Quantcast

Are Mind-Reading Teacher Robots Clever or Creepy?

SodaHead News 2012/06/04 20:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Online classes are convenient for students, but they do have their drawbacks. For instance, how do you ensure that an online student is getting the most out of their lesson? It's impossible for a human teacher to monitor each student's attention level and engage them when their attention starts to wane. Well, Bilge Mutlu and Dan Szafir at the University of Wisconsin-Madison have come up with a solution: Mind-reading wakamaru robot teachers.

"Mind-reading robot" might strike fear in the hearts of those who are worried about a dystopian future, but these robots only measure the attention level of a student. An EEG sensor monitors activity in a certain part of the brain, then employs humanoid "tricks" -- raising it's voice, making eccentric gestures -- to regain the student's attention when it wanders. Studies have shown this actually does increase test scores by about 20 percent. Does it sound like a clever way of engaging remote learners, or a disturbing step in the wrong direction?

wakamaru
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • faustbc 2012/06/05 15:17:48
  • Anonymous 2012/06/05 15:10:19 (edited)
    Creepy
    Anonymous
    +1
    There are rowdy kids in some school districts who will malfunction that thing if the teacher turns their back in a New York minute. How much will repairs cost us? I think it would be less creepy if it were just a camera off the ceiling like surveillance camera's with motion detectors. THAT YELLOW ROBOT IS JUST NONSENSE! I doubt older kids will take it seriously, preschoolers might.
  • fooley177 Anonymous 2012/06/05 19:08:05
    fooley177
    I LIKE the yellow robot. Yellow is a great color which is very much underappreciated. The sun is yellow. Donovan did a song called 'Mellow Yellow.' I have yellow boots and a matching yellow leather trench coat.
  • RicksterBear 2012/06/05 15:10:15
    Creepy
    RicksterBear
    +1
    We rely too much on machines as it is nowadays. This will only make people more dependant on machines and reduce their chance of practicing social skills with real people.
  • .: LiVi :. 2012/06/05 15:08:57
    Creepy
    .: LiVi :.
    +1
    It's one small step into a black hole of evil mwahahaha
  • ChumptyDumpty 2012/06/05 15:05:10
    Creepy
    ChumptyDumpty
    +1
    Some human contact?
  • the fuze 2012/06/05 14:49:22
    Creepy
    the fuze
    +3
    The slope just keeps getting more slippery.
  • Anonymous the fuze 2012/06/05 15:08:20
    Anonymous
    +1
    I totally agree!
  • barby karring 2012/06/05 14:43:52
    Clever
    barby karring
    +3
    Actually it's fascinating"
    I'm open to modern technology ,as long as it's not trying to hurt me.
    If modern technology can teach me things that I do not know; then its cool.
  • democoach barby k... 2012/06/05 16:07:24 (edited)
    democoach
    +1
    mind reading robots the new fascist police, if you even think harm on the government to jail you go! more like fema death camps
  • barby k... democoach 2012/06/07 02:41:41 (edited)
    barby karring
    Thanks but I don't think harm on anyone the government or anyone that's not my thing.
  • democoach barby k... 2012/06/07 02:45:59
    democoach
    by harm i mean thinking the truth about the government! liek opposing the government passing a law like SOPa, or NDAA, or even thinking anti war is going to get you in jail! your thinking is not productive to keeping america free, actually your line of thinking promotes facism!
  • barby k... democoach 2012/06/07 04:27:35
    barby karring
    Sorry if I don't fit a particular mode; though I disagree about promoting fascism, care to elaborate further.
  • democoach barby k... 2012/06/07 15:48:47
    democoach



    (NDAA, arrest without warrant or trial, indefinetly detained based on suspision NOT fact or evidence! and guess what, in america if you have an anti war mentality you are viewed as al queada! so wanting peace is a potential reason for the government to lock you up!)



    (propaganda like hitler put out)

    Acta is a fascist bill

    (iwatch for the web)
  • PeterHenderson 2012/06/05 14:40:50
    Creepy
    PeterHenderson
    +2
    It's creepy and I don't believe the nonsense about increasing test scores. The public is all ga-ga bout neuroscience right now and anyone in history who has ever marketed a gimmic can point to"studies" performed by himself, his friends, or the manufacturer which show some kind of benefit. Kids need to be free to daydream once in a while and even take their mind off their studies to stare at the girl or boy in the next row. It's called being human.
  • Philbo 2012/06/05 14:36:34
    Clever
    Philbo
    its clever yet creepy
  • emile 2012/06/05 14:33:53
    Creepy
    emile
    +2
    Its just creepy how would you like it if a robot taught ALL your lessons
  • Philbo emile 2012/06/05 14:38:01
    Philbo
    what if they use it like a teachers aid?
  • democoach Philbo 2012/06/05 16:14:12
    democoach
    +1
    still stupid!
  • Ashley 2012/06/05 14:30:58
    Creepy
    Ashley
    +3
    Teachers need to be a person, not a machine.
  • FPSRules 2012/06/05 14:23:14
    Clever
    FPSRules
    +1
    I am not concerned....I simply wear my aluminum foil headgear, toss a bucket of water on them, laugh... and they never read my mind again.
  • Philbo FPSRules 2012/06/05 14:38:39
    Philbo
    +1
    riiiigghht you must be american
  • ...Kat... Philbo 2012/06/05 16:16:00
    ...Kat...
    "Uhmmm" or he's just being sarcastic. "Uhmmm" have a nice day now!
  • FPSRules Philbo 2012/07/08 04:35:05
    FPSRules
    Riiiiiight, I am an American.......you must be an un-American??
  • democoach FPSRules 2012/06/05 16:16:01
    democoach
    definetly a retarded american!
  • FPSRules democoach 2012/07/08 04:36:34
    FPSRules
    I suppose since you have made this determination that you are well familiar with retardation......yes?
  • democoach FPSRules 2012/07/08 23:12:56
    democoach
    retard! any thing that involves truth you mock, you say people who knows the truth as tinhat wearers, you don't have the BRAINS to think for yourself! you need media and government to do your thinking for you! you idiots think that people who knows the corrupt nature of the government somehow hates america!
  • democoach FPSRules 2012/06/05 16:16:51
    democoach
    no matter what comes out what stupid *** the government passes thinks everything is ok! and refuses to see the truth! your the ignorant idiot here!
  • adam democoach 2012/06/05 17:40:39
    adam
    by saying "another retarted american" you are stereotyping. hmmm that sounds pretty ignorant to me democoach.
  • democoach adam 2012/06/05 17:52:00
    democoach
    hmm its not stereotypical when the majority of a country is stupid! and yes america is! every canadian i talk to who has been in america comes back with the same story, americans don't even know where canada is and will believe pretty much any crap they are told!
  • adam democoach 2012/06/05 18:40:14
    adam
    +1
    i will agree that tgere is an over abundance of sheeple, but stereotyping is insulting to someone like myself who actually does research. and perhaps you believe so blindly in this stereotype that you overlook the smart ones
  • democoach adam 2012/06/05 19:27:34
    democoach
    thats why i say majority! if you think and use your brain your part of the thinking MINORITY!

    the majority are unthinking!
  • adam democoach 2012/06/05 19:28:44
    adam
    unthink... k
  • FPSRules democoach 2012/07/08 04:45:25
    FPSRules
    You realize you should have stayed in school and not dropped-out in the third grade.
    In that way, when you attempt to insult someone, you would actually make sense.
    As it stands, you're revealing yourself to be illiterate as well as grammatically challenged.
  • Torchmanner ~PWCM~JLA 2012/06/05 14:22:39
    Creepy
    Torchmanner ~PWCM~JLA
    +1
    They're all over the place:

    obama robot obama robot
  • Anonymous Torchma... 2012/06/05 15:16:28 (edited)
    Anonymous
    i NOTICED YOU GAVE THE ROBOT A LITTLE DARKER SHADE. Obama is of mixed race after all. But cute, it made me kinda crack a smile.
  • Grammar Freak 2012/06/05 14:15:11
    Creepy
    Grammar Freak
    Mind-reading robots of any kind are creepy.
  • boltfox20 2012/06/05 13:38:00
    Clever
    boltfox20
    +5
    It isn't actually reading their minds (mind being what they are thinking), it's just seeing how much they are paying attention. Humans can do the same thing, though not as accurately.

    Really, this isn't a big deal at all, though it is a rather clever solution.
  • Mike J. Hirak 2012/06/05 13:37:04
    Creepy
    Mike J. Hirak
    +1
    Robots are taking over!
  • Kigan 2012/06/05 13:29:07
    Creepy
    Kigan
    +1
    A robot is not going to make a quality teacher.

    How long before it starts employing more direct methods?

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/06/20 09:37:07

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals