Quantcast

Army Vet Jailed for Christmas in PA for "wrong turn"?

Verbal 2011/12/23 12:47:39
Throw the officer in jail for Christmas
Throw the Judge in jail for Christmas
Laws are Laws, no exceptions
You!
Add Photos & Videos




WAYNESBURG, Pa.

THE PITTSBURGH CHANNEL.com




A decorated Army veteran, who has never been in jail before, has been
behind bars since Monday, and looks to be spending Christmas there as
well.



"It's been quite an experience that, to me, is very unjustified," Doug Madison told Channel 4 Action News' Jim Parsons



Madison is scheduled to be in the Greene County Prison until Wednesday.



Madison told Parsons he was driving a chemical tanker from South
Carolina to Halliburton's plant near Carmichaels, Pa., on Monday when
his GPS directed him off Interstate 79 and onto country roads that have a
10-ton weight limit.



Madison's truck weighed three times that.



He was cited by a Pennsylvania State Police trooper for two traffic violations that carry a total fine of $12,000.

Ok, this is just wrong at any level. This is a sad state of affairs that Pennsylvania cannot find it's way through to give this Army Veteran a break. It seems like an honest mistake.


FULL STORY AT THE LINK BELOW

Read More: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/45770582/ns/local_news...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • beavith1 2011/12/23 22:12:01
    Throw the officer in jail for Christmas
    beavith1
    +5
    say. isn't this how Rambo went on the attack? abuse at the hands of some back wood policeman?

    i'd call out the national guard, just to be sure.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • whitebear62 2011/12/27 20:59:39 (edited)
    Throw the Judge in jail for Christmas
    whitebear62
    +1
    Having been a victim of Backwoods Pennsylvania "Due Process", I can readily appreciate the man's situation. It's a standard for outrageous bails to be set, at first. It then takes about 60-90 days to get a bail reduction hearing. Hence the prison populations bulge like frog eyes and the local legislators push for bigger prisons and larger budgets to handle all of these "criminals". The next step in the chain is usually a "plea bargain". That way the "prisoner" can go home (finally!) and the DA is happy 'cause by the books that is a "conviction". This man got out easy because of the publicity. Who else has ever heard of an "emergency hearing"? The court, and the public officials wanted this to go away because it got press. This is STANDARD PROCEDURE in most of PA, folks. Check the records if you don't believe me! They are still PUBLIC records (althgough you may have to jump through hoops to see them)! Especially in Schuylkill County.
  • toni 2011/12/26 15:41:41
    Laws are Laws, no exceptions
    toni
    +1
    I didn't like any of the choices. My guess is that there is more involved here. People don't usually get locked up for traffic violations alone. I assume some judge set bail and bail wasn't posted. If the only charges were the ones that carry a maximum of $12,000 in fines, then I can't imagine bail set any higher than $12000. If he was a Halliburtion employee, they should have been willing to post bail.
  • aneed2know 2011/12/25 05:52:56
    Laws are Laws, no exceptions
    aneed2know
    +2
    I have to say laws are laws, but being Christmass i think there could have been a better way to solve the problem. Also with states not having enough money for one reason or another they need to make that money some how, so grab your ankles and get ready for it people here it comes, carry lots of lube with you.
  • Verbal aneed2know 2011/12/25 17:30:35
  • aneed2know Verbal 2011/12/26 05:13:02
    aneed2know
    +1
    glad you enjoyed that.
  • ShortyDoWop 2011/12/24 06:09:39
    Throw the officer in jail for Christmas
    ShortyDoWop
    +2
    and the judge
  • DDogbreath 2011/12/24 04:23:16
    Throw the officer in jail for Christmas
    DDogbreath
    +4
    Give a guy with a "small penis" a badge and a gun, this is what happens.

    guy penis badge gun
  • Noel16161 2011/12/24 04:02:27
    Throw the Judge in jail for Christmas
    Noel16161
    +2
    Silly!
  • MichaelDillon 2011/12/24 02:46:49
    Laws are Laws, no exceptions
    MichaelDillon
    +2
    Better to get ALL the story before jumping on the comment button.
  • U-Dog 2011/12/24 01:02:12
    Throw the Judge in jail for Christmas
    U-Dog
    +2
    Just more proof that the law crazy Bureatopian leach police state sees all of us -- especially commercial entities -- as their cash cow and meal ticket.
  • Ken 2011/12/24 00:28:47 (edited)
    Laws are Laws, no exceptions
    Ken
    +3
    I think there is more to this story than has been presented. .... He was driving a tanker carrying chemicals. It quite possible a bridge designed to carry 10 tons would collapse under than weight of a 30 Ton tanker. The result of such a bridge collapse may have been the driver's death. So the officer who stopped and arrested this man may have saved a veteran's life. The officer and we don't know what chemical the truck was carrying. A bridge collapse may have resulted in a spill of toxic chemicals. These toxic chemicals may have killed fetuses and/or caused birth defects. The officer arresting this veteran may have protect American children. There are reports of unethical truckers using rural roads to dispose of hazardous wastes. Is there a possibility this trucker was planning on unloading before reaching his destination? If so, the officer who prevented such unauthorized dumping protected the families in the area.

    Bottom line, there are lots of reasons why it is reasonable to expect this veteran to post a bond before being released. Given the risks involved, a $6,000 bond does not seem unreasonable. If you read the story, you will see this bond was lowered to $1,200 and the driver did get released before Christmas.

    The officer did his/her job. I think we should praise the judge for coming in on his day off so the veteran could be released rather than looking to criticize our fine judicial system and police force.
  • U-Dog Ken 2011/12/24 01:11:55 (edited)
    U-Dog
    I agree we may not have the whole story here so why make assumptions either way... And do you have any idea just how easy it is for the average person to innocently take a wrong turn... Much less a driver who is constantly on never seen before strange roads??

    I am ex-military and was a long haul trucker for a few years myself and dealing with the job, much less some of the hard azz --rules are God -- cops looking to dock your pay for the slightest excuse, is not always as easy as you might aSSume.
  • Ken U-Dog 2011/12/24 03:35:31
    Ken
    The officer was doing his duty. Do we really want to second guess a "first responder"? That is just foolishness. If the officer acted unreasonably, the veteran will have a chance to demonstrate that in a court of law...we shouldn't be making this decision in the court of public opinion.

    I support America's first responders against all challenges....the challengers must prove the first responder acted unreasonably before they get my attention. Remember it was a veteran who shot American troops at Fort Hood. If the first responders hadn't been there to deal with that veteran who knows how many loyal, law abiding Americans would have been injured and killed?

    That doesn't mean this isn't an unfortunate story but ... the veteran will not spend Christmas in jail. He was released today after posting a bond. A judge sacrificed part of his day off to make this happen. If the veteran had done his job, the judge could have spent today with his family.
  • U-Dog Ken 2011/12/24 04:24:25
    U-Dog
    Hopefully this vet and trucker will get his fair day in court and we will see how it goes but the simple fact is today's "justice" system is built on the corruption of a million contrary laws and as many subjective opinions.

    ...and Thanks but I am personally experienced enough to know that first responders, judges and other lifelong dependent bureautopians are not always as selfless, honorable and professional as you might wish to innocently portray them.
  • Ken U-Dog 2011/12/24 14:19:57
    Ken
    +1
    I agree ... not all first responders are honorable....neither are all courts .... neither are all veterans.

    Now lets talk politics and definitions. In politics we have progressives and conservatives. Progressives want to change the system. Conservatives want to preserve the system. The police officer and judge in this article represent the system. A progressive would therefore be inclined to support the veteran and use this instance to advocate for change. A conservative would be biased toward supporting the system, i.e., the police officer and the judge.

    I recognize the present system has challenges but I believe in America. So when there is no evidence to proving malicious intent or fraud, I support our first responders.
  • Verbal Ken 2011/12/24 14:54:02
    Verbal
    conversely and with the interjection of a measure of good faith, the same might be suggested about the truck driver
  • Ken Verbal 2011/12/25 06:11:08
    Ken
    +1
    Why should I believe the truck driver rather than the police officer who stopped him?

    I give the police officer the benefit of the doubt. I give the person arrested by the police officer due process. No one has suggested this truck driver's right to due process was violated. They have suggested a police officer ignore the law because the truck driver was a veteran and it was Christmas time.

    It is always dangerous to suggest a police officer substitute their judgement for the law. 1) Who is to say the police officer didn't receive a "gift" for a beneficial judgement; 2) Why should the police officer have more power to decide the law than those elected to write and interpret the law, i.e., the legislature and the courts?
  • luvguins 2011/12/23 22:25:15
    Throw the officer in jail for Christmas
    luvguins
    +4
    Cmon, the trucker did not do this for a premeditated shortcut. His GPS misled him. Were there signs on the alternate route he mistakenly took alerting him to the weight limit? The officer could have cut him a break and rerouted him back onto the correct highway.
    It is good will toward men time.
  • Verbal luvguins 2011/12/23 22:28:52
    Verbal
    +1
    Unfortunately not for this Veteran
  • luvguins Verbal 2011/12/23 22:45:39
    luvguins
    +3
    Certainly not for the officer grinch.
  • beavith1 2011/12/23 22:12:01
    Throw the officer in jail for Christmas
    beavith1
    +5
    say. isn't this how Rambo went on the attack? abuse at the hands of some back wood policeman?

    i'd call out the national guard, just to be sure.
  • Verbal beavith1 2011/12/23 22:15:49
    Verbal
    +2
    LMAO!!
  • NarcolepticGoat 2011/12/23 22:00:10
    Laws are Laws, no exceptions
    NarcolepticGoat
    +1
    But why is there jail time involved for a minor traffic violation?
  • Verbal Narcole... 2011/12/23 22:16:08
    Verbal
    +1
    Good Question goat
  • Giantfan 2011/12/23 21:57:39
    Laws are Laws, no exceptions
    Giantfan
    +1
    Laws are laws but what ever happened to giving a warning? Especially at Christmas time.
  • Verbal Giantfan 2011/12/23 22:01:40
    Verbal
    A little tactful discretion should have been observed
  • Giantfan Verbal 2011/12/24 03:37:47
    Giantfan
    How could it if he's not farmiliar with the area?
  • Verbal Giantfan 2011/12/24 13:33:19
    Verbal
    form the officer
  • Giantfan Verbal 2011/12/24 14:04:23
    Giantfan
    We don't know he didn't try that, do we?
  • Verbal Giantfan 2011/12/24 14:12:27
    Verbal
    +1
    All any of us know is what was reported. I hope the man is home with his family where he belongs
  • Giantfan Verbal 2011/12/24 14:29:48
    Giantfan
    +1
    As do I.

    nhy
  • Link 2011/12/23 21:41:56
    Throw the officer in jail for Christmas
    Link
    +2
    Yes, laws are laws... I get that... as much as I hate that we have so damned many laws and many of them are pure BS...

    None of that withstanding, while it may be that our police officers everywhere have to uphold the law, it is also a fact that some (and keyword here is some, not all) police officers break the very laws that they paid to uphold...

    Also, our police officers everywhere, on a daily basis, use what is called discretion... they decide on a case by case basis if they are going to go by the letter if said laws or if they will cut someone a break...

    In this case, the officer should have cut the guy some slack in the spirit of Christmas... as well as taking the extenuating circumstances into consideration...
  • ur XLNC 2011/12/23 21:39:51 (edited)
    Throw the Judge in jail for Christmas
    ur XLNC
    +2
    Law officers are given a GREAT DEAL of 'wiggle-room' to make judgement calls. This was very poor judgement. Let's just throw EVERYBODY in jail that makes an error of some sort.

    To address this comment below, NO; being a veteran does NOT exempt you, but asinine statements like this one demonstrate how incredibly stupid some people are, and this person demonstrates it in SPADES!
  • Pieter Joubert 2011/12/23 21:38:38
    Laws are Laws, no exceptions
    Pieter Joubert
    What??? You want all veterans to get a free get out of jail card?

    You break the law you pay the price. Whilst that "veteran" was getting pissed in the war zone, all the truckers at home had to abide by the laws whilst transporting all the luxuries the "veterans" enjoyed in Iraq and Afganistan

    What is it with this veteran crap, there are thousands of war veterans sleeping on the steets and living from soup kitchens no one gives a crap about them.
  • Verbal Pieter ... 2011/12/23 21:50:47
    Verbal
    +2
    Pieter..right? Yeah, around here we call that "Dick".
    The mention of Veteran only adds to the issue here. The greater issue is a man being thrown in jail for a minor offense.
    Also, what "luxuries" do service men get that offend you so much? No need to answer, your presence here is mute. As you should be.
  • Pieter ... Verbal 2011/12/23 21:54:00
    Pieter Joubert
    Get the full story not the vets version only, he is using his service as a tool to get sympathy
  • Verbal Pieter ... 2011/12/23 22:03:27
    Verbal
    +2
    He has all he wants from American Citizens. We offer it freely to OUR VETERANS

    american citizens offer freely veterans
  • Flowers Verbal 2011/12/23 22:20:28
    Flowers
    +2
    it's a concept that some just don't understand. our military is volunteer based, and because of that we (most people with hearts at least) go out of our way to help a veteran in return. there are always going to be the unfortunate ones who don't get enough help, and there is always more we as a country could be doing to pay them back, but I think many in the service appreciate what is done. this Pieter dude is either troll bait or ignorant to what is really going on
  • Pieter ... Verbal 2011/12/23 22:26:55
    Pieter Joubert
    Really?????

    Ethan Kreutzer joined the Army at the age of 17 and fought with the 19th Airborne in Jalalabad, Afghanistan. When he retuned home, he had no money, no education and no civilian job experience. He soon became homeless. He slept in an alley off Haight Street, behind two trash cans.

    June Moss drove from Kuwait to Iraq as an Army engineer in a truck convoy. When she returned to the United States, she lost her home, and drove her two young children from hotel to hotel across Northern California.

    Sean McKeen, a hardy, broad-shouldered 21-year-old with a wide smile, went to Iraq to clear land mines, and to get money for college. When he returned home, he became homeless in less than a week. He found himself sleeping in a cot in a crowded homeless shelter in San Francisco.

    They are all part of a growing trend of homelessness among returning war on terrorism veterans.

    More than 2,000 military personnel return home to California each month. Most have no specialized job experience, education or an easy familiarity with civilian life. And many have post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), making it difficult to get along with friends and family, and almost impossible to hold down a job.

    "You feel like the whole world is against you when you get home," said Kreutzer. ...








    Really?????

    Ethan Kreutzer joined the Army at the age of 17 and fought with the 19th Airborne in Jalalabad, Afghanistan. When he retuned home, he had no money, no education and no civilian job experience. He soon became homeless. He slept in an alley off Haight Street, behind two trash cans.

    June Moss drove from Kuwait to Iraq as an Army engineer in a truck convoy. When she returned to the United States, she lost her home, and drove her two young children from hotel to hotel across Northern California.

    Sean McKeen, a hardy, broad-shouldered 21-year-old with a wide smile, went to Iraq to clear land mines, and to get money for college. When he returned home, he became homeless in less than a week. He found himself sleeping in a cot in a crowded homeless shelter in San Francisco.

    They are all part of a growing trend of homelessness among returning war on terrorism veterans.

    More than 2,000 military personnel return home to California each month. Most have no specialized job experience, education or an easy familiarity with civilian life. And many have post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), making it difficult to get along with friends and family, and almost impossible to hold down a job.

    "You feel like the whole world is against you when you get home," said Kreutzer. "I was sleeping on the sidewalk, whereas I had been wearing a uniform less than a year before." Soft- spoken and restless, Kreutzer was recruited in a 7-Eleven while still in high school. After five months in Afghanistan, he had a mental breakdown, diagnosed as PTSD. When he returned to the United States, he spent almost four years living on the streets.

    Kreutzer said he's met several veterans of the war in Iraq on the streets of San Francisco, or sleeping in Golden Gate Park. He also said he met several veterans of the war in Afghanistan, like himself, who were in similar situations.

    200000 war veterans homeless in US Alex Jones' Infowars: There's ...www.infowars.com/200000-wa... - Similar
    You +1'd this publicly. Undo
    16 Jan 2009 – There are 200000 homeless war veterans in the United States. “On every night, 200000 people who have put on the uniform and served this ...
    Number of homeless war veterans growing in U.S. | MLive.comblog.mlive.com › Ann Arbor News Archives › Breaking NewsCached - Similar
    You +1'd this publicly. Undo
    11 Nov 2007 – Veterans make up one in four homeless people in the United States, though they are only 11 percent of the general adult population, according ...
    (more)
  • Verbal Pieter ... 2011/12/23 22:30:22
    Verbal
    +2
    Your reply is a copy and paste? You're a Troll of the worst sort..Get off my page before I have you reported

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/21 13:16:03

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals