critter171
    as for me in special ed classes i would sneak into my classes so none would find out. i remeber in middle school i had a student i believe put kick me sign on my back... my teacher saw it and jokely tried to kick me and i grab his leg. so he made it better i think i ask him to take it off.
  • Common ... critter171 2012/03/12 23:08:02
    Common Sense Conservative
    Bully my @ss. He's a kid being a kid and he gets away with it because the others let it happen. Fight back. Swing hard and often.
  • critter171 Common ... 2012/03/13 03:08:01
    critter171
    "he a kid being a kid... typical bully parents answer. thre a diffrence when a kid is joking and make a mistake on a math or homework. bully is an issue now no matter how you want to view it. a kid does not become a bully just cause he a kid.
  • Common ... critter171 2012/03/13 03:11:22
    Common Sense Conservative
    LOL, I'm a bully parent? That's comedy. My kids are taught to fight back if they are ever hit on. If they ever start a fight or "Bully", they will get an @ss whooping like never before.
  • critter171 Common ... 2012/03/14 03:47:08
    critter171
    again you are a bully... nothing more.
  • Common ... critter171 2012/03/14 06:57:50
    Common Sense Conservative
    You're stupid. And a lot more.


    Brilliant!!!
  • critter171 Common ... 2012/03/16 21:25:51
    critter171
    "youire stupid and a lot more. that just prove my point congrats....
  • Common ... critter171 2012/03/18 22:30:32
    Common Sense Conservative
    Proves your point?

    I'm a bully?

    This is comedy.

    Brilliant!!!
  • critter171 Common ... 2012/03/19 03:07:47
    critter171
    you insulted me
    you said you were not a bully parent
    you use words to insult me
    thefore you are a bully.
  • Common ... critter171 2012/03/19 03:12:25
    Common Sense Conservative
    You're a p#ssy.

    Go finish your bridge game.

    Brilliant!!!
  • Kibbles 2012/03/12 07:29:07
    No
    Kibbles
    +5
    I meant yes, people forgive me.
  • critter171 Kibbles 2012/03/12 16:27:30
  • Bob DiN 2012/03/12 07:16:35
    No
    Bob DiN
    +1
    Not all 13 year olds could handle it.
  • Kibbles Bob DiN 2012/03/12 07:30:58
    Kibbles
    +2
    And yet some can bully, hmm.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/20 03:29:23

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals