Quantcast

BP Back in the Gulf: Should They Be Allowed to Drill in the Gulf of Mexico Again?

SodaHead News 2011/04/04 19:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Like the rich, drunken frat boy who trashed your apartment, but who you like to hang with because he's a big spender, BP is looking to return to the scene of the mess it made in the Gulf of Mexico just over a year ago.

The company has asked for permission to drill 10 development wells in the Gulf, in the same area where the out-of-control well spewed 200 million gallons of oil.

According to Fox News, BP was pushing for these wells before the Deepwater disaster, but had to put its plans on hold when the Obama administration put a moratorium on new deep-water drilling following the accident.

Now, as a condition of getting a new permit, BP would have to agree to give government inspectors 24-hour access to its drilling operations, a condition that still wasn’t enough for environmentalists opposing the move.

"It's hard to see how such monitoring will adequately mitigate the dangers of deepwater drilling," Charlie Kronick, senior climate adviser at Greenpeace U.K. told The Wall Street Journal, dubbing the move “premature.”

On Monday, U.S. Interior Secretary Ken Salazar rejected the news that BP was close to a deal to return to the Gulf, according to a Reuters report.

Salazar said the report was a “misconception” and a spokeswoman for the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management regulator confirmed that, "there are no ongoing negotiations.”

Salazar added there is no agreement, nor would there be, adding that BP would have to go through the same process to resume drilling as any other company.

Should BP be allowed to drill in the Gulf of Mexico again?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Morgan Orlins 2011/04/05 11:11:01
    Yes
    Morgan Orlins
    +9
    What a question, "should they be allowed"?
    Accidents WILL happen! BP acted responsibly by directing all of their efforts and hundreds of millions of dollars towards the clean up, and making damaged businesses whole again.

    The government, FEMA in particular, displayed incompetance and malfeasence on a BIBLICAL scale. After watching FEMA inhibit the cleanup, can ANYONE tell me why they should still be around? Wanna cut spending in DC? Start with FEMA!

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • This is W³ 2012/04/30 07:44:36
    Undecided
    This is W³
    THey should be allowed, but under new and tighter regulations. If BP does not adhere to them, they should not be allowed to drill in the Gulf of Mexico.
  • Bomb a 2011/05/31 02:34:50
    Yes
    Bomb a
    Bill Clinton shouldn't be allowed to drill in the Oval Office.
  • Bomb a 2011/05/31 02:34:49
    Bomb a
    Bill Clinton shouldn't be allowed to drill in the Oval Office.
  • Bomb a 2011/05/31 02:34:47
    Bomb a
    Bill Clinton shouldn't be allowed to drill in the Oval Office.
  • Red Hat Lynn Singley 2011/05/05 18:25:59
    Yes
    Red Hat Lynn Singley
    i cannot believe that the majority of votes NO in LA..The economy is down, down, down..HELLO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • zaddaa 2011/04/28 22:11:25
    No
    zaddaa
    +1
    They should NEVER be allowed to drill anywhere again!
  • Ramon 2011/04/19 04:25:55
    Yes
    Ramon
    Drill baby drill!! If we don't produce our own oil we're that much more dependent on countries that hate us and want to see us die.
  • Andrew 2011/04/16 01:16:52
    No
    Andrew
    No, what we have to do is drill oil in our own land, but Obama and his elf pals are like, "Noooo, it's bad for the enviroment."
  • nefertari 2011/04/15 15:29:46
    No
    nefertari
    +1
    Hell no, look at all the damage they have done by their carelessness. Get another company to drill...besides, they contributed to Obama's election...that's why they got away with poisioning our gulf. it could have been stopped earlier without that big damage.
  • Jim 2011/04/12 02:42:05
    Yes
    Jim
    Why not? The Chinese Communists are doing it right near our shores! When will America rid herself of these traitors in high places?
  • smexy 2011/04/11 16:08:27
    No
    smexy
    +1
    No unless they lornd how to do it the right way, they should not be allowed to go back it just going to increat tax and pollution are oceane's!!!
  • ruthannhausman 2011/04/10 00:29:34
    Yes
    ruthannhausman
    Fully understanding they are responsible for everything they do, both morally and financially. They are oil drillers; we need oil. Alternative fuels are a terrific idea; however, nobody has come up with a nifty solution that's practical, affordable and timely and, meanwhile, we become more and more dependent on a whole bunch of strange creeps. I say step up the oil exploration in our own country and continue on the side to explore new "green" fuel ideas. Don't totally wipe out a major economic segment of American society and throw the whole country into the turmoil it's in today. Good grief, people, we have all the oil and coal and natural gas we will ever need in our lifetime. Likewise, we've got scientific brains out the whazoo. It's time to reexamine the actual motives of the "green" people. I too love this earth and its wildlife and natural springs and whatnot; have no desire to see them destroyed. The Al Gores of this country like to take pure-thought people such as myself and then play us for total idiots. Sorry, this idiot isn't buying their sincerity act at all. Working on green solutions is perfectly acceptable to me so long as we don't abandon this country to the devil with lies and tricks like they're doing today. If BP wants to resume drilling in the U.S., they will need to be monitored properly by the geniuses who are being (over)paid to monitor them and let's get on with business.
  • C 2011/04/09 14:39:35
    No
    C
    +2
    If you were a dentist who accidently killed your patient (But of course you still made money that year and paid your taxes) do you think you should be allowed to continue drilling??
  • Dave Mediate 2011/04/08 17:31:45
    Yes
    Dave Mediate
    It was a plumber sitting at home watching his TV that diagrammed what eventually put a stop to the oil flow. Need to meet the safety of all workers on all shifts so the same mishap and deaths do not occur.
  • Mac 2011/04/08 16:55:09
    Yes
    Mac
    The spill was a great disaster, however this is America. Although we aren't exactly the land of the free anymore, we must for give as we did with Exxon in Alaska. After all it's only our life line.
  • American All The Way 2011/04/08 13:50:37
    No
    American All The Way
    +3
    How about America drilling, Come on folks lets get America going again. Buy what America builds.
  • Don 2011/04/08 13:43:01
    No
    Don
    +2
    Not unless they are going to bury that former ceo at the bottom of the well
  • HowardFernandez 2011/04/08 02:57:27
    No
    HowardFernandez
    +1
    Absolutely not. They have not updated the technology for dealing with accidents in thirty years so they should not be allowed to drill again until they`ve made progress in that area.
  • pete 2011/04/07 14:45:38
    Yes
    pete
    At this point, I would support Ghadafi drilling here and NOW.

    We are soooooo lame in tying our own hands behind our backs, when it comes to America's energy policy. We continue to be beholden to these Mideast despots for our economy and almost every facet of our lives; yet we sit on the worlds second largest oil/gas reserves.

    Drill here and drill NOW!! Sell the oil to Japan, India and China and fix our trade deficits; while at the same time pursuing renewable energy sources.

    WAKE UP!!
  • hasher 2011/04/07 12:52:44
    Yes
    hasher
    its time. they should have beenallowed a long time ago. we need more of our own drilling in this country.
  • Mohammed Hashim 2011/04/07 12:08:25
    No
    Mohammed Hashim
  • AKgrandma 2011/04/07 08:32:42
    Yes
    AKgrandma
    I marked "Yes" because I didn't see a "Hell, yes" there. We need to become less dependent on other countries for our energy needs!
  • Wolf97 2011/04/07 02:27:00
    Yes
    Wolf97
    It wasnt their fault, things happen and the world needs oil.
  • lily=) 2011/04/07 02:06:26
    Yes
    lily=)
    this is annoying because when I tried to click no, it said yes.
  • AprilSkelton 2011/04/06 23:27:45
    Yes
    AprilSkelton
    +1
    America has resources that we are purchasing from other countries. America needs jobs which we are sending to other countries. It is time that America started taking care of her own.
  • Leeaqua 2011/04/06 23:11:28
    Yes
    Leeaqua
    I meant to click NO and the damn screen shifted as I was making my mark ! Haven't we learned anything after the BP disaster ? As long as we keep drilling in precarious places, there will be accidents - maybe even worse than the one that happened . There is no guarentee that this will not reoccur ! Quit sucking on fossil fuels - use the money for drilling for viable alternatives !
  • hasher Leeaqua 2011/04/07 12:54:58
    hasher
    yeah but we need oil for other things besides our cars. what alternatives will run my car? sorry i still need gas as do millions of us. better we get it fromour own land than from someone else.
  • Leeaqua hasher 2011/04/07 15:22:53
    Leeaqua
    Oil can be made from other things - like all the plastics that are made from oil that ignorant, uncaring people don't recycle !
  • ankhorite hasher 2011/04/07 20:45:22
    ankhorite
    +1
    You DO understand, Darlene, that oil gotten "from our own land" does not stay in the U.S.? All the oil drilled in the Gulf or on land goes on the INTERNATIONAL market, and is sold to whoever will pay the most for it.

    Right now, that's China. Yeah. BP destroyed the shoreline in three U.S. states and killed eleven American men, so that China could buy what you think of as "our" oil. It isn't. Remember that. Look it up if you don't believe me.
  • hasher Leeaqua 2011/04/07 12:57:32
    hasher
    then how am i going to get to work everyday? there are no subways or busses where i live. i live in the country and the only way to get around is driving. and im not about to get a stupid electric car i cant afford. besides how is that saving the planet? electricity would cost more, plus doesnt electric plants runon coal? we need to mine that as well.
  • Leeaqua hasher 2011/04/09 15:50:27
    Leeaqua
    All the Amish around here in central missouri use horses and bikes !
  • Red Hat... Leeaqua 2011/04/07 19:41:53
    Red Hat Lynn Singley
    +1
    YOU MIGHT NOT DRIVE..but knowing you use a cell phone..where do we get plastic..Think about it...LOUISDIANA lady
  • Leeaqua Red Hat... 2011/04/09 15:49:21
    Leeaqua
    Hundreds of dolphins have died from this disaster and you still want to continue it - How crass !
  • GeraldL.KingII 2011/04/06 19:52:17
    Yes
    GeraldL.KingII
    +2
    ANYONE who has been following this story knows that BP did NOT drill the well, they leased the well from the another company. BP does share some responsibility as does the Federal Government for allowing IT'S inspector's to watch pornography instead of inspecting the rig.
  • Bob DiN GeraldL... 2011/04/07 02:24:18
    Bob DiN
    Agreed!
  • wampage 2011/04/06 17:43:24
    Yes
    wampage
    +3
    SO should every US drilling and exploration company.
  • Mike 2011/04/06 12:30:44
    Yes
    Mike
    +1
    As long as they comply with regulations.
  • jilliancaffey 2011/04/06 12:14:10
    Yes
    jilliancaffey
    +1
    Ever since the accident,people have beeen wondering wether they should drill again. I think yes. They made a mistake and now that they no wat that mistake was and they no wat to do and wat not to do now
  • PaulCote 2011/04/06 11:47:44
    No
    PaulCote
    +2
    Everyone has the right to do business, right? But not everyone acts in a despicable manner as BP did. They cut corners and their own engineers stated that "the well was a disaster waiting to happen." Then it did.

    My feelings about both sides of the issues run deep. If one oil spill is too many, how many are we going to allow BP?
  • arun 2011/04/06 10:10:53
    No
    arun
    +1
    it is going to be a total mess of a valuable resource....
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 15 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/06/19 05:39:32

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals